ipl-logo

Forest Service Pros And Cons

1027 Words5 Pages

Introduction
As an agency with field offices across the country, the United States Forest Service (USFS) exhibits discrepancies between its national goals and policy in comparison to its on-the-ground operations. In fact, its procedural outcomes greatly vary across its field offices, and these localized outcomes differ from its on-the-books policy (Struthers et al. 2021, 688-689, 697-698; Shultz, Thompson, and McCaffrey 2019, 9). This variation elicits a broader question: why does the USFS produce inconsistent implementation of national goals and policy? In this essay, I propose that the USFS exhibits this inconsistency because stakeholders, on the national and local levels, complicate the agency’s uniform and effective implementation of federal …show more content…

As a component of forest management, the Forest Service has increasingly sought to engage local communities across the US by establishing collaborative groups. Orth and Cheng’s case study of three of these “collaborative groups” demonstrates that rural communities have embedded themselves in field offices’ decision-making and operational processes by negotiating the USFS’s operational boundaries (Orth and Cheng 2017, 64-65). For instance, multiple field offices have co-founded Memorandums of Understanding (MOU) with community organizations to define “boundaries of responsibility.” Through these agreements, communities can channel their “expectations, communications, interactions, and resources” to their local field offices. These MOUs have “increas[ed] the [service’s] restoration actions,” delegated the Forest Service’s work to community partners, permitted community members to acquire knowledge typically reserved for forest service officers, and opened funding channels for field offices (Orth and Cheng 2017, 71-75). Since not all field offices have established MOUs and each MOU is unique, the Forest Service’s localized collaboration produces variation in work between its offices. How these field offices reconfigure their boundaries of information sharing and work responsibilities with the public creates …show more content…

As mandated by federal law, “field offices are responsible for factoring in local needs when selecting actions, such as approving permits or beginning bureaucratic actions.” For constituent services, Members of Congress (MCs) often intervene on the behalf of their constituents with federal agencies. When field offices factor in community interests, “MCs can lobby field bureaucrats to initiate actions they prefer” and “influence the procedural rigor of [the] bureaucratic decision process” (Struthers et al. 2021, 687-693). To test whether this intervention may have had an impact on the USFS’s decisions, Struthers et al.’s empirical study found that “under low and moderate unemployment levels, forests with congressional representatives who oppose environmental regulation have higher rates of extractive actions and use less rigorous [bureaucratic] analyses than forests with” environmentally conscious representatives. These findings suggest that communities do influence the USFS’s procedures through their Congressional representatives depending on political attitudes. Making this explanation convincing, Forest Service officials have confirmed that MCs try to influence field offices’ decisions (Struthers et al. 202, 687-688). Although this study does not prove that MCs interfere or that this interference is successful, it offers a

Show More
Related
160 Words | 1 Pages

Paul Starobin’s “Pork: A Time Honored Tradition Lives On” discusses the control exerted upon local appropriations by the Legislative Branch. The author points the divide the practice of “porking” creates within the House, fiscal conservatives are fundamentally against it, while some democrats support the action. Those in opposed to the method find that it creates budget inefficiencies because the federal funding is being used to finance local projects and special interests, which is generally done for political gain. However, those in favor, believe, as elected officials, their duty is to fight for the benefits of the people and areas they were chosen to represent. In reality, there needs to be a healthy balance between the two sides, central

Read More
614 Words | 3 Pages

Lee H. Hamilton, a former congressman in the House of Representatives, wrote, The Case for Congress, to share some of the criticisms he has heard over the years and to explain the effects of such opinions. Hamilton speaks of three main criticisms: “Congress is run by lobbyists and special interests”, “Congress almost seems to promote total gridlock”, and “There’s too much money in Politics” (Hamilton 2004). For each of these criticisms, Hamilton explains these thoughts and his opinion on the matter. The strongest point of Hamilton’s argument was in defending the lobbyists in Congress. Hamilton (2004) said the public opinion of lobbyists is that “Congress is manipulated by powerful wheel-dealers who put pressure on legislators and buy votes through extensive campaigns and other favors” (p. 83).

Read More
585 Words | 3 Pages

The government has passed many conservation policies to protect animals, eco-systems, plants and trees itself and indigenous people’s way of life, but many of these policies get overlooked and require a lot of extra work. How it affects the rest of the world- This action is permanent, and all of the world is targeted as a potential setting for deforestation. It is predicted that the continuing action may result in very few rainforest across the entire globe. Cutting trees can also be harmful to our ozone layer, which protects earth from dangerous radiation.

Read More
1122 Words | 5 Pages

Ever since the creation of Congress, it has not been uncommon to hear or see negative criticisms about it. Congress has evolved from when it was created, but the role it plays has not changed. Even though there are many criticisms about the ways on how Congress is run, the system is an important and essential part of the United States government. Integral it may be, but today, many people find it difficult to answer the questions of how Congress works, what it does, and why it exists. In Lee Hamilton’s How Congress Works and Why you Should Care, the author shows what Congress actually does do and how it affects the American people every single day.

Read More
1671 Words | 7 Pages

Preservationists frequently clashed with companies who saw the wilderness merely in terms of resources for production, or spaces for residential and commercial developments. Though Roosevelt was a passionate preservationist, he understood the necessity of conciliation between the generally split populous. His compromise was a conservation program that provided the regulated use of the nation’s wilderness. In 1905, Congress created the Forest Service, at the president’s advising, to manage the newly established federally owned forest reserves; he appointed fellow preservationist Gifford Pinchot as the head of the new agency.

