ipl-logo

Is It Morally Permissible To Lie Essay

1035 Words5 Pages

In this essay, I will argue that Kant does not successfully establish that one must never under any circumstances or for any purpose tell a lie. Kant does show that one must never lie under some circumstance but fails to from varies ways to prove that must not tell a lie for any purpose, firstly the defect of the universal law formula under some situation, secondly the controversial of the humanity formula and the link between rationality and the categorical imperative. The categorical imperative suggest that tell a lie is unacceptable due to it could not become a universal law of nature. Though Kant view of the universal law that act is only morally permissible if the would run under the act is attainable. Consider if everyone is lying the world will be undermined as everything become untrustworthy. So …show more content…

For example suppose your friend runs into your house tells you he is in danger and hides in your house and a couple minutes later a murderer comes knocks on your door with a gun in his hand asking if you have seen your friend, what should you do? From Kant’s view, you should not lie to the murderer because we have a duty to not to do so. This seems irrational as you indirectly let your friend die which a rational agent would not do this. We are morally permissible to lie to the murder as it is in our power to prevent friend dying because there is nothing comparable moral importance(Singer, 1972, P.229-243). Kant respond to this said the key point is that not to lie does not necessarily equal to telling the truth. So it would, therefore, be possible that to achieve both not to lie and avoid letting the friend

Show More
Related
285 Words | 2 Pages

In the articles, “Brad Blanton:Honestly, Tell the Truth,” by Barbara Ballinger and “Rejecting all lies:Immanuel Kant,” by Sissela Bok they both think the same as well except Kant thinks even in life or death situations don’t lie. In the article,”Brad Blanton:Honestly Tell the Truth,” it shows that lying can be very stressful. As Blanton said,”Because it keeps you locked in the jail of your own mind”(Ballinger 7). This shows it can be stressful because since you lie, the truth somewhat wants to come out.

Read More
539 Words | 3 Pages

In the essay "The Way We Lie," Stephanie Ericsson explains a few of the many reasons why we lie, "We avoid confrontation, we spare people's feelings, we conveniently forget, we keep secrets" (1992, p. 159). We want to avoid a big argument or fight that might make matters worse. We lie to protect another from the truth because it might be unbearable. A lie can come out of our mouth without much thought.

Read More
1365 Words | 6 Pages

Whether you are trying to protect people from the truth by hiding secrets you are still not being honest which is the same as lying. A vague example in the novel is when Ben first hears about his terminal illness. Instead of telling his family, he decides to skip treatment and not tell his family. Keeping this secret makes the most sense to Ben at this time. “I know this is too much for your mother, but your dad is the most level headed man I know.”

Read More
797 Words | 4 Pages

But why does one feel the need to lie? One engages in lying to benefit themselves or another. Lying is used to protect oneself as well as others. Danforth, demanding an answer, yells, ‘“Is your husband a lecher!”

Read More
465 Words | 2 Pages

In the next article “ Tell The Truth” by Barbara Ballingar. Barbara says” it is tough not to lie but the right thing to do is just to tell the truth.” Then how he is truthful with his friends by telling them idiots when they are acting the way,and how he is not afraid to tell his friends that. She also states , that we developed a radical honesty. Which means that we like telling the truth in a different way.

Read More
444 Words | 2 Pages

This quote says that lying happens frequently; no one can resist it. It also says lying is deadly, which is also shown in the Bible within the story of Adam and Eve, when the serpent lies to Eve, convincing her to consume the sacred fruit. In modern society, lying is a common practice. A person may lie protect themselves, or to gain something wanted. This may be due to religious diversity or the decay of respect in society.

Read More
1095 Words | 5 Pages

One of the greatest commandments written in history is “Thou Shalt not lie.” From a young age we have been taught of the negative effects of lying. We are taught, as toddlers, not to cheat on tests and punished for our dishonesty when caught. But as we grow older we discover that lying is not as terrible as we were raised to believe. Sometimes lying is safer than the truth.

Read More
268 Words | 2 Pages

I don’t think that it’s wrong to lie to a murderer who is trying kill someone because I’m trying to help someone who is about to die, It will make me feel like i save someone and for me, saving someone life is very important to me for some reason. lying to a murderer to save someone's life make it save two people at once because if i don't tell a murderer that the person who he want to kill where is he or she, then he won't have to kill that person and he won't have to become a serial murder and he won't have to go back to jail so lying can lead things in the right way depending on what situation we are in . i dont think that Kant’s morality is not too rigid and inflexible. Even though lying is considered a bad thing to do but it is an acceptable

Read More
679 Words | 3 Pages

and she know that there is only one good answer to that question, the women just gave the man permission to lie to her. Meyer said “lying is an attempt to connect are wishes and our fantasies on who we are with we were and how we wish we could be with what we're really like” meaning, we lie to pretend to be someone we aren't. Then Meyer answered the question of when do we lie? A person can be lied to

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

Many people wonder is it wrong to lie or are there some situation where lying is the best option? In the book, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime by Mark Haddon, Mark Haddon shifts Christopher’s outlook on honesty and changed his outlook dramatically. Many people, including Christopher, believe in the statement “honesty is the best policy.” However while Christopher becomes more independent, he realizes that in some situations being dishonest might be the best answer. When his father lies to Christopher, Christopher follows his father’s actions and starts to comprehend when he must lie.

Read More
926 Words | 4 Pages

Many people have told lies and been told lies ,however the biggest lie of all is lying to oneself. Everyone has been told to share the truth because even though the truth will hurt others now, a carried out lie will hurt them a lot more in the future. It 's better to do right than to live in lies such as don 't hide all your faults they won 't just go away, you need to learn from your mistakes. In Les Miserables and The Kite Runner a man 's reputation is not as important as his family. As in giving up yourself for another and to be happy, like leaving your homeland where you are known and in charge to become a working man and make your family happy.

Read More
451 Words | 2 Pages

Stephanie Ericsson justifies the habits of lying in “The Ways We Lie” using firsthand experiences and solid metaphors. Essentially, Take into consideration before you lie, because it could be at someone else's

Read More
704 Words | 3 Pages

(Text.pg.116) Lies are morally wrong, for two reasons. First, lying corrupts the most important quality of being human: your ability to make free, rational choices is deprived of you the moment you tell a lie. Each lie you tell contradicts the part of you that gives you moral worth. Second, lies deprive others of their freedom to choose rationally. When your lie leads people to decide other than they would have had they known the truth, you have harmed their human dignity and autonomy.

Read More
747 Words | 3 Pages

4. South Sudan is an independent country from Sudan. Sudan was plagued with major civil wars, and those in the Southern region of Sudan were targeted and attacked. Southern Sudanese were killed off in large numbers; many villages were raided. Those who weren’t killed or sold off into slavery had to make mass migration to surrounding countries- the most being allowed in Kenya in refugee camps.

Read More
1959 Words | 8 Pages

The situation where this is best expressed it brought up by Kant in his case of the Inquiring Murderer. Here it is suggested that, even though you may be trying to protect a friend by lying to their assailant, you should still tell the murderer the truth. Why is this so challenging to our instincts? Perhaps it is because we feel

Read More

More about Is It Morally Permissible To Lie Essay

Open Document