ipl-logo

Examples Of The Direct Legal Issues In The Terry Case

1431 Words6 Pages

Issue at Stake: The direct legal issue at stake is whether or not a search for weapons without probable cause or a warrant is an unreasonable search and seizure under the 4th Amendment of the Constitution. While the CLSSA is concerned with the direct legal issue, we also are raising anxious about the much broader issues surrounding the disparate effects that could shape how certain groups of people interact with our law enforcement on a daily basis as a result of this case. The arguments below are designed to outline these broad and societal issues within the Terry case. First Argument: Court’s should not be making laws regarding public policy. Judges are in the position to interpret law and to decide whether the policies put in place by the legislative and executive branches violate policy. In the case of Mr. …show more content…

This is a clear indication of the disparate effects of a colorblind law on minority groups. Our laws have been built on racial inequality which in return creates racial identities. The individuals who make up the minority of the racial identities are often the most affected by the laws as they do not acknowledge the experiences and hardships these groups face (Mutua, 2007). The decision in Terry is an example of how the “reasonable” suspicion doctrine was on the surface a colorblind law, however, it has been used to target minorities unjustly. Similarly, Thomas Rawls would argue the due process is afforded to everyone in society, therefore, minority groups should not be disproportionately represented when the statistics are shown for stop and frisk (Rawls, Ch. I). Mr. Terry was subjected to a colorblind law that affected his status as a citizen subjecting him to this search. These laws that were designed as colorblind are what is inherently wrong with our system and must be looked at by the

Show More
Related

Broken Windows Policing Analysis

571 Words | 3 Pages

One concern is that BWP leads to over incarceration, which Kelling and Bratton respond to this by admitting that, yes, it does; however, the crimes people are being imprisoned for are far less serious than those that are being prevented by BWP and their sentences are thus much shorter. But, the main concern is that SQF, and therefore BWP is inadmissibly discriminatory towards minorities. Once again, Kelling and Bratton give ground by not defending the abhorrent results of the 2011 SQF’s, which resulted in over 700,000 stops and only a 6% success rate. They instead talk about how much their methods have improved with far fewer stops and a higher success rate. This may seem like an odd way to address the claim of discrimination, but the point is that they now are making much more calculated decisions when stopping people, and not just frisking minorities at random.

Read More

The Conservative Case Against Racial Profiling Forman Analysis

1055 Words | 5 Pages

In his essay “Arrested Development: The Conservative Case Against Racial Profiling” published in the New Republic on September 10, 2001, professor James Forman Jr. illustrates his disagreement with racial profiling. Forman Jr. is a professor at Yale Law School. He teaches Constitutional Law and seminars on race and the criminal justice system. In his piece, Forman primary goal is to create understanding about the effectiveness of racial profiling and how this affects the black community especially youths. Forman achieves this by appealing to a liberal audience.

Read More

Identify And Outline The Features Of The NSW Law Reform Commission

818 Words | 4 Pages

Changing social values: These values change over time and the law will represent changing social values. The values can only represent most people. Changing social values are a great source of motivation for law reform. Gay marriage is an example of a changing social value.

Read More

Review Of Mass Incarceration In The Age Of Colorblindness By Michelle Alexander

983 Words | 4 Pages

ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY Alexander, M. (2012). The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness (Rev. ed.). New York, NY: The New Press. Michelle Alexander in her book, "The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness" argues that law enforcement officials routinely racially profile minorities to deny them socially, politically, and economically as was accustomed in the Jim Crow era.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Stop And Frisk

780 Words | 4 Pages

The act of “Stop and Frisk” began in the early 1900’s when crime rates began to escalate in major cities such as New York, Chicago, and Philadelphia. Stop, question, and frisk, or SQF, is an urban policing measure that involves the large-scale deployment of officers in public spaces (e.g., sidewalks, alleys, the communal outdoor spaces of public housing) tasked with conducting frequent investigative stops (Huq, A. Z. (2017). In the articles provided, it is questioned whether New York’s stop and frisk policy is constitutional or not. I agree with the court's ruling, I believe Judge Scheindlin seemed too involved. “Judge Shira A. Scheindlin, the appeals court said, jeopardized "the appearance of partiality ... by a series of media interviews and public statements purporting to respond publicly to criticism of the District Court”

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Stop And Frisk

1217 Words | 5 Pages

Even though the Stop and Frisk program was a highly controversial law, a revised version of it should be implemented in every major city that suffers from high crime rates. The majority of people wanted the program to continue because it worked very well in NYC and It drastically reduced the number of murders and major crime in the city. First, In this essay, I will elaborate on what I mean by “a revised version” of the Stop and Frisk program, address the arguments made against the law, and then show you my argument for the program and the good it brought to the city of NYC and the good it can bring to other cities in America. First off, what was the Stop and Frisk program? The Stop and Frisk program is the practice of detaining, questioning

