ipl-logo

Is Human Nature Good Or Evil In Lord Of The Flies

1094 Words5 Pages

One of the most debated topics for decades has been whether human nature is inherently good or evil, this topic has divided people since the idea was introduced. However, human nature is fundamentally good, it is not anywhere near evil. In Golding’s Lord of the Flies he alludes to the idea that human nature is evil , savage, and violent however the true overall nature of people is kind, civilized, and nurturing which is evident in “The Real Lord of the flies: what happened when six boys were shipwrecked for 15 months” and 12 Angry Men.
Throughout Golding’s Lord of the Flies he tries to prove how violent human nature is, however, human nature is truly nurturing as seen in “The Real Lord of the flies: what happened when six boys were shipwrecked …show more content…

Golding believes that human nature is honestly evil as shown when,” Ralph wept for the end of innocence, the darkness of man’s heart” (Golding 202). Ralph is quite literally weeping, because he fears the darkness of man’s heart if human nature was honestly evil, he would not be weeping about this, he would be in agreement with this resolution. The overall idea Golding was trying to prove through this quote wrapping up his book is how human nature is dark and evil and when the laws of civilization are taken away people truly let themselves become what he believes is their human nature which is evil. Though, in 12 Angry Men a fictional story about a jury of a murder trial uses a character Juror 8 to portray the kind and compassionate parts of human nature. Which is seen when Juror 8 sates,” There were eleven votes for guilty—it’s not so easy for me to raise my hand and send a boy off to die without talking about it first” (Rose 15). Though there is a lot of evidence against the man on trial Juror 8’s kind and compassionate nature cause him to want to deliberate for a longer amount of time so that the wrong decision is not made, and they do not potentially send an innocent man off to be killed. Highlighting the good, kind aspect of human nature which proves how human nature at its core is kind and compassionate not …show more content…

Throughout the Lord of the Flies the boys slowly devolve into savages, they begin to paint their faces with clay, harm each other with spears, and use hunting dances and chants to hunt not only animals but each other. As seen when,” Jack and the two anonymous savages with him swayed, looking up, and then recovered. The littlun went on howling” (Golding 140). The boys have lost sight of any laws or civilization, they are even howling like animals, which conveys Golding’s belief that human nature is savage. Still, this is simply not the case in 12 Angry Men when the jurors are faced with deciding upon whether a man should be convicted of murder and killed Juror 3 expresses,” Everybody gets a fair trial… That’s the system” (Rose 12). Even when many of the Jurors disagree with each other they remain civilized and remember the laws of their country and do what they can do to ensure the trial is fair and their verdict is correct. Another source that helps proves how human nature is civilized is “The Real Lord of the Flies: when six boys were shipwrecked for 15 months”. This article discusses the events that happened while the

Show More
Related
394 Words | 2 Pages

“12 Angry Men,” written by Reginald Rose, is a drama or play about a boy who is put on trial for murdering his father. 12 jurors are put into the jury room to discuss and come up with the boy's verdict, but they can't come up with a unanimous decision. Juror 8 stands alone with his opinion of “not guilty,” but he isn’t the only one who convinces the rest of the jury for “not guilty.” Juror 9 also has an impact on the vote to be unanimous in favor of “not guilty.” Juror 9 played an important role for the verdict to be “not guilty” by trying to prove other points against the boy being “guilty.”

Read More
1964 Words | 8 Pages

"Don 't judge a book by its cover" is a famous saying that some of us heard it before and some of us experienced it. 12 jurors were experiencing this quote when they gathered to decide whether a young boy is guilty by killing his father or not. Juror 2 stated, "Well, anyway, I think he was guilty" (6). Juror 2 represent most of us, as sometimes we judge from what we hear and not from what we see. The 12 jurors are from various backgrounds and each one has a distinctive personality.

Read More
432 Words | 2 Pages

Name: Ethan Lang Teacher: Sasha King Subject: ELA Date Completed: N/A "A jury verdict is just a guess—a well-intentioned guess, generally, but you simply cannot tell fact from fiction by taking a vote." This quote from William Landay, the author of two award-winning crime novels, shows how jury verdicts can be wild guesses that aren’t always accurate. In Reginald Rose's play 12 Angry Men, 12 jurors debate whether to convict a boy of first-degree murder. A few of the jurors start to show signs of aggression toward one another, and things get heated very quickly, partially because of the hot conditions in the room. The jurors can’t come to a unanimous decision, which leads them to examine how the boy and the witnesses might have seen or done the murder.

Read More
916 Words | 4 Pages

Rose uses these examples to illustrate how much of Juror 3’s personal issues can twist his mind into thinking worse of the defendant. Secondly, Rose highlights the notion that you can have different kinds of prejudice in the jury room, and this can change people’s

Read More
474 Words | 2 Pages

The play Twelve Angry Men written by Reginald Rose the jury decides whether or not the boy is guilty of murder in the first degree. Juror Eight votes not guilty because, he needs more evidence. Juror Eight is compassionate, when all the other jurors voted the boy guilty. He tenderhearted proclaims that voting him guilty isn’t easy he implies, “Look this kids been kicked around his all his life.” Juror Eight doesn't want to just send the boy off to prison without further investigation.

