ipl-logo

Rhucydides: The Aftereffect Of Herodotus In History

978 Words4 Pages

Despite the fact that Herodotus makes reference to an anticipated history of Assyria, his just known work is the History. This early composition work consolidates individual investigation into the geology, ethnology, and myths of Asia Minor with an endeavor, in Herodotus ' own particular words, to record "those extraordinary and awesome deeds, showed by both Greeks and savages" and to discover the reason for the Greco-Persian battle. A great part of the topographical and ethnographical portrayal in the History is the aftereffect of Herodotus ' own voyages; yet he likewise draws widely and trustingly on the breathtaking records of storytellers. Isolated into nine books, the History is composed in an open, recounted style with numerous stimulating …show more content…

Plutarch has proposed that Herodotus ' allure for the Athenians lay just in his complimenting records of Athenian endeavors, yet since the time that Aristotle 's positive remark in the Rhetoric, Herodotus ' incapacitating artistic style, his own appeal, and his ear for a decent story have made the History both mainstream and informative. Among Herodotus ' initial spoilers, Thucydides was derisive of his strategy, making hidden references to the shallow and fleeting attractions of Herodotus ' narrating yet guaranteeing more prominent life span for his own particular recorded written work. Without saying Herodotus by name, Thucydides reprimanded his forerunner 's instability, distinctly adjusting Herodotus ' actualities in his own particular work and demanding that history must depend on post-mortem examination, not gossip. The diverting and scholarly characteristics of the History have since quite a while ago combat such requests for authentic truth. Herodotus ' record of the Egyptian rulers, for instance, was negated by the Egyptian cleric Manetho of Sebennytus, who in the third century B.C. if a rundown of Egyptian lords completely at change with that of Herodotus. Plutarch 's infamous assault on Herodotus, blaming him for intentional lie, was broadly denounced by faultfinders as an activity in questioning not deserving of its creator. Then again, Herodotus ' notoriety for being a liar does not end with Plutarch; numerous ensuing commentators have blamed Herodotus for going on to his perusers as history the incredible creations of his witnesses. Notwithstanding such feedback, the wide extent of the History, its epic abstract force, and its fair treatment of the Persian Wars have won it crisp eras of perusers. New versions of the History showed up every now and again all through the Renaissance, and in the

Show More
Related
1790 Words | 8 Pages

This book has given me a greater understanding on the Classics as a whole. The book touches on a plethora of classical topics in chapter 2, and often compares the western civilization to our west. The author also gave me better understanding of the time periods. I didn’t know slaves had better treatment than the free people in Persia at the time, or that war was an enormous role in Classics age. From the western civilization class I’ve took earlier this year, this books discuss the importance of money in a war, when Sparta beat Athens, or when Rome beat the Carthaginians because of the new money they received to build ships.

Read More
447 Words | 2 Pages

Sundiata and The Odyssey are two out of the many great great orally told tales in all of mankind history. In writing, comparing your work to another similar text is extremely important for making your paper understandable to any audience. In this case, I will be comparing the two similar texts, The Odyssey and Sundiata: An Epic of Old Mali. Both of these two tables show the characters, Sundiata and Odysseus, long quests of pursuing and accomplishing a certain objective. To reach their goal, both characters encounter obstacles and enemies who want to stop them on their prolonged journey.

Read More
721 Words | 3 Pages

“There is always someone who cares more, cries more, loves more, get hurt most and forgives more” -Unknown. In any given relationship ultimately one person has more power over the other. Throughout most stories they usually happen to have character relationships where one always has more power over the other. This theory comes from the multiple examples below. Zaroff and Rainsford are a key example of the thesis that one character has more power than the other.

Read More
226 Words | 1 Pages

Herodotus begins by describing the reasons for Darius invading Scythians. The Scythians, a century ago, invaded Media and defeated those who stood against them, thus starting the conflict with Persians. For the next twenty-eight years, they lorded the Upper Asia before returning home, only to discover a small army opposing their entrance (Herodotus, P.129) While the Scythians men were abroad, the women had intermarried with their slaves. Instead of fighting with the slaves, the military walked boldly into their territory because they thought that if they hold spears against their slaves, then the slaves might imagine themselves their equals.

