ipl-logo

How The Different Ethical Philosophies View The Use Of Animals In Biomedical Research

1349 Words6 Pages

The broad area of scientific study taken is search of ways to prevent diseases which result in illness and/or death in people and animals. Without biomedical research, many illnesses and diseases that have been wiped out would still cause issues for humanity today. Humans and animals hold special purpose in biomedical research, as, as subjects, they can help to determine cause, symptoms and treatment for the disease. However this may come at the risk of exposing said target to illness or disease, which may end in death.
This essay will discuss the history of both animals and humans as subjects of biomedical research. It will also discuss how different ethical philosophies view the use of animals and humans as test subjects. It will aim to analyse how legislation in regards to biomedical research has evolved, analysing the existing arrangements and predict how the future of biomedical research will be shaped.

Animals have been used as test subjects for biomedical research for over x years. The use of animal subjects has largely been largely successful in advancing scientific progress in the area of biomedical research. With the greatest effects being felt in the early-mid 20th century, with certain illnesses even being wiped out from work done in relation to animal testing. Contemporary uses for animal subjects include …show more content…

In Australia there is no national act governing the rights of animals; instead there are separate state legislations such as the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1979 (NSW) and Animal Research Act 1985 (NSW). In the USA the Animal Welfare Act of 1966 was introduced to help regulate the use of animals as subjects in biomedical research. The legislation in place today minimise the harm on test subjects, and place safeguards, such as codes of conduct and ethical committees to ensure all research is done as ethically as

Show More
Related

Should Animals Be Used In Flowers For Algernon By Daniel Keys

465 Words | 2 Pages

There is much controversy over whether or not animals should be used to test new procedures and medications. I personally believe that animal testing is crucial to scientific development. Every life lost is a tragedy but as seen in the story, Flowers for Algernon, by Daniel Keys, it will help us determine what will happen to a human test subjects without human losses. In this essay I will support my belief that animal research is important to human survival and is worth the risk. Animal research has played a vital part in nearly every medical breakthrough over the last decade.

Read More

A Question Of Ethics 'And Animal Research Saves Lives'

987 Words | 4 Pages

“A Question of Ethics” by Jane Goodall and “Animal Research Saves Lives” by Heloisa Sabin presents two sides of the same coin in regards to Animal testing. Thereby, questioning the validity or necessity of animal research and testing today. In “A Question of Ethics” by Goodall she presents a scenery of the living conditions of the animals which are often isolated; posing the ultimate questions of, whether animal research is essential to medical research? Or How many tests are performed only to conform to laws and not out of scientific merit? The Suggestion was made that scientists should explore alternative options, such as testing on cell and tissue cultures.

Read More

Annotated Bibliography On Animal Testing

1058 Words | 5 Pages

-Scientists have a specific responsibility to evade unnecessarily and minimize the pain in the treatments (replacement reduction refinement 3Rs). (Gannon,2007,p.519,para.4). Source 3 The ethics of animal research (Simon festing and Robin Wilkinson) -Implementation of laws that enables people to know more about the researches -The conducted regulated and controlled animal researches in addition to the implementation of the 3Rs and the use of compute models, human cell lines helped to lower our reliance on animals ” Approximately 2.7 million regulated animal procedures were conducted in 2003 in the UK—half the number performed 30 years ago”(Festing &Wilkinson,2007,p.528,para.3). -There exist solution to reduce animal testing like the use of cell culture based tests and Microdosing techniques , the inherent limitation of some non animal tests, and good experimental design and many others techniques like cooling and magnetic resonance thathelps to reduce the use of animals.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Pro Animal Testing

712 Words | 3 Pages

Since the conception of recorded history, mankind has strived to learn more about the human body. Historical accounts provide evidence of research being performed on animals by first millennium B.C. scientists in an attempt to learn more about the human body. Animal research provides a way to learn more about living organisms without hurting or killing humans. Today, animal testing is used in several ways. First, it is used to help increase the lifespan of different types of animals.

Read More

Satire Essay On Animal Testing

1188 Words | 5 Pages

The ethics revolving around animal rights and animal testing are highly controversial. A large scale of people in the United States say that animals deserve some protection from misuse, while other Americans argue animals are worthy of the same rights as humans. However, a quarter of Americans object banning medical research, which results from animal testing. A clear majority of people if they were tied up or injected with substances into the bloodstream or inhalation and force-feeding would lean towards declining the studies. As for animals, we are their voice and give them no option but to be tested on and when finished it either results in death or sold to another laboratory.

Read More

Is Animal Testing Cruel Or Inaccurate?

