ipl-logo

Analysis Of Hillbilly Elegy

1029 Words5 Pages

In the excerpt from Hillbilly Elegy, a memoir written in first person point of view, J.D. Vance writes about the time he spent at Yale, but also the identity crisis that follows with it. Throughout his memoir, Vance presents the theme that the identity that one grew up with, in a place where they felt a sense of belonging, will stick with one forever, despite stereotypes or new environments. Top schools, including of Harvard, Stanford, and Yale — the school Vance went to — are meant for the most intelligent, elite students. These students are often considered and stereotyped, quite truthfully, to be wealthy and hardcore geniuses. However, Vance comes from a poorer background where people are stereotyped as not too smart but is still able to …show more content…

Vance describes how he feels like an outcast because of his poorer and not necessarily “smart” background. He seems to struggle to find a place where he belongs, or even figure out who he is, because of this new environment. This reveals Vance’s uncertainty with his Yale identity; he doesn’t feel like he belongs or that this is his real identity. Later on, Vance says in realization, “As I realized how different I was from my classmates at Yale, I grew to appreciate how similar to the people back home” (Vance 205). A reason for finding this similarity is the fact that Vance’s hometown is where he spent most of life and belonged; he had made it into Yale, but at the same time, it is with the poorer country kids where he truly feels as though he belongs because he is like them. Compared to Yale, where many are rich geniuses, Vance feels as though he is connected more to the poor hillbillies because he grew up with them, lived there most of his life, and is where he can show his true personality because he knows he won’t be judged. In fact, Vance feels so …show more content…

Vance’s intimacy with the reader — providing multiple examples from his life in detail, from his feelings about being a student at Yale to the incident with the lady at the gas station — reveal how he feels lost with his identity at Yale but confident with his hometown identity because he explains how he feels, making the reader more empathetic towards him. For example, he says about being a student at Yale, “I was an anomaly” (Vance 204) to describe how he is different and odd compared to the other rich and intelligent students. This is effective and powerful in the first person point of view, because it is his direct words, compared to the third person point of view, in which it would be more reliable (being verified by another source) but less eye-opening and precise. Additionally, by starting from his first day at Yale to his journey through going to the university, Vance shows how his confusion about his identity ultimately helps him decide which identity he favors and feels more connected with, the one at Yale or the one at home, throughout his time at the university. Through his intimacy and description of multiple time periods, Vance also enhances the reader’s depth of knowledge of his life, providing multiple stories, incidents, and thoughts at different points throughout his journey in Yale, including of lying

Show More
Related
662 Words | 3 Pages

Paul’s desire for success in assimilating into the higher-class mirrors Richard Rodriguez’s expanded “Scholarship Boy” by mimicking his mentors, Paul uses Trent Conway’s teachings by trying to “be like his teachers, to possess their knowledge, to assume their authority, their confidence, even to assume a teacher’s persona” (Rodriguez 552). Thus, Paul uses his ability to mimic and act like a scholarship boy by adopting the language of the dominate culture to blend into higher-class lifestyle. Trent Conway becomes Paul’s mentor by teaching Paul the mannerism and language of Trent’s peers at Harvard University and their families. Also, Paul repeated exactly Trent’s teaching to Rick and Elizabeth on adopting the language of

Read More
1422 Words | 6 Pages

The Brothers faced this challenge in their, largely, futile attempts to achieve middle class status through achieving a proper education. Macleod highlights that, historically, the “overall structure of class relations from one generation to the next” is extremely reluctant to change(4). The Brothers evince this in their inability to earn work with greater wages than their parents, forcing them to live in working class neighborhoods like they did. Although some of the Brothers did manage to obtain middle class work, they struggled to keep those jobs as they either got laid off or were pressured out believing that they just didn’t fit in the workplace environment- though this is largely in fact due to differences in cultural capital, knowledge, disposition, and skills passed on generationally, that arise from the different upbringings of the supervisors and the Brothers.

Read More
165 Words | 1 Pages

Over the years, there has been an ongoing debate about “street smarts” and “book smarts” throughout the world. Many people side with either or for their own personal reasons. Although “street smarts” has developed a poor reputation which pushes people to neglect the positive aspects of this particular way of learning. In the article, “Hidden Intellectualism”, Gerald Graff evaluates the structure schools use to teach literature. He explains that intellect is not only found in the academic form of thinking.

Read More
566 Words | 3 Pages

Overall, this article helped me reflect on the novel’s theme and gain understanding of the author’s

Read More
922 Words | 4 Pages

As Johnny goes through this difficult stage in life he decides to run away not thinking about where he’s going to stay or how he’s going to get food. He decides to join a gang of orphans with his best friend Billy in order to survive. This novel is still widely read today because it provides an inhuman image of brutal conditions African Americans faced in Harlem of 1940’s. In the Rite of Passage, the main character Johnny is hit with some really bad news that his family that he’s been living with throughout his entire life is not really his own.

