ipl-logo

Discuss The Pros And Cons Of Nonviolent Protests

672 Words3 Pages

Pros and Cons of Nonviolent protests Around the world there has been a huge range of different protests about people’s strong beliefs. Some of these protests have been violent and some nonviolent. During this writing I am going to dive into some of the pros and cons of nonviolent protests to see how effective they were. I am going to explore different protests that I have researched to find out whether nonviolent protests are worth peoples time or to whether they should just go “all guns blazing” approach and make the protest violent. Firstly, I looked into finding some information about Americas protest background as I think Americans have some of the strongest beliefs which make the protests the most fascinating. In the USA between 1960 and 1995 protests were a lot more likely to be violent. I believe this is because they didn’t believe that a nonviolent process would get the job done. So, this is a disadvantage of nonviolent protests as sometimes sitting back and protesting just isn’t enough. People thought that nonviolent protests were weak and weren’t worth everyone’s time. Between this time there was “data on over 23000 protests” meaning that roughly 23000 protests were recorded within the 35 years. Many of these protests included behaviour such as, “use …show more content…

So, I read an article by Michael Fitzgerald who found out some statistics to whether nonviolent protests are good. He said, “from 1990 to 2015 about half of all nonviolent campaigns for regime change succeeded compared to about one quarter of violence insurgences”. So, this quote proves that nonviolent protests are actually more effective than violent ones. Violent protests are often good for causing short term success whereas nonviolent protests don’t really get that gain. However, as shown in the quote in the long run nonviolent protest are more likely to achieve the long-term

Show More
Related
119 Words | 1 Pages

The main idea is of this article is on the reason why protesters are protesting in the first place, not which methods of protesting they choose to

Read More
800 Words | 4 Pages

Cesar mentioned that, “If we resort to violence…the violence will be escalated and there will be many injuries and perhaps deaths on both sides, or there will be total demoralization of the workers” (Garcia, 77). He created this idea that violence does not solve anything, and will only create bigger problems. However, a nonviolent movement is a protest

Read More
533 Words | 3 Pages

When it comes to America's History you can clearly see how peaceful protest has brought this world to what it is today. If it wasn't for people such as Martin Luther King and Rosa Parks who voiced their opinions in a nonviolent manner, it's possible that our world would not have reached this equivalent state. While it is true that peaceful resistance has positively affected our society for centuries, these brave people have faced the consequences. For example, King was arrested after one of his nonviolent protests and sent to Birmingham Jail. While there he wrote the now famous piece "A Letter From Birmingham Jail".

Read More
1005 Words | 5 Pages

In this essay there will be a lot of contrasting between peaceful protest and violent protest.

Read More
821 Words | 4 Pages

This also establishes the overarching argument Chavez is trying to make, that nonviolent approaches allow for much better long-term results with less damage done to all parties involved in such

Read More
494 Words | 2 Pages

This ultimately explains how nonviolence is effective, justifies it, and makes it more favorable than violence. Chavez’s use of repetition, generalizations, and credibility effectively persuades everyone of nonviolence. In using multiple strategies, he constantly provides ways of nonviolence’s betterment compared to the pitfalls plaguing violence, and does so,

Read More
632 Words | 3 Pages

It is a sword that heals.” This quote by Martin Luther King Jr. inspired them to even think about staging a sit-in. Protesters were left alone by the police department, while people who became violent were prosecuted because this was a non-violent act. Many of the people who became violent were also arrested for trespassing. Participants in non-violent protests can introduce and inspire major changes.

Read More
526 Words | 3 Pages

Civil rights leader, Cesar Chavez, in his article about nonviolent resistance, written on the 10th anniversary of the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., justifies why non-violence is better. Chavez’s purpose is to argue that nonviolence is better than violence. He adopts a serious tone in order to prove that nonviolence is the solution to people in need. Chavez begins his article by relating nonviolence to power. This is followed by the claim that “nonviolence provides the opportunity to stay on the offensive.”

