ipl-logo

If You Were In The Bunk Part 2 Discussion Questions

1217 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Perspectives in the holocaust

1. If you were in the bunk, how would you vote and what reasons would you give, regarding God's guilt? (Write in character as a member of that bunk) 2. Given the historical perspective that you now have, is your position supported or challenged? Why and how? 3. Based on our conversation of Theodicy in class, describe some of the varieties demonstrated in the movie. The Holocaust, or the systematic persecution and murder of six million Jews by the Nazi regime and its collaborators is truly the most terrifying example of brutality in history I have ever witnessed. It hard to imagine myself in the bunks and eventually gas chambers, but my ideology would be simple. If I were in the bunk, and I was asked to value God’s guilt, I would vote him …show more content…

According to the scripture, the Israelites were in slavery for 400 years before reaching freedom and the promised land. “Know for certain that your offspring will be sojourners in a land that is not theirs and will be servants there, and they will be afflicted for 400 years.” (Genesis 15:13) When God says this to Abraham in Genesis, it is a foreshadowing of not only their slavery, but his assistance. This leaves the question, why would God allow such an event to happen for 400 years, and then assist the …show more content…

Trains were described as loading on more and more Jews everyday, and we now know over 6 million Jews were killed in these camps. So, as I conclude my first analysis of the exodus of the Jews from Egypt, I would question why God would not help us. If we have even more Jews who are being killed rather than owned, isn’t the situation worse than the one in Egypt? Why wouldn’t God help us, too? Surely, those questions are difficult to answer in the bunk. I would further label God as guilty by drawing another reference to a less-well known story of God helping the

Show More
Related

Examples Of And Every Single One Was Somebody By Phil Chernofsky

684 Words | 3 Pages

How Does One Say The Unspeakable Can you image living in a time when 6 million innocent people were killed in a span of twelve years? The Holocaust was a time when Hitler and his anti semitic Nazis were on a mission to kill all Jews that lived in Europe. The Holocaust began in 1933 when Hitler was appointed Chancellor and started Dachau the first concentration camp. How does one explain the unthinkable? Writers say the unspeakable about the Holocaust through several techniques such as repetition, symbols, and words not being able to express feelings.

Read More

Discussion Questions For Night By Elie Wiesel

502 Words | 3 Pages

Topic #3 There are few periods of time in history that are darker or more shocking than the Holocaust which was the mass killing of jews and other groups that hitler did not deem worthy to walk this earth. The Holocaust lasted about 12 years which is an insane amount of time for the mass killing of jews to be happening without anyone putting a stop to it. In the book “Night”written by Elie Wiesel writes about how no one in his town did anything despite the advance of the German army and Moishe the Beadle explaining what the germans are doing to the jews.

Read More

The Importance Of Silent In Eile Wiesel's Night

115 Words | 1 Pages

Holocaust, it was unforgettable and the most famous history in 1933-1945. There were 11 million people were killed by different ways. But, no one help them to say anythings, just keep silent.... Night, a book that is about the boy who is 15 years old to overcome the challenges unceasingly and still survives under the Holocaust. Eile Wiesel is a very lucky survivor, but something couldn 't reverse for him.

Read More

Holocaust Heroes: Miep Gies During The Holocaust

1454 Words | 6 Pages

Holocaust Heroes - Miep Gies. The holocaust was the worst genocide ever realized on earth, it left millions of victims dead. Thousands of people helped this horrible and non human movement to be executed, the German Politics, SS police, German Soldiers and other organizations, but not everyone let Hitler’s propaganda and speeches influence on them, A lot of people helped thousands of Jews to hide during the war. Nazi-sponsored persecution and mass murder fueled resistance to the Germans in the Third Reich itself and throughout occupied Europe.

