ipl-logo

Michael Tomasello's Book 'On Origins Of Human Communication'

964 Words4 Pages

Critical review On Origins of Human Communication

Michael Tomasello ’s book, On Origins of Human Communication (2008), is the third book that concludes his extended analysis on social cognition, learning and use of language/ communication between humans and primates ( CV -Michael Tomasello). In this study Tomasello analyzes Paul Grice’s fundamental basis of cooperative human communication and links it to the joint structure of social interaction that we, as humans, use today. He finalizes his study by presenting three conclusions that summarize the evolution of the origins of human communication, these being as follows:

The fundamental idea behind cooperative human communication lies on the psychological framework of what he calls, shared …show more content…

He begins this comparative by referencing Karl Buhler’s, Theory of language, to help the reader distinguish simple forms of gesture that chimpanzees use to request certain things. We must consider that principle of “requesting” as one of the three basic pre-linguistic social purposes of communication, the other two being “sharing” and “informing”. With this in mind we move onto chapter three where the psychological framework of cooperative communication in apes and humans (children and adults) is distinguished. Tomasello summarizes that although chimpanzees are attributed with the skill of requesting, human children are additionally able to share and inform, and by the time they’ve reached adulthood they will also know how to identify and work with cooperation norms. Therefore, it’s not until chapter three where, as a reader, his hypotheses regarding the principles of natural gestures, shared intentionality and conventional forms of communication started to make sense to …show more content…

In both chapters –and throughout the book- Tomasello either forgot or didn’t consider other ape groups, such as the Gelada-Baboons (as oxford colleague, Robin Dunbar suggests), which would challenge Tomasello’s empirical research on the inflexibility of vocal skills in chimpanzees. Therefore, a really big issue of “confirmation bias” arises, which is when researchers select their data in order to coincide with their own hypothesis rather than challenge it and prove its

Show More
Related
850 Words | 4 Pages

To get Washoe to pay attention so the sign language rather than what we spoke, the Gardeners ask for the teachers to never speak while signing with Washoe. In other studies, the teachers would expose the chimps to spoken languages and the chimps would not pick up on the signs as much. The Gardeners method was proven to work, Washoe thrived in ASL. If she didn’t know a sign she would make one up, like “dirty good” for toilet. When Washoe was exposed to other chimps, she was able to teach them ASL to communicate with each

Read More
1871 Words | 8 Pages

Nim was removed from his mother for a research project led by Professor Herbe Terrace. This project featured a radical experiment aimed to teach a chimpanzee sign language. Although, the documentary Project Nim (2011), directed by James Marsh, has an objective to present the progress and results of this experiment, it also carries a purpose to inform the viewer on a message regarding the components of and differences between communication and language. Marsh uses specific

Read More
1038 Words | 5 Pages

This transition from illustrating characters through objects to personal traits and empathy may assume the narrator had increased his connection among his companions, sharing similar insight, undergoing equivalent events, and so forth. Accordingly,

Read More
767 Words | 4 Pages

A lot of authors provide nonverbal communication in their books to develop the plot and the characters. Ernest Gaines does this particularly well in his book A Lesson Before Dying. Most of the nonverbal communication in this book focuses on the eyes of the people interacting with and around the narrator, Grant Wiggins. Gaines' use of nonverbal communication both enhances the plot and develops the characters in a way that is realistic, effective and easy to read.

Read More
981 Words | 4 Pages

“Reading...is not an instinctive skill for human beings. It’s not etched into our genes the way speech is” (Carr 238). In this Carr is discussing the ways in which humans learn. The book is an “anomaly” in the fact that it cannot be changed easily, and is not fluid like human society (Batson 259). Batson discusses how books are credited to one or two authors, but the authors themselves have been shaped by the people around them,

Read More
691 Words | 3 Pages

Although hands don’t seem like an important thing to pay attention to while reading, some authors may be conveying a deeper meaning behind

Read More
1157 Words | 5 Pages

Is spoken language really a superior option of communication over gesture? From Hand to Mouth; Michael C. Corballis uses many examples to show why communication through spoken language is better than gesture. Corballis uses the appeals of Ethos, Logos, and Pathos to effect his readers. Ethos is a strategy that uses ethics and the establishment of credibility. Logos reaches someone’s mind with logical arguments and with clear structure.

Read More
665 Words | 3 Pages

In the next section, “The Case of the Disobedient Orangutans”, the author further delves into the concept of language and animal behavior by arguing that orangutans develop a “vocabulary”, a type of language when interacting with their trainers. The author uses situations found in literature, research, and real life examples to illustrate that animals are more sophisticated than initially considered and have an ability to work with a language. “Wittgenstein’s Lion” begins with a reference to Immanuel Kant and his role in separating human beings from animals by saying that animals apparently do not cry. This beginning is

Read More
1272 Words | 6 Pages

Janni Pederson with the Great Ape Trust of Iowa (2008) believes that language is more than vocalization of information and consists of a combination of interactions, and that is why they possess their own language and can learn new languages with great effort. Pederson (2008) found that language with non-human primates and humans can consist of turn taking, negotiation, pauses, repetition, and sharing of information through use of lexi-grams; not just vocalization. Pederson (2008) noticed that bonobo monkeys were capable of understanding words and conversations humans had and then reacting with this combination of interactions in order to get what they wanted from the humans interacting with them and caring for them. Understanding words being spoken is an important skill found in the bonobo monkeys, but so was the use of these other components of communicating in order to make up a system of language to effectively obtain the results wanted in response to what was being said by the humans, despite the actual inability of the bonobo monkeys to produce human words. Some research has found that while non-human primates may not be able to control vocalization well enough to produce human words, they are still capable of producing certain taught sounds in response to reward encouragement.

Read More
727 Words | 3 Pages

Although the narrator does not take an action, the interplay between two readers

Read More
882 Words | 4 Pages

This clearly specifies that communication depends upon content and relationship. • Also, in many scenes the protagonist used non verbal messages such as writing HELP on the beach and creation fires to signal ships and boats. This showcases that interpersonal communication can be both verbal and non-verbal in

Read More
523 Words | 3 Pages

There are different types of nonverbal communication. Body movements is a different type of nonverbal communication. Body movements are the most noticeable elements of nonverbal communication. Body Movement consists of posture, gestures, face and eyes. A posture can say a lot of a person.

Read More
495 Words | 2 Pages

His concepts of the four stages of communication are interesting as they start with biological communication through verbal language, writing and the use of symbols, which he uses this as his perception of the beginning of civilized society.

Read More
1138 Words | 5 Pages

(ll. 27-28, p. 142). In this example, Holly’s position is exclusively described, however, it can be concluded that she feels small and uncomfortable. The use of ‘show, don’t tell’ makes the text more difficult to read, as it requires the reader’s own interpretations to gain an understanding of the described events and experiences. Additionally, everyday language is used in dialogue, which is illustrated in the following passage: “”Holly,” I go. “It’s true, Duane,” she goes.

Read More
1333 Words | 6 Pages

The questionable and ambiguous nature surrounding the notion that children play an active role in acquiring language has been debated by many theorists of different perspectives. These three perspectives include the learning view, the nativist view and the interactionist view. In this essay I will discuss each perspective with reference to psychological theories and research that relates to each view. The learning perspective of language acquisition suggests that children acquire language through imitation and reinforcement (Skinner, 1957). The ideology behind this view claims that children develop language by repeating utterances that have been praised by their parent, therefore gaining a larger vocabulary and understanding of phrases over

Read More

More about Michael Tomasello's Book 'On Origins Of Human Communication'

Related Topics

Open Document