ipl-logo

Insanity In Henry James's The Turn Of The Screw

1475 Words6 Pages

Palmer Reynolds English 310 Honors Dr. Zubizarreta 29 October 2014 The Unreliable Narrator Henry James’s The Turn of the Screw is a psychologically thrilling novel that leaves readers from beginning to end wondering the solution to a single question: is this novel a story of ghosts or of mental illness? The question has kept readers in an air of mystery for centuries and may possibly never arrive to an agreed upon denouement. In a straightforward sense, the story features a new on the job governess who is greeted by a male and female ghost. However, a comprehensive analysis will prove a different side to the story. There is an array of evidence that leads the deeper reader to observe the story of a young woman who is driven to insanity. When …show more content…

One such case can be found in Chapter X. In this chapter, Flora was found out of bed and Miles on the lawn. This scene in particular evokes a chilling response as the governess relates, “(Flora) was face to face with the apparition we had met at the lake, and could now communicate with it as she had not then been able to do. (72)” With even more petrification the governess states, “the presence on the lawn—I felt sick as I made it out—was poor little Miles himself. (74)” The narrator used this circumstance to further her mindset that the children were being controlled by Peter Quint and Miss Jessel. The governess argued to the reader that the eerie event took place because of the possession of the children by the ghosts (71-74). Suppose, however, that the narrator of Turn of the Screw was one of the children. Would we read about a plan carried out only to play a funny prank on their governess, where Miles was to sneak out of the house at night? Similarly in Chapter XX, the governess assumes that Flora is being possessed by Miss Jessel because Flora has becomes afraid of her (116-121). The governess may argue possession, one must consider the outside perspective. Would not a sane individual be able to realize that any child would be afraid of her care taker acting out in such a manner, demanding to know about the existence of ghosts? …show more content…

However, there are some suggestions as to what took place. There is a possibility that Miles could have known that the governess thought she was seeing Peter Quint and that he only exclaimed Quint’s name in order to appease, or possibly prank the governess. There even exists a theory that, “the Governess ' anxiety-driven hysteria causes her to refuse to give up on the possibility that Miles is somehow connected to the ghosts, ultimately ending his life to fulfill her personal desire for the psychological truth. (Herold)” Either way, there is sufficient evidence to provide that in this scene Miles was not aware of any kind of supernatural presence. The governess even takes realization to this idea when she states, “wasn’t he looking through the haunted pane for something he couldn’t see? (147)” This theory could be supported by Mile’s change in demeanor in the scene, “more and more visibly nervous” and “suddenly afraid” because his governess was acting mad (149). The narrator in The Turn of the Screw bestows the reader with the tale of a boy possessed by ghosts. However, vigilant reading of the passage will provide a reader with the story of a boy who is terrified only because he is in the same room as someone suffering a mental

Show More
Related
550 Words | 3 Pages

Many locals were reluctant to go near Putney Mountains fearing for their personal safety. Knowing whatever was up there, although unexplainable, was dangerous and life threatening. Other townspeople speculated it was the ghosts of miners. Stirring up their remembrance of these mysteries one morning, a leading member of the town never arrived at his office; his secretary called his home looking for him. After his wife found his car in the garage with the engine off, but the key in the ignition, she called the police.

Read More
581 Words | 3 Pages

On the other hand, “Psychologically we can explain the presence of the ghost as being a figment of an imagination under the stress of grief” (Mediation and Multiple Narrative in Love Medicine). Because Grandma Kashpaw loves Grandpa too much so the way she treats him is the way to kill him. However, according to Kathleen M.

Read More
756 Words | 4 Pages

5: How to overcome the temptations from the devil. Letters 1-4 1: Wormwood is Screwtape's nephew. 2: Patient resembles humans in the story. Since Screwtape is a devil, he tries to tempt the patient to win him over. 3:

Read More
965 Words | 4 Pages

Governess’s Sanity In the novel The Turn of the Screw by Henry James, the governess is a fluid character who can be interpreted many ways. She is forced to deal with an odd situation when the ghosts of past workers appear around Bly. The manner in which she confronts issues in the story creates a deliberately ambiguous character that can be seen as sane or insane.

Read More
1049 Words | 5 Pages

The governess’s sanity in Henry James’s Turn of the Screw is often disputed over in literature. Because the governess sees ghosts in the novel, she is often argued as insane. The definition of sanity proves otherwise, stating that it is the “state of being sound of mind or having appropriate judgment skills” (Psychology Dictionary). The governess is sane because she behaves rationally, protects the children above all costs, and is not the only character witnessing a supernatural presence.

Read More
1063 Words | 5 Pages

Despite this, the opposing side fails to realize that Flora wanted the governess to stop pestering her after their encounter by the lake. When she finds out that Flora is leaving Bly to live with her uncle, she tells Mrs. Grose, “What Flora wants, of course, is to get rid of me” (James 74). The governess’ words and actions eventually terrify Flora as a result of her insanity. It is certainly evident that the children are scared for her abnormal concern for them and want her out of the house. Others may also argue that the reason of Miles’ death was because he sees Peter Quint, but they do not understand that Miles dies because of how the governess handles him.

