ipl-logo

God Bless America Analysis

1027 Words5 Pages

Is God Bless America An Offensive Song?
A Review of the Literature
The article, “Major League Baseball must permanently retire ‘God Bless America,’ a song that offends everyone”, by Gersh Kuntzman seeks to address how a particular religious song and professional baseball interact negatively. The argument discusses inappropriateness of “God Bless America” being played at baseball games and how it offends people everywhere.
In order to create a strong, well-rounded argument, there are several components that go into a writer’s piece, such as tone, logic and evidence. Kuntzman’s article is weak because of lack of evidence, immaterial logic and ill-mannered tone.
Kuntzman’s weakest point in this article is his usage of such arrogant tone in his …show more content…

This article is flawed with comparisons that either do not pertain to the article or otherwise do not make sense. For example, he states, “Unlike “God Bless America,” the better seventh-inning song, “Take Me Out to the Ballgame,” captures the essential joy of American life”. This comparison is purely opinionated. He states his personal belief that “Take Me Out to the Ballgame” is a better song than “God Bless America”. According to the title of his article, the article should be focused on why God Bless America is an inappropriate song to play, not comparing a different song that he likes better. Furthermore, this comparison is almost completely inaccurate because both songs include great lyrics that do, in fact, depict American life. Once again just to reiterate Kuntzmans’ words, “the song still embodies great things about America, but also our worst things: self-righteousness, forced piety, earnest self-reverence, foam”. While Kuntzman’s article may support this quote by following up with quotes from others depicting American’s as people who portray these traits, Kuntzman’s article is actually the best example of these forementioned traits, as I explained in the analysis of his

Show More
Related

Rhetorical Analysis Essay On Dave Grossman

212 Words | 1 Pages

This point is an example of the contradictions Grossman makes and also a point in which causes the reader question the author’s credibility in the essay. Subsequently in the essay, Grossman mentions a mental response which incite

Read More

John Duffy's 'Virtuous Arguments' Reading Response

550 Words | 3 Pages

John Duffy makes a pivotal point. Us students should take advantage of the vital writing courses offered at the universities to further our education as well as our life skills. Learning to make a valid argument is a necessary tool in college to achieve a valid viewpoint from both sides of the given

Read More

The Locavore Myth Analysis: Argument

941 Words | 4 Pages

The Toulmin method is an effective tool that helps determine the efficacy of an argument by using this method the author’s argumentative strategies are evaluated to determine their strength. This essay will use the Toulmin method in order to assess the strength of James E. McWilliams’ argument. The Toulmin method will break down the author’s argument into components—the claim, evidence, warrant, qualifiers, and rebuttal. Through using the Toulmin method, Williams’ argument and the components of his argument will be dissected and individually analyzed to determine each component’s effectiveness and how it contributes to the overall power and credibility of Williams’ argument.

Read More

Welcome To America By Lecrea Analysis

411 Words | 2 Pages

The song “Welcome to America” by Lecrea, conveys the double entendre of America. Lecrea demonstrates how America is a stage prediction that is set up to look picture perfect to the outside world, however, some may argue that America is not what it claims to be. Lecrea portrays three different characters, and their view on America. One character lives in poverty, the second character is a military veteran, and the final character is a foreign man whose dreams of coming to America. Lecrea’s tone is solemn, serious, critical and incredulous, he raises awareness of what America represents when it comes to their own, and people from other countries.

Read More

My Body My Closet Analysis

599 Words | 3 Pages

Issac, "Skeletons in the Closet", by Clara Spotted Elk, is an effective essay due to Elk's usage of emotionally packed words and phrases. Her passionate stance on the topic as well as her personal experience on the issue. The rhetorical questions, as well as her strong vocabulary help the audience clearly understand her opinion and reasoning. Readers feel personally connected to the issue and, as a result, feel more connected to the topic. Elk also provides her audience with in-depth background information that gives readers a full understanding on the topic.

Read More

Gerald Graff And Birkenstein's 'THE SAY, I Say'

577 Words | 3 Pages

Have you ever noticed that the voices of others build up your own response? Gaining a perspective on this question is not an easy task to reflect on especially when people’s arguments determines your own. Gerald Graff’s and Cathy Birkenstein’s book, “THEY SAY, I SAY”, abridges their perspective on difficulties students face with persuasive writing. By deliberately including academic templates, the book assists students to overcome their inability of constructing their own arguments, based on what others have said. Covering the first four chapters; “they say”, “I say”, “trying is all together”, and “In specific academic context” I will showcase how Graff and Birkenstein’s book aid students to better express their personal thoughts.

