ipl-logo

Euthanasi AO Reasoning And Analysis

1095 Words5 Pages

Christie Howell
Jennifer Wiesman
AO Reasoning & Analysis
January 31, 2018 Why Euthanasia Should Not Be Made Legal
Euthanasia, which was derived from the Greek word meaning “good death”, is the practice of assisted suicide with the purpose of relieving pain and suffering (Anderson, 2014). Euthanasia is also known as physician-assisted suicide or mercy killing, it has been a controversial debate due to its infringement of a person’s fundamental right to live (Anderson, 2014). Many people approve such a quiet and easy way of death and argue that euthanasia should be legal. But in fact, euthanasia conflicts with many religions and will bring great negative influences in society. People on both sides of the debate care about the people suffering …show more content…

The matter of death constitutes one of the most important things that religions deal with (Religion and Euthanasia, 2014). Almost all religions pay special attention to death and according to most religions human life is sacred and is worth protecting (Religion and Euthanasia, 2014). Practically all religions state those who become vulnerable through illness or disability deserve special care and protection, and that proper end of life is better than euthanasia (Religion and Euthanasia, 2014). All religions are opposed to euthanasia for several reasons, such as, all religions that have a supreme God states “thou shalt not kill”, human lives are special because God created them, and that human beings are made in God’s image (Religion and Euthanasia, 2014). God gave us our lives and we must allow our lives to end at the time and in the way God allows, not any other way (Religion and Euthanasia, 2014). Only god knows when it’s our time to leave this …show more content…

Such as, a family member that is going to inherit a large amount of money or a doctor that makes a mistake and the patient dies, both of these instances allows people to be killed due to either someone else’s decision or someone’s mistakes. For family members, when it comes to financial considerations, it’s possible for them to resort to euthanasia to get rid of the burden of the person sick. Allowing voluntary euthanasia or physician-assisted suicide releases the door for the disabled, sick, and elderly people to see themselves as a financial and/or emotional burden. In Oregon (one state that euthanasia is legal), 49% of those receiving physician-assisted suicide in 2016 mentioned “concern about being a burden” as a reason for choosing this option. According to Dr. Harvey Chochinov, a palliative care researcher, most of the ones that desired to end their lives did so because of the fear of being a burden (Jalsevac, 2007). Alex Schadenberg, the executive director of the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition, stated “The facts that we need to recognize from this study is that of the 379 palliative care patients who were studied, only 22 seriously considered intentionally dying, and of the 22 people, 12 felt that they were a burden to their family or a drain on health care, 4 felt that assisted suicide was a compassionate choice, 3 expressed a need for autonomy, and the others were either

Show More
Related

Pros And Cons Of Physician Assisted Suicide

689 Words | 3 Pages

Those who oppose PAS state that it makes a public statement that not all lives are of value, specifically to the disabled and elderly citizens. Proponents who oppose such practice, also claim it allows for an unacceptable level of abuse, as the physicians prescribe, but do not control the administering of the lethal drug. With healthcare costs continuing to rise, in addition to an increasing elderly population, it is argued that individuals could be pressured into electing PAS against their true wishes as a way to alleviate the financial burden to loved ones. However, the opposing group that accounts for what seems to be the majority is those from the religious sector, often referring to the ten commandments, thou shalt not kill.

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Is Ethical Essay

559 Words | 3 Pages

“The question of whether or not euthanasia is ethical revolves around the meaning of human existence. Those who favor euthanasia argue that human life only has meaning when the individual is free from unendurable physical and mental suffering” (“Preface to ‘Is Euthanasia Ethical?’” 1). Physician-assisted suicide is a practice that was first introduced by Dr.Jack Kevorkian in June of 1990 (“Chronology of Dr.Jack Kevorkian’s Life”, 1), in which a patient is either injected with life-ending drugs or given a carbon monoxide mask to place over their mouth and nose in order to end his or her life (Jackson 3).While this practice may sound harsh and unethical, it is the exact opposite; assisted suicide grants terminally-ill patients the option to end their suffering early and to avoid the loss of meaning to their life (“Preface to ‘Is Euthanasia Ethical?’”, 1). When a person is faced with the possibility of suffering through a dehumanizing and humiliating death, they should always be given the option of legally undergoing physician-assisted suicide; this option benefits both the patient and their family by allowing the patient a chance to end their life in a euphoric state, eliminating the costs of long term care, and to allow a morally acceptable

