ipl-logo

Herbert's Diary Of A Harlem School Teacher

1025 Words5 Pages

In their 1970 correspondence, Coca Cola Vice President Ira C. Herbert and Grove Press representative Richard Seaver argue over the use of the phrase “It’s the Real Thing” in marketing two separate items: Coca Cola and the book, Diary of a Harlem School Teacher. Whereas Herbert’s purpose is to ask Seaver to eliminate the contested phrase from advertisements, Seaver’s purpose is to sarcastically mock the absurdity of Herbert’s suggestion that the public would confuse cola with a book in order to keep using the phrase as a marketing tool, and because of the ease in which Seaver dismantles Herbert’s argument, his letter is more persuasive.
The letter from the Coca Cola Corporation reflects the seriousness of the matter of the use of the “It’s …show more content…

In response to the Herbert’s appeals to reason, Grove Press’ Richard Seaver begins his retort by mentioning that Herbert’s letter must have been delayed because of the “mail strike.” Herbert’s letter is dated March 25; Seaver’s is dated March 31, so any delay was inconsequential, just as he feels that Herbert’s request for the small publishing company to stop using the slogan is inconsequential. This establishes his irreverent, sarcastic tone that mocks Herbert’s irritation and demands.
Seaver refutes the arguments presented by Herbert. While Herbert fears that the public will confuse Coca Cola and Diary of a Harlem Schoolteacher, Seaver contests this and illustrates how silly this concern actually is while joking that he will ask salespeople to “make sure…the customer wants...the book” and not a Coke. By doing this, he pokes holes in Herbert’s primary concern. Seaver then mocks the formal, corporate-based tone of Herbert’s letter by joking that after an “executive committee” and a “vote,” they will keep using the phrase, even if it benefits Coca Cola. By making this comment, he continues to reveal that the public probably never would make any connections between an advertisement for a book and Coca Cola, and if anyone did, Seaver mockingly hints that …show more content…

He points out that the publishing company has had its successful book Games People Played imitated by other books, which is far worse than a coincidental phrase being used in an advertisement, and mentions nothing about having asked those imitations to stop. His longest paragraph contains this information and is a break from Seaver’s usual mocking tone. This break in style helps give credibility to Seaver and shows that he is aware of copyright issues surrounding publications and that Grove Press is well within its rights as a company and the Coca-Cola company is overreacting and acting

Show More
Related
191 Words | 1 Pages

Juice and soda have been around for a long time, however; during that time, two brands have weathered the societal storm of advancement and have stayed effective in their reiteration the nation over. Sunny juice and Crush soda are the two brands that I have chosen for my compare and contrast of the rhetorical strategies used inside their takes note. The chief advertisement we picked was from Sunny juice. This print advancement, which we found on the web, shows a container made out of 100% of vitamin C that have stayed in American culture since their hidden rising to reputation. Next, we have the Crush soda advertisement.

Read More
88 Words | 1 Pages

In Advertisements R Us by Melissa Rubin, she analyzes how advertisements appeal to its audience and how it reflects our society. Rubin describes a specific Coca-Cola ad from the 1950’s that contains a “Sprite Boy”, a large -Cola Coca vending machine, a variety of men, ranging from the working class to members of the army, and the occasional female. She states that this advertisement was very stereotypical of society during that decade and targeted the same demographic: white, working-class males- the same demographic that the Coca-Cola factories employed.

Read More
680 Words | 3 Pages

He maintains a conscious naivety by using derisive underlying sarcasm masked by tactful verbal articulation in response to the authoritative and condescending tone of Herbert's letter, which allows for a persuasive and entertaining argument. Though Seaver uses humor to establish his purpose, he maintains the mutual respect between the two parties, despite him believing the conflict to be childlike and absurd. Since Herbert’s argument can be interpreted in multiple ways, Seaver attacks a fallacious interpretation of Herbert’s argument: the reason he is against the two companies using the same slogan is because consumers will be unable to tell the physical difference between a book and a beverage. Seaver says that “in order to avoid confusion between the respective products due to the slogan, each sales personnel is to make sure that what the customer wants is the book, rather than a Coke,” and adds that he fears “those who read (his) ad may well tend to go out and buy a Coke rather than (his) book.” Seaver also recognizes that Herbert cannot use the threat of the law and therefore ironically mentions his “strong sentiments concerning the First Amendment” and willingness to “defend to the death” Herbert’s right to use the slogan, even though his response was intended to regard his own rights.

Read More
118 Words | 1 Pages

Herbert starts his letter with his claim to the slogan it 's the real thing and states that Seaver has no right to the slogan. Herbert then backs up his argument by saying that Coca-Cola has a history with the slogan and that therefore the slogan belongs to Coca-Cola. Seaver then replies to Herbert 's absurd claim with a very sarcastic tone. Seaver mentions in his letter how they have instructed all of their salesmen to notify bookstores that whenever a customer asks for a copy of Diary of a Harlem Schoolteacher that the salesman asks the customer to clarify and make sure that what they are asking for really is a book and not a six pack of Coca-Cola.

