ipl-logo

How Did Abraham Lincoln Rash Or Unjust

717 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Abe lincoln suspending habeas corpus executive order

Habeas Corpus is a legal term meaning “the government cannot hold you without cause”. During Abraham Lincoln’s presidency this issue caught fire because on May 25, 1861 John Merryman was arrested for recruiting, training Confederate(southern) soldiers in the north. Abraham Lincoln suspension was a rash and unjust decision because it was used for personal agenda. Also it would allow the soldiers to become judges, executioners, and juries.of the so-called criminals. Another reason is he tried to make an example out of John Merryman.
Abraham Lincoln suspension was a rash and unjust decision because it was used for personal agenda. It was used for personal agenda because Abraham Lincoln wanted to keep anything and anyone who supported the southern …show more content…

April 19, 1861 troops from massachusetts volunteer squad moving through Baltimore to Washington were gunned down by a southern mob. The mob shot at the troops and when the troops opened fired on the mob causing 4 troops and 12 civilians dead in the streets. Therefore a angry Governor Thomas Holliday Hicks called a special meeting. John Merryman was ordered by Governors Hicks to blow up bridges in attempt to stop troops coming from Pennsylvania to Baltimore and starting riots. On May 25, 1861 federal troops arrested John Merryman for treason and Merryman was sent to Fort McHenry. While John Merryman was in McHenry, his lawyer petitioned Chief Justice Roger Brooke. After one of Lincoln disobeyed the court.Chief Justice Brooke let out his opinion saying” only congress could suspend habeas corpus”, with that John Merryman was released from Fort McHenry. Due to Chief Justice Brooke’s ruling it was now ruled that only habeas corpus cases be dealt by only the president and congress from here on out. Along with John Merryman, others member of the Maryland legislators were arrested because Abraham Lincoln thought they were working for the south. With that being said, they were released based on the same criteria as John Merryman was released

Show More
Related
139 Words | 1 Pages

So what legal or perceived authority did Lincoln act on? When the South attacked Fort Sumter in April 186, Lincoln almost immediately started his quest to circumvent the Constitution. He would justify his actions not on law, rather his interpretation of judicial review. However, his decisions stretched the meaning of the Constitution and violated many sections of the document. Lincoln amplified Constitutional lines by raising money for troops without the approval of the U.S. Treasury, suspending that writ of habeas corpus and the issuance of his Emancipation Proclamation. The President openly admitted that his original proclamation held no true legal authority; it was issued as a measure of war and not a true attempt at emancipation.

Read More
689 Words | 3 Pages

Habeas corpus is the right of a person who is arrested to have a trial. By suspending habeas corpus, President Lincoln is preventing everyone who is arrested from being released. While the northern army was traveling around, people kept burning bridges and other nuances to slow their advances. Lincoln had to find a way to prevent this from happening so he suspended habeas corpus and had some of the perpetrators arrested. Lincoln said, “... often a limb must be amputated to save a life; but a life is never wisely given to save a limb.”

Read More
990 Words | 4 Pages

In conclusion, all of Lincoln`s “controversial” decisions was to keep the union together. Its all justifiable even though these actions were technically an abuse of presidential power. It can be argued that he abused the power of the presidency when he suspended the Writ of Habeas Corpus and upheld the Declaration of

Read More
326 Words | 2 Pages

Abraham Lincoln’s assassination was unjust because he was a helper, and he was a role model; however, some believe he had too much power. There are many reasons why Abraham Lincoln’s assassination was unjust. First, it was unjust because he was a helper and he free the slaves. Also he helped out during the civil war.

Read More
1079 Words | 5 Pages

The supreme court is the interpreters of the Constitution, and if they say that something is not allowed, it means that it is against the Constitution. By taking a power of Congress and then ignoring the Supreme Court, he had been extremely unconstitutional with the decision to suspend Habeas

Read More
695 Words | 3 Pages

Vu Pham Professor Sunshine McClain History 170 May 22, 2016 Abraham Lincoln Does Not Deserve To be The Great Emancipator Abolition of slavery was a big controversy in the United State of America in the nineteenth century due to the different stances between northern and southern states which led to the American Civil war. At the present time, Abraham Lincoln was the president of the United States who supported the north (Union) thought that free the slave could help him united all the states. As the result, he passed out the Emancipation Proclamation on September 22, 1862, which give freedom to slaves in the states that the Union did not control. After the war, he issued the Thirteenth Amendment on December 6, 1865, to free all slaves.

