ipl-logo

Film Analysis: The Khmer Rouge Killing Machine

887 Words4 Pages

The Khmer Rouge killing machine was filmed in the Tuol Sleng High School which the Khmer Rouge used as a detention center called S21 and is now a genocide museum. Between 1975 and 1977, nearly 17,000 people passed through its doors where they were interrogated, tortured, and executed. Vann Nath, one of only three survivors of the detention center, was a painter whose work found favor with his captors. He consoles another survivor who is unable to speak because of the grief that overcomes him in remembering the past. Nath then talks to a dozen former Khmer Rouge fighters who were prison guards, a doctor, and a photographer Houy, the deputy head of security, Khan the torturer, and Thi who kept meticulous registers at S21 try to justify their …show more content…

The guards dispassionately and predictably insist that they were just following orders, that indoctrination and fear for their own survival forced them to devolve into inhuman killing machines, but their overly enthusiastic re-creations of past abuse contradict their already sketchy rationalizations. It 's clear that institutional insanity and the regime 's perversion of Marxism have indelibly marked the guards as vividly as the righteously angry former prisoner, but S21 denies audiences any sense of catharsis or closure. Some crimes are just too horrifying to be forgiven or rationalized, and the film allows the almost unbearable horror of the Khmer Rouge to linger like an open wound in the blazing sun, playing powerful witness to an almost inconceivable tragedy. Panh 's disturbing documentary illustrates a point that the ubiquity of war renders perpetually timely: Those who deny their enemies ' humanity and dignity are doomed to lose their own.
On the other hand, “Inside Pol Pot Secret Prison (S-21)”, film does an outstanding, realistic story as to what happened in Cambodia under Khmer Rouge 's Pol Pot 's regime. My friend and I recently toured the beautiful temples and impressive history, but also part of our trip was to visit the so-called "killing fields" where Cambodians killed 1.7 million of their own people in a terror campaign of torture

Show More
Related
1384 Words | 6 Pages

One example from the novel comes from Hong when she and Amah are reunited with the rest of the Ung family. Hong tells them about her own Khmer Rouge experience. Chou narrates Hong’s story and says, “ Hong tells them about how she saw a young boy beaten to death with sticks because the soldiers said he was lazy. Hongs words come out in spits and anger when she reports that the boy was slow with his work because he was sick and starving… After that Hong became the best worker in her unit even though she was many years younger than the others. ”(pg55)

Read More
937 Words | 4 Pages

The pills dance in my palms, gleaming white and inviting…. Somewhere in Cambodia, I dream that Pa and Ma are sleeping together in the ground. I close my eyes and wait for Pa to come take me with him. In her crib, Tori cries but I ignore her.” (180-181) Loung has a deep need to kill herself not only because of her painful memories of Cambodia but also because of her grieving for Pa, Ma, Keav and Geak.

Read More
1594 Words | 7 Pages

The Elimination: A Survivor of the Khmer Rouge Confronts His Past and the Commandant of the Killing Fields. Rithy Panh is an internationally and critically acclaimed Cambodian documentary film director and screenwriter. Rithy Panh was a young boy when Khmer Rouge revolutionaries arrived in Phnom Penh on April 17, 1975. Starting that day, he and his family were designated “new people”—the revolution’s code for those who needed “re-education”—and forcibly evacuated out of the city. That day began a terrifying experience that gradually took away most of his family, forcing Rithy to survive a series of brutal, and often arbitrarily cruel, ordeals.

Read More
844 Words | 4 Pages

He conveys a very accurate depiction of the brutality and chaos that emerged in Sierra Leone during the war. He shows how young boys were exploited by armed groups. His depiction of the atrocities he has watched and carried out himself is horrifying and deeply upsetting. For example, the image of guns in the book represents the power and control of those who wield them. In his memoir, Beah says, “The corporal gave the signal with a pistol shot and I grabbed the man’s head and slit his throat in one fluid motion,” (Beah).

Read More
183 Words | 1 Pages

In Ishmael Beah’s memoir ‘a long way gone’, Beah describes his experience as a child soldier. A deep message that Beah conveys is that “children have the resilience to outlive their sufferings if given the chance”. During Beah’s journey as a child soldier, he commits multiple graphic acts under the influence of drugs, such as demanding that prisoners dig their own graves, then burying them alive (151). This event shows how far gone mentally Beah

Read More
436 Words | 2 Pages

All the killing and torturing of prisoners, the massacre of My Lai and etc. was not right. This is not how people should treat other human beings. One soldier in the documentary said he wonders about the families of the Vietnamese he just killed. He felt that the Vietnamese was fighting to reunify

