ipl-logo

Why Did The Right Thing In Walking Away

771 Words4 Pages

SUNFLOWER ROUGH DRAFT Imagine you in a concentration camp being a prisoner and the amount of food you receive is little to none. Where the bed you sleep on is harder than a rock and the clothes you go to sleep in is the same clothes that you wore while working. Where you have to witness families being torn apart and you can not do anything about it. Well in the book The Sunflower that how it happened to the jews but apart from that there was a decision that had to be made. Simon a jew prisoner was begged for forgivenes by a SS soldier. Karl the SS soldier begged Simon for forgiveness as he killed a lot of jews. Simon decided that walking away was the right thing to do and I agree. I would have done the same as Simon due to the fact that mass murder can not be forgiven. Was that the correct way …show more content…

I believe that Simon did the right thing in walking away from Karl. I believe that karma exist and if you act heartless then it will come back to you. Like how it happened to Karl he acted heartless towards the jews and didn 't care or acted like he didn 't care about the jews lives. Then when he was dying and asking for Simons forgiveness Simon walked away acting heartless towards Karl and i see that as karma. Karl made a huge mistake therefore he does not deserve forgiveness. Put yourself in Simon’s shoes and think about it. Would you have done things differently? What if someone killed one of you relatives? Or a friend? Would you forgive someone for that? Do you even believe that something like that can be forgiven. Is forgiving always the right to do? For example, when you are being treated below a human being and animals are being treated with more respect than yourself. In my opinion i forgiven due to the damage that he did to the jews. The question is did simon do the right thing in just walking away or would it have been better

Show More
Related
465 Words | 2 Pages

I realize forgiveness is different for everyone and I am typically a forgiving person depending on the situation at hand, but in Simon’s position I would not have felt comfortable forgiving this man for his sins that were committed against entirely different people. I also am in no position to be forgiving him when I have the ability to be just as wicked as him. The only one who could have forgave him would’ve been God and the families who suffered at his hand. Personally, I imagine I would have kept my silence as Simon did or would have told the man it is not my place to forgive him and give him that comfort

Read More
1099 Words | 5 Pages

Simon wants to find his destiny “ I think God made me the way I am for a reason.” ~ Simon Birch. Later in the story Simon finds his destiny,Saving kids from a sinking school bus which had crashed into a freezing cold lake. Simon had an ability to talk to kids and have them listen with no distractions because of his small stature.

Read More
1055 Words | 5 Pages

“In the end, we remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends.” – Martin Luther King Jr. During the Holocaust, the Jews felt helpless. People either hated them or felt sympathy for them.

Read More
831 Words | 4 Pages

If I were in Simon’s place, I would not have granted Karl forgiveness. I think Simon was right not to have forgiven Karl because

Read More
1159 Words | 5 Pages

In the story Generosity Thassa and Spock Thornell are characterizations of Aristotelian and Stoic ethics. These two dynamics clash after Spock attempts to rape Thassa. After the aforementioned rape, the power dynamic shifts from Spock to Thassa. As a result, Thassa wrongly distorts the Aristotelian concept of happiness and selflessness and allows for the continuation of Spock’s misguided Stoic suffering.

Read More
518 Words | 3 Pages

Although Simon does show traits of a Christ figure, he does not fully live up to the archetype of a Christ figure. To be a Christ figure is someone must show the traits of the Biblical Christ. In the Bible, Christ fed people who could not feed themselves, and Simon fed the littluns ripe fruit, so that they could eat without getting sick. Simon’s role as a failed Christ figure is shown in his violent and ineffective “crucifixion” and “resurrection”, and his failure at getting them to listen and be reassured by what he had to say. One of the reasons Simon is a failed Christ figure, is that he just died, unlike Christ, who died a martyr to save humanity, and was resurrected from the dead.

Read More
567 Words | 3 Pages

A man has done immense evil against you and your family and now is asking you to forgive him. He is a new believer in Christ his sins of his past are forgiven by God. Would you rejoice and forgive him, or deny and live the rest of your life with hate clutching ever tighter at your heart. We can all agree that Corrie ten Boom was treated horribly at the wretched concentration camps. Some believe Corrie shouldn’t have forgiven the prison guard while others believe she should have.

Read More
894 Words | 4 Pages

According to Jewish religion, fully repentance was really important for them to determine whether a person deserve forgiveness. As Wiesenthal’s friend Bolek mentioned in the book “In our religion repentance is the most element in seeking forgiveness” (Wiesenthal 83)”. From this quote we could conclude that any person who was deeply repentance was eligible to ask for forgiveness. Therefore, firstly we should decide whether Karl was truly sorry about the mistake he has made. It was important to note that if he was not truly regret about his fault, he would not find someone who might hate him so much according to his identity as a Nazi soldier to confess his sin when he was dying.

Read More
732 Words | 3 Pages

As Mila Bron said, “In order to heal we must first forgive…and sometimes the person we must forgive is ourselves.” In “The Seventh Man” by Haruki Murakami the narrator should forgive himself for his failure to save K. because he could have died himself and he was not wholly in control of his actions during the life-or-death situation. The narrator was not responsible for the wave that killed K. and he should not punish himself for something that was out of his control. The narrator blamed himself for K.’s death, but in reality, he was not able to do anything without endangering his own life.

Read More
729 Words | 3 Pages

This quote shows that on two separate occasions when he was younger, he was an objectively bad person with bad behavior. Now if we relate this to his current day life, you can’t say that much has changed. He has already shown that he is still a bully with his actions against Simon, and this consistency shows that he is also unlikely to change for the

Read More
195 Words | 1 Pages

Simon is different from the rest of the boys because he

Read More
1553 Words | 7 Pages

Similarly, Simon has an engrained goodness in him that shines through even in the toughest moments. He retrieved Piggy’s glasses after they were knocked off his face post a punch in the face by Jack, and, like Christ, he was good with kids, helping the younger littluns pick fruit, finding “for them fruit they could not reach, pulled off the choicest from up in the foliage, passed them back down to the endless, outstretched hands” (Golding 56). Simon was also very wise and insightful, and maybe even slightly prophetic. When he was dehydrated and hallucinating, he imagined the

Read More
585 Words | 3 Pages

Simon also tried to keep the peace between all of the boys by assuring them that everything is ok, and that there is nothing to be afraid of. “I just think you’ll get back all right.” (111). Simon was vigilant, and calming to the others. This shows true leadership, and that civilization is still present so long as he’s around.

Read More
932 Words | 4 Pages

Religious: “‘Simon’s always about’”

Read More
1029 Words | 5 Pages

Redemption was the only answer that will stop one’s suffering and gain peace with their internal

Read More

More about Why Did The Right Thing In Walking Away

Related Topics

Open Document