Read More
311 Words | 2 Pages

In his letter Ira C. Herbert straightforwardly introduces the reasons for which he is writing his letter, which is to get Mr. Seaver to take down the advertisement in which he uses the phrase "It's the Real Thing" which according to Herbert, belongs to Coca-Cola. Herbert dully and unsuccessfully explains why Coca-Cola has claim over the phrase, his supposed evidence for this is that Coca-Cola was the first one to come up with the phrase. On the other hand, Seaver successfully rebuttals the idea of changing the advertisement through the use of logic and a sarcastic tone. For instance, in lines 4-6 Seaver sarcastically explains “I can fully understand that the public might be confused by our use of the expression, and mistake a book by a Harlem schooler for a six-pack of Coca-Cola. ”(lines 4-6).

Read More
584 Words | 3 Pages

Adrienne Lafrance, in ¨Alphabet, Jigsaw, and the Puzzle of Google’s New Brand,¨ conveys a message that consumers need to take a closer look at companies because are deceiving consumers through branding. The author transmits this message through using the rhetorical triangle, diction, and rhetorical transaction. The rhetorical triangle is the first technique most authors use when writing. Lafrance wrote her article towards a tech-savvy audience and posted it in the technology section of The Atlantic.

Read More
691 Words | 3 Pages

Herbert begins his Letter by acknowledging the effects of having similar slogans and their outcomes. Through the appeal to logic, Herbert claims that having the same slogan will cause confusion between both Coca-Cola and the book Diary of a Harlem Schoolteacher, he indicates “There will always be a likelihood of confusion as to the source of sponsorship of the goods” (p 3). Although his logic is weak, Herbert shows Mr. Seaver the problems that may occur since they have the same slogan in order to convince Mr. Seaver to change his advertisement theme. The effect of using this logic was to reinforce the idea that having similar slogans will cause problems between the two companies. This was used to convince Mr. Seaver that he and his company should change their slogan to prevent

Read More
658 Words | 3 Pages

Both letters, by Herbert and Seaver discuss the usage of the slogan "It's the Right Thing." Each writer uses Reductum ad Absurdum and logos as their rhetorical strategies. While Herbert, executive of the Coca Cola Company, argues that the slogan is plagiarized, Seaver, representative of Grove Press, disputes the use of the slogan as it is protected by the First Amendment. Seaver has a more persuasive prose to emphasize his idea that the "It's the Real Thing" slogan is not copyrighted.

Read More
72 Words | 1 Pages

In this article, Gary Ruskin and Juliet Schor are completely unbiased on their argument on how our country is being controlled by corporations. Both authors show awareness on how large corporations have gained access to every aspect of our lives with advertising. Ruskin and Schor do this by sharing influential background information on the corporations. Throughout my high school career several brand names like “M&M’s” and “Sprite” sponsored my school’s sport teams.

Read More
874 Words | 4 Pages

Ian Buswell Mrs. Chimo Honors English 11 20 April 2023 The Catcher in the Rye Analysis Essay “I like it when somebody gets excited about something.

Read More
1058 Words | 5 Pages

Her strategies enable the reader to feel and imagine the position that she is in, and this allows them to efficiently understand her argument. However, she does not demand the reader to hate advertisements, but allows them to draw conclusions on how effective they can be. While also stating her argument, she allows the reader to show sympathy and desire to her children in this “experiment” by thoroughly writing in an engaging and humorous tone. Steingraber finalizes her argument by counter-arguing that leaves the reader to believe this experiment was a “success”. Because of Steinbarger’s rhetorical devices, readers are able to grasp the idea of what advertisements can do to a person’s perception.

Read More
753 Words | 4 Pages

Language in the Hands of Corporations: The Effects of Advertising In William Lutz’s essay “With These Words I Can Sell You Anything”, he emphasizes the words and phrases used by companies to make claims that appeal to the consumer, while simultaneously preventing the company from being legally bound to fulfill those claims. He advises to look out for words such as: help, more, virtually, new and improved, up to, acts, works, and like. Lutz claims “Every word in an ad is there for a reason; no word is wasted” (62), and that critical thinking is the only way to see what an advertisement is actually saying (63). For example, an ad by Delta for a bath faucet reads: “Save up to 32% more water per minute.

Read More
1061 Words | 5 Pages

These advertisements are created in a way that capture’s the audience’s attention and makes them want to purchase the product. In specific, the ad “It’s Beautiful” and “Taste the Feeling of Summer with Coca Cola” are only two of multiple others that sells their product successfully with the use of the rhetorical appeals:

Read More
978 Words | 4 Pages

To censor Mark Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn would not only do a complete disservice to the author himself, who chose his words carefully to convey a certain message, but

Read More
238 Words | 1 Pages

This song represents anomie within the structural functionalist theory because Miranda Lambert’s composition of “Mama’s Broken Heart” expresses multiple examples of a lack of moral regulation in terms of what is expected in the terms of society and what is respectable and proper. We can see this in quickly into the song with the lyrics “My mama’s phone started ringin’ off the hook, I can hear her now sayin’ she ain’t gonna have it”(Lambert). Placing this line of lyrics under the microscope of the anomie perspective, we can see Miranda knows exactly what her mother, who raised Miranda, expects of her considering the situation she is in. She is purposively going against what she knows the right and morally ethical expectations. Another example

Read More

More about Herbert's Diary Of A Harlem School Teacher

Related Topics

Open Document