Read More
645 Words | 3 Pages

Ryder, who also known as the dean of the Blue Veins. He is an African American, but he wants to improve his condition and being resemble to white person. He lived in the society where white people were privileged. I see the idea of realism in the following passage: “The occasion was long memorable among the colored people of the city; not alone the dress and display, but for the high average of intelligence and culture that distinguished the gathering as a whole. There were a number of school-teachers, several young doctors, . . .”

Read More
632 Words | 3 Pages

1. “I am still a little afraid of missing something if I forget that, as my father said snobbishly, and I snobbishly repeat, a sense of the fundamental decencies is parceled out unequally at birth.’ Ch.1 Analysis: nick is tying to say that Money isn’t always what people are born into; especially in this time people who are born into money are considered the upper class and above all. Some people are just a better person in general even without being born into a rich family he doesn’t know if a person has to be born into wealth to have natural class or just be classy on their own.

Read More
855 Words | 4 Pages

Sutherland starts off the essay with a narrative about her husband’s lost keys. While she uses to chase her husband around helping him in the search, she now ignores his racket and continues washing the dishes. While she loves her husband, there are little quirks about him that she wishes she could change. She describes him as “well read [and] adventurous…but also tends to be forgetful, and is often tardy and

Read More
1147 Words | 5 Pages

The growing gap between the upper class and the lower class has been expensive. In “Biographies of Hegemony”, Karen Ho looks into the prevalent ideology named “culture of smartness” and explores the close tie between some of America’s most powerful and prestigious universities and Wall Street firms. Joseph Stiglitz, the author of “Rent Seeking and the Making of an Unequal Society”, is concerned about

Read More
1127 Words | 5 Pages

Walter responded with “I know ain’t nothing in this world as busy as you colored collage boys with your fraternity pins and white shoes”(Hansberry . 84). Walter was basically saying wow your a preppy rich boy that thinks he 's better than me. George was thinking that he was better than walter just because he had more money. But that is not the case he is no better than walter. Walter works hard for his money while george just gets it handed to him.

Read More
1348 Words | 6 Pages

However, the outcome of Vance’s life was different as he was graduated from Yale Law School, able to get a well-paying job and currently living the American Dream with his wife Usha. The purpose of the author in this memoir was to understand the reader of how social mobility feels and more importantly, what happens to the lives of the white working-class Americans, in particular the psychological impact that spiritual and material poverty has on their children. J.D Vance provides an explanation for the loss of the American dream to poor white Americans living in a toxic culture in this Ohio steel town.

Read More
608 Words | 3 Pages

Some classmates felt that his last shred of hope to keep him alive was his hatred for the party while others agreed that his love for Julia would help him from conforming back to the ideals of the party. When discussing what another classmates have found in class it has helped me to understand other points I might have overlooked in the novels we have read. I have improved from these activities by writing down other points and

Read More
1568 Words | 7 Pages

Instances of Displacement In Neil Gaiman’s “Bitter Grounds” “In every way that counted, I was dead,” begins the narrator-protagonist of Neil Gaiman’s “Bitter Grounds”, hinting at the theme of a profound shift in identity that will soon be explained. Indeed the reader will soon be introduced to a subtle slip from one reality into another through the eyes of a man faced with loss, love and his own identity. The elements of fantasy heighten the sense of displacement that accompanies the narrator from his initial purposelessness and self-exile, through the shaping of a new identity and search for a new purpose to his final act of abandon in the end. The idea of displacement, as evidenced by the very volume that features the story discussed

Read More
1912 Words | 8 Pages

Donna Tartt’s The Secret History tells the story of Richard Papen’s transfer from a small college in his hometown Plano, California, to an elite college in Vermont, Hampden College. During his first week, he becomes obsessively captivated by the five students in a highly selective Greek class and goes to extreme lengths to be accepted by the group’s members Henry Winter, Bunny Corcoran, Francis Abernathy, twins Charles and Camilla Macaulay, and their teacher Julian Morrow. This obsession and desire to please causes Richard’s involvement in two murders that distort his idea of morality. The novel is best analyzed by applying psychoanalytical and feminist theory to the characters with critical articles providing additional information and showing a different perspective. I have chosen to analyze the narrator, Richard Papen, the group leader, Henry Winter, and the only major female character, Camilla Macaulay.

Read More
837 Words | 4 Pages

As the story progresses, he begins to understand why he thinks in the manner that he does. Sanders does an excellent job of showing how his thinking changes as the text progresses. He does this through his brilliant use of interior monologue and personal anecdotes. In his essay, Sanders opens with a debate that he had with his friend Anneke.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Hillbilly Elegy

Related Topics

Open Document