ipl-logo

Dr Grimesby Roylott Compare And Contrast Essay

851 Words4 Pages

Aadya Sharma
Skalisky
Language Arts
15 February 2023
Dr. Grimesby Roylott: Compare & Contrast
The Adventure of the Speckled Band: Compare and Contrasting Dr. Roylott
“The Adventure of the Speckled Band” is considered to be one of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's best works, with all the best elements of a Victorian murder mystery and unique gothic elements. Dr. Grimesby Roylott is the antagonist of “The Adventure of the Speckled Band ” in both the original book by Arthur Conan Doyle and the 1984 movie adaptation, part of the series of The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, directed by John Bruce. In “The Speckled Band ”, sleuthing detective and Sherlock Holmes and his associate Dr. John Watson met Helen Stoner, the stepdaughter of Dr. Grimesby …show more content…

In the film, he has a more cruel and brutish personality, often spoke of in hushed and fearful tones by Helen Roylott. During her meeting with Holmes and Watson, she states that he had taken part in “a series of disgraceful brawls” and describes him as “the terror of the village”. These details greatly shaped how the audience perceived him as these are the first details revealed about him, not including the fleeting scene at the very beginning. In comparison, the text does not go into much detail about him or his personality in the so he is almost never portrayed like that. Due to his lack of appearances, he seems to be more of a cunning and reclusive antagonist in the book, quietly plotting in the shadows. These small but noticeable details can cause a big difference on the type of villain the audience sees him as. The fact that even his own stepdaughter found him scary greatly transformed the way he was represented in the …show more content…

Sometimes these changes are minor, other times these changes can drastically change the perception of the characters. An example can be noticed in the movie when Dr. Roylott barges into Holmes’ office and exclaims, “Which of you is Holmes?” According to the movie, he said it in a very demanding manner, and was clearly outraged. This was shown in the text as well, however, he did not seem to be as furious as the movie. This may be due to a change in perception, as the text is shown from Watson’s point of view while the movie was in third person. However, his behavior in many scenes in the movie was still exaggerated when compared to the

Show More
Related
737 Words | 3 Pages

An example of this is the description of the forest. In the movie, it sounds beautiful and full of life. But in the movie, it sounds overgrown and not as pleasant. Another example of this is the lake by the Tuck’s house. In the book it seems to have more movement and goes better with Angus’s analogy for life, “It’s a wheel, Winnie.

Read More
871 Words | 4 Pages

Eliezer Wiesel and Jeanne Wakatsuki have very many things in common through rough experiences in the camps they were in. Eliezer and Jeanne have a lot in common like how they both changed personality’s throughout the story, how they showed fear in many situations, and lastly they both learned from these hard experiences. Even though Eliezer and Jeanne can relate in many ways they are actually quite different and experienced different things. For instance, Eliezer was not obstinate like Jeanne. Also, there was a point in the novel where he was completely alone while Jeanne had her family with her throughout the whole time in the camp.

Read More
664 Words | 3 Pages

How a character presents themselves and the manner in which they speak can play a monumental role in how the audience perceives and characterizes that person, which is why Walls and King both pay special attention to creating

Read More
505 Words | 3 Pages

Comparison and Contrast Analysis “A Study in Contrasts” In his essay “A Study in Contrasts,” Bruce Catton effectively delineates the extreme contrasts between Civil War generals Ulysses S. Grand and Robert E. Lee, but also describes their surprising similarities. Cattons’s purpose in employing comparison and contrast in his essay is to describe the differences in the two Civil War generals from the North and the South and how their colossal differences reflect the sectional tensions that lead to the war, but also how they have remarkably similar fighting qualities that help pave to road to peace after war. For instance, he corroborates that Lee was an aristocrat that valued tradition and culture. Catton states that Lee believed that men were

Read More
1187 Words | 5 Pages

Sherlock Holmes Argumentative Essay While Sherlock Holmes habitually portrayed a considerate, helpful man, it was certain he felt not a twinge of guilt concerning the death of Dr. Grimesby Roylott. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s story entitled “The Adventure of the Speckled Band” features the famous detective with a shocking turn of events during the resolution, when it was revealed Sherlock Holmes was responsible for a poisonous snake bringing the end of Dr. Roylott’s hostile life. This event did not catalyze shame inside of him, though, as each man felt harsh despising towards one another. Furthermore, Sherlock Holmes could not have known the snake would kill Dr. Roylott. Lastly, it was the irrational decision of Dr. Roylott that caused his death, arguably more than Sherlock Holmes’ cane did.

