ipl-logo

How Is 1984 Similar To The Russian Nkvd

1834 Words8 Pages

1984 and the Russian NKVD Savanna Fries Honors Literature II Mr. Spalding 10 May 2024 Imagine living in a society with no control over yourself and constantly tortured and manipulated. In George Orwell's novel “1984”, the Party contains control and power through strong surveillance, threats, and the use of propaganda to their society. Similar to the Russian NKVD and the ways of the Soviet secret police. The acts of the NKVD spark terror and are a reflection of the dangers unchecked powers and totalitarianism can have. The actions of the Russian NKVD, with its powerful surveillance and enforcement of state control, make multiple connections to George Orwell's, “1984”. These share the haunting similarities of the ways they use surveillance …show more content…

In NKVD, they would beat them and would leave them with parts of their bodies cut off. In both cases, they also showed power through their manipulation and brainwashing to rewrite history. In “1984” the concept of “doublethink” involves the Party's ability to manipulate historical records and erase anything true. This connects to the NKVD's practice of rewriting history to fit the government's narrative through the changing of documents and the defeat of rebellion voices. Changing the past allows both to control the future and present, making sure their power stays unchallenged. Their strong structure and power to crush dissent and force obedience created a climate where individuals were afraid to have their own thoughts or associate with things outside of the government's rule. Lastly, the impact and legacy of “1984” and the Russian NKVD changed their society forever. The NKVD and “1984” instilled a climate of mistrust and paranoia. This made citizens fearful to speak up and do things on their own. Both made relationships with friends and family untrustworthy and tore them apart because there was no one they could trust for their own individual safety. In the Russian NKVD, the trauma continued through decades of suppression and violence

Show More
Related
955 Words | 4 Pages

Marcelo Navarro Mr. duryea English 12 March 15, 2018 Inhumane The Book 1984 is a book based on a totalitarian government where the government has complete and total control over every aspect of someone's life. In 1984 you couldn't even have privacy in your own home, you would be under constant supervision and if you were caught doing something illegal the thought police would come and arrest you. In 1984 the government controlled its people through fear, the people of 1984 where always scared of being caught doing anything illegal and where also scared because the government would bomb itself saying that they were in a war. This book shows what could happen if people would let

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

The NKVD was notorious for attempting to give a false sense of security to the victims. They were constantly depriving them of everything and then would claim to be heroic when rewarding them with a minuscule amount of things that are imperative

Read More
580 Words | 3 Pages

1. Josef Stalin and the Soviet Union are expertly portrayed in Orwell's novel, 1984, through the character of Big Brother and Oceania. One of the aspects in which the similarities are clear is how both Stalin and Big Brother invoked fear into their people by controlling them through a totalitarian government. The Soviet Union's main media and forms of art were controlled by the government, as is in 1984. Another similarity between Big Brother and Stalin is that history was changed and rewritten to make them seem important and always correct in their stance on politics and society.

Read More
1515 Words | 7 Pages

Whereas, in 1984 the government has reached a level of control such that even the resistance is not really violent resistance but a form of thought-based resistance and thus the government seeks to trample this resistance through orthodoxy and on an unconscious level. The government in V for Vendetta does seek to control the minds but physical compliance is a more important factor than in 1984, where physical compliance is generally established. Both texts underlie the importance of media and communication of ideas for tyrannical governments to maintain their control over

Read More
3179 Words | 13 Pages

Caroline Rolston Mr. Perry Freshman Honors English 2 15 March 2024 The Treacherous Gulags “The dark history of the Gulag has left generations of Russians scarred and damaged. Even today, some survivors are too fearful to discuss their experiences” (history.com). The Gulag camps, too traumatizing to even talk about out loud, killed both people physically and emotionally. The creation and expansion of the tormenting and demanding Gulags proved to be a deadly and grueling work for all the unfortunate people imprisoned.

Read More
1183 Words | 5 Pages

A community that challenged this book was the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union was a communist nation from 1922 to 1991 which frequently banned books, such as 1984, if they were to go against the Soviet’s beliefs regarding their government and the actions they took to control the country. Therefore, the impact of this is that people, especially children, are not exposed to different governments; this is shutting down vital details about the idea of illegal surveillance; and the vulgar material that children need to grasp is being censored. The causation of the book’s challenging was due to the inclusion of

Read More
937 Words | 4 Pages

Imagine a world where the ability to think for oneself is not allowed. The novel, 1984, and real-time events including Joseph Stalin’s regime show this. There are various similarities between the two. Both gained power through manipulation and sacrificing human lives in order to strive for a totalitarian society. In the novel 1984, due to the manipulation of time and events in Oceania it is difficult to process the beginning of the era of Big Brother.

