ipl-logo

Derek Parfait's Personal Identity: A Conceptual Analysis

1050 Words5 Pages

A scientist with issues: a thought experiment on existence.

To imagine waking up to a mad scientist prepping another human body for a brain transplant in which you are the supplier of a body, and, most importantly, the brain. The idea has been said out loud, by the mad scientist with Einstein styled hair, that your brain shall be split in half. The left stays within your body, and the right is implanted in a brainless vessel. Having gone ahead and agreed with Parfaits dismissal of the “I do not survive” argument and accepting “How could a double success be a failure?” as a sound statement,(pg.354) the experiment continues! During your endeavors, the thought flashes through your mind, “Where will I continue to exist?” I believe you don’t. If it were to be me, and they had me strapped down to the metal operation table, in the unlikely event that I would stop screaming …show more content…

Though as stated earlier, how can two successful operations result in a “failure” of survival? He contradicts this with saying “Identity is a one to one relation.” (Pg. 357) However, if my brain is “I” and I am my brain, how can I not be me? This reminds me of a quiche I made for the International Food Fair at UTEP. I had preheated 12 crust, and began on one giant serving of batter. Many, many ingredients and fierce whisking later, the batter was finished. I decorated the bottom of the finished crusts with 2 different layers. Six were provolone cheese, artichokes, and sundried tomatoes scattered at the bottom, the other filled with spinach and Guerre cheese. After, decorating the piecrust with the chosen ingredients, I filled them with the batter. Half went to the artichoke quiche, the other half to the spinach. Though the two were completely different recipes, different quiches, different flavors, the batter never ceased to be the same

Show More
Related
994 Words | 4 Pages

It wouldn’t be correct to say that if Mary’s body had the original brain the she is Julia, but if Mary’s body had the duplicate then it’s not Julia. The problem is the body wouldn’t be able to tell which brain it had so picking one brain over the other would be wrong so in the end Mary is the one that survives and not Julia. Miller counters back on Weirob saying that personal identity allows one to know who they really are without having to look at their own bodies. Thus placing Julia’s brain inside Mary’s body it can tell it is Julia not by looking at her body because her body says otherwise but by the fact that it remembers being Julia, and has all of Julia’s memories, beliefs and ideas. Miller continues on with the fact that memories and personal psychological traits that a person has is what makes one unique not their body.

Read More
372 Words | 2 Pages

This entrée is the finest meal to go with the superb dessert. Key lime pie is the splendid dessert, right after you have a juicy French dip. A bountiful, piquant slice of Key Lime Pie was impeccable with homemade whipped cream and a crumbly graham cracker crust. The pie was very tasty and saccharine. The whipped cream and graham cracker crust balances the tartness of the key lime pie.

Read More
1007 Words | 5 Pages

Stream rises from the plate as freshly grated parmesan cheese is sprinkled around the plate and light layers, lowly melting into the pasta. After enjoying the main meal, the waiter kindly hands, me a smaller menu containing all the different deserts they offer. After looking through the menu the waiter suggested the most popular item, which is the chocolate pineapple upside down cake. The moistness of the cake can be seen once it arrives at the table. On top the chef drizzles raspberry, mango and pineapple sauce across.

Read More
785 Words | 4 Pages

It’s surely enough to feed any hungry family. Apple Cupcakes Melody bakes a mean apple pie and is a wise teacher. This recipe puts a sweet twist on the “giving an apple to the teacher”

Read More
323 Words | 2 Pages

In the video of the Stanley Milgram Experiment People were given roles as teachers and students. The students had been hooked up to an electrical system were they had been received questions and whenever they had answered incorrectly they received a dosage of electricity and got progressively got stronger each time they were wrong. At a certain point the student stopped responding to pain and the scientist had kept making them give a voltage. Some People discontinued the experiment.