Read More

Hospice Home Care Ethics Case Study

1029 Words | 5 Pages

The job of medical professionals is to save lives, and relieve pain, so euthanasia and assisted suicide become a discussion when the only way to relieve pain is by dying. Cancer patients who are on hospice may look into these options. The main argument made with euthanasia is that it will lead to consequences. Having active voluntary euthanasia legalized could eventually legalize active involuntary euthanasia. A consequence of this ethical implication is that physicians and other health providers may become too comfortable with inducing the progress of death.

Read More

Doctor Assisted Dying Pros And Cons

1714 Words | 7 Pages

Haley Price Phil 203 12-3-15 Prompt 2 The right to doctor assisted dying is a compelling topic that comes with much debate. The debates that take place go back and forth about whether a patient should have the right to die with assistance of a physician or if this aid in taking one’s life should not be permissible. Some are against it because of moral or religious beliefs, and others are for this type of dying because of the respect and compassion they have towards death. I believe that if a patient is given no chance of survival, and are tired of the countless medications that are only making them more miserable, they have come to terms with their condition and have already said their goodbyes, and death is imminent - time is the only factor

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Physician Assisted Suicide

1276 Words | 6 Pages

Assisted Suicide Persuasive Essay Physician assisted suicide or euthanasia is defined as “suicide by a patient facilitated by means (as a drug prescription) or by information (as an indication of a lethal dosage) provided by a physician aware of the patient's intent” (“physician–assisted suicide”). Most of the patients who request physician assisted suicide have life threatening illnesses and want to end their suffering. There has been a debate, mainly for the past two decades, about whether or not it’s ethical for physicians to legally be able to cause someone to die even if the patient is requesting it. Even though according to Northwestern University “Physician-Assisted Suicide is not a new phenomenon. Suffering has always been a part

Read More

Should Physician Assisted Suicide Be Legalized Essay

1930 Words | 8 Pages

A survey of physicians conducted by the Canadian Medical Association found that "a significant proportion of respondents reported that they had been asked for assistance in dying by patients whose primary motivation appeared to be loneliness, lack of social support, or perceived burden on others" (Downar et al., 2017). This means that if physician-assisted suicide is legalized, at-risk people could be vulnerable to coercion or abuse. Opponents say allowing doctors to assist in suicide would undermine their role as healers and could lead to unwanted or unnecessary deaths, or a loss of respect for human life. The American Psychological Association echoes these concerns and highlights the major risks associated with such decisions. Among those concerns are, “Depression causing a desire for death,” “A loss of autonomy and function causing a desire for control,” and “worries about future pain” (Weir).

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Physician Assisted Suicide

1102 Words | 5 Pages

Supporters of assisted suicide trust that terminally ill patients have the freedom to end their lives on their terms. This can mean to pass in their homes, if they choose, rather than at a hospital in pain. Tom Coburn, US Senator, in the consideration of Pain Relief Promotion Act of 1999, stated: "Do we want doctors deciding who lives and who dies? No, we do not want that. This is a slope, a real slope where we are going to become God.

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Argumentative Essay

1376 Words | 6 Pages

The right to die is one’s own choice to make for themselves. “In 2014, 155 terminally ill patients in Oregon made a request and 105 of those patients used it. In 2015, there were 218 requests and 132 uses” (Physician, Jones). Based on these statistics it is shown that people are for physician assisted suicide and euthanasia because they have already requested and used it.