Read More

Moish Mysticism In Night By Elie Wiesel

274 Words | 2 Pages

However, when he witnesses the horrific events inside of the camps all he can think of doing is to question why. Questioning as for what have the Jews done to deserve such severe punishments, why were so many of his people being massacred,

Read More

Analysis Of Night By Elie Wiesel

841 Words | 4 Pages

God helps those that help themselves. “We realized then that we were not staying in Hungary. Our eyes opened. Too late” (p. 23). It’s difficult to imagine how people can be so inhumane to one another, it’s sad to think about.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Auschwitz And Buna

187 Words | 1 Pages

For many Jews in the 1940’s, Auschwitz and Buna were a living nightmare. There were many scenes, ideas and feelings that were unforgettable for me. The first scenes that I found shocking were when Elie Wiesel saw the bodies of babies being thrown in a flame. I couldn’t imagine watching small, innocent bodies being treated like that. Second, the lack of mercy at the concentration camp were unbelievable.

Read More

Holocaust Dbq Essay

1663 Words | 7 Pages

"Concentration camps, that's what you call, uh, a camp what actually is annihilation...they annihilate people, actually. " This quote by Abraham Lewent sums up the story of the Holocaust and what an egregious time it was. The genocide of over six million people during World War II was the Holocaust. It all started with a man named Adolf Hitler and his rise to power and the German people who were desperate to believe anything they were told.

Read More

Thesis Statements For Night By Elie Wiesel

1243 Words | 5 Pages

This violence can be compared to today’s world in the way of being punished for seeing or knowing certain things or possibly just to have violence, but the independent and dependent variables need to be taken into account. The cruel way the guards would move the Jews from camp to camp could be an example of the unnecessary force and bloodshed used. “ “Faster, you filthy dogs!” We were no longer marching, we were running.

Read More

Dbq Essay On The Holocaust

556 Words | 3 Pages

In history there was many events that were horrifying. The Holocaust was one of those frightful events. During the World War II, the nazis were the ones in charge of the Holocaust. Six million Jews, homosexuals, and gypsies were killed and the survivors had to live their life with fear. These writers use several techniques in order to convey the horrors of the Holocaust.

Read More

How Did Frederick Douglass Contribute To Freedom

1356 Words | 6 Pages

There were many passages in the Bible that condoned slavery. The Bible represented the mind and will of God, and biblical stories such as “The Curse of Ham” defended the inferiority of African people. Slavery was actually considered moral, not only justified. The words of the Bible were thought of as true principles of Christianity, and following the words of the Bible meant that a person was carrying out God’s will. Paternalism, or limiting freedom from someone based on the idea that they know what is best for them, was an attitude that was common among slave owners.

Read More

How Did The Holocaust Impact Me

508 Words | 3 Pages

The Holocaust is the most significant historical event that I have studied so far. This tragic event took place during World War II and only very few survivors lived to share their shocking experiences. I have read a few of these survivor’s stories, such as Night, by Elie Wiesel and it has personally impacted me and influenced my thinking in various ways. The Holocaust was the greatest act of hate, violence, and anti-semitism.

Read More

How Did The Holocaust Affect The World

830 Words | 4 Pages

The Holocaust was one of the most devastating times for all of the world. It strained the world’s economy and resources; death tolls were tremendously high and injuries were severe. This was one of the worst events in our world’s history. For the 12 years that Germany was ruled by the Nazi Party, a central belief was that there existed in society, certain people who were dangerous and needed to be eliminated for German society to flourish and survive (Impact of the Holocaust).

Read More

Walter Sinnott-Armstrong's Argument Analysis

2349 Words | 10 Pages

124). His other point is that God having a sufficient reason for permitting evil is not the same as having a hallucination. He states that having good reason for the existence of God increases the possibility that He has a reason for permitting gratuitous suffering (p. 124). He also counters the claim that there is no evidence to suggest that God is all-good and all-powerful. He refers to his moral argument—wherein without the existence of God, objective moral values would also cease to exist, but objective moral values do exist and thus God also must exist—to make the claim that God is all-good (p. 125).

Read More

Does The Bible Justify Slavery?

199 Words | 1 Pages

For more than three hundred years, African Americans were ‘legally enslaved’, enduring manual labor, gruesome beatings, and horrific deaths. Master expected absolute loyalty and submission from the servants while inflicting pain and fear. After studying slavery in the bible, comparing and contrast modern and ancient slavery, and interpreting the biblical text that was used to justify slavery, left me with unanswered questions and mixed emotions. What made a person think that it is ok to enslave a race for more than 300 years?

Read More

More about If You Were In The Bunk Part 2 Discussion Questions

Related Topics

Open Document