Read More
650 Words | 3 Pages

Olivia Seeney ENGL 305 The Art of the Essay 3/22/17 Insert Flap A and Throw Away Analysis The main point of this essay was to point out to the reader the ridiculous state of human nature when presented with a situation that is outside of our expertise. As we observe the narrator’s struggle to put together this cardboard toy, his use of both overstatement and understatement show the progression of his frustration with this task. One example of this ironic language can be found in the first sentence when the narrator states “I made a most interesting discovery: the shortest, cheapest, method of inducing a nervous breakdown ever perfected. (Perelman)”

Read More
773 Words | 4 Pages

To answer some of the questions, he considered Wiggins’s brain splitting experiment. In the experiment, Parfit’s brain is split into two different bodies, both of which now contains personality and memories. Parfit deduced that there are only three possible outcomes. “(1) I do not survive; (2) I survive as one of the two people; (3) I survive as both.” (354).

Read More
950 Words | 4 Pages

While arguably one of the defining psychological studies of the 20th Century, the research was not without flaws. Almost immediately the study became a subject for debate amongst psychologists who argued that the research was both ethically flawed and its lack of diversity meant it could not be generalized. Ethically, a significant critique of the experiment is that the participants actually believed they were administering serious harm to a real person, completely unaware that the learner was in fact acting. Although Milgram argued that the illusion was a necessary part of the experiment to study the participants’ reaction, they were exposed to a highly stressful situation. Many were visibly distraught throughout the duration of the test

Read More
2594 Words | 11 Pages

Freimuth, a participant stated that “To find whatever diseases that are occurring, to find out the solution to that, or cure ' '. One man illustrated the value of research in blunt terms, “Because if nobody do it, somebody gonna die, I mean, more people gonna die ' '. (P.804 Freimuth). This shows that some participant volunteered out of their own free will despite of not knowing. Some believe that by volunteering for the experiment it was necessary to find solutions for this situation and that it would help greatly to the researchers on finding a cure.

Read More
1354 Words | 6 Pages

Each hemisphere of the man’s brain is then separately transplanted into the two waiting bodies. The aim of this case for Parfit is to establish whether or not the man survives. It has been proven

Read More
1157 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout my life I have come from and created a few identities for myself. Perhaps, the most dominant identities that have been apart of my life are being an athlete and being a family orientated man. In this paper I will write about how my identities have shaped my life. First off I believe my biggest identity is being an athlete.

Read More
1517 Words | 7 Pages

In Aldous Huxley’s book, Brave New World, an unimaginable dystopia has been created. The World State was formed on three principles: community, identity, and stability. These three principles dictate how members of this society live and interact with one another. In modern society, there is an emphasis on the importance of motherhood, commitment, and countless other ideals that are rejected in the World State. Throughout the novel, the principle of community is shown with castes and hypnopaedic slogans, such as everybody belongs to everybody else.

Read More
708 Words | 3 Pages

Joshua, a man involved in the experiment, ““I shocked. I feel bad about that. I shocked but I only went to 150, I broke it off at 150.” He keeps repeating this, as though to reassure himself….

Read More
1210 Words | 5 Pages

Identity is social construct that many have mistaken for something an individual is born with. There are many aspects of identity that one can inherit like genes that can drive a certain type of character and certain aspects of identity a person can adopt and build for themselves. However the most part of one’s identity is consistent of what the person wants and adopts for themselves and what the society/the people around him/her choose to give him/her. Identity is a said to not remain unchanged once established.

Read More
885 Words | 4 Pages

Self-identity is defined as the recognition of one's potential and qualities as an individual, especially in relation to social context. In other words, self-understanding. Finding self-identity is more more difficult for some people than others. In the autobiography Black, White, and Jewish: Autobiography of a Shifting Self by Rebecca Walker, the author reflects on her identity as a mixed raced individual which is illustrated through Walker’s reflections. People define themselves in many different ways.

Read More

More about Derek Parfait's Personal Identity: A Conceptual Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document