ipl-logo

Ethical Issues In The Case Of Richard Moore

3117 Words13 Pages

Richard Moore was tried and convicted of robbing a convenience store, murdering the clerk of the store in the process. He was sentenced to death, despite his defenses’ claims that he had no intention of robbing the store or committing the murder. Issues emerged throughout his trial, appeals, and the execution process, such as ineffective counsel, possible discrimination and arbitrariness, the state’s refusal to reevaluate his case, and lethal injection drug issues in his state of South Carolina. In this paper, I engage with the works of Michel Foucault, Mona Lynch, Timothy Kaufman-Osborn, William Bowers, and Austin Sarat, as well as Baze v. Rees, Glossip v. Gross, and Bucklew v. Precythe to explore how Richard Moore’s constitutional challenge …show more content…

Though the court did, however, concede that a state could fall in violation of the 8th amendment if an inmate offers a known and available alternative method of execution, and it is not granted without a proper justification (Baze v. Rees, 553 U.S. 2 2008). Through this, a test of constitutionality was estalblished, providing that a challenge must include evidence of significant pain, as well as a known and readily available alternative. Glossip v. Gross is often discussed in tandem with Baze, as they both challenged the constitutionality of execution by lethal injection. Glossip emerged when an inmate in Oklahoma had woken up during his execution and suffering for forty minutes before death. The tree-drug protocol was reevaluated, and a new protocol emerged, one that used one of the drugs from the first. This prompted seveal challenges to the constitutionality of the new protocol, which the Supreme Court held was constitutional, as the test previously established in Baze had not been adequately met by the …show more content…

In the disappearance of punishment as a spectacle, a private sphere of pain and punishment emerges, one that came under the guise of “humanity” (Foucault 8). Though bodily pain was still present in this new sphere, it was often hidden, especially from the public eye. This punishment focused on interiorization, the punishment of the soul, a punishment shaping the souls of inmates through “supervision and constraint” (Foucault 29). This creates a fake illusion of humane-ness within the criminal justice system. In Moore’s election of death by firing squad, the proceduralization, or “timetable” that Foucault explores is made clear through the details of the process. In this execution style multiple executioners fire live ammunition at the inmate, after a separate guard places a hood on their head and a target at their heart. This division of tasks creates the illusion of bureaucracy and medicalization, though it appears more obvious within lethal injection executions. Bullet-proof glass was also installed for witnesses to see the execution live, suggesting that the “public spectacle” that Foucault suggests is still present today, in a more private and restrained setting. The psychological pain suffered from such an execution as one by a firing squad is sure to be enough to constitute cruel and unusual punishment,

Show More
Related
284 Words | 2 Pages

New York Times (NYT) column-writer, conversely a certified lawyer, Adam Liptak, in his article, “Supreme Court Rejects Alabama Death Row Inmate’s Appeal”, describes how a death-row inmate from Alabama requests death by a firing squad as opposed to lethal injection, that contains the sedative midazolam, for his death sentence, but was rejected by the Supreme Court of the United States. Liptak’s purpose is to demonstrate that the Supreme Court’s decision to reject the appeal may have been unconstitutional due to the means of execution by lethal injection causing “prolonged torture” rather than a quick death due to midazolam, which disputes the eighth amendment in the Bill of Rights, the first ten amendments of the U.S. Constitution. Liptak develops

Read More
661 Words | 3 Pages

In its third execution of 2022, Arizona executed Murray Hooper for a 1980 crime that was never analyzed using modern forensic methods. In the days preceding his execution, his attorneys continued to request DNA testing and pursued new claims of prosecutorial misconduct based on evidence not revealed until Hooper’s clemency hearing. All challenges to his conviction and death penalty have failed. In an investigative report published the day before Hooper’s scheduled execution, Liliana Segura of The Intercept reviewed the issues of race, misconduct, and innocence that have been central to Hooper’s legal challenges.

Read More
636 Words | 3 Pages

Homicides are unlike many others, since one’s intentions are discrete as soon as they have a reason to murder. Threatened obligations are innumerable due to the character's personality and their way of thinking into certain circumstances, although a distinct detail can affect the situation. When little to none consequences have any impact to the “murderer” who caused victim's injury, or death, they are responsible regardless of what their intentions are. For instance, a distressed officer, U.S. Marshal Edward Mars, pleaded to end his miserable life due to the pain he was suffering from the shrapnel. Everyone in the camp suggests the cruel deed.

Read More
851 Words | 4 Pages

The issue in this case is whether the imposition of the sentence of death for the crime of murder under the law of Georgia violated the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments. Gregg argued that the sentencing procedure allows for arbitrary grants of mercy that reflects a misinterpretation and ignores the reviewing authority of the Georgia Supreme Court to determine whether each death sentence is proportional to other sentencing for similar crimes. Gregg was pleading for a life sentence instead of death. Georgia argued that the statute did not constitute a cruel and unusual punishment and did not violate the Eighth and Fourteenth amendments. Georgia also argued and proved that there must be specific jury findings as to the circumstances of the crime to determine whether the death sentence was fair for the case.