Read More
231 Words | 1 Pages

In the play “twelve angry men” by playwright, Reginald Rose showcases the events of A jury room filled with 12 jurors who are tasked to deliberate a case of a young boy who was accused of parricide. In the play, the 8th juror emerges as the hero of the play when he showcases the qualities of a hero including, Integrity, empathy, leadership and courage, which back up his heroism. The play continues to exhibit the argument that juror 8 is the hero of “Twelve angry men” because of his persistence in investigating evidence and thoughtfully going through it; in the pursuit of justice. The 8th juror exhibits a extensive level of persistence in investigating the evidence presented before him at the trial.

Read More
569 Words | 3 Pages

In the play Twelve Angry Men by Reginald Rose, we can see that prejudice gets in the way of truth. Many of the jurors that participated have let prejudice get in their way to see the truth and look at the real situation and facts, for example, Juror Three, who “is a very strong, very forceful, extremely opinionated man within whom can be detected a streak of sadism… is intolerant of opinions other than his own, and accustomed to forcing his wishes upon others.” He has a son that he identifies as a “tough guy”, which is one of the descriptions of the 19-year-old accused, Juror Three let the image of his own son be reflected on the boy and made him think unfairly. Getting to the bottom of a complex issue takes time and effort. At the beginning of the play, most jury members wanted to get over the case and go home as early as they could, but one of the jury members, Juror Eight, who was sure the boy was not guilty, took many hours to question the evidence and the case and murder itself, but he was not the only one as other jury members also spoke about what they thought in the past options, fairly quick, it was almost six in the evening and Juror Six wanted to leave to go to his family, it may have been more of an excuse to leave, but the jurors did not let him leave because they had gone far enough to decide where the trial was going

Read More
466 Words | 2 Pages

"12 Angry Men" is a play by Reginald Rose that explores several themes related to the American justice system and the human condition. The play takes place in a New York City courtroom as jurors deliberate to reach a verdict in a murder case. Through the interactions and perspectives of the jurors, Rose sheds light on important themes such as the pressure of conformity, the influence of personal biases, the value of critical thinking, and the fragility of justice. One of the central themes of the play is the pressure of conformity.

Read More
412 Words | 2 Pages

The play 12 Angry Men begins in a room of 12 jurors as they discuss the guilt of a boy charged with the murder of his father. The facts of the case have been laid out, and each Juror already has decided how they feel. The foreman, a man of authority, not exceptionally bright, tends to believe the young boy is guilty. Ten other jurors decide to monotonously agree with him, despite their either opinionated, hesitant thesis. For instance, Juror number three, a narrow, humourless man, and Juror number two, a dubious, afraid persona, both determine guilty.

Read More
1191 Words | 5 Pages

The play 12 Angry Men is about a jury of twelve men that are given the task of deciding the fate, guilty or not guilty, of a young boy accused of murdering his father. The theme of standing up against the majority is very prevalent in this story because of the decisions some of the jurors make throughout the play. Juror 8 makes the decision to vote not guilty, he is the one and only juror in this play that decides to vote not guilty for the boy in the beginning. The other eleven jurors decide to vote guilty because of the evidence that they have been presented with. The act of Juror 8 standing against the majority of the other jurors about the case, voting not guilty, allows the jurors to thoroughly dissect the case, understanding it fully and thoughtfully before making their decision of guilty or not guilty.

Read More
580 Words | 3 Pages

Judgment of character isn’t always black and white. Those on trial for their alleged crimes rely on a jury chosen of their peers to decide their fate. The life of a juror and the events that they have gone through to get to that specific point in their life alters their standpoint in any situation. A jury could be made up of a combination of people with different economic backgrounds, races, or ages. In ‘Twelve Angry Men’ by Reginald Rose, two jurors have drastically different fundamental beliefs.

Read More
801 Words | 4 Pages

What are the Defensive Driving Procedures for School Bus Drivers? Meta description: School bus driving is a challenging and risky concern. Let 's check out the defensive driving procedures for school bus drivers, which aids them to elude adverse situations Defensive driving skills comprise practices that assist the drivers to drive the vehicle through challenging conditions. Consequently, it is essential for the school bus drivers, especially due to varied reasons.

Read More
915 Words | 4 Pages

People act upon what they think. Within “12 Angry Men”, all of the jurors have an opinion but some voice their more than others. One juror in particular, Juror Ten, voices his opinion about the boy in question. Repeatedly throughout the play, Juror Ten makes many thoughtless and hurtful comments about a certain kind of people. It is clear that Juror Ten’s uncompromising belief that the accused is guilty is because of his dislike for the boy’s race.

Read More
1206 Words | 5 Pages

The people’s sympathy and concern for this young man’s life was the main goal in this murder trial. When he convinces the other jurors to talk it over for another hour, Juror eight also exemplifies the foot-in-the-door approach. In additional to the above tactics, he

Read More
1127 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout the novel of Lord of the Flies, William Golding provides a profound insight into human nature. Golding builds on a message that all human beings have natural evil inside them. To emphasize, the innate evil is revealed when there’s lack of civilization. The boys are constantly faced with numerous fears and eventually break up into two different groups. Although the boys believe the beast lives in the jungle, Golding makes it clear that it lurks in their hearts.

Read More

More about Is Human Nature Good Or Evil In Lord Of The Flies

Related Topics

Open Document