Read More
680 Words | 3 Pages

As propaganda begins to dominate all information, reality gets buried deeper and deeper. Unfortunately, some rulers strive to achieve this control, to the extent of altering the past. Two works exemplify this: 1984 and Life Under Stalin. The former is a dystopian novel by George Orwell, that warns readers of the horrors of a totalitarian state. The latter is a documentary produced by Jo Adendorff, that reveals how Joseph Stalin transformed the Soviet Union under his rule.

Read More
1907 Words | 8 Pages

“1984 The Party and The Nazi Party” Mia Bongiorno Honors Literature II Mr. Spalding 24 May 2024 Imagine living in a world where your individual freedom was taken away from you, your feelings, emotions, and independent thoughts were not allowed to be spoken freely. The government of Nazi Germany and the government in the novel 1984, by George Orwell, depicted this very type of government where its main agenda was maintaining complete control and power over the citizens it governed. The Nazi Party and the Communist Party in 1984 had many similar ways to maintain power and control over their citizens. Both parties used propaganda to brainwash their citizens into thinking that their beliefs were the way to live. Propaganda tools included

Read More
1255 Words | 6 Pages

The Devastation of Totalitarian Regimes George Orwell's novel 1984 and the film adaptation of Alan Moore’s graphic novel V for Vendetta are interesting pieces of work that stir up controversial ideas surrounding certain government organizations, in this case, totalitarian governments. Both works have satirical views on totalitarian governments and present the horrifying aftermath of such regimes, such as the erasure of individuality and the deceit and violence that occurs. In addition, both works serve as a warning to the current society about such governments. However, while V for Vendetta has an optimistic tone and concludes with the individuals overthrowing the regime, 1984 presents a darker reality in terms of how hard it is for citizens

Read More
916 Words | 4 Pages

In 1984 the most insidious aspect was “changing the past” because of the complex ways in which it manipulates the trust of Oceania's people. It creates loss of identity, idolization of big brother and confusion among the citizens of Oceania. When talking about loss of identity, I mean that changing the past creates a lack of understanding of oneself for the people of Oceania. Changing the past causes them to lose who they are, and furthermore, causes others to not recognise them, eliminating trust. When I speak about the idolization of big brother, I'm referring to the ways that the citizens view big brother.

Read More
717 Words | 3 Pages

1984 by George Orwell is a dystopian novel that portrays a society controlled by a totalitarian government known as "the party". The party's main objective is to maintain its power and suppress any form of dissent among its citizens. The party's use of fear and control is a crucial aspect in maintaining its authority and preventing rebellious behavior. They do this through their use of 24/7 surveillance, strict laws, and harsh conditions The party uses 24/7 surveillance as a means to keep watch over its citizens and maintain its control over them.

Read More
870 Words | 4 Pages

Government Manipulation in 1984 People generally rely on the government as a source of protection and stability. However, the government does not always have the citizens’ best interests in mind, as shown in 1984. The government has the power to distort realities and the ability to detect the truth. They can manipulate, or influence people’s minds without them even knowing. George Orwell’s 1984 uses a futuristic dystopia to show how the government is able to manipulate human values through the use of fear.

Read More
860 Words | 4 Pages

1984 A Totalitarian government has to be the worst type of government there is. Being controlled all the time, doing what someone with more “power” tells you what you have to do to or telling you what you can not do. It is horrible. Surveillance in every place you can imagine, Big Brother watching your every move.

Read More
2133 Words | 9 Pages

“1984” is a fictional book written by George Orwell in 1949 with the underlying purpose of warning against the dangers of a totalitarian government. Totalitarian governments are governed by dictators, and assert complete control over the lives, actions, and thoughts of their citizens. Orwell wrote this book during World War II after watching dictators like Joseph Stalin and Adolf Hitler rise to power in real time. He feared that if countries like the Soviet Union and Germany were able to fall to totalitarian control, then other countries such as the United States and Great Britain could as well. The book, appropriately named “1984,” takes place many years after Orwell initially wrote it.

Read More

More about How Is 1984 Similar To The Russian Nkvd

Open Document