Read More
547 Words | 3 Pages

James Anderson’s The Education of Blacks in the South, 1860-1935 discusses the creation and black devotion to education. Anderson argues that contrary to popular belief, blacks laid the foundation for their education, and even though others sought to control the system, blacks still fought for their own education the way they saw fit. He also argues that there has been pivotal relationship between education and oppressed groups—American education has always funded education for all (Anderson, 1988, p.5). I believe Anderson argues this through opposition, emancipation, and fighting low standards. Anderson begins the monograph with discussion of the postwar South and how they were hostile to the idea of black schooling.

Read More
764 Words | 4 Pages

The Corps projects and impact of their work was seen in “the towns and villages neighboring the more than 5,000 camps nationwide” (Pg. 115). Ecological changes began altering local economies and changing physical landscapes, such as Coon Valley, Wisconsin with the production of dairy farms. This allowed local farmers to ship their dairy products to distant markets, which created the idea that “natural resources were commodities ripe for exploitation” and symbolized “a farmer’s competence to the wider community” (Pg. 118-119). With the arrival of camps, also known as “bright spots” in the Great Smokey Mountains, portions of hillsides were replanted, forest floors were “fire proofed”, and motor roads were built throughout national parks (Pg. 135-137). Thousands of natural landscapes left behind by the Civilian Conservation Corps are still seen across the country in farms, forests, and parks.

Read More
751 Words | 4 Pages

President Theodore Roosevelt, the 26th President of the United States, was known for his love of nature. This was conveyed most strongly in his speeches, such as “Conservation as a National Duty”, in which he advocated for the preservation of natural resources in the interests of the nation and its people. In this speech as well as others he gave during his term as President, he stressed that conservation did not just pertain to preserving natural resources or deferring their exhaustion; rather, it was closely intertwined with the patriotic duty of ensuring that the nation would be able to provide for future generations, and was second only to the “great fundamental questions of morality”. One such example of how Roosevelt connected conservation with morality is found in his “The New Nationalism” speech, given in Osawatomie, Kansas in 1910. Here, he compares the way he believes the nation must behave in terms of conservation to the manner in which a farmer acts in reference to his children and the land that provides for them.

Read More
793 Words | 4 Pages

In 1905, Roosevelt helped fund the U.S. Forest Service. The U.S. Forest Service was created to protect natural areas and forests from excessive development. Roosevelt appointed Gifford Pinchot to be head of the Forest Service. Like President Roosevelt, Pinchot advise a policy to conserve the natural environment while balance out the demands of economic development the need to conserve the natural environment. Under Roosevelt, the federal government set out of the way almost 150 million acres of national

Read More
539 Words | 3 Pages

This essay will discuss the impact of lobbyist on legislation in Washington, DC and the amount of dollars spent to influence federal policies. Throughout a normal day in Washington DC, the hustle and bustle of lobbyist is taking place in the Capital building, White House and along K Street, which is the home of many of the lobbying firms. There are special interest groups, corporations and industries that hire in-house lobbyist or lobbyist firms to influence legislation to benefit their cause. For example, some of these causes may include, but are not limited to tax breaks, subsidies and changes to current regulations or laws.

Read More
1022 Words | 5 Pages

His friend, Gifford Pinchot, studied forestry in Nancy, France. Theodore had been acquainted with Pinchot prior to his presidency, and appointed Pinchot Chief of the U.S. Forest Service. The partnership made a formidable combination. The national forests covered 56 million acres at the U.S. Forest Service’s conception in 1905 and 172 million acres only 5 years later. Not only did the two men increase the area of national forests, but also set precedents for responsible management of forested areas.

Read More
1616 Words | 7 Pages

Enter Bob Heil, a resident of California. He is intrigued by actions, both politically and environmentally. Heil finds interest in learning new things about the world where the government and nature meet, creating new opportunities for volunteers, politicians, and environmentalists alike. Heil also notices the “ground troops” in most nature-based charities and how they are constantly striving and helping to make a difference in both the United States’ wilderness and government (Heil). Heil hopes to encourage more and more environmental clubs to be involved politically and make a difference.

Read More
1003 Words | 5 Pages

For an example, if there is a community that has a plant near their neighborhood and they are polluting their water supply. Homeowners will notice that their water supply are polluted with the plant’s chemical. They will most likely take this up with their elected officials. Then congress gets an issue that a plant is polluting into a water supply and the people would like this business to fix this problem. Now congress has to decide if they should or should not regulate

Read More
944 Words | 4 Pages

Interest groups in Texas are relatively powerful actors in the political process. Organized interest groups and their representatives, also known as “the lobby” participates in the policymaking and political processes in Texas. Interest groups provide critical channels for Texans to communicate their political preferences and attempt to influence government actors and their fellow

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

His research includes important insights about how directives are interpreted by Forest Service administration. In supporting his argument in regards to the effective organizational structure of the USFS, Kaufman emphasizes several key components that contribute to its success. He points to the Park District Rangers who were given a great deal of autonomy in the agency 's decision-making process. This is the first of several important aspects of the organizational structure that the book talks about. The USFS decentralized much the responsibilities and authority to the District Rangers.

Read More

More about Forest Service Pros And Cons

Related Topics

Open Document