ipl-logo

Critique Of Cultural Relativism By Ooneigh Reitman

1259 Words6 Pages

Introduction Cultural relativism is the principle that the beliefs and activities of each person must be understood in the culture itself (Bayley, 1992). Feminism is a movement and ideology to fight for equality for women in the political, economic, cultural, private space and public space. Feminism was never an ideology of hatred ( Beasley, 1999). Since cultural relativism and feminism are two different things, many different critiques of cultural relativism and feminism in international human rights occur. Those critiques come from cultural relativists and feminists. As we know, the journal written by Ooneigh Reitman explains about those two different critiques. By this journal review, I would like to review the journal deeper. Objectives, …show more content…

The author explains the basic concepts of cultural relativism and feminism. It is mentioned in the journal that cultural relativism is the concept of Western thought and has become a study of Western philosophy since long. The author also explain political hidden concepts. The method used by the author is comparative method which is the method used in research aimed to find out whether there is a difference between the two variables studied in one respect(Ragin, 1987). In this study there was no manipulation of the researcher. Research done naturally, by collecting data with an instrument. The results are statistically analyzed to look for differences in the variables studied. The author uses comparative method because as we can see, the writer compares the two different perceptions and critics coming from two different actors which are cultural relativist and feminist. The other method used by the author is Ethnographic method which is is a method used to interpret the cultural, social groups and a community system Ethnographic study aimed to describe ways of thinking, customs, languages, beliefs and behavior of life of a society(O’reilly, 2005). The research process is usually carried out in the field in a long time, the natural form of observations and interviews with participants and collect documents or objects (artifacts). The final result is usually very comprehensive study and describe the …show more content…

For instance, rape cases. There are a lot of rase cases happen and the victims are mostly women and this makes me agree to the feminist critiques of international human rights which says feminist sees that men dominate the authority of human rights, here the feminist claims that men are holding human rights, and women are not. The author of the journal, however, does not seem defending cultural relativist or feminist. The author seems neutral.

Conclusion Both between cultural relativist critiques and feminist critiques of International Human Rights are correct. None of them should be blamed because everyone has the right to say their opinions, and I think cultural relativist and feminist have their right on criticizing something and we have the right to choose whether we defend cultural relavist or feminist critiques because both of those critiques are created to defend people and it is all back to

Show More
Related

Analysis Of Jane Mcmanus 'Gym Class Girls Who Just Wanna Play Football'

696 Words | 3 Pages

As of today, people are generalized to specific ideas, and life choices because of their gender. Despite being more open-minded, the general public still manages to keep each other limited to doing certain things just because of their sex. This is prevalent in the development of younger children. Jane McManus authored the article, “Gym Class Heroes—Making It Better For Girls Who Just Wanna Play Football,” where she highlights one common stereotype branded on girls. The article includes a prominent amount of personal experience, tone, and pathos making it credible to only a certain extent.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of We Should All Be Women By Adichie

1015 Words | 5 Pages

Adichie answers that question and the answer is “Yes”. Once more, Adichie’s definition for feminist is “a man or a woman who says, ‘Yes, there’s a problem with gender as it is today, and we must fix it, we must do better.’” ; Therefore, Adichie says it best – “Culture does not make people. People make culture. So if it is in fact true that the full humanity of women is not our culture, then we must make it our culture.”

Read More

Summary Of A Fair Country By Rachel Walker

1314 Words | 6 Pages

Within Canada and Canadian studies there are many different aspects that issues can be analyzed. With many different issues happening now it is important to understand these viewpoint and lenses used to analyze. One way an issue can be looked at is through a feminist viewpoint. This is an important lens to consider when wanting to understand how women issues play out in Canada. This idea is noted in Rachel Walker’s article “A Fair Country

Read More

Cultural Relativism Vs Female Circumcision

102 Words | 1 Pages

Our moral beliefs indicate the kind of environment or culture we grew up in. Therefore, if we were born in Somalia, we would believe that it is morally right to go through female circumcision as a rite of passage. However, if we grew up in the western world, then we would not believe in female circumcision. We can therefore see the relativist 's argument of cultural relativism in this case, because if cultural relativism exists, then naturally, morality will also be relative. Additionally, to support his stance, the relativist will also argue that tolerance comes into play when it comes to cultural relativism.

Read More

English 102 Class Reflection

696 Words | 3 Pages

So far, we have completed an editorial and evaluation papers. I liked the editorial paper

Read More

Cultural Relativism: Rites Of Passage

1580 Words | 7 Pages

Cultural relativism is the understanding of other cultures in their own terms. To achieve the understanding of the rituals used in the cultures of another, one must be able to look at them from an emic (insider) perspective. One must also be able to look at his own culture from an etic (outsider) perspective. The ability to look at one’s culture from the etic point of view will make it easier to explain the rituals to someone from a different culture, for example, rites of passage. Rites of passage are used to mark a life stage and are celebrated by tradition or religion, meant to separate a specific group.