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Argumentative Essay

906 Words | 4 Pages

The American College of Physicians states, “the organization of 152,000 medical professionals stands against the legalization of physician-assisted suicide”. The organization is calling this act “the practice of which raises ethical, clinical, and other concerns”. (“Fewer Doctors Support Assisted Suicide Poll Says”) On the other hand, the number of physicians who support physician-assisted suicide is increasing. In 2010 forty-six percent of physicians were pro-euthanasia.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Physician Assisted Suicide

788 Words | 4 Pages

This argument is fallacious, as life is not a lone event, but involves a community of family and friends. To state otherwise and end life solely out of fear is a deeply flawed message. Despite this, addressing the pain and anxiety experienced during the dying process is paramount to arguing against physician-assisted suicide. This alternative is hospice care, where the principles of autonomy, benevolence, and nonmaleficence allow terminally ill individuals to be active participants in their final journey. According to the National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization (2014), hospice is optimum for those facing a life-limiting illness, as it provides medical care, pain management, and emotional and spiritual support according to the wishes and needs of the patient.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Assisted Suicide

700 Words | 3 Pages

Religions and morals come into careful consideration, yet society promptly presumes assisted-suicide patients get the “unnatural, easy way out,” while assisting-physicians benefit from performing a “quick and painless” death as they move on to their next patients. A mass number of people sense that since the performance is illegal in some states, the self-destructing act should remain illegal. Also, people against euthanization agree all parties must fight, instead of performing a “simple solution,” especially if the sicks’ probability to live is slowly elevating. On the contrary, “physician-assisted suicide is not a guaranteed quick and painless death, and there are tremendous consequences for those who have complications” (Wise). Even with advanced medicine and technology, physicians, patients, and patients’ family and friends deliberate whether the life-ending action will benefit patients’ overall health.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Euthanasia And Assisted Suicide

799 Words | 4 Pages

Euthanasia and assisted suicide is huge controversy that we face today. Many people believe that euthanasia is morally wrong and that it should be banned but others say that euthanasia should be a choice given to terminally ill patients who are suffering in immense pain. Many believe that euthanasia shouldn’t be an option because patients have palliative care to keep them out of pain but the thing is that palliative care doesn’t always work and without the choice of assisted suicide, patients will find their own method of ending their lives. Susie Byrne states, “I’ve always felt that even though access to good palliative care is first and foremost in end of life care, there are just some occasions where despite everyone’s best efforts, you’re

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Right To Die

1041 Words | 5 Pages

Euthanasia is a universal subject even if someone is not personally considering assisted suicide. Dr. Fenigsen writes, “We are equal in our ability to suffer, fear, and hope, and equal in our final necessity to face death and die” (Fenigsen, 100). Foremost, this decision affects the patient and their families. This is exhausting, emotionally, physically and financially. Furthermore, Dr. Fenigsen continues, “Many of us strongly feel that every human being's life, beginning with our own, has inestimable value” (Fenigsen,

Read More

Arguments Against Euthanasia And Assisted Suicide

1600 Words | 7 Pages

However, Ms Purdy did win her case and guidance was issued for her. As a result DPP did not prosecute her due to the public interest as she has already gone to Switzerland for assisted suicide. However religion believes that death is an important part of human life, but religion does have a strong view on euthanasia, as they disapprove euthanasia as they believe human life is sacred and special gift from god. All religion believe euthanasia is not an option, they believe illness or disability makes people vulnerable and they need extra care, assistance and protection by having a proper way to end their life, such as natural death instead of euthanasia.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: The Right To Die

1321 Words | 6 Pages

Terminally ill patients have right to die through refusal of medication such as withdrawing a respirator and refusing food and water until dying in about ten to twelve days because of their religion. Being a Christian has a lot to deal with this, especially physicians because the tradition doesn’t allow murder and that only god decides what to give and what to take. It’s hard for them to take their own life because of their own religion. Christianity has a role in both patients and

Read More

More about Euthanasi AO Reasoning And Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document