ipl-logo

How Effective Was The New Deal Essay

1121 Words5 Pages

How effective was the New Deal?
American history has undergone many different changes, some beneficial, some stepping stones to where we are now, and some just disastrous. Franklin Roosevelt "conceptualized the idea of the New Deal by implementing recovery, relief, and reform." (HIST 131 Lecture, March 16, 2023) in hopes of getting America out of the Great Depression. Roosevelt's recovery program was made possible by implementing the Agricultural Adjustment Act (1933), which was set in place to offer farmers government money in exchange for limiting the production of certain crops for crop prices to go up. Roosevelt's relief program was put in place to "bring immediate aid to those who needed it, which came from the Federal Emergency Relief …show more content…

Martha was a reporter hired by Harry Hopkins (the director of the Federal Emergency Relief Administration), and her job was to report what was happening in the nation. This letter was written about one and a half years after Franklin Roosevelt was elected president during the Great Depression. She states in her report, "These people will be slow to give up hope; slow to doubt the president. But if they don't get their jobs; then what?" (Gelhorn, p.2) In her report, Martha Gelhorn acknowledges that the New Deal by Franklin Roosevelt did provide some relief for people, especially those who suffered throughout the Great Depression. Still, she also argues that the government needs to do more. She mentioned that the New Deal that was put in place was failing to help the people that needed it most. She capitalizes on the fact that rates for unemployment were still high, and insufficient housing as well as healthcare in America. There was also a lot of discrimination in who was allowed to be a part of the government relief programs, discriminating against African Americans and other minority groups. Her overall argument was that the government needed to intervene more, or the same issues would continue as they did in the Great …show more content…

Huey Long believed that after three years of Roosevelt being president, unemployment was still an issue, and it even felt like it was getting worse; people were not able to afford to live in their homes and were struggling even to feed themselves and their families. He felt so strongly about it that he organized a program called "Share the Wealth" that endorsed wealth redistribution and gave a speech on his thoughts on the New Deal. In his speech, he mentions this about the New Deal, "We find not only the people going further into debt, but that the United States is going further in debt." (Long, p.1) He feels like some of the reform from the New Deal is working and thinks the best way to fix the economic issues is to heavily tax the wealthy class so that no family has a certain amount of monthly income. This angered both political parties and upper-class citizens (business owners) because it threatened their wealth and

Show More
Related

Analysis Of Kid Kustomers By Schlosser

434 Words | 2 Pages

In Schlosser’s article, “Kid Kustomers” the main argument is that major ad agencies are focusing to much time advertising to children. He uses multiple topics and threads to portray the negative effects of marketing to children. Using the example of Fast Food industries partnering up with toy companies to appeal to the younger consumer and goes into the effects the children have on their parents as a consumer. Using the example of fast food Industries backs up his claim when marketing to children can be bad. Fast food companies are already unhealthy and when they paired up with big toy companies the influence on the child is even greater.

Read More

How Successful Was The New Deal Dbq

738 Words | 3 Pages

The New Deal included programs that would help average citizens find relief and provide recovery from the dire economic situation, helped farmers recover from foreclosures produce more crops and reduce the prices of crops for citizens and consequently expanded the role of gov’t because more people depended more on their gov’t in a time of need. The Great Depression started after the stock market crash of 1929, shortly thereafter companies started firing millions of workers (Document J) to save money because CEO’s are always greedy and always want to keep as much money as possible for themselves. FDR’s response to mass unemployment was to create agencies like the TVA (Document I) which employed unemployed workers in Tennessee for public projects such as bridges, roads, dams, parks etc. Anything that benefited the public was built so that people had jobs and were able to bring the economy out the depression.

Read More

How Successful Was The New Deal Dbq

311 Words | 2 Pages

This plan consisted of three things relief, recovery, and reform. The New Deal improved a variety things in the nation, therefore, was a successful plan. The New Deal was a success because it helped and changed a variety of people’s lives. For instance, in Document C George Dobbin clearly says that it was the first time that someone stood up for the workmen.

Read More

Analyze The Social And Economic Responses Of Thomas Welsh

336 Words | 2 Pages

Thomas Walsh was born in 1952 while the United States was still recovering from major political and economical crises that took place in the decade before. Many of these events were war related, including World War II, the Cold War, and the attacks on Pearl Harbour. The economical crises caused severe poverty as seen in the Great Depression and with inflation. Between the years 1942-1952 the American people suffered a lot of damage from war, but also prospered greatly in social aspects with new media and attractions. World War II began a year before Roosevelt was elected into his third presidential term in 1940.

