ipl-logo

Cruel And Unusual Punishment Analysis

757 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Biological psychological and sociological reasons for crime

It’s not every day you see young adolescents committing murder and heinous crimes, but unfortunately there are days when a young teen walks in the courtroom with handcuffs ready to hear their trial, punishment and sentencing. It is hard to understand how anyone can have these thoughts about brutal, horrifying crimes, but it’s even harder to understand how anyone can oppose punishment for these criminals just because of their age. “On June 25, 2012, the Supreme Court ruled that juveniles who committed murder could not be sentenced to life in prison because it violated the Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment” I would like to give my opinion and say that there is nothing cruel and unusual about giving an underaged “child” a …show more content…

Possibly because there are normal functioning kids, and then there are those who have mental illness that provokes them to kill instead of interact with society. The authors i do not agree with are Marjie Lundstorm and Jennifer Jenkins, i do not agree with these authors because they simply keep making the mistake of thinking and calling these criminals “the poor children in prison” and “they’re not adults” these two authors think that the only ones to blame here are is the U.S. and criminal system, but i find it funny that it wasn’t the U.S who killed those people and it wasn’t the criminal system who conjured up the idea. Personally i find these “children” as guilty as any other criminal, their age shouldn’t make a difference on their punishment, when someone asks me the definitions of a child i describe them to be playing with dolls and action figures, pretending to be superheros and the good guys, i don’t describe them as these horrible monsters you see now, and apparently it’s because “We’ve created this image that teenagers are something to be feared” but that is not something i agree

Show More
Related

Christopher Simmons Case Study

1018 Words | 5 Pages

The court’s opinion on this case, overturning the death penalty, I personally agree with. This case addresses the Eighth Amendment, cruel and unusual punishment and sentencing a juvenile to the death penalty violates Simmons’s Eighth Amendment Right. Simmons being 17 years of age, impulsive, immaturity, behavior changes, alcohol and drug abuse, and bad home environment is crucial to his behavior. These facts all play a role in this case; however, were not addressed during the sentencing process. During closing arguments the defense harped on Simmons’s age; to remind the jurors that legislatures made laws that prohibited juveniles from drinking, serving on juries, even buying or renting R rated movies believing that individuals under a certain age simply are not responsible enough.

Read More

8th Amendment Pros And Cons

1086 Words | 5 Pages

So the court then deemed that capital punishment can’t be given to anyone under the age of 16 no matter what the crime is. Basically the Eighth Amendment was interpreted to have that no one under the age of 16 shall have the death sentence in the United States since it a cruel punishment to give to a minor. In addition, the next evidence brings up Penry v. Lynaugh. Johnny Paul Penry was a mentally disabled person who had the mental age of 7.

Read More

Roper V. Simmons Case Of 2005

827 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction In response to question one of unit 4, I will discuss the facts, issues, as well as court holdings referencing the Roper v. Simmons case of 2005. Discussion The Roper v. Simmons case is noted for being one of the most significant cases in the history of the juvenile court system as it abolished capital punishment for offenders under the age of eighteen in the United States (Death Penalty Information Center, n.d.). This case was argued on October 13, 2004, and a decision was reached by the United States Supreme Court on March 1, 2005. The case referenced the sentencing of Christopher Simmons to death for a crime he committed at the age of seventeen (Cornell University Law School, n.d.).

Read More

Compare And Contrast Miller Vs Alabama

903 Words | 4 Pages

This is not providing life for minors when they do not have fully developed brains and do not know the way of life yet. This should deny them from being charged with life without parole as a minor. Your brain is not fully developed when you are a child. In other cases, parents must take accountability for the child in civil and criminal court. The Supreme Court of the United States uses the Constitution to support its decision by stating the 8th Amendment and its prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment.

Read More

Impact Of Roper V Simmons

1055 Words | 5 Pages

Roper v. Simmons is considered a landmark case and is one of a handful that shows a new direction in granting some relief from what has been established as harsh “adult” punishments for juveniles (Elrod & Ryder, 2014). In fact, many studies are showing that the differences between adults and juveniles are quite significant (Elrod & Ryder, 2014). The courts are realizing that these differences must be taking into account when dealing with juveniles in the criminal justice system (Elrod & Ryder, 2014). However, that being said, change does not occur overnight, and for the unforeseeable future, juveniles will still continue to be waived into adult courts (Elrod & Ryder, 2014).

Read More

Eighth Amendment: Cruel And Unusual Punishment Clause

575 Words | 3 Pages

The Eighth Amendment (Amendment VIII) of the United States Constitution prohibits the federal government from imposing excessive bail, excessive fines, or cruel and unusual punishment. The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that this amendment 's Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause also applies to the states. The phrases in this amendment originated in the English Bill of Rights of 1689. This amendment was adopted on December 15, 1791, along with the rest of the United States Bill of Rights. To begin with, the Eighth Amendment was adopted, as part of the Bill of Rights, in 1791.

