ipl-logo

Is John Brown A Hero Or Villian?

682 Words3 Pages

Eli Antes Mr. Murray 7th Grade Social Studies. John Brown, Hero Or Villan When Brown was hanged in 1859 for his raid on Harpers Ferry, Virginia, many saw him as the harbinger of the future. John Brown was a good person with many flaws; he might have attempted to abolish slavery, but he committed many crimes. Some of these crimes include murder, the greatest crime he committed, treason, and plenty of other non-moral crimes. This article states that from a historical perspective, John Brown was a good person for many but think that he did a lot of unnecessary things like committing treason and murder. John Brown was a villain because the text states that John Brown entered houses and killed people he thought were bad, He was lying to the judge of his trial, and he committed treason and …show more content…

John Brown is a villain because he is willing to barge into some people's houses and kill them in cold blood. A letter from Mahala Doyle to John Brown states, “When you then and there entered my house and midnight and arrested my husband and 2 sons and shot them in cold blood.” (Mahala Doyle) This statement shows that John Brown was willing to let himself and other innocent people die just to stop slavery. Typically, if you are willing to walk into other people's houses, as Mahala Doyle states, you are not a good person. This shows that John Brown is most likely a villain. John Brown was willing to lie to the court to save his mission and his life after committing treason and murder. In his speech during the court, John Brown mentioned that he did not mean what he did. He also said that he did not mean to commit treason and attempt to steal the weapons from the US arsenal. Generally you might lie about not trying to commit the biggest crime in US history, but also attempting to hide the fact that he got other people to do it with him is not OK. Since he lied and stretched the truth, it shows that he is willing to lie in court about

Show More
Related
1104 Words | 5 Pages

He brutally kills many innocent people just because they are in his way. Although John Brown tries to end slavery, which is a good deed, he does use violence, and murder people who are innocent; therefore, John Brown is guilty of murder, treason, and insurrections. John Brown not only starts a very violent insurrection, almost like a war. He also brutally murders people who are just in his way. Insurrection means a violent uprising against authority.

Read More
525 Words | 3 Pages

In document F, John Brown says, “I have, it may please the Court, a few words to say. In the first place, I deny everything but what I have all along admitted.”. He also said in document G that his statements clashed and that he did not intend for there to be any killing, but just to place the slaves in a condition to defend their liberties. This example shows that John Brown was untrustworthy and went against his word by denying all of his actions and even admitting to his statements not matching up at all. He also said that he did not intend for there to be any killing.

Read More
334 Words | 2 Pages

John Brown Hero or Villain The story of John Brown happened many years ago, yet it still puzzles historians today. John Brown was an anti-slave abolitionist who was put to death after pleading guilty of murder, but is he considered a hero or a villain? John Brown is a villain for three simple reason, he murdered many different people, he attacked a federal arsenal, and he could be considered a terrorist. The first reason John Brown is a villain is because he murdered many different people.

Read More
714 Words | 3 Pages

This relates to the evidence because John Brown has already been sentenced and telling this information wouldn’t have been in John Brown’s favor. John Brown is making a death confession and telling the truth which shows he is trustworthy. John Brown is a hero because he has freed slaves, people believe he is a good person, and he is considered to be trustworthy by many people. As stated before, John Brown was an abolitionist whose goal was to abolish slavery in

Read More
659 Words | 3 Pages

(Document F) Since he lied about almost everything, that is another reason to believe he is a villain. Even though he was facing death, he could have told the truth and tried to tone it down, not lie about everything. He also ended up saying something that would be completely contradicted in a later letter to his friend. Finally, he tried to start a revolt/civil war. In document G and H, it proves that John Brown WAS trying to start a revolt, despite what he said in F. He said, in a letter to his friend, that he “wanted to put the slaves in a condition to defend liberties” (Document G), which translates to putting the slaves in a place where they can fight back, or in other words, he was supplying them with

Read More
495 Words | 2 Pages

John Brown Did you know that John Brown planned to use slaves in a revolt at Harper Ferry? John Brown was an abolitionist who wanted to put an end to slavery. But he came across many obstacles in the process of removing slavery. During this time slavery was a very serious topic and would create fights against people and states. John Brown was a villain in my opinion because he killed three men, lied in court, then told the truth once he knew he was sentenced to death, and freed slaves and gave them weapons just so he could start a revolt at Harpers Ferry.

