ipl-logo

Sincere Flattery By Virgil And Dante Alighieri In The Divine Comedy

876 Words4 Pages

Jeanne McDonald
LIT 4330
8 October 2015
Sincere Flattery It has been said that flattery will get you everywhere. According to Dante Alighieri in The Divine Comedy everywhere includes the pits of Hell. In Canto XVIII of Inferno, Virgil and Dante make their way through the second pouch of the eighth circle of Hell. It is here that Virgil introduces those who have been damned for the sin of flattery. This includes the Greek hetaira Thaïs who is punished for flattering her lover. While there are many unique characters seen along Dante and Virgil’s descent into the depths of Hell, none might be more deserving of a reprieve from its horrors than Thaïs. To make The Divine Comedy a piece of fiction that appeared as non-fiction, Dante had to cast …show more content…

This is seen in Canto VI, lines 58 and 59, “I answered him: “Ciacco, your suffering / so weighs on me that I am forced to weep”, however, there is no indication from the text that Dante actually cries over Ciacco. He’s stroking the shades ego to obtain the information he pleases. Him complimenting a sinner, someone who is in the pits of Hell, in order to gain their trust and thus their story is no different than the historical manifestation of Thaïs complimenting her lover to gain his favor in the political realm. More, where is the proof that she did not, in fact, mean what she said? Focusing on the historical version of Thaïs, her being a courtesan in no way makes her a gold digger or a seeker of fame, which is exactly the type of people Dante flattered. It is her independence that made her viable to not only Alexander the Great but also to her eventual husband, Ptolemy the king of …show more content…

If anything, her crime was lust, not flattery. Even Virgil calls her a harlot. If that were the case, why was she put in the lower level of Hell? Her only
McDonald 3

sin would be of appetite not malice, and even still that is not a proven fact. While history records that Alexander the Great enjoyed Thaïs’ company, there is no verifiable proof that any kind of sexual relationship took place between the two of them. Once again, this leads to the belief that she did not deserve to be placed in Hell. Now, this is not to say she is blameless of any or all sin, but her sins did not warrant her punishment. The contrapasso bestowed on her is invalid. Forced to into the furthest depths of Hell and encrusted in human excrement seems like a vicious punishment for someone who allegedly did nothing more than Dante did himself. If judging her only on the basis of Dante’s actions, her release from Hell into Purgatory seems reasonable. After all, she was only doing her job. McDonald

Show More
Related
570 Words | 3 Pages

There are copious beliefs that the uncommitted life is not worth living, which is especially believed within Jesus. In the Bible, the story explains how Jesus was sacrificed by dying for our sins. Jesus died for all of humankind to have a chance of redeeming our sinful acts, but not for wasteful lives. This relates to Dante’s Inferno because being uncommitted is a sin, as it is in the real world. Being Uncommitted is enough to be doomed to Hell, which is where suffering really exaggerates pain and distress.

Read More
1247 Words | 5 Pages

Dante’s Inferno is an epic poem by Durante “Dante” degli Alighieri, written in the 1300s. He wrote a trilogy, known as the Divine Comedy, consisting of Inferno, Purgatory, and Paradise. Dante was inspired by many events and issues happening at that time, such as the war between Guelphs and Ghibellines, the Battle of Montaperti, and Christian religious beliefs. In this paper, I will explore the first book, Inferno, on the topic of Hell and how the sinners had a significant impact on Dante’s journey through Hell. In Circle 5: Styx, Canto VIII, Filippo Argenti, a sinner of Wrathful, helped Dante to symbolize to readers his anger towards Black Guelphs, political enemies of the White Guelphs.

Read More
1345 Words | 6 Pages

The prisoners receive a thematically equivalent punishment to their actions in their previous lives. As the deeper circles of hell are populated by the worst inmates, the concept of contrapasso elicits exceedingly jarring punishments the further Dante travels. The nine total circles of hell are large enough to populate a lifetime 's worth of the world’s sins. When Dante is introduced to the first circle of hell, reserved for pagans, it is clear that the inmates are bound eternally to live in the Inferno, for even those who did not conciously commit sin, are forced to stay in this realm. In his real life, Alighieri was highly vocal about political stances.

Read More
1237 Words | 5 Pages

Thus, Francesca and Paolo committed the sin of adultery. Yet, Dante wants to draw attention to something; the word “adultery” never appears through the 147 lines of Inferno 5. This is quite interesting. Dante makes the reader to realize the fact that it is not the adultery causing the fate of these lovers, yet something else causes it. Francesca was helpless in the face of love, yet her passivity against love does not negate any guilt.

Read More
1662 Words | 7 Pages

Throughout his “Divine Comedy,” Dante Alighieri encounters with two women, who are antithetical to one another in terms of their roles in the context of love. These two women; Francesca di Rimini and Beatrice, have similar emotional experiences since both have relationships outside marriage; yet, they have different roles when Dante explores the notion of love. The reader meets Francesca in Inferno, while meets Beatrice in Paradiso. In other words, one of them is being punished, whereas the other woman is placed at a divine level. Thus, the female characters within the poem represents two distinct roles of women: either as a pure and holy being, or as a sinful entity.