Read More
1383 Words | 6 Pages

The novel, Turn of the Screw, by Henry James takes place in England and is told from the point of view of the Governess, whose sanity is questionable. The Governess is insane because throughout the novel, she is the only one who sees the ghosts, she is in love with the master, and she allows her desire to protect the children to drive her to insanity. First, the Governess is insane because she is the only character in the novel to ever have seen the ghosts. Early in the novel, the Governess claims she sees the ghost of Peter Quint, and immediately tells Mrs. Grose.

Read More
984 Words | 4 Pages

The never-ending sway of human nature Bloody cheers fill the street, glazing the air with a fervor rarely seen: the witch hunt has begun. In Arthur Miller’s gripping tale titled The Crucible, he retells the story of the Salem witch trials - all while twisting truths to make the events fit into what was occurring in the present. But what he had written as a showcase of the madness ensuing at the time of writing, the themes present within still hold a flame within events happening today. In short, the Crucible details the events of the trials held for the 'witches' – beginning with the girls who got caught dancing in the woods.

Read More
766 Words | 4 Pages

Thesis: Amongst the library of supernatural fiction and ghost stories written within the late 1800s, The Turn Of The Screw offers a direct commentary on the suppressed social fears of class change through the embodiment of ghosts. Introduction: Written in 1889, during the rise of supernatural psychical research and supernatural fiction, The Turn Of The Screw by Henry James tells the tale of a governess driven to insanity. The governess claims to have seen ghosts of the late governess, Miss Jessel, and the deceased valet, Peter Quint, on the grounds of castle Bly. The ghosts that she sees throughout the novella are not real and were created by the governess, due to the social pressures that she faced working at Bly. Her repressed desire to belong to a higher social class and her fears of trying to elevate her status were

Read More
1165 Words | 5 Pages

The governess is insane because she is the only person at Bly to witness the ghosts of Peter Quint and Miss Jessel. During her employment, the Governess claims to experience several ghostly interactions, however no one else could relate to her sightings. For example, after claiming to see two ghosts, the Governess confides in Mrs. Grose and later says “she herself had seen nothing, not the shadow of a shadow, and nobody in the house but the governess was in the governess’s plight,” (James 24). Mrs. Grose is eliminated as a witness and cannot argue if the paranormal activity at Bly was real. Since no one can support the governess’s claims, then presumably, they were hallucinated by

Read More
169 Words | 1 Pages

The protagonist from “The Turn of the Screw”, is perceived to be despearate as she tries to achieve her dream but her personal pride leads her to an unstable condition. The author depicts the Governess believing that to attain her goal of gaining attentionby her employer, she must be a hero. Therefore, she invents lies about seeing her predessors haunting her pupils. Nonetheless, the more times James makes the Governess mention the ghosts the more she believes they are real and they, “want to get them (the children)” (82). The Governess is blinded by making it appear she sees the ghosts that she looses herself in her own lies leading her to an unstable condition of not knowing what is real or not.

Read More
1270 Words | 6 Pages

Matthew Lewis’ The Monk and Ann Radcliffe’s The Italian are two of the most iconic Gothic novels of the Eighteenth Century, both written only a year apart and one in response to other. It is of no surprise that both novels have various subjects in common—one of these, the Supernatural. Ghostlike forces, specters, demons and locations are approached differently in The Monk and The Italian, one uses the supernatural deliberately—and in a much larger role—while the other uses the supernatural to heighten certain scenes of terror. Certainly, both novels use it as a shock factor, but furthermore both use it for different reasons in their novels.

Read More
1021 Words | 5 Pages

In Henry James’s novella, The Turn of the Screw, the topics of sanity and insanity are commonly argued among the readers. Insanity is the state of madness or being irrational while sanity is reasonable behavior. It is up to the audience to decide on whether the author intended for the governess to be sane or insane. Despite this dissension, the governess is insane throughout the whole story because she possesses all the symptoms of a paranoid schizophrenic, has an obsessive personality, and is the only one who claims she sees the apparitions.

Read More
1317 Words | 6 Pages

Within the Bly household as read in The Turn of the Screw, where the governess is the only person able to see ghosts, everything seems as it is falling apart. As the governess starts working at Bly, everything seems picture perfect, but is quite the opposite as the story progresses. As everything unfolds at Bly the governess seems to become progressively mentally incapacitated. As days pass by the governess believes she begins to see the ghosts on a daily basis, and she becomes so frustrated she accuses the children, Miles and Flora, of meeting with the ghosts. The children never admit to her accusations, which upsets the governess to sure a high degree that she even starts to blame the children of conspiring against her.

Read More
709 Words | 3 Pages

Wynnes becomes a major character in the story. She tells the young native boy to get a bowl of milk, from this she is proving the colonel wrong, but the readers don 't know it yet. Mona uses her as a game piece, when the colonel jumps and screams, the American asked Mrs. Wynnes how she knew about the snake. Mrs. Wynnes character replied with, “ it was crawling across my foot”. This proves the colonel untrue because his whole argument was men has added self control in any crisis.

Read More

More about Insanity In Henry James's The Turn Of The Screw

Related Topics

Open Document