ipl-logo

How Was The Murder Of The Imperial Family Justified

2979 Words12 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Effect of war Communism on Russia society

The Russian Revolution is a turning point in Russia’s History. During the Revolution, the Russian’s free themselves of the autocratic rule of Tsar Nicholas II and established a Communist government. Although the Communist government wasn’t ideal, it was a step forward from the feudal rule of the Tsarist Family. However the question, “To what extend was the Murder of the Imperial Family justified?”, takes a different angel towards the subject; in which the I will discuss who far a murder can be justified. This is worth investigating as, the soviet government denied any association to the murder and even arrested 28 man; from which 5 of these men were executed for the shooting of the royal family and their entourage. However the telegram ordering the murder of the imperial family was delivered by Lenin's bodyguard2

There were three revolutions in Russia; one was in 1905 and the other two were in 1917. The revolution in 1905 had …show more content…

Most of these unrests where about the government, whilst others just wanted a change in their daily life. The first revolution included peasant unrest, attacks on generals, worker strikes and the ‘Bloody Sunday’. This was “...the massacre in St. Petersburg, Russia, of peaceful demonstrators marking the beginning of the violent phase of the Russian Revolution of 1905.”3 This revolution resulted in the formation of a limited constitutional monarchy, the Duma, a multi-party system and the Russian Constitution of 1906. The February/March revolution in 1917 was caused the russian citizens wanting more say in the government and after the Tsar had closed down the Duma and went against the October Manifest the people rioted. The Duma also wanted to have a bigger part in governing Russia but after being

Show More
Related
698 Words | 3 Pages

This angered the Russian citizens which led to the Russian Revolution of 1905. On January 22, 1905, approximately 150 workers were killed by soldiers who fired on peaceful protestors, led by priest, Father Gapon, in Saint Petersburg. This event was known as Bloody Sunday and signified the beginning of the Revolution of 1905. Subsequently, several radical groups formed an alliance and organized several mutinies and strikes against the Russian autocracy. Left with no choice, Nicholas II issued a manifesto on October 30, 1905 that granted more suffrage rights, got rid of arbitrary arrest without a trial, and provided for an elected legislature.

Read More
727 Words | 3 Pages

In addition, from March 1917 until July 1918, the Romanov’s were prisoners in their own country (Anastasia Nicholaievna Romanov 3). Suddenly, a dozen armed men burst into the room and gunned down the imperial family in a nail of gunfire ( Anastasia Nicholaievna Romanov 3). Bolsheviks had killed the family, burned and burried the bodies in a mass grave ( Anastasia Nicholaievna Romanov 3). Those who were still breathing when the smoke cleared were stabbed to death ( July 16, 1918: Romanov Executed 2).

Read More
1271 Words | 6 Pages

With no signs of the czar’s attempt to solve the complications, Russia banded together and filled the streets with strikes and riots. A revolution was peaking among the peasants. The uprising brought Nicholas ll no choice but to abdicate his throne. This was an opportunity

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

The Russian revolution resulted in the overthrow of the country’s monarchy and the establishment of the Soviet Union. It started off with many protests and strikes that forced Tsar Nicholas II out of power. As a result, a provisional government was put in place but it was weak and ineffective so the Bolsheviks took control and established a socialist government. The Bolshevik Revolution was caused by a combination of unstable and corrupt monarchies, unfair treatment of the populace, and a lagging industry, which eventually led to the creation of the USSR.

Read More
1036 Words | 5 Pages

In the early nineteen hundreds, Russia was ruled by Czar Nicholas II. He was the last in line of a long line of monarchs called Romanovs. By 1915 , most of the Russian people had lost complete faith in the Czar. Many factors include the corruption of the Russian government, approximately 3 quarters of Russia was poverty stricken, substandard working conditions and wages, and the dreadful involvement in World War I. Russia’s political problems during the Russian Revolution caused a major shift in people’s lives government, and religion. In 1917, there were two revolutions that took place in March and October.

Read More
675 Words | 3 Pages

This is suggesting that it was needed to free Russia from Nicholas’s power, even though he had already abdicated. Although it is understood that the purpose of killing his family was to ensure an end to the Romanov reign, these murders were unjust because the entire family along with their help was killed as well. Nicholas II was a poor government figure for Russia, however death was the incorrect punishment. An alternative plan would have been to imprison the family to prevent the Tsar’s children taking over power rather than killing them. The punishment was unjust for the Czar and his

Read More
1355 Words | 6 Pages

For even though they gained power, they controlled only the land between Petrograd and Moscow, which is a rectangular strip of land that was 30 miles by 400 miles big. Beyond this land there were many others who opposed the Bolshevik rule. The first task that Vladimir Lenin performed once in power was to withdraw Russia out of the First World War. Vladimir Lenin instructed his people to find peace at any price; this resulted in the treaty of Brest-Litovsk (this treaty was signed on march 1918). This treaty took away from Russia all the land gained since Peter the Great and it separated the Ukraine.