Read More

New Deal Dbq Essay

564 Words | 3 Pages

The programs created by the New Deal satisfied the needs of citizens, even though several thought Roosevelt was overstepping his power. Roosevelt’s administration was not very effective in ending the Great Depression, however, some of the programs did help relieve

Read More

The New Deal Dbq Essay

587 Words | 3 Pages

Because of these people the supreme court decided that there was going to be limit for how much the government could get involved. This changed how the government's role would be during this crisis.having this restriction meant that the government could not control businesses and other things that were private to the

Read More

New Deal Dbq Essay

363 Words | 2 Pages

The New Deal was successful because its programs were beneficial and provided aid to those who suffered from this predicament. For example, Document A: “Fireside Chat” states, “Next, the Congress is about to pass legislation that

Read More

New Deal Dbq

688 Words | 3 Pages

Roosevelt’s New Deal was to Recover from the damage the Great Depression had caused. He created temporary programs and agencies to restore the flow of consumer demand. Years previous to the Great Depression, technological advances allowed farmers to grow more crops. Because of this they overproduced, supply went up, demand went down, and the prices dropped so low farmers were not able to make a living. The Agriculture Adjustment Act (AAA) taxed food processes and gave the money directly to farmers for not growing any crops.

Read More

New Deal Dbq Essay

1051 Words | 5 Pages

The New Deal helped clean up the mess of the stock market crash and helped stabilize banks but The New Deal didn’t just save those things it saved this American Democracy as we know it, We see many examples of this in document 3 when we see all the actions that took place like granted emergency loans to banks or even the employment of 8 millions people, but the greatest of this was when they established 40 cents minimum wage and 40 hours in the work week. The New Deal millions of jobs and hosted public works projects that reached most every county in the nation. Abuse of the stock market was more clearly defined and monitored to prevent collapses in the future. In less than a decade The New Deal gave jobs to many in every country, state, and city in the world, and because of its effects Franklin Roosevelt was known as one of the greatest presidents we have ever had, but we could also say that World War 2 ended the Great Depression and to this day we as people never want our stock market to crash as badly as it

Read More

The New Deal Dbq Essay

584 Words | 3 Pages

President Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal, a series of economic and social reforms enacted to combat the Great Depression, was met with both support and opposition. While some Americans supported the New Deal as a means of providing relief and recovery, others opposed it for various reasons. Critics of the new deal claimed that it expanded the federal government's role, was harmful to the economy, and was too closely associated with communism. The New Deal, a series of policies implemented by President Franklin D. Roosevelt in response to the Great Depression, was met with both support and opposition.

Read More

How Successful Was The New Deal Dbq

590 Words | 3 Pages

Now some may saw that this New Deal that President Franklin D. Roosevelt made take place was a failure , however it was a success for many reasons. The two that greatly bettered the people the most was because of the Fireside Chats that President Roosevelt gave and because of the hot lunches that he made possible for schoolchildren suffering from not being healthy.

Read More

The New Deal Dbq Essay

705 Words | 3 Pages

World War and economic depression brought about numerous social movements in the United States. As expected, these movements lead to the passing of various pieces of legislation. However, the legislations seemed to draw from ideals not specific to one set of American ideals, making them incredibly complex. This was mostly the case during the during Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s presidency where the progressives and the New Deal were well on their way to creating a liberal America. This made them immediate enemies of anyone who believed in the old ways of America.

Read More

The Great Depression Research Paper Outline

502 Words | 3 Pages

The New Deal also opened soup kitchens were the unemployed could go to get a free meal. The New Deal also managed banks so the banks couldn’t spend money that they didn’t even have, and it also helped end the depression and helps prevent new ones from happening in the

Read More

Was The New Deal Successful Essay

520 Words | 3 Pages

Was the New Deal successful or unsuccessful for the United States of America? Overall the New Deal had a more positive impact the negative impact. The New Deal created many new opportunities and did many great things for America. There are many reasons to help contribute to the fact that the New Deal was successful.

Read More

The New Deal: Positive Effects Of The Great Depression

847 Words | 4 Pages

“The WPA taught 400,000 African American women and men to read and write” (Katz). This is a freedom from the effect of the Great Depression because now more African Americans can read and write, unlike when the Great Depression was happening. Again, this is a positive effect of the New Deal because now that these African American men and women can read and write, and they can now get a jobs. The Roosevelt Administration set up the Resettlement Administration to help poor farmers relocate to marginal lands by providing loans (“New Deal”). First, this is a positive effect of the New Deal because it helped poor farmers move to better land to grow better produce to make up for the lost from the Great Depression.

Read More

More about How Effective Was The New Deal Essay

Related Topics

Open Document