Read More

Disadvantages Of Being Mexican America

70 Words | 1 Pages

Hi Azaliaiza, I totally agree with you when you say that both authors focuses on how they feel unaccepted by society in the United Sates and Mexico. Nevertheless,it is true that both authors express the struggles of being Mexican American but also in Americo Poem he expresse the advantage of being Mexican America when he says that we get to celebrate more holidays since we come from two different cultures.

Read More

Black Lives Matter Movement Rhetorical Analysis

501 Words | 3 Pages

The National Anthem goes on every single time before a game begins. Each time it is being sung everyone usually stands up to show respect for America. While, news said that a few athletic players that have been sitting down, while the National Anthem goes on. This keeps happening more and more slowly because those athletics don’t believe that America lives up to that potential in the song as it once represented. As well as the incidents that happened with the police of excessive force being used against people unassertively.

Read More

American Baseball Religion

882 Words | 4 Pages

Yenesis Murillo 16 December 2015 Professor Cummings RS 100 The Hidden Religious Significance of American Baseball Abstract I have reviewed the hidden religious significance in American Baseball, how similar the two matters tie together is remarkable. There is not one aspect of baseball that does not tie together with religion from the first pitch being thrown to the hot dog eating fan in the stand; the similarities are undeniable. I. Introduction

Read More

Walt Whitman And Langston Hughes Essay

648 Words | 3 Pages

"I Hear America Singing" focuses on the glories of America, showcasing the happiness and joy that is present on a daily basis. This is clearly evidenced in one of the lines from Whitman's poem: "Singing with open mouths their strong melodious songs." However, "I, Too, Sing America highlights the darker side of American life during this era. Unlike Whitman, Hughes' poem takes a much more serious tone, that forces the reader to consider the other side of the coin. This is poignately illustrated in the line, "And be ashamed -" which points to the "they" that will be ashamed in the future for how "they" treated the African American

Read More

I Hear America Singing And I Too Essay

835 Words | 4 Pages

In the two poems, “I Hear America Singing,” and, “I, Too,” there are many similarities and differences that show us that know matter what is happening you have to stand up for yourself and do what you love. We see this in the two poems, “I Hear America Singing,” and, “I, Too” when the authors, Walt Whitman and Langston Hughes, both talk about what America was a like in the 1900s, and how people were doing jobs that they had liked to do. We can see how a African American man would stand up for himself and we see this in the poem “I, Too” because we are able to see how he was able to stand up to everyone else and prove he was able to be treated like anyone else.

Read More

Persuasive Speech About Native American Culture

946 Words | 4 Pages

The United States of America is a land of freedom, a land of equality, and opportunity. We value independence and should look to exercise this in every form, as a nation. We must stay united and show respect to one another. This means we should not disregard ones ' ethnicity and culture, and use names in which are offensive towards their culture, in order to promote any sort of activity. This is aimed mainly at sports teams that carry racially inappropriate names.

Read More

Baseball In America Research Paper

847 Words | 4 Pages

“Every day is a new opportunity. You can build on yesterday 's success or put its failures behind and start over again. That 's the way life is, with a new game every day, and that 's the way baseball is”(Bob Feller). People in America besides the food, the jobs, and the freedom love and enjoy Americas sports. While a great many of people see football as “America 's game”, baseball has been “America 's game” for over a generation.

Read More

The Yellow Birds By Kevin Powers: A Literary Analysis

1010 Words | 5 Pages

Long, American fingers crossing over 49ers jerseys. Orioles caps plucked from foreheads. A troop of nine year olds in blue speedos impatiently tapping their feet and twisting their legs as a loudspeaker screeches overhead. A celebrity wrapped in a tight red dress, pressing a microphone to the puckered “o” of her lips as her vocal cords strive for new heights. Every Superbowl, every little league game, every hot, heated, and overcrowded band of bottoms squeezed on metal, dented bleachers, Americans, aided by pride and alcohol, bellow the “Star Spangled Banner.”

Read More

A Quilt Of A Country Analysis

584 Words | 3 Pages

America is a place where countless diverse ethnicities have accumulated over time, mingling together to establish the American culture as we know it today. Although the pieces themselves are differing from each other, they actually have a few similarities. They both discuss the point that America is from a plethora of cultures and there is no “stock” American. For example, an excerpt from A Quilt of a Country:”That’s

Read More

More about God Bless America Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document