ipl-logo

In Us History Conservation Has Improved Life For Americans

911 Words4 Pages

For this essay, I chose to focus on the statement of “In US history, conservation has improved life for Americans.” I believe that this is a very multifaceted statement with compelling arguments for both sides. With this loaded statement, my opinion stands in the middle. I believe that conservation has drastically improved the lives of some Americans, but for others, such as Native Americans, it hasn't. One example of conservation not benefiting Native Americans comes from the reading “Nature and Nation” by Karl Jacoby. Native Americans gravitated to the Yellowstone National Park because of its volcanoes, which provide warmth and attract many game animals, which is how they were able to survive and make a living. As tourists came into the National …show more content…

Indians were portrayed as rootless beings who had no ties to the land even though they helped it exponentially by improving the landscapes with the use of fire to ward off pests and recycling nutrients. Due to Indians being portrayed in this way, 1883 was the year they tightened reservation rules. This led to park superintendents being employed, which didn't last for long as they realized Native Americans knew the land better than them. Eventually they found a more permanent solution, which was making Yellowstone a military reservation. This allowed them to “make the necessary details of troops to prevent trespassers or intruders from entering the park.” (Jacoby 21). Ultimately, this led Yellowstone National Park into a militarized state, which prohibited any Native Americans from entering what was once a remote spot for them to reside. Regardless of the negative impact that can be seen from conservation in the United States, there are still some positive impacts. One positive impact that we can analyze comes from the reading “New and Old Forestry” by S.P.

Show More
Related

Indian Givers Chapter Summary

1209 Words | 5 Pages

“Indian Givers” “Indian Givers: How the Indians of the Americas Transformed the World,” by Jack Weatherford, is a book about the American Indians and their contributions to the rest of the world. The book goes into great detail about the changes that occurred from when settlers first arrived to the Americas and began interactions with the Indians to the modern century of when the book was published, which was 1988. Weatherford did an outstanding job as putting into perspective how much the world has learned and obtained from the American Indians and their land. The book sheds light on these topics with a positive mood, yet also points out some failures of the Indians and their legacy. Jack Weatherford is a retired “DeWitt Wallace Professor

Read More

Summary Of Part One Of American Colonies By Alan Taylor

380 Words | 2 Pages

In Part One of American Colonies, author Alan Taylor accentuates the natural disharmonies that transpired due to humanity, throughout the colonization of the New World. Taylor attributes humans as the most endangering species to the environment, both Native Americans and the settlers. Prior to and during the settlement of the North American colonies, all of humanity’s survival depended on the environment and how they used it. If the Natives or the settlers did not use their surrounding to the fullest advantage, themselves or others potentially could die. The first example of environmental demise that Taylor illustrated was the “…the extinction [of] two-thirds of all New World species…including the giant beaver, mammoth…” and others,” (Taylor 8).

Read More

Summary Of Changes In The Land By William Cronon

1057 Words | 5 Pages

In the book, Changes in the Land: Indians, Colonists, and the Ecology of New England, author William Cronon address the permanent environmental changes and concerns that took place at the hands of Native Americans and colonists in New England. With references to Henry David Thoreau, the first part of the book lays the ground for the reader to feel nostalgic towards the original beauty of New England that was assumed to exist prior to when the Europeans arrived. Cronon expands upon this imagery of New England environmental beauty through an arrangement of sources by presenting the drastic landscape changes that happened after the interaction of two different civilizations. Extensive evidence from this book shows how Native Americans were slowly

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Government Must Preserve National Parks

613 Words | 3 Pages

The underlying reasons for the belief, impression or thought that the US gov-ernment must continue to fund national parks is often overlooked, misunder-stood or unheeded. In his essay, “Government Must Preserve National Parks.” Author Todd Da-vidson builds a cogent, detailed and absorbing argument by employing a varie-ty of rhetorical techniques and persuasive strategies, most notably, an array of pertinent facts and statistics, appeal to emotions, and a logical argument to persuade his audience that the US government must continue to fund national parks.

Read More

Dbq Hetchy Project

663 Words | 3 Pages

In the testimony before the House Committee on the Public Lands on June 1913, Pinchot (an advocate for conservationists) stated that “the use of the park will be enormously increased” (Pinchot and Raker 2).  This means the the ability to have multiple use of the land can allow the government to create more than just an attraction site, but also create activities and different things people can do there for a price. Also in the testimony before the House Committee on the Public Lands on June 1913, Pinchot also stated that “the national park will be visited by a very large number of  people who cannot visit them now” (Pinchot and Raker). This gives government the opportunity to make money, because people would pay money in order to see the beauty of the land now that it is cleared up.  

Read More

John Muir's Ethical Dilemmas

336 Words | 2 Pages

John Muir, a naturalist and preservation pioneer of nature took an ethical stand for land ethics when he shared his thoughts that all living things are equally important parts of the land, and animals and plants have as much right to live and survive as people do. In the 1600’s when Europeans began to settle in North America, there were 1037 million acres of forestland. Today, a little over 700 million acres in the United States is forestland—only thanks to preservation laws. In the 1800’s, that number of tress and forests decreased tremendously because expansion and progression recklessly exploited natural resources by clear-cutting forest to use wood for fuel and building supplies.