Read More
424 Words | 2 Pages

On the other hand, using nonviolence allows people to participate and fight for what they believe in through non-violent ways like boycotts, marches, and strikes. These effective nonviolent “weapons” allow people to fight for change and keep their sense of strength and justice which would have otherwise been lost through

Read More
671 Words | 3 Pages

“We advocate militant nonviolence as our means of achieving justice for our people, but we are not blind to the feeling of frustrations, impatience and anger” ( L.45 prompt). Chavez writes of an understanding referring to the positive effects of nonviolent resistance and the negative impact violence has on justice for minorities. He demonstrates a use of ethos, an appeal to the reader’s emotions, and their moral standards throughout his writing. He supports his point of nonviolent protest being the best solution to expresses a just and moral cause by using counter arguments and repetition of ideas. This article explores the possibilities that are within reach for the people who practice nonviolent strategies, and this passage explains the tactics

Read More
1922 Words | 8 Pages

Additionally, Chenoweth noted that nonviolent campaigns have succeeded less and became smaller than their historical counterparts in a downward trend since the 1990s. On the other hand, Chenoweth indicated that nonviolent confrontations, despite their lessening success rates, outperform violent ones by a four to one margin. As a result, the conflicting findings demonstrate a middle ground between purely nonviolent protests and those who embrace violent aspects of civil disobedience. Thus, for a civil-resistance movement to be effective, discipline plays a pivotal role in maintaining nonviolent principles but because of divergent views on the effectiveness of inhibiting violence in civil disobedience, discipline among movements may only work to an extent. Although some argue that nonviolent confrontations may be ineffective in pressurizing changes in discriminatory laws and policies if purely nonviolent, the addition of violence into a largely nonviolent confrontation lacks adherence to the principles of moral

Read More
357 Words | 2 Pages

My fellow activists, Based on results and movements in the past, non-violent resistance is the most effective form of protesting against injustice. It provides higher morals, positive influence, and possibility for a form of self defense that does not degrade the movement. Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. also agrees with this philosophy. As he once stated “Nonviolence offers the only road to freedom for my people”, this not only is peaceful, but a quote that inspires other activists to follow the same road of nonviolence.

Read More
1128 Words | 5 Pages

The consequences of peaceful protesting is, the marchers from Selma to Montgomery, had to go back and march three times. The first march wasn 't what they wanted to achieve and got sent back to the bridge. The second march was when they were crossing the bridge. The police officers attacked them with stick, teargas, clubs, arrested innocent people, guns were fired, knocked people to the ground, whips, rubber tubing wrapped in barbed wire was a weapon that the police officers whipped at the marchers. The third time they went to march, they won Federal Protection and they successfully marched for their cause.

Read More
234 Words | 1 Pages

Erica Chenoweth and Mari J. Stephan interprets the statistics in favour of nonviolence by arguing that the key elements for the success of nonviolence are participation rate which is mostly higher than violent resistance movements, and mobilization allowed by this participation (Chenoweth, Stephan, 2011, p.31). High participation may increase diversity and increased diversity will have three benefits: a) The more diverse members of movement are, the more people with different ethnicities and ideologies can be influenced which will increase the impact of the movement; b) It will retain the movement from being the subject of a single group and c) The higher number of people encourages more people by giving them the sense of security (Chenoweth,

Read More
794 Words | 4 Pages

Peaceful Resistance no matter what way you look at it, it 's still going against someone whether it involves words or actions, resistance still causes more conflict. The last 5 years we have had people say they want change through these “peaceful protest” but these peaceful protests have done nothing but turn to violent riots were theirs damage to vehicles, business families rely on destroyed, bystanders hurt, officers killed and our country torn apart. Back when Martian Luther King Jr was around and he had his Peaceful Resistance or rallies for equality, they were peaceful and brought our country together with something that needed to be changed, but the protest we’ve had the last 5 years… he would be ashamed of. Peaceful Resistance to laws does negatively impact our free society in America. First going along with what I said about there being “peaceful rallies” even though some people may be at these rallies to make a difference to support their opinion, not everyone can respect that.

Read More

More about Discuss The Pros And Cons Of Nonviolent Protests

Related Topics

Open Document