Read More

Promoting Urinary Incontinence

1323 Words | 6 Pages

The literature review gives justified information for the need of conducting the research. Apart from the introduction, there is no other information concerning the research title that could offer detailed information (Chaliha et a., 2001). Despite giving the justified information in the introduction section the paper should have had the literature review section, thus it did not follow the due steps and format of a research paper. The methodology part follows after the introduction and it discloses the methods used, the design, the people included in the study and how the data was sampled and examined. However, the reasons for choosing the design in the research were not

Read More

Sexism In American Culture

1000 Words | 4 Pages

The inherent sexism in American culture has caused discrimination against women. Some people do not believe that inequality between genders exists, they are wrong. In the past every achievement that women made was omitted from history books (Philosophical Feminism). Many things that women were a part of are just now being introduced to modern people, such as the fact that women did all of the calculations that made the first ever human in space possible. It is harder for women to get hired in the first place and if they get hired they are paid less for the same amount of work, and race also plays into the wage figures (Wage Gap Figures).

Read More

Arguments Against Cultural Relativism

1020 Words | 5 Pages

Therefore, different cultures with result in different moral codes. In that case, people should see matters from many aspects instead of having a general truth as the standard. A second reason why cultural relativism has a more logical way of reasoning is because it teaches us to keep in an open mind. This can be seen from the fact that people should respect and tolerate other’s culture since there is no universal truth that holds for all people. Taken together, these two arguments demonstrate the logical way reasoning of cultural relativism and highlight the advantage of the cultural relativism

Read More

Examples Of Cultural Relativism

827 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout this essay, cultural relativism will be questioned, but also supported in some ways. The idea of cultural relativism reminds me of a sociological term--ethnocentrism--that essentially means the opposite. Ethnocentrism is essentially a bias about your own culture against other cultures. One can only see their culture (usually as dominant to the others), rather than attempting to see the perspective of whatever culture is in question. An example of real-life cultural relativism is female circumsition or clitordectomy.

Read More

Women's Role In Feminist Research

911 Words | 4 Pages

There are several question that are asked surrounding feminism. One of them are questions about women's role in research like is there a feminist research research different from other social science research and are there any specific feminist research methods? If one believes that feminist research is research about women, by women, and for women, then one may conclude that there are distinct methods that feminists use to study the oppression of women. Also, if one believes, as does Liz Stanley (1993), that there is a direct relationship between feminist consciousness and feminism, then there is research that is distinctly feminist. In trying to answer the above posed questions, we need to examine not only political ideologies as suggested

Read More

Essay On Feminist Critique Of International Human Rights

1594 Words | 7 Pages

While in the other hand the feminist argue that universal human rights subjecting man as their concern, while woman are being discriminated and given low priority in the

Read More

Feminist Legal Theory

1204 Words | 5 Pages

The concept is particularly significant for the minority groups, females and to the poor. In reference to the Feminist Legal aspects, women must be treated equally as men regardless of different aspects including race, gender, national origin, ethnic group, religion and capabilities without any discrimination and biasness. In context of modern equality feminist legal theory, women are entitled to have equality before the law and should be discriminated based on gender. Finally, it determines that with enhancing globalisation and improvement of human rights discourses, equality and dominance in feminist theory started to be

Read More

Ethical Relativism Strengths And Weaknesses Essay

2607 Words | 11 Pages

(Luco, Week 3 Notes, p.9) Cultural Relativism is simply a combination of the following three theses: 1. The only criterion of moral truth or falsehood is the moral code of a cultural group. 2. A moral claim is true, relative to a culture’s moral code, if and only if the claim is generally accepted within that cultural

Read More

Feminist Theories Of Feminism

1243 Words | 5 Pages

First of all, it is essential to establish the understanding that Feminist theory is constructed from what is known as core international relations feminism, and the four-variant feminist international relations: liberal feminism, critical feminism, postcolonial feminism, and post-structural feminism, these theories branches off of the core theory. Each theory applies a different understanding to how feminism might be applied to certain fields and situations; like how feminism might be applied to an international situation like the Arab Spring. Therefore, understanding core feminist theory is essential to understanding feminism as a whole. As well, majority of the current international relation theories are masculine in nature, feminism is a political tool that struggles to free all women from the oppressive nature of patriarchy. Because feminism is a political tool for equality and

Read More

More about Critique Of Cultural Relativism By Ooneigh Reitman

Related Topics

Open Document