ipl-logo

Differences And Similarities Between Odysseus And Bilbo

1252 Words6 Pages

The similarities in the stories include the overall structure, the episodic progression of the texts, and the similar traits of the characters. To gain nostos, the two main characters, Odysseus and Bilbo, share their use of intelligence to get them out of situations instead of brute force. For instance, Odysseus uses wordplay to trick Polyphemus, and Bilbo uses riddles to bargain with Gollum. To escape the island, Odysseus hides "a man beneath each middle sheep" (p.). Analogously, Bilbo hides the Dwarves in wine barrels to escape the cells of Mirkwood. Lastly, both characters face difficulty when they reach their destination. However, while Bilbo attempts to prevent violence, divine intervention is needed to stop Odysseus’ violence.

Greed …show more content…

His intelligence is evident when he tells Polyphemus that his "name is Noman" (p. ) so that Polyphemus is unable to call for help. However, he cannot resist taunting Polyphemus and reveals to him that "Odysseus, the city-sacker, Laertes’ son, who lives in Ithaca, destroyed [his] sight." (p.). By revealing his name and household, he gains kleos, which enables Polyphemus to curse him. Polyphemus asks Poseidon to cause Odysseus to "get [home] late and with no honor, in pain and lacking ships, and having caused the death of all his men" [reference p.]. He dooms himself and his sailors to a long and deadly journey. Another example of Odysseus’ intelligence succumbing to greed is when he is able to avoid being turned into a pig by Circe. Although he saves his men, his journey is halted for a year because he cannot resist staying with her. Similarly to Thorin, greed overpowers Odysseus’ intelligence, causes him to stall his journey home, and similarly puts himself and his companions in danger. Therefore, the destructive effects of greed on character and purpose are evident in The Odyssey as well. Both Thorin and Odysseus make decisions that do not benefit the greater good and instead act as a way to fuel their greed. In this way, both present society and Homer’s society emphasize …show more content…

Tolkien uses Bilbo as a character who is not so easily corrupted by greed and is thus, able to carry the journey forward. Because of this virtue, Bilbo is able to see reason and make decisions that will benefit the greater good and stop useless violence. Even though this is not his home, Bilbo feels a sense of duty and risks his life to help the Dwarves. Unlike Odysseus, Bilbo is an unlikely hero who only sets out on the journey after being persuaded by Gandalf, a wizard. Bilbo relies mostly on his luck and on Gandalf to be saved. However, as the story progresses, Bilbo gains confidence and bravery. Independently, he is able to slay the spiders and use his newfound confidence to free the dwarves from the prison cells of the Mirkwood elves. Ultimately, Bilbo tries his best to stop Thorin from waging war by giving the Arkenstone to Bard so that they may negotiate. Bilbo makes these decisions independently without guidance from divinity or fate, decisions that represent his values because he does not allow greed to blind him. Through Bilbo, Tolkien shows that it is possible to change the destructive nature of greed and violence if one is able to realize that greed will bring destruction and thus make better

Show More
Related
787 Words | 4 Pages

Even though this part of the hero’s journey was portrayed pretty similarly, there is still a bit of a difference. They both used their instincts, but Bilbo was influenced a bit by the dwarves. His Took side had shown while the dwarves were contemplating whether he was fit for the adventure or not. This made him want to prove himself to them. Instincts aren’t normally the cause of the call to adventure, but for some reason, these two very different novels are similar this way.

Read More
763 Words | 4 Pages

In the story “The Hobbit” Bilbo can be seen as the hero when he sacrifices his family’s name to be a part of the quest to get Thorin's gold back Bilbo's first approach is his attempt on stealing the trolls’ treasure. He later is met by the goblins, Gollum, elves, and spiders. Each fear he faces develops Bilbo as a hero, getting him ready for his greatest quest, stealing the treasure from Smaug.. Another example of Bilbo putting others before himself is the treasure he willing to give in order to bring peace to the men, elves, and dwarves. Last, but not least, Bilbo is willing to sacrifice his life for a cause bigger than himself.

Read More
1277 Words | 6 Pages

Penelope, his wife, is greatly affected; as many greedy suitors disrespect her and move into their home to try and win her hand in marriage. Throughout ‘The Odyssey’, the greed and folly of men play a huge part in increasing the difficulty and severity of Odysseus’s situations and ultimately change his fate and the directions of his journey. The greed and folly of men are largely represented by Penelope’s suitors. In the very first book of The Odyssey, the disgusting actions of the suitors were introduced to the readers.

Read More
704 Words | 3 Pages

TS1 (Thesis): In The Odyssey, Homer depicts Odysseus’ real foe as the theme of temptation with displays of hubris and lustrous goddesses, which portrays the importance of being vigilant to not submit to temptation. ST1: Homer depicts that Odysseus is determined to get home, but Odysseus succumbs to temptation when he leads his crew into the cyclops lair, eats the cyclops’ food, and demands for a gift, resulting in a protracted journey home. 1: Homer displays Odysseus as recklessly brave when he requests, “we’re at your knees, in hopes of… a guest-gift”(9.300) from the cyclops. 2: It is apparent that Odysseus has given into the temptation to be arrogant when he declares for the cyclops to give them, “a guest-gift,” after Odysseus and his men have broken into the cyclops lair, showing even further Odysseus’ isn’t vigilant to