Read More
1427 Words | 6 Pages

Written in Classical Greek, it has been translated into dozens of languages, including Old English and modern English, and kept the ancient traditions, morality, and stories alive centuries after the author’s passing. As the “Father of History”, Herodotus holds a status of academic immortality, and through his work we have a foundation for how to keep record of history for future generations to know and almost place themselves in those times. What reading Clio has reminded me of is the importance of history to the world, and how this book and its eight brethren were the blueprints for all future historical writings. It shows how well recordkeeping can stand the test of time, and how keeping information and knowledge of the past can continue to teach and shape the

Read More
142 Words | 1 Pages

Herodotus was considered “the father of history” and he was an inspiration for the founding fathers of America. His most famous work was Histories. The founding fathers read Histories with admiration. They agreed with Herodotus’ conclusion as to the source of the Greek victory over the Persian. Herodotus’ conclusion was: “Free man fight better than slaves”.

Read More
1042 Words | 5 Pages

This character is brought to light using several incidents and events that help to analyze and interpret the ancient Greek world and the values surrounding them. Each episode supports and allows for the development of Odysseus’ character and acknowledges the effects of these features. Through these specific incidents, the reader uncovers the quality of Odysseus and how his characteristics relate to those praised by Greeks and those that were criticized. Persistent components of Odysseus’ character include cleverness and pride, while major themes that are reiterated are Greek ideals and the struggle to reach home. Conclusively, definitive occasions in “The Odyssey” establish and expand upon the character of Odysseus and how it impacts himself and

Read More
1603 Words | 7 Pages

Socrates spent the entirety of his life practicing philosophy. He questions everyone who claims to have wisdom and eventually comes to either aggravate those he made to look foolish or inspired those who kept an open mind. At one point Socrates claims that his life has been no less heroic than the heroes who fought at Troy. Considering how vital heroism is to Athenian culture, this claim can be unfavorable. Most Athenians when prompted about what is a hero, will picture Achilles, or one of Homer’s other heroes, not a man who “Corrupts the youth”, or “Is an Atheist”.

Read More
758 Words | 4 Pages

From Arrian, The Anabasis of Alexander, together with the Indica. (c.86-160; E. J. Chinnock, tr. (London: George Bell and Sons, 1893.) and Plutarch. Plutarch’s Lives. (c.46-120; Bernadotte Perrin.)

Read More
1178 Words | 5 Pages

In Homer’s “The Odyssey” the traces and nuances of this pursuit can be found in the very structure and hierarchy of Ancient Greece. Through his storytelling, Homer paints a vivid picture of adventure and wonder, but even while Homer tries to deliver an

Read More
1519 Words | 7 Pages

Silvy Elsa Mathew Hum 120 3/1/18 Paper 1 - The Epic of Gilgamesh and Homer’s Iliad The two main oldest epic tales in the world, ‘Epic of the Gilgamesh’ and Homer’s ‘Iliad’ deals with many significant issues that pose a meaning in the life of an individual and communities. The Epic of Gilgamesh was written 1500 years before Homer wrote the Iliad.

Read More
964 Words | 4 Pages

Since early childhood I was very much interested in mythology, particularly in Greek mythology. The images of ancient Greek Gods and Goddesses were not only simply aesthetically pleasant but contained mysterious and exciting myths behind them. When I first began studying Armenian history and visited National Museum of History, I discovered for myself amazing analogies with ancient Greece as well as realized one important matter, that on a large scale, my life today is in many ways determined by ancient Greek culture. In this essay I will try to explain the impact certain historical facts had on my belonging to Armenian culture.

Read More
2304 Words | 10 Pages

Introduction. Greek mythological heroes, and Roman mythological heroes share similar trades, however are different in many ways. These similarities and differences can be identified when looking at the means for the creation of a hero, and a hero’s life. This essay will discuse the similarities and differences in Roman and Greek heroes by anylysing the primary and secondary sources they feuture in respectively. Firstly will context be given, secondly the secondary sources in which the heroes feature, and lastly the spefic Greek and Roman hero will be compared.

Read More
1564 Words | 7 Pages

Herodotus also shows historians his personal opinion as well as that of the Greeks on ancient

Read More
473 Words | 2 Pages

In the first chapter of Erich Auerbach’s novel Mimesis titled Odysseus’ Scar, the stylistic properties of the Old Testament and Homer’s The Odyssey are contrasted to show the two foundational styles for ancient epic literature. Auerbach starts the chapter with an analysis of Homer’s use of digression with in book 19 of The Odyssey, when Odysseus’s true identity is discovered by Euryclea, to alleviate suspense within the book. He goes on to discuss how the comparison of the Homeric style with the “equally ancient and equally epic style” (7) of the tale of the sacrifice of Isaac in the old testament demonstrates “the genius of the Homeric style” (7). Auerbach then goes on to discuss how the Bible and Homeric representation of Gods differ in that

Read More

More about Rhucydides: The Aftereffect Of Herodotus In History

Related Topics

Open Document