Read More

Nathan Ybanez Case

1069 Words | 5 Pages

The unfaltering dissension about sentencing juveniles to life in prison without parole has yielded opposition in the criminal justice system and dysfunction towards the young lives facing unsettled, extreme punishment for their mitigating crimes. While this particular topic can branch to very detailed discussions in divergent aspects such as: socially, politically, scientifically, and morally, it should be eliminated to only two characteristics: is it fair and is it right? Although it seems painless and facile to act on impulse when punishing juvenile criminals severely, the consequences are ineffective and adverse to the needs of the victims, the development of adolescent offenders, and the primary function of the criminal justice system.

Read More

Sigg's Essay On Punishment And Teen Killers

805 Words | 4 Pages

An indication that disproves the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision centers on the idea that one’s age should not be used as an excuse to minimize their punishment. In her essay “On Punishment and Teen Killers”, Jennifer Jenkins supports this by arguing that a juvenile should not use their age as an excuse to get out of trouble with the law. After mentioning the horrific case of a teenager who killed a pregnant woman for satisfaction, it is revealed that the murderer was charged with three life sentences. Despite the murderer’s wicked actions, some people still believed that the murderer did not deserve life sentences just because the killer was not considered a legal adult. To support her argument that age isn’t enough of an excuse, Jenkins writes “There are advocates who wish to minimize

Read More

The Eighth Is Great: The Case Of Titus Oates In England

1221 Words | 5 Pages

As new crimes have surfaced the proper means to address those who commit them has come into question. One drastic change brought about by the 8th Amendment was that the death penalty was prohibited for juvenile offenders for non-homicidal cases as of 2005 ("Roper v. Simmons. ", Oyez). The right of every American to remain free from “cruel and unusual punishment” is of the utmost importance in order to maintain fairness and equality for all people, even those convicted of dire

Read More

Compare And Contrast The Cruel And Unusual Punishment During The Revolutionary Era

807 Words | 4 Pages

Revolutionary Era During the Revolutionary Period, there were any crimes and punishments that took place, while reading and researching more of the lesson for this week I learned a great deal about the Revolutionary Era and the cruel and unusual punishment that took place during this time. Because of the extent of these punishments the American Criminal Justice system came together which included the courts, policing, and prisons on a local and state level, to apprehend, and arrest the responsible criminals and determining if they were guilty and to impose the right sentencing for the offenders. The two crimes and punishments that really stuck out to me are “the crime of Treason, and Piracy and Smuggling”. During this time of Era, the American

Read More

8th Amendment Essay

732 Words | 3 Pages

The Eighth Amendment is all about punishment. In the Amendment it states, “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.”, as well as allowing the Death Penalty. I believe this Amendment is right. Because of the fact that cruel and unusual punishment wouldn’t be fun, I believe the Death Penalty should be legal, and excessive fines would be crushing to our economy. Cruel and unusual punishment would not be fun.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Juvenile Life Without Parole

1528 Words | 7 Pages

Crimes are happening around us whether we pay attention to them or not. Those crimes as dangerous as murder are committed by all ages but should younger criminal in their juvenile age received the same punishment as older criminals. On June 25, 2012, the Supreme Court ruled that juveniles committed murder could not be sentenced to life in prison because it violates the Eighth Amendment.(On-Demand Writing Assignment Juvenile Justice) Advocates on the concurring side believes that mandatory life in prison is wrong and should be abolish. However, the dissenting side believe that keeping the there should be a life in prison punishment for juvenile who commit heinous crime regardless of their age.

Read More

Essay On Juveniles Deserve Life Sentences

582 Words | 3 Pages

In 2012, the Supreme Court ruled that it is immoral to give juveniles life sentences, even if they commit a crime as serious as murder, because it is a cruel and unusual punishment. This has been an issue in America as teenagers are often treated as adults in court due to a belief that their crimes warrant a harsh punishment. Many believe that these kids should not be given such major sentences because they are still immature and do not have the self control that adults do. I agree that juveniles do not deserve life sentences because they put less thought and planning into these crimes and they often are less malicious than adults. The article “Startling Finds on Teenage Brains” explains that the teenagers lose brain tissue that is responsible for self control and impulses (Thompson 7).

Read More

Essay On Why Juveniles Should Be Tried As Adults

1392 Words | 6 Pages

When people commit crimes, there should be disciplined no matter what. Juveniles need to learn that their behaviors have consequences. Why should kids be given any less of a punishment for committing the same crime? According to one author, “Taking a life is murder regardless of the age of the offender, and the penalties to be imposed must not discriminate. After all, the victim’s life will never be returned, and the family will permanently lose their loved one” (“7 Top Pros and Cons of Juveniles Being Tried As Adults”).

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Juvenile Justice

729 Words | 3 Pages

Juveniles Justice Juveniles who are criminals being sentenced to life without parole can be shocking to some people. I believe if a juvenile is able to commit a crime, then they are able to do the time. The article “Startling finds on Teenage Brains” talks about how the brain can be different from the time you are teens to the time you are an adult. After, considering both sides on juvenile justice it is clear that juveniles should face life without parole because they did the crime so they can do the time. Also I believe the juvenile’s age should not influence the sentence and the punishment give.

Read More

More about Cruel And Unusual Punishment Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document