ipl-logo

Examples Of Reintroduction Of Wolves In Scotland

2236 Words9 Pages

Abstract The purpose of this essay is to critically evaluate the proposed reintroduction of wolves to Scotland and how this can be regarded as a wicked problem. Specific examples will be used to explain how the different attributes of complex problems can be seen in this context decision making and critically evaluate the extent to which structured decision making could be used to address this wicked problem. Introduction This essay will evaluate controversies about reintroduction of wolves to Scotland and how it can be conceptualised as a wicked problem (Ritchey, 2005, p.5), a variety of examples will be demonstrated to explain how different attributes of wicked problem can be observed within this decision making context. An evaluation …show more content…

One important aspects of the restoration of the ecosystem is the reintroduction of organisms that are locally extinct (D. Manning et al, 2008). The first proposal for the reintroduction of wolves to the Scottish Highlands was in the 1960s, at that time the majority of the proposals were unfounded and without scientific credibility .Currently the (Scottish Natural Heritage) which is the government organization responsible for wildlife and habitats in Scotland , have no plans to consider reintroduction of wolves (The Wolves and Humans Foundation). Problems with complex social economic or organizational Interactions and cannot be solved fully are considered as a wicked problem (Lucky, 2009), therefore reintroduction of wolves to Scotland could be considered as a challenge and when it comes to challenges wicked problems are the most difficult (Nixon, 2012). In previous years many researches had multiple views points to characterized wicked problems (Rittel & Webber (1973), Ritchey (2005), Robert Horn (1980), Jeff Conklin (2000), Roberts (1997, 2000, and …show more content…

The controversies of reintroduction of wolves is a stopping rule because there is no definitive statement of the problem , Ritchey (2005) found that wicked problems do not have a described set of potential solutions , the problems solvers have no right or wrong because each solution has an unpredicted and irretrievable consequences. In order to reintroduce wolves to Scotland first of it is necessary secure a safe and viable futures for wolves, Ritchey (2005) argues that every wicked problem is an indication of another wicked problem, seeing that before reintroduction wolves to Scotland several measures must be implemented such as interventions authorities and legal protection and this could result in another wicked problem (European

Show More
Related
530 Words | 3 Pages

Mowat’s rhetorical strategies Wolves for thousands of years have been one of man’s greatest enemies. In Farley Mowat’s book, published in 1963, he makes us rethink why we are still at war with this species. Never Cry Wolf is about Mowat’s adventure as he studies wolves in the Northern Canadian Plains. His research brought him to become friends with Eskimos and a small family of wolves that he’s learned to respect and love. During his six month period he learns that wolves have been wrongly judged and are not the beasts that they have been titled.

Read More
544 Words | 3 Pages

There is an estimated 60,000 wolves in Canada. Farley Mowat studies the grey wolf in his book Never Cry Wolf (1963). Throughout the book, Mowat uses the rhetorical strategies pathos, logos, and personification to disprove the misconception about wolves. The book is about a scientist (Farley Mowat) that flies into the Canadian Barrens in order to research wolves. His goal is to prove that wolves are killing thousands of caribou for sport, but he find that the wolves are not to blame for the decrease in caribou populations.

Read More
650 Words | 3 Pages

Over the past few years, a rise in concern for endangered species has emerged. There have been many animals that were mistreated by humans who wanted them as pets. Problems of potential extinction, unsatisfactory living conditions, hunting, and trading in the market have put special species of animals in danger. Many people have started to wonder if some species will still be alive in a few years. If this problem continues to heighten, it will not look good for some populations of endangered animals.

Read More
2055 Words | 9 Pages

Although Jeremy Rifkin, Bob stevens, and Lois Frazier have all written about their view on animals and how they are treated globally, but when bringing in animal rights groups like ASPCA and PETA, different bias and tactics are newly introduced. Of all the articles, Jeremy Rifkin uses the most credible sources such as lab studies and examples. In the article “A Change of Heart about Animals” Rifkin uses sources such as Purdue University and the European union when talking about situations. One situation he writes about is how pigs need social activity so the pigs are not “lacking mental and physical stimuli [which] hand result in deterioration of health”.

Read More
1820 Words | 8 Pages

All Quiet on the Western Front Essay World War I is one of the most influential and bloody wars in history. Soldiers did not always receive fair treatment, and often encountered harsh conditions, especially those men who were fighting on the front line. World War I took place between 1914-1919 (pbs), during which millions of lives were lost, and nearly everyone’s life was touched by the war in some way.

