ipl-logo

Horace Greeley Letter To Lincoln And His Response

715 Words3 Pages

Horace Greeley's Letter to Lincoln and His Response

Horace Greeley's Letter, and the fact that it warranted a response, speaks greatly to the American Public Sphere, facilitated by the freedom of speech and the press.
In the letter itself, Horace Greely expresses his concern for what was happening in the
Country. At this time, the Civil War was in full swing. There had been passed confiscation acts, which allowed generals to keep runaway slaves and confiscate others that they had encountered, but what awaited them was not the freedom they had hoped for. Contraband camps, camps of freed slaves that were sent to work building infrastructure for the Union army, were formed because the slaves were still seen as property. “Contraband” as …show more content…

“I do not intrude to tell you - for you must know already -” he begins, “that a great proportion of those who triumphed in your election, and of all who desire the unqualified suppression of the rebellion now desolating our country, are sorely disappointed and deeply pained by the policy you seem to be pursuing with regard to the slaves of rebels.” The way Horace Greeley writes his indictment, one would think he was writing a strongly worded letter to a close friend in an argument, not the president of the United States. Addressing Lincoln as “you” and openly criticizing his administration, Greeley pens a perfect example of the public debate in the public sphere so essential to American Politics. In response, Abraham Lincoln wrote another public letter, stating, “I would save the Union. I would save it the shortest way under the Constitution. The sooner the national authority can be restored, the nearer the Union will be ‘the Union as it was.’" In response to Greeley’s ostentatious critique of his administration, Lincoln responded by signing not a death warrant, but a rebuttal. In times past, this language towards someone in power would mean imprisonment, but not now, because debate, and the public sphere, had become essential aspects of American …show more content…

In 1733, long before the First Amendment, a german immigrant by the name of John Peter Zenger published an indictment, very similar to the one Horace Greeley published, exposing the acting governor of New York as corrupt. Unlike Greeley, however, Zenger was arrested by the aforementioned governor, and put on trial for Libel. Andrew Hamilton was Zenger’s lawyer in this trial, and he spoke the words of liberty, and freedom of the press to deliver Zenger to a not guilty verdict. Americans had to be able to express opinions, and voice truths about the government that it did not want the public to hear. An important stepping stone to the public sphere that is so associated with American life had been crossed. There were problems after the constitution’s passing as well. In 1798, the Adams administration passed the Alien and Sedition acts, a group of laws that essentially allowed the Federalist powers at the time to deport immigrants (who usually voted Democratic-Republican) and “friends of aliens” who were essentially anyone who disagreed with the federalist’s views. The response to these acts was overwhelmingly negative, and played a big part in kickstarting the revolution of 1800, a peaceful transition from a federalist administration to a democratic-republican one (and another great example of the American public sphere and debate in itself). The fact that these laws were despised by so many shows the attachment that

Show More
Related
224 Words | 1 Pages

On November 2, 1734 an arrest warrant was issued for John Peter Zenger on the account of him publicly publishing a libel and misrepresentation of the Governor in his New York Weekly Journals. In attendance of the issue of the warrant was the Governor William Cosby, Captain General and Governor in Chief, Mr. Harrison, Mr. Kennedy, Mr. Livingston, Chief Justice Delancey, Mr. Cortland, Mr, Horsmanden, and Mr. Lane. The warrant calls for the Sheriff of New York City to find and arrest Mr. Zenger. His reasoning in the warrant for arresting him is because it “tending to raise factions and tumults among the people of this Province, inflaming their minds with contempt of His Majesty’s government, and greatly disturbing the peace thereof” Essentially

Read More
194 Words | 1 Pages

On October 22, 1734 the Governor William Cosby ordered for the Public burning of some of John Peter Zenger 's journals entitled: The New York Weekly Journals. Since the Journal’s said so much about the affairs of the Governor, the journals became extremely popular and were purchased by the majority of people living in New York City. To the Governor this event was looked at as a disturbance of the peace. Zenger 's Journals were said to have contained false accusations against the governor and therefore were in violation of bringing contempt toward the government itself. Only the Journals 7, 47, 48, and 49 contained Libel.

Read More
882 Words | 4 Pages

’s Thesis was centered around the idea that Lincoln viewed emancipation as “a goal to be achieved through prudential means, so that worthwhile consequences might result.” He argued that every gradual step Lincoln took towards the abolition of slavery was done to “balance the integrity of ends with the integrity of means,” to accomplish this while still placing the constitution above all of his personal opinions. Guelzo then presented and answered four questions that he believed arose as a result of his prudence argument; why is the language of the Proclamation bland, did the Proclamation actually do anything, did the slaves free themselves, and finally did Lincoln issue the Proclamation to only to prevent European intervention or inflate Union morale? In response to the first, Guelzo makes the point that the Proclamation was a legal document, and that “every syllable was liable to… legal

Read More
629 Words | 3 Pages

Prolific for its apocalyptic portrayal President Abraham Lincoln’s Election, the speech delivered by Senator Robert Toombs to the state legislature in Georgia reveals anxieties of Southerners about the longevity of their lifestyle. Utilizing passionate rhetoric, The South Must Strike while There Is Yet Time displays how the future of the Union remains gloomy and unpredictable. Addressing the fellow legislators with vigorous pathos, the speech details how the security of Southern values remains paramount to the decision of secession. Moreover, Toombs features the question of slavery and its expansion heavily in his speech, deeming it the quality most necessary to preserve to preserve the Southern way of life. As Lincoln has been perceived by Southerners to support radical

Read More
464 Words | 2 Pages

President Abraham Lincoln, in his inaugural address, addresses the topic of the civil war and its effects on the nation and argues that America could be unified once more. He supports his claim by using massive amounts of parallel structure and strong word choice. Lincoln ‘s purpose is to contemplate the effects of the civil war in order to unite the broken America once again. He adopts a very hopeful tone for his audience, the readers of the inaugural address and others interested in the topic of American history and the civil war.