Read More

A Comparison Of The Lewis And Clark Expedition

1887 Words | 8 Pages

The migration of Americans to the west was a good thing for innovation and building up the United States as a country, but the Native Americans who lived in these lands were changed forever. Any Native Americans found in lands where United States citizens wanted land was immediately excavated from their land and brought to an Indian reservation of some kind. Overtime though, these Indian reservations began to limit due to the rising population in Americans during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. “They [Lewis and Clark] provided valuable information about the topography, the biological sciences, the ecology, and ethnic and linguistic studies of the American Indian. The mysteries of

Read More

Conservation As A National Duty Speech By President Theodore Roosevelt

1063 Words | 5 Pages

In Osawatomie, Kansas on August 31, 1910, President Theodore Roosevelt gave his Conservation As A National Duty Speech. Roosevelt gave this speech to consider the question of the conservation and use of the great fundamental sources of wealth of this Nation. This is the first time in the Untied States’ history the chief executive officers of the States separately, and of the States together forming the Nation, have met to consider this. With the governors come men from each State chosen for their special acquaintance with the terms of the problem that is before us. The Senators and Representatives in Congress; the Supreme Court, the Cabinet, and the Inland Waterways Commission have likewise been invited to the Conference, which is therefore

Read More

How Was Ecologically Different From New England In The 1600s?

270 Words | 2 Pages

Elaborating on concepts from the previous chapters, Cronon discusses how and why New England in the 1800s was ecologically different from New England in the 1600s. The author lists many relevant issues which influenced the ecological change: deforestation, dams, crop disease, European pests, and so forth. Cronon states that there is a clear difference between New England before and after European colonization, but stresses the dangers of analyzing ecological change simply by contrasting two landscapes (before and after European colonization). Cronon discusses how disease helped to promote European expansion, and how economic and ecological imperialisms reinforced each other. He also mentions that Indians continuously evolved, and an earlier

Read More

Westward Expansion Dbq

831 Words | 4 Pages

Westward expansion will forever be a reminder of the horrors Native Americans endured for the sake of the country that never treated them justly to begin with. Likewise, one can see in document 5 the population of buffalo from 1800-1889, how it decreased drastically after the beginning of westward expansion. This elucidates that not only were Native Americans dealt with unjustly, but so were that which they held dear were dealt unjustly too. An important part of Native American culture revolved around the animals they would take care of, use for resources, and be apart of their daily lives. However, when westward expansion took place, Native Americans were not considered for, nor what

Read More

Mexican Americans Dbq

275 Words | 2 Pages

No other transformation was more measurable in the west was the Assault on Indian way of life caught by miners and settlers who grasped their homes and federal Government extortion, (Doc C) by the 1890s Native Americans reservations had been the aftereffect on Most Indians, natives effortlessly combated to preserve their assets. Bison and buffalo had been their Linked article commonly utilizing it for food, clothing and trade. Promptly of the millions of

Read More

American Natural Identity Dbq

642 Words | 3 Pages

Americans Natural Identity In the late 18 hundreds, Americans witnessed the destruction and abuse of their countries nature and resources. This destruction sparked a new age, ready to establish the conservation and preservation of America's backcountry. Legislation, such as newly declared laws and acts, assisted in creating a new sense of American identity and nationality, strongly relating to nature and national parks. Individuals, such as Theodore Roosevelt and John Muir, were influential and essential within this movement.

Read More

National Parks Ethos Pathos Logos

528 Words | 3 Pages

Nature, with its awe-inspiring landscapes and abundant biodiversity, is a testament to the Earth’s enduring beauty. Within the borders of the United States lie remarkable treasures: the National Parks. These protected areas not only safeguard natural wonders but also provide crucial habitats for countless species. In this essay, we will delve into the significance of national parks, employing persuasive rhetoric to highlight their importance. By appealing to ethos, pathos, and logos, we hope to inspire a deep appreciation for these remarkable landscapes and emphasize the imperative of preserving them for future generations.

Read More

The Indian New World James Merrell Analysis

696 Words | 3 Pages

Merrell’s article proves the point that the lives of the Native Americans drastically changed just as the Europeans had. In order to survive, the Native Americans and Europeans had to work for the greater good. Throughout the article, these ideas are explained in more detail and uncover that the Indians were put into a new world just as the Europeans were, whether they wanted change or

Read More

Native Americans Changed Over Time

101 Words | 1 Pages

Have you ever had a family and a bright future in one place and were forced to move the place where you have lived for most and or all of your life? Well the Native Americans have or “The First Americans.” North America had people living in it long before the first explorers and settlers arrived. Unfortunately, they were pushed off of their land to make way for white settlers, who felt they had the right to own the land. In my essay I will be explaining how and if the way we treat the Native Americans over time has changed.

Read More

More about In Us History Conservation Has Improved Life For Americans

Open Document