Read More
1161 Words | 5 Pages

Frederick Douglass throws light onto the American slave system by explaining how things really were. He explained how they were treated. Not how the slave owners said that they treated their slaves. They were treated like they were just property and an object they could play around with. He also throws light on how slaves were stripped from their rights.

Read More
740 Words | 3 Pages

Abraham Lincoln caused the civil war. Abraham Lincoln was elected the 16th president on November 16, 1860. Abraham was the first republican president ever. He was born near Hodgenville, Kentucky on February 12, 1809. His family moved to Indiana when he was seven and he grew up on the frontier.

Read More
369 Words | 2 Pages

A common controversy in American history is the fact that Abraham Lincoln freed the slaves. Many claim that he freed them with the Emancipation Proclamation but it’s more complex than that. There were many events that helped free slaves and the Emancipation was only a small portion of America’s journey to freedom and “equality”. In reality, Lincoln helped the process of freeing the slaves but, he did not do it himself. Lincoln was not an abolitionist.

Read More
303 Words | 2 Pages

One important person is, Abraham Lincoln, who helped end slavery in, 1863, by issuing his memorable Emancipation Proclamation that declared freedom of slaves within the Confederacy. This particular event has changed the lives of many slaves whom lived throughout any state in the United States. Although it took time to declare freedom for slaves, now many years later, slaves are free to become anyone they want to be. Not only did this event affect the lives of slaves, but it affected the lives of everyone living in the United States because now our society has a diverse culture. Therefore, allowing a person to love who they want, whether the person is of a different ethnicity.

Read More
1108 Words | 5 Pages

In the early morning hours of October 1st, 1818, at the age heedless age of nine, the first of many tribulations stared young Abraham Lincoln in the eye: The death of his mother (Sandburg 24). This tragedy impacted Lincoln greatly, but also planted the seed of compassion and reason. Lincoln recalled how he would comfort his older sister when she would become overwhelmed with their late mother’s household duties, and at night, how he would appease his younger brother by telling him wild stories which young Abe would think of throughout the day. Abraham Lincoln’s resolve, and steady voice of reason enabled him to motivate his troops during the first days of the Union advance, and throughout the entirety of the Civil War; His calming demeanor,

Read More
514 Words | 3 Pages

Over hundreds of years America has had many presidents, some able to complete the tasks at hand, but many were not worthy of leading this nation. President Abraham Lincoln was one of the few who led the United States of America with great strength and courage. Abraham Lincoln was the best U.S. president because he had a great impact on ending slavery and he was one of the greatest natural strategists and leaders of all time. Abraham Lincoln is considered to be America 's wisest president. Abraham Lincoln, "proved to be a shrewd military strategist and a savvy leader during what became the costliest conflict ever fought on American soil."

Read More
351 Words | 2 Pages

When Abraham Lincoln was about eight, he was kicked in the head by a horse which caused the left side of his face to droop a little bit more than the right side. During Abraham Lincoln's early life, he had many struggles, such as not getting a proper education. Lincoln was born February twelfth, 1809 to Thomas and Nancy Lincoln in Hodgenville Kentucky. Lincoln was a rail splitter, he helped on farms, built fences, tended for live stock until at age twenty-one, he moved out to try and find a life away from home.

Read More
568 Words | 3 Pages

Of the Anglo-Saxon heritages, the debate over the writ of habeas corpus has endured extensive manipulation throughout American history. Controversial since its ratification, the “Great Writ” is a written disposition by a common-law court to require the establishment of the legal and jurisdictional basis for detaining a prisoner. The court then mandates the release or continued incarceration of a prisoner pending the results of this evidence. Though the founding generation was well aware that the Habeas Corpus Clause lacked perfect clarity and was intended for use by future generations, the historical context from which the clause stemmed may aid in illustrating the Framers’ scope and meaning.

Read More
1309 Words | 6 Pages

This states that the judges have the authority to punish and accuse criminals that break the law. With saying that, the government needs judges to do so or none of the criminals could be punished. If we had no criminals punished for their crimes or we had unfaithful judges than that can cause a major downfall of our government. According to the Petition of Right from 1628, “ and that no freeman, in any such manner as is before mentioned, be imprisoned or detained; and that your Majesty would be pleased to remove the said soldiers and mariners, and that your people may not be so burthened in time to come…” This is stating that a freeman should not be imprisoned and your judge would gladly take out soldiers from the situation but can not so fellow americans will not be bothered by it.

Read More

More about How Did Abraham Lincoln Rash Or Unjust

Related Topics

Open Document