Read More
1043 Words | 5 Pages

Some situations are magnified to help clarify or even change how we feel about a character. The characters change and grow as new information is revealed.

Read More
666 Words | 3 Pages

“The Adventure of the Speckled Band” Argumentative Essay In “The Adventure of the Speckled Band” by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Dr. Roylott was bitten by the swamp adder, forcing Sherlock Holmes to feel guilty. For numerous reasons, Sherlock Holmes could not have been directly responsible for Dr. Roylott’s death. In the beginning, Sherlock Holmes was paid to protect Helen, along with himself.

Read More
354 Words | 2 Pages

Evolution is defined as a “process of change” and sin leads to changes in a person’s life. Hester Prynne was guilty of adultery. She committed the sin with Arthur Dimmesdale. In addition, Hester wears a scarlet letter in the form of an A on her dress as a sign of shame, but Dimmesdale has a burnt A on his chest, that is not visible to the public. Although they bear some minor similarities, the differences between Hester’s and Dimmesdale’s responses to their guilt are pronounced.

Read More
1344 Words | 6 Pages

Living Somewhere in Between Good and evil are present within every person one will encounter in his/her life. Is it better for to just solely focus on the good and live life blissfully ignorant, or to focus on just the bad and live life aware and depressed? Is it easier to focus on the bad in others and ignore its presence in oneself? Nathaniel Hawthorne portrays both of these situations in his stories “Young Goodman Brown” and “The Minister’s Black Veil,” showing the reader that the world is not simply black and white. There is a grey, blended area for one to live in that allows him/her to live peaceful but not ignorant.

Read More
994 Words | 4 Pages

Malcolm Bradbury once said ¨Culture is a way of coping with the world by defining it in detail.¨ meaning culture can influence how people can see the world. Cultural background can also affect how people see the world.cultural background affect perspective as evidence the stories "An Ordinary Man" by Paul Rusesabagina,¨Desiree's baby¨ by Kate Chopin, and ¨The Lottery¨ by Shirley Jackson shows how cultural background affects them. In Paul Rusesabagina's "An Ordinary Man," the author provides insights into how cultural background affects perspective. Rusesabagina, a Rwandan man, reflects on the events leading up to the genocide that occurred in his home country in 1994. He writes, "As an African, I was brought up to believe that the community is more important than the individual.

Read More
878 Words | 4 Pages

Overall the character development and viewpoints were carefully thought out and without the minor details being picked out above the characters were portrayed

Read More
823 Words | 4 Pages

Because of this transition, there were drastic changes made to the movie, but also there were similarities that had to be kept in order to maintain the original ideas of the book. Characters are the center of any movie or work of literature. How they are developed and portrayed makes an impact on the

Read More
462 Words | 2 Pages

When asked about cheerleading most people tend to think the obvious, like It’s a female sport, or It’s not a sport at all just girls on the side line supporting other athletes. Well, there has been a change in the game that people will either accept or debate because of its history or because of its future. For over a year now cheerleading has been declared as a legal sport, “High School cheerleading would become an official school sport in California under legislation that passed the Assembly on Monday. Assembly Bill 949, which passed on a 71-3 vote, would have the California Interscholastic Federation regulate competition cheer like other sports, which the bill’s author said would mean better safety and coaching training standards and potentially more resources for cheerleaders.” (White, 1) Due to all the changes and difficulty skills needed for example flexability, strength and even tumbling it

Read More
732 Words | 3 Pages

Holmes and Watson’s antagonist in the novel is the logic aspect of the case. For example, Holmes says “Of course, if...we are dealing with forces outside the ordinary laws of Nature, there is an end to our investigation. But we are bound to exhaust all other hypotheses before falling back to this one.” Also, in the novel, the logical solution and evidence is explained in further detail, for Holmes gives “a sketch of the course of events from memory” in the resolution. There are many subplots in the novel, such as Seldon’s escape, Sir Henry and Mrs. Stapleton, and Sir Charles Baskerville and Laura Lyons, which answered many questions about the case and evidence against Stapleton.

Read More
621 Words | 3 Pages

“Adventure of the Speckled Band” Persuasive essay Sherlock Holmes was undoubtedly, not responsible, for the death of Dr. Grimesby Roylott. There are many examples of why Sherlock Holmes is not responsible for the death such as Sherlock Holmes had no way to locate Roylott in the adjacent room, Dr. Grimesby Roylott had clearly tried to kill Helen many more times that she suspected and lastly, Dr. Grimesby Roylott’s had a violent temper. Since Dr. Roylott had a violent temper.

Read More

More about Dr Grimesby Roylott Compare And Contrast Essay

Related Topics

Open Document