ipl-logo

Did Herman Ludd End The Book With The Death Of Billy Budd

389 Words2 Pages
Have you ever written a book and had a dilemma on how to end it? We all agree that Herman Melville ended the book with the death of Billy Budd. But some believe that Herman Melville should have ended the book with the escape or salvation of Billy Budd. I think Melville made the best choice in ending the book with the death of Billy Budd for three reasons: It would turn it from a good book to an excellent book, It would make the book realistic,and it sets an example of the law being enforced.

The first reason that I agree with Melville's choice to end the book with the death of Billy is it would turn it from a good book to an excellent book. It makes a surprising ending because no one is going to expect the main character to die. There are
Show More
Related
682 Words | 3 Pages

Near the end of the book, a big battle occurred between a mountain lion and Billy and his dogs. It was brutal, with claws, biting, and axe chopping but in the end, the mountain lion died but the fight sadly left Old Dan with extremely fatal wounds that even Billy’s family can’t fix completely. A few days later, Old Dan died from his wounds and Little Ann lost the will to live. A few days after Old Dan died, Little Ann also died. Billy seems to just can’t get over the loss of his dogs but he learned anyways.

Read More
1810 Words | 8 Pages

The end of the book focuses on the kids’ life after the decision is made in court. The juvenile justice system was supposed to save all of them or at least try. The system only saved three, proved itself incapable before one killer, and gave up on the

Read More
951 Words | 4 Pages

In the novel, you can see that there is a lot of Pathos throughout it. It lists many things like the death and sadness. You read many parts in the book that are like this, especially in the Death part of the book. When Henrietta was in the hospital, everyone who knew she had cancer was sad. They were hoping and praying for her to recover from this but was disappointed when they learned the doctors were lying by saying she looks fine when she wasn’t.

Read More
1147 Words | 5 Pages

We may feel a bit frustrated, or agitated, that Fitzgerald would end ‘The Great Gatsby’ like he did, but we have to give him the credit. Fitzgerald did an absolutely flawless job at summarizing how real life ends more often than not; messy and quite

Read More
470 Words | 2 Pages

Reading Robert Peace’s story knowing how it would end made the book more stimulating. I wanted to know if Robert Peace was trouble from the start or was he going to make something of himself. I was eager to finish the book to see why and how he died. Knowing that a young man’s life was going to end early made me pay attention to the details in the book for any foreshadowing that could give me a hint on how he would die. I wanted to know how a young man with lower income, who is Ivy League educated with a full scholarship, manage to die at a young age.

Read More
1068 Words | 5 Pages

In the book death happens frequently, and it 's enjoyable to them. Violence in the book is a warning because in the future, violence could have a huge impact on our life. If violence starts to grow like Fahrenheit 451, everyone would enjoy seeing the death of others too. This could also turn society against each other with too much violence. For these reasons,

Read More
948 Words | 4 Pages

The story is written in a way that makes you believe the main character is alive and free, but in reality you are reading the last wishes of a dead man. The ending definitely caught me by surprise due to author’s efforts in playing with the main character’s point of view. I think the author also performed well with descriptive words as I could paint the scenes in my head like the, “...whirled on with a velocity of advance and gyration which made him giddy and sick” and “...the abrasion of one of his hands on the gravel...” (Bierce 604). The use of this imagery also helped the author convey the illusion of fantasy and

Read More
643 Words | 3 Pages

Willy’s death was inevitable; he was hopeless. Gatsby’s death could have been avoided and Gatsby would have lived to have a successful

Read More
1478 Words | 6 Pages

Although this story ends on a good note, with the antagonist, Bob Ewell, dead and Scout and Jem being okay after the attack on Halloween night, I felt that the plot lacked a denouement because when the story ended, it left many unanswered questions. An example of a something that I wanted to know was what happened after Jem woke up. I wanted to know how he found out what happened and if he met Boo Radley to thank him. If this part was known to the reader, the ending would have left the reader satisfied knowing that Jem woke up and interacted with Boo, which I’m sure many readers would have anticipated since the beginning. Another example of a part that I wanted to know the result of was the lives of the Ewell kids after Bob Ewell’s death.

Read More
1479 Words | 6 Pages

By using ambiguous language, Herman Melville’s Billy Budd, Sailor explains homosexuality and the issues the group had in society. It can be assumed that at least three of the Bellipotent’s crew were homosexual and other members of the crew knew this as well. Through the time period there was constant fear and persecution of homosexuals which led to the crewmen being silent in their justice just as homosexuals were silenced in their prosecutions by others. By using historical aspects, Melville has hidden under everyone’s nose the implications of homosexuality on the ship. Captain Vere is seen as a scholarly figure who keeps to himself until the end of the novella where he is forced into the conflict of a potential mutiny brewing.

Read More
600 Words | 3 Pages

Gatsby is unsuccessful in his goal and ends up murdered. Throughout the novel the persona James Gatz had set up for himself is slowly destroyed in the eyes of the reader. This makes many readers skeptical to why Fitzgerald

Read More
560 Words | 3 Pages

In the novel, As I lay dying by William Faulkner, the Bundren family go through a mental journey of loss and death of their mother later to go on a physical journey to bury their mother. To the conclusion of any novel, many have an opinion on what is much happy or not a happy ending. In the case of the ending to As I lay dying, include no real burial of how the mother wanted, which was the point of the physical journey in the first place, secrets comes out, one of the five the siblings gets taken away, and many are left with unfinished business, was not a happy at all for most of the characters. The novel is narrated by 15 characters that are not all part of the Bundren family but in some way connected.

Read More
359 Words | 2 Pages

However, even if there was some notional deaths, the reals deaths were what created the ending and driving point of the story. The first death of Dan Cody, was originally what sent Gatsby to find a method to fortune. “Insert quote of losing inheritance”. Then After the events

Read More
406 Words | 2 Pages

In Herman Melville's novel "Billy Budd", Billy is accused of killing Claggart and having attempted a military mutiny and is hanged to death with the support of Captain Vere. Recalling all the characters in the novel, Captain Vere should take the greatest responsibility for Billy Budd's death. Although Captain Vere knows well about Billy and his loyalty, he chooses to ignore these factors and instead sees Billy as a criminal. First and foremost, he knew Billy's personality and know that he would not have sought to mutiny, but as a Captain, he was responsible for enforcing the war order and punishing any act of mutiny or disobedience. While Billy has a good reputation and he dedicated service to the crew, he ultimately opted to follow the laws and regulations and orders Billy's execution, knowing it was unjust.

Read More
804 Words | 4 Pages

From the brief passage from the story, you can see how many bad decisions are being made and how they are adding up, leading towards the tragic end. As can see from reading, the

Read More

More about Did Herman Ludd End The Book With The Death Of Billy Budd

Related Topics

Open Document