ipl-logo

Coming Of Age In Ernest Hemingway's The Girl

717 Words3 Pages

Approach I have chosen to comparatively analyse these two stories by using the story grammar. By doing so I am able to show how each components (characters, objects, structure, language, events, and location) in these stories contributes in representing the theme: “coming of age”. Theme Development The theme “coming of age”, can be described as the protagonist’s psychological and moral journey to define oneself. Through this process they become more awake to limitations, more realistic, and more mature. In the beginning of both stories, the protagonists are illustrated as sensitive and perhaps weak. It is clear in Hemingway’s, The Girl is dependent on The American, countlessly considering abortion in order for things to ‘be like they were’, …show more content…

This causes an emotional strain for the protagonist, thus fuelling her towards this quest of self-realisation. In Hemingway’s story, The Girl journeys into this quest when she awakes to the limitation of her decision -set by The American. The Girl tries to regain (or discover) her autonomy by rebelling. First rebelling inwardly through her subconscious by seeing the hills ‘…like white elephants’, and describing ‘the colouring of their skin through the trees.’ Moreover, she continues to rebel outwardly, by using sarcasm continuing to straightforwardly speak out against The American. For Munro’s protagonist, Janet fulfils this journey by finally acknowledging history and its repercussions. The predetermined faith of her father helps her reach this conclusion, especially as he consoles her about his regrets in “a wasted life” and reiterates his expectation of her. Firstly, his regrets makes her conclude that age and atrophy is inevitable and she too may have lived “a wasted life”. Secondly, she has allowed external factors -such as overcoming her father’s expectations, or illusions of Nicola’s leukaemia- influence her happiness and

Show More
Related
1497 Words | 6 Pages

“Where Is It Written?” by Adam Schwartz, is a story about a dysfunctional Jewish family, which his parents get divorced. Sam first was in his father's house. Then, his mother’s wanted him back, when he went to his mother house, everything went upside down, fight and more fights. they had a lot of fights during the story. Finally, he went to live with his father and he never saw his mom again.

Read More
1089 Words | 5 Pages

1 “Where Is It Written?” by Adam Schwartz, is a story about a boy who wanted to live with his father because he didn’t like how she treats him and how he was living. Then, his mother tried to stop him from leaving instead of trying to solve the problem by listening to him, and do what he is asking her to do. She decided to not listen and that’s what made Sam tell his father to go to court and sue his mother. Finally, the judge decided that Sam can live with his father. Coming of age is important theme in which is when the character understands something profound about him/ herself or their social environment .

Read More
678 Words | 3 Pages

Surviving through the death of a loved one, especially a brother is not ordinary. Surviving once again through a suicide attempt is not ordinary. Conrad has already faced more than a teenager has should, being forced to grow up even more than he is able to so he can cope with the pain. This can also be seen with Calvin who is also trying to cope with a failing marriage and keeping his son alive. The stories show just how mirrored the two men are in their ways of action through their reversal of the coming of age story.

Read More
428 Words | 2 Pages

Comparing the two coming of age stories, Araby’s coming of age story is less apparent than A&Ps. The story lines depict the coming of age in two different

Read More
620 Words | 3 Pages

The man she is with keeps pushing her to make a life-changing decision about an abortion and she says, “I realize… Can’t we maybe stop talking?,” (Hemingway 3). Including this issue specifically is bold for Hemingway as it is controversial, yet he crafts it to bring even more attention to the Girl’s rights and intentionally characterizes her with this strong will and independence. She later threatens to scream, demonstrating that the Girl is unafraid to bring attention to this altercation. Hemingway provides the Girl with a voice that many women did not have. The man craves authority and manipulates her by saying, “I think [getting the abortion is] the best thing to do.

Read More
490 Words | 2 Pages

Sallie Tisdale describes an uneducated sixteen-year-old girl that doesn’t even know how babies are formed. It was not the girl’s fault for getting pregnant; she was raped (Tisdale 416). Knowing this, the audience, like the author, feels compassion for the girl. It would be unfair to the girl if she couldn’t have the abortion. The audience recognizes that although abortion is cruel, it is needed.

Read More
1062 Words | 5 Pages

“I said the mountains looked like white elephants. Wasn’t that bright” (Hemingway31). Her lack of being able to make her own decision contributes to her loss of power. She doubts herself and does not

Read More
853 Words | 4 Pages

The struggles presented between these two characters bring to light issues in human relationships that weigh into everyday life. Hemingway’s short story reveals to readers how relationships affect communication, decision

Read More
821 Words | 4 Pages

It is even implied that this makes her the real protagonist of the story (Bauer, p 134). The transformation from a dependent girl to a mature woman making her own choices happens on feminine terms. Read in such a manner the story can be viewed as feministic and anti-patriarchal, since she opposes the man’s wishes and single-handedly takes the decision that will affect her for the rest of her life (Lee, p 15). It shows a Hemingway more perceptive about the underlying dynamics of female-male relationships than he has been given credit for (Bauer, p

Read More
987 Words | 4 Pages

Ernest Hemingway’s characters are frequently tested in their faith, beliefs, and ideas. To Hemingway’s characters, things that appear to be grounded in reality and unmovable facts frequently are not, revealing themselves to be hollow, personal mythologies. Hemingway shakes his characters out of their comfortable ignorance through traumatic events that usually cause a certain sense of disillusionment with characters mythologies, moving them to change their way of life. His characters usually, after becoming disillusioned, respond with depression, suicide, and nihilism. However, this is not always the case.

Read More
286 Words | 2 Pages

Hemingway is shown to discover and critique the superficiality of his characters’ lifestyles while touching upon other themes, which draws out

Read More
2035 Words | 9 Pages

Critics of Munro most often recognize two distinct features of her writing: her emphasis on female characters and feminist ideas, and a vibrant sense of realism that provides both imagery and symbolic meanings within her stories. These two factors are

Read More
1044 Words | 5 Pages

In his story “Hills Like White Elephants”, Ernest Hemingway points out the couple's inability to make the decision: whether to abort the unborn child or not. The reader finds that the story deals with couple's miscommunication through the conversation and the emotions that they express. One can observe that no descriptions are given to the characters, thus, Hemingway creates universal dilemma to focus on the crucial issue. In this way, Hemingway leads the reader to identify with his female character that undergoes a struggle.

Read More
1052 Words | 5 Pages

“Hills Like White Elephants,” by Ernest Hemingway: The Morality Within The Operation Ernest Hemingway created the iceberg theory, by which he expects the reader to know a great deal of information from the little he expresses. This style is evident in his short story, “Hills Like White Elephants,” because the information the reader must obtain is hidden underneath the surface. This writing style confuses the reader for the most part, but when the short story is given a chance, the reader connects to Hemingway’s use of a variety of essential elements to engage and understand the story. This connection formed is strengthened by the important combination of allusion and symbolism expressed within this great short story. Most of the short story focuses on the dialogue between a young couple of an American man and the girl, Jig, who remains nameless for most of the short story.

Read More
744 Words | 3 Pages

They begin discussing the old man’s attempt at suicide. The story which seems to start off about the old man really becomes about the fear the old waiter has of becoming like the old man. The importance of the characters, setting, and symbolism of the story all help Hemingway to express the hopelessness and loneliness of the old man and the older waiter. The story’s characters consist of the young waiter who is confident but seems to be a bit naïve about what life is really about.

Read More

More about Coming Of Age In Ernest Hemingway's The Girl

Related Topics

Open Document