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Stop And Frisk

1159 Words | 5 Pages

This stop and frisk approach to policing is not isolated to N.Y. and is known as the Terry law in many other states. Terry v. Ohio decision made the suspicion of danger grounds for a reasonable search. In principle Stop and Fisk is a reflection of the broken window approach of policing theory suggests that neighborhoods with greater concentration of physical and social disorder should evidence higher stop and frisk activity, especially for "quality of life" crimes (Fagan, Davies). In effect the unchecked citizens are in fact the broken window. How this approach effectively addresses concerns with crime will be analyzed from both

Read More

Michelle Alexander The Lockdown Analysis

718 Words | 3 Pages

Not to mention all the undocumented people that feel oppressed by officers and scared to talk back to them with a “no”. In chapter two, the author presents a section titled Just Say No. In this section the author illustrates a time where two police officers stopped a bus to search for drugs. Police officers never warned individuals that they had the right to remain silent and, therefore, minorities were trapped and found guilty for carrying drugs. In addition, the book discusses the Florida vs Botsick case that states that people have the right to refuse answering the police.

Read More

Stop And Frisk: Discussion Of Stop And Frisk

459 Words | 2 Pages

Studies have shown that Hispanics were stopped 33%, and African-American were stopped 51%, despite only being 24% (Hispanics) and 26% (African-American) of the community (Gelman, A. et al, 2012). In the other hand Caucasians made up 43.4% of the population, but were only stop and frisk 12.9%(Gelman, A. et al, 2012). Do to the disparity of who was stopped with the use of stop and frisk there were protest by unsatisfied civilians who saw the actions of the police as unfair and unjust. “On June 17, 2012 several thousand protester marched down Manhattan Fifth Avenue from lower Harlem to then Major Michael Bloomberg’s upper eastside townhouse” to protest the policy of the NYPD of stop question and frisk (Francesani, C.,

Read More

The Debatable Topic Of Stop-And-Frisk

865 Words | 4 Pages

Stop-and-Frisk The Stop-and-Frisk program has been a debatable topic for many years. In some regions of the United States, it is also known as Terry Stops. This program is based on the decision of the US Supreme Court in the case of Terry v. Ohio. The program has led to many disagreements and protests throughout the states that use it.

Read More

Summary Of The Buffalo Creek Disaster By Gerald M. Stern

1521 Words | 7 Pages

Our legal system allows judges to make important decisions on their own, which is a huge responsibility, and if it falls into the wrong hands, there could be severe

Read More

The Problem Of Police Brutality

1362 Words | 6 Pages

Police Brutality The use of excessive force by the police is nothing new, and with so many cases out there, it is clear that "to serve and protect" does not exactly apply to all of law enforcement as it should. Even though in some cases the use of harsh force has resulted into solving big crimes, officers have used the excessive force for personal reasons like race. It has affected many lives in a different way and question the authority officers have.. Police Brutality is an ongoing problem and existent concern in the United States; the unjustified shootings,fatal choking, and rough treatment have contributed to the present problem of police brutality.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Racial Profiling

1530 Words | 7 Pages

Throughout history, disputes and tensions between law enforcement officials and communities of minorities have endured hostility and violence between each other. Racial profiling has become a “hot topic” for researchers as well as for politicians and by now it is likely that most citizens are at least aware of the common accusations of racial bias pitted against law enforcement (Cochran & Warren, 2013). Communities of color are being discriminated against and racially profiled by white police officers for any suspicion of criminal activities. It has been widely assumed by policy makers and citizens alike that allegations of racial profiling are mostly associated with the policing practices of white officers and their treatment of racial and ethnic minorities (Cochran & Warren, 2013). Also, individuals of minority descent will certainly recognize that they are being racially profiled during a stop that is being conducted by a white police officer.

Read More

The Separation Of Powers In The United Kingdom

1896 Words | 8 Pages

The separation of powers, together with the rule of law and parliamentary sovereignty is considered to be one of the most important and fundamental doctrines of the constitution of the United Kingdom. The separation of powers is a doctrine often described as the trias politica principle and it involves the allocation of powers to the three branches, namely the legislature, the executive and the judiciary and how the function between them. In this essay I have to explain and critically analyse the doctrine of the separation of powers as it applies to the UK Constitution. Historically, the separation of powers is traced back in the ancient Greece from Aristotle in his work Politics where in order to prevent absolutism, he introduced the three

Read More

Constitutional Law In Bangladesh

1518 Words | 7 Pages

Introduction The Parliament of Bangladesh, known as the Jatiya Sangsad unanimously passed "The Constitution (Sixteenth Amendment) Bill, 2014", empowering itself with authority to remove and investigate Supreme Court judges on the grounds of their incapability and misconduct, making the higher judiciary accountable to the legislature. As a result, the Parliament will be able to remove judges if allegations of incapability or misconduct against them are proved, a provision that lawmakers had enjoyed only for four years after independence. Hence, through this latest amendment, the Parliament’s authority to remove judges has returned after 40 years. A new law to guide the investigation and gathering of evidence over the allegations against a judge

Read More

More about Examples Of The Direct Legal Issues In The Terry Case

Related Topics

Open Document