Read More
819 Words | 4 Pages

Attributing human form or personality to things that are not human is defined as anthropomorphizing. When following and recording wild animals it is a known fact that you shouldn’t take part in this. This was not the case for the state of Montana. Humans got politically and emotionally attached to the reintroduction of the Nine mile wolves. Throughout this controversial period of time, humans played a significant role in changing the fate of these wolves forever.

Read More
172 Words | 1 Pages

A night too deep It's been like three years since I shortly mentioned Night Wolves in my ScanBike editorial. Coming to summer 2016 a lot has happened. Recently, the finnish media has been covering a russian MC leader, who has not got the faintest idea of very basic historical facts since WWII.

Read More
797 Words | 4 Pages

Sadly, many Americans believe that losing the wolves would not be a bad thing for the prey’s sake, but in all reality losing the wolves would be devastating. One major thing that is present in all ecosystems, the place in which animals live, is a trophic cascade. A trophic cascade is explained in the essay as a “sequence of impacts down the food chain” (578). Hannibal gives the reader this example: “…In Wyoming’s Yellowstone National Park … wolves were virtually wiped out in the 1920’s and reintroduced in the ‘90s. Since the wolves have come back, scientists have noted an unexpected improvement in many of the park’s degraded stream areas”

Read More
1555 Words | 7 Pages

Every year hundreds of wild, exotic animals are killed, primarily in Africa, for money, bragging rights, and even decoration. Big game trophy hunting is a booming business, but has sparked a worldwide debate, especially after the killing of Cecil the Lion. Trophy hunters claim they are helping conservation efforts, but in reality, they are harming them. This sport is damaging the overall population of a species, especially lions, rhinos, and elephants. Also, the overall revenue from big game hunting is a small amount, and only a small percent of that goes to help the community.

Read More
724 Words | 3 Pages

Wolves, when in groups, are universally threatening and recurrently feared. This being known, they are often portrayed as an evil or opposing force. Although, on occasion, they have also been known to be referred to as “noble creatures who can teach us many things.” (http://www.wolfcountry.net/) But consequently, despite the popular interpretation of wolves and their characteristics, each story presents its own interpretation of their many characteristics.

Read More
1750 Words | 7 Pages

Sixty years after the extirpation of wolves in the Northern Rockies and Great Plains of America, biologist and ecologist in Yellowstone National Park reintroduced wolves into a declining ecosystem that once thrived during their presence. The reintroduction brought immense controversy into the West and continues to stir outrage among anti-wolf groups. These anti-wolf supporters argue wolves are ruthless predators that cause destruction to natural environments and livestock. Conversely wolf advocates and scientists suggest that wolves are a keystone species that are essential to the natural regulation of our Western ecosystems. Although pro and anti-wolf advocates can agree that wolves have an effect on livestock, ungulate populations and ecosystems,

Read More
1133 Words | 5 Pages

Wolves are getting less and less fearful of humans and are moving closer to towns. The debate about killing wolves has been controversial a lot in the past couple of years. Although many citizens don’t want the wolves to be killed because, there isn’t a tremendous amount of them and they were almost extinct in 1930(Zhang). There is many farmers that need the wolf population to be regulated because the

Read More
973 Words | 4 Pages

Poaching and illegal hunting can cause an off set in the ecosystem by overhunting animals. When one animal population decline drastically, other organisms are affected too. The decline in native predators is the main cause for overpopulation of animals like deer. Deer overpopulation has led to rapid decrease vegetation life causing other animals to be put at risk. Removing predators from the food web disrupts the entire balance of an

Read More
1026 Words | 5 Pages

Should Teenagers Have Access To Birth Control? Many debate the idea of teens, under eighteen, having access to birth control; it is a controversy that has presented itself in recent presidential and state governor elections. Many states have considered, and even attempted to remove funding from Planned Parenthood and other pregnancy resources to no avail. The argument has not been focused solely on teens, but anyone who seeks birth control or an abortion with the claim that, “you should not have sex if you do not intend to reproduce.” Teenagers are impressionable, no doubt about it.

Read More
1285 Words | 6 Pages

WWF is an organisation established to protect the future of nature and has been over the last fifty years. Operating in one hundred countries globally, WWF has more than one million supporters in the United States and almost five million worldwide, as a result there advertisements can reach an incredible size audience. This advertisement is particularly striking as it circulates against the recent poaching of animals in the wild for their valuable horns which are sold illegally on black markets. The message of this advertisement can be dissected into three elements: objects, signs and what is being interpreted. It can be furthermore broken up into the basic level of meaning, the connotative level and the ideological level of meaning.

Read More

More about Examples Of Reintroduction Of Wolves In Scotland

Related Topics

Open Document