ipl-logo

Essay On Electoral College

952 Words4 Pages

Lola Cleverley American Government Mr. Baker 2 March 2023 The Electoral College vs. The District Method The Electoral College is the system by which the United States elects our president. The number of electors each state gets is based on its representation in Congress, 1 vote for every senator and representative. The electors vote for the candidate that got the most votes in the state, meaning winner takes all the votes. The electoral college has always successfully chosen a president and benefited small states. However, in the more recent years there has been much debate as to whether or not this system works for our country. There have been five times when the winner of the popular vote loses the election leaving citizens wondering …show more content…

Instead of ‘winner takes all’, the winner would receive one vote per congressional district won, with the popular vote winner gaining an additional two votes per state. This method would be easy to implement because people already know how it works. Maine and Nebraska are the only two states currently using this method, so people are familiar with the idea. Likewise, it’s similar to the way the House of Representatives are voted in, meaning American voters would understand how and why we are using this method. The constitution states in Article II, Section 1, Clause 2, “Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of electors…”. This gives each state the freedom to choose how the electoral votes are chosen. Significantly, the district method is constitutional and has already proven to work in two states. Admittedly, it is known that gerrymandering can take place using congressional districts. While this is a big problem, our legislation will have to do their best to prevent gerrymandering from changing the election. This is only one flaw of the district method and does not outweigh the benefits and positives this method …show more content…

This method is already used in Maine and Nebraska and has proven to work successfully in both states. Voters already understand congressional districts so it makes the process easier to implement. Both candidates have a true and accurate shot at winning the election and a more precise winner will be chosen. Last, this will persuade more voters to show up and cast their vote, because they will believe their vote will actually make a difference. Overall, the congressional district method will show more benefits than drawbacks and will change the future of voting and electing presidents

Show More
Related
1456 Words | 6 Pages

I propose that the population decides how much representatives a state has. Which would mean that states with a large population would contain more representatives than

Read More
910 Words | 4 Pages

While this is a system that is working and has worked before, it is not entirely fair. The Electoral College has its flaws. For starters, third parties are given virtually no chance to win the electoral vote. The amount of electors for each state doesn’t give all states a fair amount of power and the electoral system as a whole undermines

Read More
686 Words | 3 Pages

If neither candidate has a majority of the electoral votes, then our House of Representatives votes for our next president. There is a way to exploit this part of the system. Each state is split into a certain number of congressional districts; one for every house member they have. These districts are supposed to be drawn in a way that allows each district to have an equal number of people. However, gerrymandering happens when one party draws these lines in a way that favors their group.

Read More
904 Words | 4 Pages

Several years after the United States came to be, the Constitutional Convention met to determine how the new nation should govern itself. The delegates saw that it was crucial to have a president and vice president, but the delegates did not want these offices to reflect how the colonies were treated under the British rule. The delegates believed that the president’s power should be limited, and that he should be chosen through the system known as the Electoral College. The Electoral College is a body of people who represent the states of the US, who formally cast votes for the electing of the president and vice president. Many citizens feel that the Electoral College goes against our nation’s principle of representative democracy, while others

Read More
796 Words | 4 Pages

Electoral college has been with us since the birth of the constitution, and to this day we are still using this type of system to this day. The Electoral College is a system that the United States uses to elect our upcoming presidents and vice presidents. Each state has electors equal to their senate member and house of representatives, however who ever gets the highest popular vote in the state gets the electoral vote. The issue is the Electoral College do not give votes to the people, but to the states. Which has some unfair consequences.

Read More
1334 Words | 6 Pages

Through this method of choosing, the candidates with the most votes win, thus not equally representing a possible larger majority that could have been fragmentized by many candidates. It is possible that the candidate that wins just won because they are the larger of the minorities that ran in the election. Under this model, a majority of people could end up being represented by someone they did not vote for as their representative. A solution to this would be to incorporate proportional representation during elections to represent the composition of the public more accurately, but still apply a moderately high minimum percentage threshold in order to prevent extensive fragmentation and a massive amount of new parties. A truly proportional representation isn’t completely necessary, but can be incorporated more into state elections to form a more mixed system.