Read More
1434 Words | 6 Pages

David Oshinksy’s most recent book, Capital Punishment on Trial: Furman v. Georgia and the Death Penalty in Modern America, focuses on the extremely controversial yet important issue of capital punishment in the United States. Oshinsky’s text covers the debated topic in a scholarly yet concise way. With the text being a mere 125 pages, he covers the prolonged, contentious history of the death penalty. At the beginning of the book, Oshinsky describes what occurred in the early hours of August 11, 1967. William Micke was suddenly murdered in the hallway of his house by William Henry Furman, a disabled, illiterate 24 year old who had a troubled past with law enforcement.

Read More
872 Words | 4 Pages

The most important issue that must be addressed in this case is the principle of the “evolving standards of decency” and the uses of a national consensus. The “evolving standards of decency” were developed by Trop v. Dulles and have been implemented in one way or another in all of the precedents dealing with “cruel and unusual” punishment. It is important to treat these principles as an important aspect of “cruel and unusual” punishment jurisprudence, therefore turning from these set of principles would be foolish and a disregard for every precedent. However, it is important to acknowledge that each case satisfies the standards by using a different method; some use the presence or lack of state legislature as a judgment of consensus while others look at foreign countries.

Read More
314 Words | 2 Pages

Sherman Alexie’s “Capital Punishment” made me feel sad when reading it. I have always believed that America can do something other than execution of criminals. Something that surprised me in this poem was when the speaker says, “but the killer doesn’t want much: baked potato, salad, tall glass of ice water” (3-4). I always thought of criminal’s last meals being extravagant. I always thought their last meal would be expensive and something they don’t have very often.

Read More
475 Words | 2 Pages

The prisoners had seen and experienced so much brutality, endured repeated beatings, and humiliated beyond imagination, so one more death did not affect them. Their emotions hardened to the point of being non-existent… or so they thought. Although the prisoners seemed hardened and unaffected by death, a different hanging did deeply affect them.

Read More
754 Words | 4 Pages

(Greenblatt and Smith 21). This reference to the death sentence is an excellent way to keep the reader engaged and evoke an emotional response from the audience since they already have an opinion on the matter and also gained insight as to why some states have a death penalty while others

Read More
976 Words | 4 Pages

His enjoyment of the event shows that public executions are a means to amuse the public, rather than a solemn punishment. Syme’s desensitized reaction to such cruelty showcases how the Party has cultivated a society in which people are numb to the horrors of violence. In addition, executions are shown to be a monthly occurrence, becoming a consistent practice for the

Read More
430 Words | 2 Pages

Foucault starts by differentiating two types of punishment: the fierce and clamorous open torment of Robert-François Damiens, who was sentenced endeavored regicide in the mid-eighteenth century, and the very controlled day by day plan for detainees from a mid nineteenth century jail (Mettray). These cases give a photo of exactly how significant the adjustments in western reformatory frameworks were after not as much as a century. Foucault needs the peruser to consider what prompted these progressions and how did western society move so radically.[3] He trusts that the nature's topic of these progressions is best asked by expecting that they weren't utilized to make a more philanthropic correctional framework, nor to all the more precisely rebuff or restore, however as a feature of a proceeding with direction of subjection. Foucault needs to tie logical

Read More
531 Words | 3 Pages

“ Delware,Washington, and New Hampshere use hanging as a primary method in place of lethal injection” ( Methods Of

Read More
596 Words | 3 Pages

In In Cold Blood, the issue over the death penalty is prominent. Did Perry and Dick deserve to die? Should the severity of one’s crime determine one’s fate? Although Truman Capote writes the novel in a straightforward, “from a distance” way, he conveys, through his characters, theme, and plot development, that the death penalty is an issue that should be looked at from all sides and that the legal system itself is the real issue at hand, and that the death penalty is used as a means to suppress the distress and indignation of the citizens surrounding the case, instead of suppressing the victim himself.

Read More
733 Words | 3 Pages

In Darrow’s closing argument he gives his famed “A Plea for Mercy” to the judge. This plea not only acted as a conclusion to his defense, but it also acted as an introduction the eradication of the death penalty. Darrow uses a mix of ethos, pathos, logos, and other rhetorical devices to impose a merciful effect on his audience in hopes to reduce his clients punishment and the use of capital punishment. Darrow gracefully uses all three appeals when referring to the rise of crime after war “I know that it has followed every war; and I know it has influenced these boys so that life was not the same to them as it would have been if the world had not been made red with blood.

Read More
209 Words | 1 Pages

1. In this chapter, Brown discusses the cultural representation of punishment and prison in the media (particularly in American cinema) and how it shapes the way that penal spectators view crime through and punishment and its complex relationship with penality as both influence and are influenced by each other. In classical cinema, representations of punishment relied on the desires of the audiences and familiar penal elements, which were reflective of current cultural events, to gain notoriety. These elements allowed for audiences to identify with the lives of the characters and reproduces the idea that these inmates were capable of rehabilitation.

Read More

More about Ethical Issues In The Case Of Richard Moore

Related Topics

Open Document