ipl-logo

Essay On The Dred Scott Case

483 Words2 Pages

The majority decision of the Dred Scott case in 1857, was unconstitutional. As a slave wanted his freedom he was denied said freedom by the courts.

The Dred Scott case was all about a slave who wanted freedom because he said the Constitution allowed him his freedom. As it precisely does, in it, it says, as the first 3 words of the Constitution “We the People” with no specifications or criteria. Just “People” nothing else. Thats for a good reason as well no criteria needs to exist to define a person in that context, the only difference between Caucasians and African Americans is the amount of melanin in each of our bodies. Frederick Douglass once said “..not we, the citizens, or the legal voters” showing that even back then, African Americans were still treated as lesser peoples. Not able to vote at all and were not considered citizens, even with the lack of criteria in the Constitution.

Some believed that the Declaration of Independence should not and was not meant to include African Americans. In the Dred Scott majority opinion they believed it to be “conclusive” that the Declaration of Independence was not meant to include the “enslaved African race”. They were meant to be “excluded from civilised government and doomed to slavery”. They were under the impression that slaves were property and that they had the right to …show more content…

As a slave wanted his freedom he was denied said freedom by the courts.The majority reason had no valid points, all it had was assumptions. As previously stated any existing human being should be considered apart of “We the People” and anyone who says otherwise does not know the definition of unconstitutional. Due to the fact that the Constitution only said “people” with no qualifiers; Which meant slaves were supposed to be included in the Constitution. So if you were to disagree your opinion would be unconstitutional. Therefore the majority decision was

Show More
Related

Summary Of Our Declaration By Danielle Allen

1675 Words | 7 Pages

However, the overwhelming realities of the Black American experience disallow any optimism to truly shine. Not only does Sinha discuss the lack of a specific definition of what it means to be an American citizen in the Declaration, but also that it allowed for a sense of White nationalism to take place due to the absence of the Black community being mentioned. Seventeen years after the Revolutionary War ended, the 1790 Naturalization Act was passed to only allow White immigrants into the US (Sinha, 1). Shortly after, a slew of laws were passed aiming to disenfranchise Black people and support the view that Black people were property rather than citizens with legislature like the Fugitive Slave Act of 1793 (Sinha, 1). The Declaration of Independence is a document that to Allen fights for equality and freedom, with the potential to answer the question of who is a citizen and finally include those unmentioned in the document itself.

Read More

Slavery In Joseph J. Ellis's Founding Brothers

946 Words | 4 Pages

Never directly mentioned in the Constitution, and commonly refereed to as “others”, African Americans were often denied existence in the Constitutional Conventions. James Madison embodied the complacency of the average white American man. Ellis describes his thinking as “a kind of mysterious region where ideas entered going in one direction but then emerged headed the opposite way.” (114). The Southern founding fathers, Madison included, acknowledged the moral evils of the slave trade but many of them slave owners themselves, did not desire an end to it, admittedly for their own profit.

Read More

Civil War Dbq Essay

1104 Words | 5 Pages

Southerners believed they had a right to have slaves on their land because they technically owned them as property and going against the Fifth Amendment would be unconstitutional. A few cases, such as the Dred Scott case, tried to counter this statement. In the Dred Scott case, a man named Dred Scott, who lived in Missouri, was taken from his home and moved to Minnesota, which was a free state. He argued that since he was living in a free state, he should be free. However, Roger B. Taney, the Supreme Court Justice of this case, ruled that Congress never had the right to prohibit slavery in any territory and that “free territory” did not really exist.

Read More

The Controversy: The Dred Scott Case Of 1857

643 Words | 3 Pages

When one holds a prestigious position on the United States Supreme Court, they possess the opportunity to alternate the future of the country. However, that impulse should not be entertained in the majority of instances, as with the Dred Scott Case of 1857. Although that conflict should have dissolved after the subject dissolved, Chief Justice Roger Taney allegedly overextended his reach to determine the legality of another issue that had troubled the United States. In addition, the decision decided on the case itself negates the framework of the U.S. Constitution by infringing on an individual’s rights, regardless of who they might be. At the time of the Dred Scott Decision, the United States had become deadlocked over the controversy

Read More

Civil War Dbq Essay

871 Words | 4 Pages

Dred Scott was a slave who tried to sue his owner because he said since he lived in a free state he was a free man. The north went on to back up the dred scott by using the missouri compromise and that in the constitution the writers meant “we the people” as everybody including slaves, so that gives them the rights of a citizen. The south had many arguments one being the missouri compromise was unconstitutional and congress couldn’t tell states if they could be free or slave and what the can do with their property. Lastly slaves or former slaves for that matter had no rights of a citizen. In document H the fugitive slave act of 1850 it talks about how slave owners have the right to claim their slaves if they escape no matter where they escape to.

Read More

How Did The Constitution Allow Slavery To Continue?

400 Words | 2 Pages

Therefore, freeing the slaves was not important. All men aren’t created equally as shown in these times. The belief that slavery was wrong, was not strong enough for the the Constitution to overcome. Mr. Freehling said, “The only way Africans could be free was if they were sent back to Africa”.

