ipl-logo

Fiction Over Fact Of Frankenstein

2200 Words9 Pages

Maya Shaked
Dr. Matthew Margini
Research into Anglophone Literature
5 April 2023
Fiction Over Fact: Shelley’s Critique of the Scientific Method During the Romantic Era
Science evolves to reflect the beliefs of its time, regardless of whether doing so builds on or undermines the work done up until that point. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein exhibits this evolution of the scientific method as Victor Frankenstein tries to integrate the Romantic ideas of the nineteenth century into science. He begins his studies motivated by those ideas, saying, “I entered with the greatest diligence into the search of the philosopher's stone and the elixir of life” (Shelley 25). Yet, the destructive effects of his experiment erode this hope and expose the fallacies …show more content…

The ideas of Romantic scientists such as Sir Humphrey Davy, while revolutionary for their time, were not completely novel, but referenced scientists and philosophers from before the scientific revolution. Stuart Peterfreund discusses in his article “Composing What May Not Be ‘Sad Trash’: A Reconsideration of Mary Shelley's Use of Paracelsus in "Frankenstein" that such ideas parallel those of alchemists Albertus Magnus, Cornelius Agrippa, and Paracelsus. He points out how Paracelsus in particular had a significant influence on the studies of psychology and medicine of the nineteenth century. Often dubbed pseudoscience or associated with magic, Paracelsus’ theories have several similarities with Victor’s experiments and carry a significant influence on Victor’s perception of science (81). Therefore, Shelley’s critique of Romantic science extends to older scientific eras as well. When Victor reflects on his journey as a scientist upon choosing to study the ancients over modern science, he narrates, “The train of my ideas would never have received the fatal impulse that led to my ruin” (Shelley 24). From the beginning of his education, Victor views science through a historical lens and believes that adapting older techniques will foster scientific progress. Yet, in his narrative to Walton, he cautions against the ancients and labels this method as flawed. Shelley traces the flaws of the Romantic movement back to this reliance on older iterations of

Show More
Related
128 Words | 1 Pages

In Mary Shelley’s novel Frankenstein, the character of Victor Frankenstein epitomizes the adage that intelligence and knowledge can be both a blessing and a curse. Victor’s brilliance and unrelenting thirst for knowledge drives him to create life, and it also leads to his ultimate downfall. His intelligence serves both an advantage and a problem throughout the novel. On the one hand, it enables him to make remarkable discoveries and achieve great feats, but on the other hand, it blinds him to the consequences of his actions and the ethical implications of his scientific pursuits. Thus, Victor Frankenstein's character in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein exemplifies the double-edged nature of intelligence and knowledge, as in Victor, whose brilliance

Read More
608 Words | 3 Pages

Shelley wrote the scene of his discovery in a single sentence that takes up the space of one regular sized paragraph coupled with a rhetorical question to emphasize the lengths that Victor went through to finally reach his glorifying moment of enlightenment and to question what he is striving for. To further elaborate on Victor’s journey to his discovery, Shelley juxtaposes his childhood education to his current endeavors that follow a completely opposite path; “In my education my father had taken the greatest precautions that my mind should be impressed with no supernatural horrors. I do not ever remember to have trembled at a tale of superstition, or to have feared the apparition of a spirit.” The juxtaposition enhances the contrast of the ideas Victor was raised upon, and the ideas he holds deep within himself during the present. Victor’s unconforming ideas and predilection for the mysterious reveal Shelley’s background in Romanticism and the effects that the era holds on her

Read More
398 Words | 2 Pages

In Mary Shelley's acclaimed novel 'Frankenstein,' making discoveries is presented through the scientific form of discovery, the alchemic nature in which the discoveries are made, their disastrous consequences, and highlighting the main issues of creating life. The presentation differs from that of Margaret Atwood's 'The Handmaid's Tale,' with the form of discovery focusing on personal identity, the methods being reflection and rebellion, and the consequences being resistance and terror. The concept of creating life contrasts sharply with Frankenstein, as it serves as the foundation of Gileadean society. One way which Mary Shelley presents making discoveries is through the nature of the discoveries. In ‘Frankenstein’, discoveries are often

Read More
1187 Words | 5 Pages

Nate Schramm Kusak AP English Lang Due 4/3/23 Pursuing a personal belief or ideology is a fundamental part of the human experience. This desire to accomplish one aspiration is somehow part of everyone's lives. This yearning feeling can be seen in the novel Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. However, this pursuit has negative consequences on individuals and society altogether.