Read More
1631 Words | 7 Pages

Along the journey home, Odysseus and his men are presented with many situations that act as tests of their personal character and self-control. Whether it is the temptation of revelry, the ability to escape their worries, or gluttony, the men must choose between their own selfish desires or resistance for the communal good. The crew’s success or failure in giving in to their temptations depends upon their possession of certain characteristics. Throughout Homer’s Odyssey, the failure of Odysseus’s men to recognize their lack of self-control due to foolishness results in them bringing misfortune upon themselves and ultimately their community while their king and commander, Odysseus, successfully displays how to avoid this lack of self-control

Read More
764 Words | 4 Pages

The company faces many challenges while Gandalf aids them. Eventually, Bilbo becomes forced to take charge and lead the company to the mountain. The experiences Bilbo encounters throughout his journey define and shape him into the hero he becomes. The Hobbit follows the story of Bilbo by mirroring the heroic journey, showing Bilbo’s dramatic change from the Hobbit he once was.

Read More
779 Words | 4 Pages

Bilbo wishes he could turn around, go back home, sleep in his bed, and eat his own food. The dwarves also feel as if the burglar is worthless at the beginning of the novel. Gandalf quickly shuts down all accusations and lets everyone know that Bilbo will be very helpful in this mission. In chapters four and five, the group of fifteen finds themselves in a mountain filled with goblins. On their way out a goblin finds them, so in shock, a dwarf drops Bilbo.

Read More
1064 Words | 5 Pages

Earlier in the epic, Odysseus frequently abuses his role as captain of his crew because of his curious nature. He makes several stops on their journey home in search of more opportunities to prove his skillfulness, even though he is already a king and has won a major war. One of these stops is at the Island of Polyphemus, home to the cyclops famed for eating all humans that enter his cave. Even though Odysseus is well aware of the danger ahead, his curiosity tempts him to

Read More
2273 Words | 10 Pages

At the beginning of the story, Bilbo seems very cowardly, but soon proves that he is indeed brave. Bilbo is very tied up in his very boring, monotonous life and he really does not want to go on the adventure that he is

Read More
558 Words | 3 Pages

Bilbo Baggins is a hobbit who enjoys a peaceful and comfortable life in his hobbit-home. His mother and father came from two different hobbit families, the Tooks and the Bagginises both of which were very rich and respected. One day Bilbo received an unexpected visitor called Gandalf who turned out to be a very famous wizard. He persuades Bilbo to join him on an adventure along with thirteen dwarves who were going to try and reclaim a treasure which had been stolen form them many years before. The dwarves weren’t impressed by Bilbo but Gandalf assured them that he would become very helpful.

Read More
422 Words | 2 Pages

Bilbo’s adventures are a prophecy of the dwarves and are Bilbo’s stepping stones to his inner journey to look for his courage. Bilbo and the dwarves face many trials and in these trials Bilbo has to find his strength and become resourceful in order to fulfill his task as the dwarves’ thief.

Read More
858 Words | 4 Pages

The Hobbit; A Most Unexpected Journey In a hobbit hole, in The Hill, in Hobbiton, in the Shire, in Middle-Earth, sat a hobbit named Bilbo. Bilbo started off a safe hobbit, unknowing of the adventures that lay ahead of him. One afternoon, twelve hobbits and a wizard came over for a party that he didn’t know about. Two years later, he had outwitted a slimy creature, battled giant spiders, earned a share of a mountain full of treasure, and learned more than anyone in Hobbiton could teach him.

Read More
633 Words | 3 Pages

The second conflict is when Bilbo meets a hungry crazed creature named Gollum. Bilbo gets lost and comes across a dangerous creature who wants to eat him, named Gollum. Bilbo strikes a deal with Gollum that if he can stump him with a riddle, Gollum has to lead Bilbo back to the dwarves, and if Bilbo loses Gollum gets to eat Bilbo. Bilbo resolves his man vs man conflict by tricking Gollum with an especially difficult riddle, and using an invisibility ring that he stole from Gollum, to fool Gollum into showing him the exit. This triumph sparks a sort of courage in him.

Read More
414 Words | 2 Pages

While Odysseus and his crew are slowly moving away from Cyclopes Island, Odysseus tells Polyphemus that he is “Odysseus, Laertes’ son,” whose home “lies on Ithaca” (Homer 459 and 460). Because of his arrogant decision to tell Polyphemus the truth of his origins, he essentially dooms him and his crew. Polyphemus, who is Poseidon's son, asks of his father to punish Odysseus for his arrogance, whom grants his prayer. In cessation, Odysseus’ haughty decision to tell Polyphemus his whereabouts leads to his utter

Read More
1270 Words | 6 Pages

Along the way, they overcome many obstacles that threaten their lives and put their trust for one another to the test. Bilbo learns that there is more to him than he realizes and through hard work and dedication, he can accomplish almost anything. Overcoming these problems and learning more about himself helped Bilbo change from an ordinary, self-doubting hobbit into a clever, courage-filled, loyal hero. In the beginning, Bilbo has no desire to go on an adventure of any kind, but he quickly learns about the cleverness he obtains when he is forced to make quick decisions.

Read More

More about Differences And Similarities Between Odysseus And Bilbo

Related Topics

Open Document