Read More
332 Words | 2 Pages

After the successful repression of the 1905 revolution, dissatisfaction with the political structure in Russia was high. The firing of the Duma, the perception of the Romanov rule as corrupt and inadequate, the disillusionment of the peasants by the Tsar with the rise of radical socialist parties and the backward thinking policies of governance were all prominent factors in the failure of the Russian political system to satisfy the Russian people leading up to the 1917 revolution. At the end of the 1905 revolution the Duma was put in place to give the citizens of Russia more of a say in how their country was run which threatened the Tsar’s autocratic rule. The Duma was dissolved and reinstated on 3 occasions by the Tsar but despite opposition

Read More
281 Words | 2 Pages

Tom’s rigid adherence to rules and perceptions contrasted with Huck’s tendency to question authority and think for himself. If they had both been brought up in the same level of society would they still have become friends? Huck’s opinions, distrust and emotional personality were formed due to growing up with a drunk for a father, not being indoctrinated with social values and often being homeless. He has his own sense of logic and fairness which makes him question and really ponder the things that Widow Douglas and society try to teach him, especially when it comes to the ownership of Jim. While because Tom Sawyer was brought up in a comfortable lifestyle and he has formed his ideas and opinions from the adults around him and

Read More
716 Words | 3 Pages

The Russian Revolution, which was started by Lenin and his followers, was a rebellion that occurred in 1917 which forced higher powers to act to the needs of the lower class. For instance, many citizens were worried for their protection in consequence to the lack of survival necessities due to an early drought. Furthermore, their current czar during the time was incapable for his position as a czar and made horrendous decisions as czar. For example, when the czar, Nicholas, entered in World War I, he sent untrained troops into countless battles of failure which costed in mass amounts of lost life (paragraph 23).

Read More
179 Words | 1 Pages

The February and October Revolutions of 1917 produced a world that would be governed by Marxism and set the stage for an armed struggle that would shape the second half of the Twentieth Century. In the traditional telling of the history, the working class people rose up to remove the shackles that had kept them oppressed by the capitalists and the monarchy. However, Richard Pipes with the benefit of access to classified records contends that the Revolution came about because of a series of accidents that would alter the world and produce catastrophic results for the Twentieth Century. In his book, Pipes presents three why question of the Revolution and goes into each one individually. The Three Why’s of the Russian Revolution are; why did the

Read More
608 Words | 3 Pages

Russian revolution started when Russia had to make to many changes that cause them to choose ideas that did not help and made some wrong choices. Russian revolution started in a hard period of time where the world war 1 was in 3 years into the war. Russia was in the war with a weak army and had many dead soldiers. Caused russia to go on a downfall and economic and many more problems that cause them to go that route. This period of time started to in 1917 this when Russia had struggles.

Read More
747 Words | 3 Pages

Both have had workers protest to a palace, in France there was the March of Versailles to the Palace of Versailles, and in Russia there was Bloody Sunday where workers stormed the Winter Palace. They both had a cluster of riots because of the increasing price of bread. A few differences between the French Revolution and the Russian Revolution’s radical uprisings are during the French Revolution, France declared war on Austria, and Prussia joined Austria, while during the Russian Revolution, Russia had a civil war. There were more panicked uprisings during the French Revolution because of rumors and the lack of technology for

Read More
1308 Words | 6 Pages

By doing this, they overthrown the poorly run government as the Russian people were in favour of a new system that would work in their favour. The Russian Revolution was triggered by the social, political and economic problems, that combined caused the Russian people to rebel. This Revolution was triggered by the poverty of the Russian people, the loss from the wars, the sneakiness of Rasputin and the failure of the Tsar, Nicholas II. The social causes of the Russian Revolution arose from centuries of oppression towards the lower classes.

Read More
932 Words | 4 Pages

The February Revolution can be considered an instinctive revolution; during that period, Russian people were living in misery and relentlessness: food went bad in trains between the long transports leading to food shortages and mortality rates increased due to poor housing conditions. In the October Revolution instead Bolsheviks seized power from the Provisional Government. “The movement broke out spontaneously without preparation and exclusively on the basis of the supply crisis… The military either today or tomorrow will come out openly on the side of the revolutionary forces that the movement which has begun will not subside but grow ceaselessly until ultimate victory and the overthrow of the government”; this communicate was written by the Okhrana Report on the 26th of February 1917 during the first revolution. Things worsen during March of the same year when wages rose and Russia’s currency (rouble) totally dropped… food prices rose and the great majority of people couldn’t afford anything.

Read More

More about How Was The Murder Of The Imperial Family Justified

Related Topics

Open Document