Read More
1334 Words | 6 Pages

This system should be retained. All the voters in one district tend to cast one vote for their candidate. The geographically defined regions form districts which send one representative to the legislature. The design tends to make it hard for new parties to enter and compete.

Read More
184 Words | 1 Pages

“The Electoral College was created by the Founders because they did not trust people enough to allow them to directly elect the president.” Since the majority of the American people had limited education and communication, the founders felt the “average voter lacked the information to be an informed, unbiased judge of candidates for presidency.” Therefore when voters cast their ballot, the college reviews the peoples’ choices and then decides which of their preferences are best. (Lenz and Holman, 87) Many people feel that this system is undemocratic because they are not able to directly vote for their candidate and because the winner of the popular vote can lose the electoral vote.

Read More
1026 Words | 5 Pages

Granted a candidate would almost never win all eleven states because the majority of these states tend to be predominantly democrat or republic, the fact that only eleven states alone can determine who 's the president puts to question the value of the remaining 39 states. Document B, explains the winner-take-all method and how unfair the method is to third party candidates. The chart shows how even though both third party candidates won about 7% and 19% of the popular vote but won 0% of the electoral vote. In Document E, Will states “the winner-take-all electoral vote allocation tends to produce a winning margin that looks like national decisiveness” There are over 300 million people in the United States, but just 538 people get to decide

Read More
2190 Words | 9 Pages

Christopher Pearson gives us an interesting piece of data that “the winner-take-all rule is why 70% of American voters are ignored”(NCSL Website). This statistic states that a majority of voters’ votes are meaningless overall, as the winner takes all system overrules their vote. This statistic shows the people’s ideologies of being able to vote for their presidential candidate and to have an equal say as everybody else is not being followed as it ignores many of the voter’s votes in order to give all of the electors to one presidential candidate, rather than splitting the electors among the electoral candidate in either a popular vote of the state, or by regions of the state. However, for the political parties, the winner takes all system helps their political parties much more than it does for the people. Pearson gives as an example that the winner takes all system “gave then-candidate Donald Trump all of Pennsylvania’s twenty electors the moment he got one vote more than Hillary Clinton inside Pennsylvania” (NSCL Website), stating that the political parties had much more benefit to this system by not having to worry about certain states, such as California and Texas.

Read More
162 Words | 1 Pages

This week’s lesson gave me more clarity on the-the Electoral College. It was confusing at first to hear that the popular vote does not win an election. Bush lost the popular votes, but won the electoral vote in 2000, cleared by the Supreme Court (POLS201). I think it is better for the candidate to worry about the crucial electoral votes than the popular votes.

Read More
976 Words | 4 Pages

Each district will be formed with population and land area taken into equal account to form a group of districts that are equally balanced demographically. The popular vote of each of the three-five districts will be counted as a point to a candidate in a general election, sizing down the electoral college to a mare inclusive voice. In state referendums, each district will represent itself. Districts will be sectioned off by experts on demographics and bipartisan political analysts to make each one more balanced. They will

Read More
826 Words | 4 Pages

Electoral College has maintained for hundreds of years and it’s time for a change because of the more and more serious problems it is causing. These are some reasons why we should consider replacing this system with a new more efficient one. Firstly, Electoral College creates the possibility for the candidate who loses the popular vote but wins the electoral vote to become president. In the much-publicized election of 2000, Vice President Al Gore beat Governor George W. Bush by more than 500,000 votes in the national popular tally but lost in the Electoral College because of a last-minute, 537-vote margin in Florida .

Read More
469 Words | 2 Pages

The Electoral College began with Article II of the Constitution, stating that each state will appoint as many electors as it is entitled senators and representatives. (Levin-Waldman, 2016) The president of the United States is elected by what is called the Electoral College. There are a total of 538 electoral votes cast, and all candidates elected to run for office from their respective party needs 270 in order to win. “For most states, the candidate who wins a majority of votes in that state takes all of its electors.

Read More
975 Words | 4 Pages

The Electoral College is the process to which the United States elects the President, and the Vice President. The founders of the Constitution came up with this process. This was done to give additional power to the small states, and it was done to satisfy them. It works by the citizens of the United States electing representatives called electors. Each state is given the same amount of electors, as they are members of congress.

Read More

More about Essay On Electoral College

Open Document