Read More
163 Words | 1 Pages

In First they Killed My Father by Loung Ung, Loung Ung writes about what her family experienced living under the Khmer Rouge during the Cambodian genocide. The pattern expected of people that experience atrocities like the ones Loung Ung and her family did is that, if they are to survive, they’ll want to take revenge upon the people who are responsible for it or at least see justice for the people that lost their lives during the genocide. While she does not carry out the revenge herself, in one of the most brutal chapters of the book, Loung Ung, does exactly what’s expected when she goes to watch the execution of a Khmer rouge soldier, despite her sister telling her that she didn’t want to attend at that she shouldn’t attend either. Loung

Read More
1219 Words | 5 Pages

Loung Ung’s First They Killed My Father is a vivid, detailed memoir of a young girl’s experiences in Cambodia throughout the Khmer Rouge era. It records in expressive detail the horrors suffered by the Ung and her family while living under the oppressive rule of the insane Khmer Rouge. Meanwhile, First They Killed Her Sister by Soneath Hor, Sody Lay and Grantham Quinn is a lengthy criticism in direct opposition to the aforementioned memoir. Although the authors of First They Killed Her Sister made some excellent points throughout their assessment of First They Killed my Father such as showing how Ung having misrepresented some aspects of Khmer culture and history, they completely and utterly failed in their attempt to discredit her based on the claims that she perpetuated racial tension and distorted what really happened in 1970s Cambodia, which breaks down the few good points they did have. The critics correctly assert and prove that Ung misrepresented certain aspects of Khmer culture and history, showing that at times, Ung’s description of what had happened was distorted or partially fabricated.

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

The Khmer Rouge was a revolutionary group who wanted to reconstruct Cambodian society.   On April 17, 1975 the Khmer Rouge attacked the capitol Phnom Penh. As soon as the Khmer Rouge got to the capitol they started to force the people to leave all their possessions and march to the rural part of Cambodia. “Hospital patients

Read More
112 Words | 1 Pages

The My Lai Massacre was a significant event in the Vietnam War. Hundreds of innocent villagers were murdered by a portion of the Charlie Company. Most of the victims were elderly, 70-80, and children, as young as three. They also raped women, clubbed people, executed them (then most likely dumped into a mass grave), and carved C’s into their chests. A cover-up was created but it was no use, the American people found out.

Read More
1813 Words | 8 Pages

Between 1975 and 1979, an estimate of 2 million Cambodians were sent to the Killing Fields after the Khmer Rouge regime took over power. Within these fields, many people were either killed, starved, or worked to death so the regime may maintain an ethnic superiority and partake in an extreme version of Maoism. The Missing Picture and Enemies of the People are documentaries that take different approaches to tell the stories of Cambodians who were not only affected, but took part in the genocide. Both documentaries ultimately display documentary filmmaking, styles and issues that occur while making a film.

Read More
654 Words | 3 Pages

Rahul Mone Mrs. Marsden ELA Honors I 4 February, 2016 The Cambodian Genocide The genocides of Cambodia and the Holocaust were two major genocides that have changed the history of the world forever. The Cambodian genocide started when the Khmer Rouge attempted to nationalize and centralize the peasant farming society of Cambodia (Quinn 63).

Read More
971 Words | 4 Pages

The dehumanization of the Vietnamese is further stressed by the scene in a village where the squad is attacked by the VC and one of the soldiers is killed. Seeing their friend dying, Meserve and other soldiers express their hatred for the Vietnamese. Considering the Vietnamese as their sworn enemy, the soldiers take their kidnapping and rapping the girl as almost natural avenging actions, which shows the loss of humanity during the

Read More
896 Words | 4 Pages

When the Rwanda genocide began in 1994, its population stood at more that 7 people. Roughly 85% of the population was Hutu, 14% Tutsi, and 1% Twa (un.org). The decades following Rwanda’s independence from Belgium in 1962 saw growing ethnic tensions and periodic violent attacks and reprisals between Rwanda’s Hutu majority and its Tutsi minority. On April 6, 1994, the deaths of the Presidents of Burundi and Rwanda in a plane crash caused by a rocket attack, ignited several weeks of intense and systematic massacres.

Read More
852 Words | 4 Pages

By 1975 the Vietnam war had claimed over 5 million lives, many of which were civilians. This has made it a war that Americans have been ashamed of and tried to forget. W. S. Merwin was outspoken on how he felt about war, which he shows in “The Asians Dying.” He makes a statement on the inhumane way the Vietnam war took human lives. ” The Asians Dying” will shock readers with its gruesome imagery and force them to look at what war does.

Read More

More about Film Analysis: The Khmer Rouge Killing Machine

Related Topics

Open Document