Read More

Opposition To Slavery Dbq Essay

1173 Words | 5 Pages

They al-so believed that demand for abolition of slavery was unconstitutional, upheld by the Supreme Court in the Dred Scott decision, which upheld slaves as property, protected from confiscation by the 5th amendment. They also asserted that cohabitation of slav-ery and freedom was possible due to its very existence, and considered themselves to be aiding in the protection of an inferior race, not physically capable of surviving in American societies like the North. The South, however, did little to “aid” in the integra-tion or preparation for blacks to assimilate. Most planation owners forbid slaves from learning to read or write. The South also saw justification in slavery in how poorly freed African Americans, along with the rest of the immigrant population, were treated in hor-rid factory conditions and poverty and disease stricken cities of the

Read More

Civil War Dbq Essay

1033 Words | 5 Pages

Another example of growing sectional divisions over the issue of slavery spreading is the Dred Scott Decision of 1857 (Doc 9). In this court case, the U.S. supreme court ruled that slaves have no rights, and that slavery was free to expand into the territories. This decision pleased southern defenders of slavery, and angered northern abolitionists, further dividing the

Read More

1815 To 1850 Dbq Essay

985 Words | 4 Pages

According to document 3, digital history, growth of the African-American population in 2016 the claim shows that when the population of African-Americans have increased so have the number of slaves that are African Americans over 40 years, this shows that this group of people were treated unfairly because more and more people have became slaves other that free men. The number has increased by over 2 million African-American slaves over 40 years This is just one way to show that they did not have equal political, social, or economical rights as free men. Also according to document 4 Charles Mackay, life and Liberty in America: or sketches of a tour in the United States and Canada in 1857-1858 London 1859. ”We shall not make the black man a slave; we shall not buy him or sell him; but we shall not associate with him.” Through his observation he was able to see that even free men were not treated equally like the Declaration was meant to do.

Read More

History Of The Scottsboro Trial

489 Words | 2 Pages

The forefathers of the United States built this country on the ideals of freedom and equality for all people. Unfortunately, the fight for equality and freedom did not end with the revolutionary war. The fight has continued throughout the decades. Many of these issues were fought in the courtroom. Auburn University created an online Alabama Encyclopedia, there, the following quote stated, “Scottsboro became an international cause celebre that dramatically encapsulated the American south troubled post reconstruction history of legal and extralegal racial violence, the social and political upheaval of the great depression, and the lingering cultural divide between the north and south.”

Read More

The Dred Scott Decision

335 Words | 2 Pages

he Dred Scott decision of 1857 was a significant decision made by the U.S. Supreme Court that declared that blacks, regardless of whether they were free or a slave, had no legal standing because they were not American citizens. The decision was not the first to be made regarding Dred Scott; a Missouri jury ruled in Scott 's favour when Scott claimed that his residence in Illinois and Wisconsin made him free, but the state supreme court ruled against him, which lead to the case being escalated to the US Supreme Court. The US Supreme Court ruled against Scott 7-2. The Dred Scott decision is considered a landmark decision and is indicative of the tumultuous political climate of the time.

Read More

Dbq Civil Rights Movement

1354 Words | 6 Pages

The founding documents such as the Constitution were created by the people and for the people, however, these people were white, land owning men. The Constitution was created to help establish “a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty and prosperity”(Document 1). The men that created the Constitution were set in the ideas of natural rights for all human beings and the basic freedom of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. However, they neglected to apply these ideas to the people in their own country such as African Americans.

Read More

Slavery Vs Federalism

611 Words | 3 Pages

The Dred Scott V. Sanford case of 1857 declared that African Americans were not citizens of the United States and did not receive the same support from the Federal Government. During this time the Congress also lacked the power to ban slavery in all territories belonging to the United States. In 1850 Dred Scott and his family were declared free under the state court however, this did not last long. The Supreme Court of Missouri revoked the Scott’s family freedom which led him to take his case to the U.S. Supreme Court. The U.S. Supreme Court denied him citizenship of the U.S. even if he was a citizen of a free state.

Read More

Cause And Effect Of The Scottsboro Boys Trial

610 Words | 3 Pages

The trial of the Scottsboro boys was a trial that was the cause of two white women accusing nine black men of raping them. Their appeals, retrials, and legal proceedings attracted the attention of the nation and produced to Supreme Court rulings in their favor. The Scottsboro boys trial demonstrates that nonconformity to unjust practices can lead to justice for all people because their trial triggered The Supreme Court ruling that had a major impact on the American system of laws for the right to adequate counsel, the ruling for the right to not be excluded from a jury based on race, and still has a continuing effect in our own time which affirms the principle of equal protection under the law. Their case not only saved them from the death sentence but also started up debate about equal protection under the law such as in the first Supreme Court ruling.

Read More

Example Of Black Inequality Essay

585 Words | 3 Pages

Richard Allen wrote that when he and his ‘brothers’ went to St. George church in Fourth Street, the people from that church had treated them unfairly. For example, he and other black peoples had been placed around the walls when people get numerous attending the church. Besides, during the Sabbath morning they were asked to go to the gallery by the sexton and they also were asked to give up their seats to white people even though they were praying at that time. All in all, even though in the Declaration of Independence people are said to have equal rights because all men are created equal, we can clearly see that what actually happened in the United States after the Declaration of Independence was written were really contradict with what written in that doctrine. In other words, there are inconsistencies between the principles that being put up in the Declaration of Independence and the continual presence of slavery, as black people seems like they did not receive the unalienable

Read More

More about Essay On The Dred Scott Case

Related Topics

Open Document