951 Words | 4 Pages

The Animal Welfare Act provides little protection for 5% of animals tested on, and does not protect the other 95% of animals tested on (aldf.org). The Cruelty to Animals Act on the other hand states, ¨The law covered only vertebrate animals (mammals, birds, reptiles, fish, and amphibians), with more restrictive provisions on the use of donkeys, horses, mules, dogs, and cats. The law required all experimenters to have permits, and it established guidelines for the kinds of experiments and the way they were performed.¨ (aldf.org). Many laws, activists, and acts are working to prevent animal

Read More

The Controversy Of Animal Experimentation

1263 Words | 6 Pages

The issue that the Literature Review Essay will be based upon is the use of animal experimentation. The use of animal experimentation has caused the country to divide into two sides whether animal experimentation should be continued or if it should be prohibited. Animal experimentation has been used to find many animal breakthroughs in the medical and science field. Although animal experimentation has been useful, it is seen to others as cruel and inhumane treatment of animals. This issue affects many biopharmaceutical companies, research labs, PETA, and other individuals concerned regarding the topic.

Read More

Arguments Against Animal Testing

766 Words | 4 Pages

The Ethics of using animals for testing for the purpose of advancement in medicine has been a controversial non ending argument. For many periods, researchers and scientist have used animals. Millions of animals are being researched, tested within the US every year. Most of this animals are not given pain medications or drugs. Some animals being use are as small as rodents, rats, mice, hamsters.

Read More

Animal Testing In Medical Research

1866 Words | 8 Pages

Then again, medical examinations involving animal testing have greatly improved the health being of humans. Surgical methods and medications nowadays would not be discovered if it was not for the understanding of the diseases and how the body works. This can be approached by using animal testing. Animal experimentation has contributed to the abundance of medication we now have in the palm of our hands. For instance, we have treatments for asthma, high blood pressure, and diabetes which were all discovered using animal testing.

Read More

Introduction To Animal Ethics

1268 Words | 6 Pages

Introduction: The Animal Ethics Committee (AEC) has developed a Code of Ethical Conduct that complies with requirements laid down by the Animal welfare act 1999 (New Zealand legislation website) including sections 80 and 100 of the Act, which set out the purposes of the regulatory system for the use of animals in science, the promotion of the three R’s (Reduction, Replacement and Refinement), and the criteria for decision-making. This Code was approved by the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI). The Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1986 requires that institutions conducting research using animals comply with the Australian Code of Practice for the Care and Use of Animals for Scientific Purposes 2004 (the Code) and nominate an Animal Ethics

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Animal Testing

398 Words | 2 Pages

Researchers estimated over 26 million animals were used for scientific tests and commercial testing subject every year in the United States. Over the years animals were used to be tested on medical treatments, products for human uses, health care, and etc. The practice of researching on living animals has started since 500 BC. Opponents of this act say that it is cruel to experiment on animals, there are other methods available to replace the cruel act of experimenting on living animals, and that the human bodies and animal’s bodies are totally two different features and the research often yields irrelevant results. The federal Animal Welfare or AWA passed the animal testing act in 1966 and amended in 1970, 1976, and 1985.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Animal Rights

1390 Words | 6 Pages

In today’s world of neuroscience research, the use of animals has become a controversial topic. In the past, research on animals has been used to gain a deeper understanding of the human body especially the brain. This type of research has allowed breakthrough in medicine, medical devices, surgeries and other methods to improve the health. However, animal rights activists have voiced their opinions in recent years against the use of animals as they deem it cruel. I believe that animal research is vital to the advancement of medicine and knowledge of not only humans but of many other animals as well.

Read More

Animal Experimentation

778 Words | 4 Pages

Animal Experimentation for Medical Development The use of animals for medical research has been around for centuries, it is not a new concept and there is a deep passion for and against this practice. This topic intertwines a great deal of emotion and facts, which takes solid evidence to distinguish between the two. There is the scientific view and the view of ordinary people who challenge the morality of animal experimentation.

Read More

Why Animal Testing Should Not Be Banned

796 Words | 4 Pages

The Animal Welfare Act (AWA) of United States gives some protections to warm-blooded animals used in research laboratories, which only cover 5% of animals normally used for testing. Under AWA, all testing on animals which are covered must minimized the pain on animals and provide appropriate veterinary care. The AWA should make further improvements which cover as much animals as possible. In UK, the Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 defined regulated procedures as animal experiments that could potentially cause "pain, suffering, distress or lasting harm”. It prevents animals from unnecessary suffering.

Read More

Ethical Issues In Biomedical Research Essay

1002 Words | 5 Pages

In biomedical and behavioural research, there can be issues that arise during the discovery of new processes and products, such as the ethicality of certain experiments and the results obtained. Back in the old times, when standards for conducting scientific research and experiments were not strictly adhered to, experiments conducted resulted in people or other living things being put in harm’s way, to obtain a certain result or confirm a suspicion. While such experiments claimed to be justified because they were meant to advance medical knowledge, is it always right to make sacrifices for the greater good? In this essay, I will use some case studies to discuss ethical issues in biomedical research. A common ethical issue concerns the use

Read More

More about How The Different Ethical Philosophies View The Use Of Animals In Biomedical Research

Related Topics

Open Document