Read More
1040 Words | 5 Pages

(354-357) Born then says the final line within Canto 28, “Thus is observed in me the counterpoise.” (358) Not all of Dante’s Hell continues the trend of being a place made only for people who have committed grave sin. The reader finds in Canto 4 that many great poets and people that existed prior to the death of Jesus Christ inhabit the first circle. (88-90) Finally, Dante’s phrases his idea of hell in a very interesting way in Canto 3 by saying those in hell have “foregone the good of intellect” (18)

Read More
982 Words | 4 Pages

In The Comedy, Dante the Pilgrim develops a relationship with his damned idol, Virgil, in order to journey through both Inferno and Purgatory. Even though Virgil was a good man while living, he lacked understanding of certain virtues, like pride, which prevented him from being able to reach higher levels in the afterlife. Dante the Poet’s choice to damn Virgil conveys that obeying a higher order is the way to one’s salvation. The developing relationship between Virgil and Dante the Pilgrim throughout the first two canticles brings light to the opposing separation between the two characters because of the devotion Dante has to Christian virtues in comparison to Virgil’s pagan misunderstanding of virtue. While Dante the Pilgrim experiences many

Read More
609 Words | 3 Pages

Contrapasso shall always be just because justice is not prejudice. Justice like contrapasso has no pity or remorse, and it cannot be reasoned with or bribed. It is set perfectly and Dante set hell up with that philosophy for its cruelty. All evil shall receive the eternal discipline that God had set

Read More
851 Words | 4 Pages

The Misfit was a purely evil character while the Grandmother had good intentions. Color symbolism was used throughout the story to give an insight of what is going to happen eventually. The animals also played a large portion of the symbolism attached to… The Misfit along with Hiram and Bobby Lee were all purely evil characters that killed everyone in his way.

Read More
1078 Words | 5 Pages

The year is 1302, Dante Alighieri is absent from his role as one of the six supreme magistrates. Prior to that he had an extremely successful political career who had no problem exerting his power. Dante considered himself “a moderate White, he found it necessary during the two-month term to join in banishing his brother-in-law, Corso Donati, and his "first friend," Guido Cavalcanti, as ringleaders respectively of the Blacks and Whites.” Blacks and Whites were faction groups who had ongoing fights in the streets of Florence. This is an extremely admirable trait of a great ruler and/or ruler, the ability to at any moment turn on friends or family in order to uphold the city or government.

Read More
1203 Words | 5 Pages

In the epic poem The Odyssey, Homer portrays Greek gods and goddesses as possessing human qualities and faults. Through their actions and emotions, Homer emphasizes the detrimental effects of lust, envy, wrath, and greed in ancient Grecian society. He also never fails to remind readers of the importance of respect for holy figures because of their powerful abilities to create chaos and wonder". Homer wants to prove that gods and humans share a variety of traits, and the only difference is that god don’t allow these flaws negatively to impact their society. To help further his argument, we can compare Greek gods and goddesses to that of Christianity.

Read More
1874 Words | 8 Pages

But, as the poem continues to progress, it becomes quite clear the there is a perfect balance within God’s justice as the degree of each sinner’s punishment perfectly reflects upon the gravity of the sin. Furthermore, the inscription on the gates of Hell explicitly states that Hell exists as a result of divine justice; “ll. “ Justice moved my great maker; God eternal / Wrought me: the power and the unsearchably / High wisdom, and the primal love supernal (III.4-6).” Prior to delving into the structure of Hell and how it displays God’s divine justice, one must first familiarize themselves with both the historical context of Dante’s life, along with the beliefs of the medieval church.

Read More
1207 Words | 5 Pages

Dante ensures this happens by using the concept of contrapasso, which describes the relationship between sin and the resulting justification in Hell. The literal definition of contrapasso is the 'counter-strike' or the 'counter-suffering which translates literally as "counter-penalty." And in Dante’s Hell, sinners are punished according to the nature of their sin, so that their punishment fits their crime. And as we see throughout the story, some sinners literally become the personification of their sins while others become victims in Hell of the crimes they committed while on

Read More
741 Words | 3 Pages

Dante’s Inferno represents a microcosm of society; meaning, laymen, church, politicians, and scholars are all compiled into one place and punished for their sins. Hell, despite being depicted as brutal, ugly, and chaotic, is made realistic because the inhabitants come from every country and every walk of life. While Dante Alighieri did not invent the idea of Hell itself, he did create an important and in depth concept that still receives attention in biblical, classical, and medieval works. The Divine Comedy itself was written sometime between the years 1308 and 1321 and scholars still consider it the “supreme work of Italian literature.” The work itself is an epic poem divided into three separate sections: Inferno, Purgatorio, and Paradiso; respectively Hell, Purgatory, and Heaven.

Read More
480 Words | 2 Pages

Dante’s Inferno details the long journey of Dante and Virgil, throughout the bowels of Hell, or the Inferno. Dante’s Inferno is organized into nine different levels, each distributing a different and awful punishment to every different sin. The main sins include the seven deadly sins, “Wrath, Sloth, Lust, Greed, Pride, Gluttony, Envy”, he also included “Treachery” and “Violence”. The three sins that I believe fit their sins would be “Wrath/Sulleness”, “Greed” and “Gluttony”.

Read More

More about Sincere Flattery By Virgil And Dante Alighieri In The Divine Comedy

Related Topics

Open Document