ipl-logo

Analysis Of Susan Sontag's Illness As A Metaphor

732 Words3 Pages

In Illness as a Metaphor, Susan Sontag presents an argument that metaphors used to explain illnesses with either unknown or multiple causes can actually complicate their understanding rather that strengthen it. Furthermore, illnesses can be incorrectly used to create metaphors (Sontag 3). Using two prominent examples of illnesses with histories of metaphors complicating understanding, tuberculosis and cancer, Sontag is able to elaborate upon her thesis and provide evidence about how their perception in society was affected by metaphors. The first point that Sontag introduces is the fact that historically, tuberculosis was viewed much like how cancer is viewed nowadays. There was very little knowledge about the causes of tuberculosis and contracting it …show more content…

Tuberculosis was seen as the preferred way to go back in its prime; people apparently died a peaceful and relatively painless death. Sontag introduces the idea that “the dying tubercular is pictures as made more beautiful and more soulful; the person dying of cancer is portrayed as robbed of all capacities of self-transcendence, humiliated by fear and agony” (Sontag 17). All of the language surrounding TB suggests that it is an easy way to pass, but dying of cancer is painful and dehumanizing in some sort of way. Sontag sums up her arguments by pointing out that there were plenty of people whose experiences completely defied the common understandings. Both diseases can lead to painful (or painless) deaths. Tuberculosis can affect more than just one organ. Examining the metaphors surrounding diseases can provide great insight into how society views death. The metaphors chosen reflect how we handle pain and suffering. Considering this notion, perhaps more information on the causes and treatment of cancer will lead to a more positive prognosis for patients and in turn, change the metaphors used to describe

Show More
Related
193 Words | 1 Pages

Cancer is one of the scariest diagnoses to go through or experience with a close family member or friend. Henrietta Lacks a black woman in the 50’s was diagnosed with cervical cancer little did she know her doctors stole her cells for research and never spoke about it. In The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks you get to experience what the author. Rebecca Skloot goes through as she tries to figure out what happened with Henrietta Lack in the early 200’s Skloot gets in contact to get to know the situation better but the Lacks family knew little to none about Henrietta’s condition and the research that was being done to her revolutionary cells.

Read More
680 Words | 3 Pages

Figurative language is sometimes used to make events have certain moods such as happiness, sadness, mystery, and suspense. The book focuses on a deadly virus that is highly contagious and is very oppressive. The virus had originated from the central rainforests of Africa, then had suddenly appeared in Germany. The book describes how Charles Monet bled out from the disease in the Nairobi Hospital waiting room, how monkeys contributed to spreading the disease, the effects the virus has on the body, and how the United States Army Medical Research Institute of Infectious Diseases, or USAMRIID tested the virus on monkeys and tried to find a cure for the virus. In The Hot Zone, by Richard Preston, the author uses figurative language such as foreshadowing

Read More
293 Words | 2 Pages

Another example of metaphors in

Read More
1523 Words | 7 Pages

What makes a story enjoyable? Is it the plot? Or is it the methods the author uses to connect to the reader? Plot is a big thing, but it is the literary devices that bring the story together. In the three stories, “The Tunnel” by Sarah Ellis, “The Skating Party” by Merna Summers and “The Bicycle” by Jillian Horton all have unique literary devices to make each story more intriguing and to give them the feeling of being part of the story.

Read More
142 Words | 1 Pages

In Rhetoric and Argument and What Words Can Tell , Francine Prose brings upon a compelling look into the world of writing. A excerpt from her own personal view of writing, the article is primarily for students or those that are interested in learning more of the process of writing as told by a recognized author. Prose seeks to enlighten and teach his audience about the complexity and difficulty involved in writing a good piece of literature, and how the careful choosing of certain words can significantly alter the literature. Prose uses the rhetorical device of metaphor in your excerpt to compare the details involved in writing to the intricate wirings of a computer. Prose reveals to the audience a new view of literature, where the writing

Read More
839 Words | 4 Pages

The poet successfully illustrates the magnitude with which this disease can change its victim’s perspective about things and situations once familiar to

Read More
1086 Words | 5 Pages

When a patient is told they have a disease, they are shocked. Some patients worry that they may die, and others feel numb or confused about it. They may have a hard time realizing that their disease could be fatal. “When he asked if she was okay, her eyes welled with tears and she said, “Like I’m always telling my brothers, if you gonna go into history, you can’t do it with a hate attitude. You got to remember, times was different” (Skloot 276).

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

In most stores that people read, they never notice metaphoric language. Readers may think that it is just a weird way to say something, but most metaphors have meanings. If readers pay more attention to this element it makes the story more interesting to read. Once someone reads while identifying metaphoric language, they will never stop. The authors of the two stories “The Long Rain” and “Harrison Bergeron” used metaphoric language to shape the mood and dominant themes of the stories.

Read More
170 Words | 1 Pages

Thomas C. Foster uses the twenty-fourth chapter of How to Read Literature Like a Professor as a place to investigate how authors employ illnesses to give meaning to their stories. But not all illnesses are physical, and Courtney Cole’s novel, Nocte, displays how the human body reacts to extreme trauma in ways of self-preservation. After surviving a car crash in which her mother and brother died in, Calla Price’s body shut itself down into a coma and rejected all notions that pointed to reality. Instead, her brain blocked out anything that could make reality seem real, and she woke up from her coma believing that her brother and mother were still alive. Her illness may not have been as literal as heart disease or cancer but her inability to

Read More
753 Words | 4 Pages

I only began to understand the concept of an individual being terminally ill when my grandmother went into the hospital. I placed my hand inside of hers and stared at her emotionless face. I could only imagine the pain running through her body and the agony of not being able to vocalize a response to my ‘I love you’. Day after day she waited only anticipating her death and the pain she would feel if indeed she woke up the next day. I would have done anything to not have to see her go through the pain, and to allow her to get to her fate quicker and more comfortably.

Read More
702 Words | 3 Pages

Another way a metaphor is used is “when someone died it wasn’t dying...because they had their lines memorized, irony mixes” (O’Brien 480). According to the evidence, psychologically, it describes the idea of death in the minds of all soldiers while physically they had to endure suffering. Therefore, all soldiers are shown to have hardships through

Read More
730 Words | 3 Pages

Cancer is also a disease that is extremely painful to have. Tuberculosis was seen as a disease that gave a person a beautiful and peaceful death. Both diseases are painful and terrible. Although romanticized, tuberculosis was not as beautiful as it seemed; many people infected with tuberculosis died painful deaths. Cancer is also not always painful.

Read More
1567 Words | 7 Pages

Psychosocial Advances in Oncology Research and Practice In the 1800’s, a cancer diagnosis was viewed as the equivalent of death (Holland, 2002). In this day and age, there was no known cause or cure, and it was considered inhumane to reveal the diagnosis to the patient. In a constantly changing and advancing society, this ideology was transformed as the result of an accumulation of technological advances, education, and research initiative. This led to the acceptance of the notion of cancer worldwide.

Read More
941 Words | 4 Pages

In this model, Leventhal defines disease representations as a person’s perceptions

Read More
1014 Words | 5 Pages

Imagine being unable to walk, unable to speak, unable to move and unable to breathe. Imagine being in a state of complete paralysis where the only thing that keeps on functioning is your brain, and you live chained to a machine doctors call life support. Imagine being told that you have an incurable disease that will inevitably kill you. Maybe next month. Maybe next year.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Susan Sontag's Illness As A Metaphor

Related Topics

Open Document