Read More
1510 Words | 7 Pages

The end of the Civil War presented a unique crossroads for the war torn United States. How would the North and South reunite? At the helm, there was a moderate politician and a reflective thinker – President Abraham Lincoln. One of the greatest statesmen of all time, Lincoln had advocated a lenient stance, envisioning a “restoration” whereby the southern states would pledge allegiance and reenter the Union under the Constitution.

Read More
789 Words | 4 Pages

1. How did revolutionary America see both improvements and limitations in women’s roles and rights? Revolutionary America saw improvements and limitations in women's roles and rights through various methods. One of the common limitations in women's rights is the topic of gender versus power. In most cases, the husband had legal authority over their wives, ultimately considering the women to be unfit for citizenship.

Read More
869 Words | 4 Pages

On September 2nd, 1862, Abraham Lincoln famously signed the Emancipation Proclamation. After that, there’s been much debate on whether Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation truly played a role in freeing the slaves with many arguments opposing or favoring this issue. In Vincent Harding’s essay, The Blood-red Ironies of God, Harding argues in his thesis that Lincoln did not help to emancipate the slaves but that rather the slaves “self-emancipated” themselves through the war. On the opposition, Allen C Guelzo ’s essay, Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation: The End of Slavery in America, argues in favor of the Emancipation Proclamation and Guelzo acknowledges Lincoln for the abolishment of slavery through the Emancipation Proclamation.

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

The civil war was not started in an attempt to abolish slavery, but to reunify the United States. Many of the slaves didn’t see it this way. They saw it as a way to freedom. General Benjamin F. Butler would take in the slaves as “contraband of war” since they were seen as property to the south. In 1861, the First Confiscation Act authorized the members of the union to confiscate any property the confederates were using to assist them in the war.

Read More
475 Words | 2 Pages

For years slavery was an issue but when the Emancipation Proclamation was issued some issues “resolved.” When this freedom statement was being issued to the Union and the Confederacy many slaves gained freedom and were allowed to fight. The Emancipation Proclamation impacted the war greatly due to the freeing of many slaves. In the Emancipation Proclamation, Lincoln was trying to free slaves in the Confederate States.

Read More
695 Words | 3 Pages

President Lincoln stated that: “if I could save the Union without freeing any slave, I would do it,..., and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone, I would do it.”. This quote clearly shows that the freedom of slaves was not his concern and unnecessary if it did not help the Union; as the result, slavery still exists if there is no war. Free slave from bondage should be a Great Emancipator’s primary goal and he will do his best to achieve it no matter what, but president Lincoln’s thought differed from that because all he cares was the Union. Although he had many times admitting himself an anti-slavery but his words and thoughts obviously prove that he is

Read More
962 Words | 4 Pages

During the 18th century, Southern slaves commonly practiced ways of everyday resistance towards slavery. From stealing their owner’s property, faking illness, or just complete arson, slaves’ actions of resistance were geared mainly towards hurting their masters and challenging his authority. One act of resistance that began increasingly common in the 1830s was slave flight. Running away became so popular for slaves during this time because slave revolts were pointless, and slaves began to escape to places like the Northern U.S., Canada, and Mexico, so they could receive their freedom. “The Political Significance of Slave Resistance” by James Oakes is a detailed examination of the political influences of the slave resistance in the American

Read More
657 Words | 3 Pages

It would be more than difficult not to read Abraham Lincoln’s First Inaugural Address without some sense of pride or honor for one’s own country. He brings about a call to civility among all citizens striving for unity and harmony with one another. Lincoln understood the dilemma that slavery became for not only the Northerners attempting to abolish the practice entirely, but also for the Southerners perpetuating it in the first place. The fact that there was a faction rising in favor of slavery on a scale that would divide the country indefinitely and that Lincoln foresaw this danger demonstrates the level of prudence he was able to acquire up until his presidency. In this address, Lincoln stressed the importance of the nation staying unified and true to the principles set by

Read More
3339 Words | 14 Pages

NHD Outline *primary* (paraphrase) Introduction We had on the plantation an overseer, by the name of Austin Gore, a man who was highly respected as an overseer proud, ambitious, cruel, artful, obdurate. Nearly every slave stood in the utmost dread and horror of that man. His eye flashed confusion amongst them. He never spoke but to command, nor commanded but to be obeyed.

Read More
672 Words | 3 Pages

This historical study will define the moral leadership of Abraham Lincoln’s role as president during the Civil War. Lincoln’s role as an anti-Slavery supported in the north provided the necessary moral leadership to sustain a complex war involving the continued argument about the continued existence of the institution of slavery. In this context, Lincoln had not previously been a supporter of the northern abolitionist movements before becoming president, yet throughout the Civil War, he incrementally began to realize the political and moral implications of slavery as a dire threat to American freedoms. Lincoln’s opposition to slavery during his presidency defined a major change in U.S. history, which galvanized the North to challenge the dominance of pro-slavery in the South. This commitment to ending slavery formed the foundation of Lincoln’s role as a liberator of African-American slaves as a defining factor of the war.

Read More

More about Horace Greeley Letter To Lincoln And His Response

Related Topics

Open Document