ipl-logo

Insanity In Hamlet And The Piano Man's Daughter

1133 Words5 Pages

Insanity is the ability to notice and derive messages from everyday life, which are usually ignored. Shakespeare’s play Hamlet takes place in Denmark during the 1600s. The King of Denmark is murdered by his brother Claudius, who then subsequently married the widowed Queen Gertrude. Prince Hamlet, nephew to the new King, is suspicious of the sudden death and seeks revenge. However, while striving to execute his plan Hamlet, as well as his love Ophelia, is consumed by insanity. Madness is a recurring theme in the play; however the characters who display its characteristics do so differently. On contrary, Findley’s novel The Piano Man’s Daughter takes place between 1868 and 1939 in Canada, Toronto. It focuses on Lily who touched by a hybrid …show more content…

In both Hamlet and The Piano Man’s Daughter it is evident that when a character becomes obsessed with their unconscious thoughts it awakens their Id, thus regressing into their primitive state. For instance, during the confrontation between Hamlet and Ophelia, he urges her to attends a convent: “Get thee to a nunnery” (3.1.123). Nunnery, as a symbol, represents Hamlet’s inconsistency. Sending his loved one to a brothel shows that he does not love or respect Ophelia. This sudden change in treatment towards Ophelia demonstrates his inconsistency in emotion and behaviour. This could also be viewed as a side effect of madness, which creates an emotional turmoil and begins to destroy his relationship. Moreover, there is an ambiguity in “nunnery” as it can mean either a convent or a brothel. Therefore, there is uncertainty whether Hamlet sends Ophelia to preserve her innocence and purity or to continue her alleged promiscuous behavior. In addition, since Hamlet speaks this quote towards a women he used to love, it shows the weakening of his superego, which directs appropriate speech towards those you love. If the superego is not able to ensure behaviour within moral boundaries then there is an imbalance in Hamlet’s self. Thus, the ID is in control demonstrating the primitive emotion of anger and in this case hurt inflicted by Ophelia. Hamlet’s ID expresses anger and resentment towards

More about Insanity In Hamlet And The Piano Man's Daughter

Open Document