ipl-logo

Differences Between Gayle Forman's If I Stay

803 Words4 Pages

When books are made into movies, some details tend to be lost in translation. When the book If I Stay by Gayle Forman was adapted into a major motion picture in 2014, several key details and events were distorted and changed. Some key differences between the movie and the book include what Mia and Adam, the two main characters’, first date is like, the relationship Mia has with her grandpa, and an important discussion that Mia has with her father that would later influence her decisions of going to college at Julliard. These differences are important because they impact how the reader, or watcher, interprets the story. Throughout the book and the movie, while Mia is in a coma, she undergoes a series of flashbacks. One of her flashbacks is the memory of how her and her boyfriend. Adam start dating. Amdam originally begins to like Mia when he sees her playing the cello, so he begins saving up money for a concert. In the book Adam takes Mia to see an unnamed female cellist, whereas in the book there is a huge emphasis on the the artist that they go see because it is Mia’s favorite cellist, Yo-Yo Ma. This difference is important because in the movie, it shows that Adam listens to Mia’s interest. The importance of seeing Yo-Yo Ma play in …show more content…

This moment is included in the book, but it is not present in the movie. In this scene, Mia is comforted by her grandpa when she expresses that she is nervous for the audition. This is important because it shows the bond that Mia has with her grandpa and how much they mean to each other. This memory of her grandfather makes it more difficult for Mia to choose life or death, as he does not want to live without her parents, but she does not want her grandparent to live without her. The fact that this is left out of the movie causes leaves a key detail to why Mia chooses to live out of the

Show More
Related
693 Words | 3 Pages

Both stories show how a person’s inner desires can alter the way their minds see and react to different situations. “Apple” is the story of a young girl who starts to imagine everyone’s parents

Read More
1455 Words | 6 Pages

To continue with the character differences, another main one is that in the book Hannah has a brother,Aaron, and Aunt Eva has a brother, Grandpa Will or Wolfe, who was with her in the camp. A somewhat minor difference is that Hannah is referred to as Hannah in both the dream and reality in the movie. In the book however, Hannah is referred to as Chaya in the dream and Hannah in reality. Not to mention that there was also more missing characters between the book and the movie. An example would be that there is no Gitl or Yitzchak in Hannah’s dream in the movie while there was in the book.

Read More
503 Words | 3 Pages

There is also a connection between these two since the author in both sections often says how much she misses other people in her family whom she left behind in Mexico, especially her mom who is supposedly considered as careless. The difference between these two excerpts, however, is that the author faces near-death experiences in the first one, whereas the second one is more peaceful and optimistic overall. This is evident from the change in author's use of tone. For example, the writer utilizes words such as "jeopardy" and "darkness" at first, then this switches to words such as "happy" and "perfect" after their crossing. The parts of the narrative that is presented in scenes are where her family attempts to cross the border and where her family goes to beach.

Read More
314 Words | 2 Pages

There are many simularities and differences in the book and movie " The

Read More
392 Words | 2 Pages

In the end I found the film to be easier to understand vs the book as it was an easier and more straight forward plot line whereas in the book it seemed to jump around leading to constant flipping between stories and pages to get a better

Read More
661 Words | 3 Pages

It provides a profound window into one of the most incredible stories to ever be told. As a reader you feel like a silent member of the family as Jeanette describes the events in such vivid detail and emotion. The raw emotion you feel from the words on a page are amplified tenfold as the movie brings the novel alive. The brilliance from the movie shines in the director’s choice of cuts, shots and music selection. A problem that most books turned novel is that the director tries to make the movie their own as opposed to building the movie on the foundation the book has already provided.

Read More
301 Words | 2 Pages

The format of the book changes your entire understanding of it, and the scenes of the movie change your understanding of the emotion. The way the author words the book changes how the reader thinks of it, for example, if

Read More
719 Words | 3 Pages

Yet the distinct differences between them also affect the plots to an extent to which the suspense in the movie is less compared to the novel. Although the differences greatly alter the two, it makes each of them unique and exclusive from each other. Despite these differences, there is one theme that links both the novel and the movie together: that people with different personalities, interests, and appearances are also the same to each other. The book shows more examples of this theme than the movie, making the novel more understanding to other individuals than the film itself. Because of this, we would recommend the book and film to those who experience a likeliness to the conflicts in each storyline, such as a fight between two different social

Read More
447 Words | 2 Pages

Another item that is extremely important in both stories is the use and importance of fate. Both characters rely on their fates for assistance and for achieving

Read More
817 Words | 4 Pages

If I Stay, a movie by R.J. Cutler and a book by Gayle Forman, has different flashbacks, character descriptions, and overall plots between the two types of media. The story centers on Mia, a high school student, who gets into a car crash with her family. However, this car crash is unlike any other. Mia is able to see herself and others through an out of body experience, but others cannot see or hear her. While Mia is in the hospital, she thinks back to memories with her family and friends, and as she nears her death, she decides whether to give up or to stay and fight for her life.

Read More
345 Words | 2 Pages

The movie and the book have similarities and differences In the book and the movie there is some similarities and there is some differences. There are a lot of differences, one of them is in the movie she never changes her name to F . Jasmine but in the book she does. In the movie she goes and looks for a dress for the wedding but in the book it never mentions anything

Read More
1221 Words | 5 Pages

World War One has the moniker “the War to End All Wars”; however, it was anything but that. World War One began due to the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, the heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne. However, historians believe that several smaller factors ultimately led to the bloodbath that was the First World War. The outcome was larger than what was anticipated due to the rise of militarism, the European system of alliances, imperialism, and nationalism. The scope of World War 1 grew due to untrained soldiers in 1914, Allied forces becoming more well trained in 1916, and both Allied and Axis soldiers being well trained by 1918.

Read More
703 Words | 3 Pages

However, as tension builds up in the conversation, the type of camera shot changes to a one shot. We now view each of them as an individual whenever they speak, unlike previously.   Above we see that Mia is almost engulfed by her background, as the soft green curtain is the only thing we are able to see behind her, forcing the audience to look upon the facial expressions on her face. Although the dialog has abruptly ended, you aware of her emotions because

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

In both stories, how she was treated by her stepsisters before meeting the prince, and Cinderella’s way in marrying the prince was the

Read More
885 Words | 4 Pages

Storytelling has been a part of people's’ lives since the beginning of time. It started with just verbal communication, then it was translated into written word, and now there hundreds of ways to tell those same stories. Movies and books, for example, are two very different ways to tell stories to an audience. A story can be a book, but not a movie or vice versa. Many books are made into movies, but lose major elements in translation.

Read More

More about Differences Between Gayle Forman's If I Stay

Related Topics

Open Document