Read More
909 Words | 4 Pages

In Mary Shelley’s, “Frankenstein,” Victor Frankenstein tests his limits and explores his curiosity too deeply, leading to long-lasting chaos, responsibilities, problems, and regrets. In connection to the Romantic Period in the 18th century, Shelley’s novel contains two ways of understanding how the creature Frankenstein created connects to the morals and values of the Romantic era. One, is the creature and his creator, and their obligations to each other. And two, the potential for rebellion due to the lack of obligations in place. Through Shelley’s work, we will analyze how specific aspects of Frankenstein’s work intertwined with the Romantic period writers’ reasonings.

Read More
1439 Words | 6 Pages

Kyle Lyon Professor Ed Steck AWR 201 F3 14 April 2015 Annotated Bibliography Shelley, Mary. Frankenstein. Ed. Hunter, Paul J. Norton Critical Edition.

Read More
573 Words | 3 Pages

“What Victor Did Wrong to His Creation” Frankenstein By: Draven Baker Introduction: The Book Frankenstein has many themes, exhibitions from the bible, and modern debates in the book. The book begins with a man by the name of Robert Walton, a Captain of a ship.

Read More
911 Words | 4 Pages

Reagan Evers Ms. Roberts & Mrs. Moore ENG 11: World Literature 15 March 2023 Nature and Science Are Intertwined Nature is a way to for some to escape. Lightning and electricity bridges nature and science together by the studies Victor Frankenstein conducted. In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, Victor escapes to nature any time there is adversity. While Victor’s loved ones appreciate art and humanities, Victor turns to science for understanding about how the world works.

Read More
974 Words | 4 Pages

Furthermore, Shelley examines the relation that Frankenstein and his monster have towards relevant motifs of Enlightenment such as science, religion, and humanity. To begin with, the era of Enlightenment was characterized by numerous scientific discoveries in Europe. Advances were made in various scientific fields such as astronomy, physics, and mathematics. They caused large controversies which had a deep impact on people’s thinking about God and religion.

Read More
921 Words | 4 Pages

What truly, is deception? Perhaps it may be the ability to persuade others into committing certain actions. Perhaps, it may be the ability to keep the truth hidden. The truth itself, is a very controversial topic fueled by ideology and aspects of individuals, communities and societies. While the truth may be heartbreaking , unbelieveable or may even seem irrational, its exposure will always lead to a series of events in relevance to the past.

Read More
1083 Words | 5 Pages

The classic novel Frankenstein, written by Mary Shelley in 1818, displays the use of literary devices, foreshadowing, allusions and figurative language, which aid the reader in understanding the authors opinion on scientific exploration. These techniques are used to arouse anticipation within the reader, therefore engaging them throughout the text. Along with providing a greater understanding of the novel, by referring to other books, and using the novel to portray the authors own perspective on scientific exploration. All these devices are effectively used within the novel to provide a deeper understandings of Mary Shelley’s work. Add scientific exploration here-

Read More
923 Words | 4 Pages

Castro, Maverick Ms. Levin / Ms Wu English 24 March 2023 Unknown science In modern times, science is used for both good and bad and changes as time moves forward. The novel ‘Frankenstein by Mary Shelley’ shows us what happens when you play with science and create a monster and the effect it has on people. Mary Shelly uses the characterization of Victor and the conflict he encounters to convey that there are boundaries that science should not cross, shown by his ambitions, risk taking behavior, and accountability. Everyone in life has some sort of ambition, but not always do those ambitions work out.

Read More
667 Words | 3 Pages

The knocking stopped suddenly although it’s echos were still in the house. “I’m sorry” The words resounded through the room, giving off an eerie atmosphere. Mrs.White slowly turned around, a mix of both fear and desperation in her eyes. “You didn’t” she whispered, as tears threatened to fall.

Read More
1555 Words | 7 Pages

This story is about a group of friends exploring a forest finding a cottage, but the book they get is really as strange as they thought... well more strange. “Ow!” Violet said as she was getting up from her bed banging her head on the top bunk. “Are you ok?”

Read More
1420 Words | 6 Pages

ENG-3U0 November 20 2015 Frankenstein: The Pursuit of Knowledge Throughout the course of their individual journeys, Victor Frankenstein’s extreme passion for gaining knowledge about creating life, Robert Walton’s curiosity to discover land beyond the North Pole and the monster’s eagerness to obtain knowledge about humans was the principal cause of each of their suffering. As such, In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, the pursuit of knowledge is a dangerous path which leads to suffering. Victor Frankenstein develops a keen interest in discovering knowledge about living beings which ultimately results in his personal suffering as well as others suffering. To begin with, Victor embarks on an assignment through combining body parts and following various

Read More

More about Fiction Over Fact Of Frankenstein

Related Topics

Open Document