Read More
626 Words | 3 Pages

Was he doing the right thing, or was he just a corrupt villain trying to get his way? John Brown was a villain because he killed innocent people, changed his intentions, and kept switching his stories. First off, John Brown killed innocent people. An example from the text is a letter from Mahala Doyle to John Brown. She was a married mother of two sons until Brown and

Read More
648 Words | 3 Pages

John Brown was a murderer who shot three innocent family members. “...entered my house at midnight and arrested my husband and two boys and took them out of the yard and in cold blood shot them dead in my hearing, you can’t say you did it to free our slaves, we had none and never expected to own one...” (Mahala Doyle Document E). John Brown mentions in his speech during his trial that his ultimate goal was to abolish slavery without violence. However, the murder of three men with no interest in slaves does not fit that plan.

Read More
863 Words | 4 Pages

John Brown was an abolitionist from the North who was raised to think that slavery was a sin. He was so devoted to God, that he broke many laws and killed a lot of white slave owners in order to achieve a "moral end." So in reality, he thought he was doing good and serving God's will, but he was actually costing lives and doing more bad than good. Over the course of his life, he had over twenty children with two wives and John Brown and his sons fought against slavery, which resulted in some sons dying. Brown moved his family a lot over many different states, and his home in Pennsylvania was a stop on the Underground Railroad.

Read More
784 Words | 4 Pages

(Brown Doc F). If you look at what he did before the speech he had made, you could tell he was lying. Many people argue that John Brown was a hero who saved the slaves. However, what this argument fails to consider is that John Brown had murdered many innocent people during his missions, committed treason, stole weapons, and damaged property that was not his. John Brown even admitted his actions, meaning it is true he lied by saying he did not mean to commit murder and treason.

Read More
824 Words | 4 Pages

In a letter written to Brown by Mahala Doyle, she states “[...] you then and there entered my house at midnight and arrested my husband and two boys and took them out of the yard and cold blood shot them dead in my hearing, you can’t say you did it to free our slaves, we had none and never expected to own one.” (Mahala Doyle Document E) Many would agree that harming innocent people is inexcusable and would classify you as a villain. In addition, Doyle expresses her opinion further by saying, “[...] I do feel gratified to hear that you were stopped in your fiendish career at Harper’s Ferry, with the loss of your two sons, you can now appreciate my distress[...]” (Mahala Doyle Document E) Near the end of his life, John Brown proved more untrustworthy than previously shown. After being captured in his raid of the arsenal at Harpers Ferry, Brown was found guilty and was to be hanged for treason.

Read More
804 Words | 4 Pages

Later in a letter to prosecutor Andrew Hunter, he states that he gave the slaves a chance to fight back though he never intended to free the slaves. Usually, if someone says something very serious like that they would dedicate their life to free slaves, they would most likely stick to their word and not contradict everything they’ve ever done in their life. “ I intended to convey this idea, that it was my object to place the slaves in a condition to defend their liberties, if they would, without any bloodshed, but not that I intended to run them out of the slave States” (Brown Document G). John Brown says that he gave the slaves the chance to fight for their lives while he didn’t actually intend to free them, while in his speech, he tells everyone that he did not want people to die and that he only wanted to “free” the slaves. It is often thought that John Brown was a hero because he had many supporters who supported his doings.

Read More
869 Words | 4 Pages

Lastly, we acknowledge the fact that he died to end slavery. John Brown raided Harpers Ferry, the home of the U.S. arsenal. His goal was to steal weapons from the arsenal to give to many slaves in hopes that they would revolt against their masters and other pro-slavery supporters. However, he and his followers were caught and later hanged for treason. With one speech at his trial and one letter sent after he was sentenced, John Brown didn’t try to escape or plead; he accepted his execution and died as a fierce martyr for all of the slaves and abolitionists (Documents F and G).

Read More
593 Words | 3 Pages

The story “A Long Walk To Water” is about the factors Salva Dut used to survive during his incredible journey. Salva was on of the lost boys who had to walk tirelessly across the desert because of and attack on his village. Salva stayed at a few refugee camps in his life until he eventually got the chance to got to America. Salva had many survival factors too get him through his journey.

Read More
527 Words | 3 Pages

Morality Writing Ever since modern science started becoming more popular and intriguing, subjects like morality, human values, and religion are starting to come into play more and more. Many people believe that certain factors come into play when evaluating what is right and what is wrong, and this essay is to prove exactly that. In the short story “The Storyteller”, the plot was about an aunt who expected three children to act perfect, even though they didn’t want to be. A man who was also on this train noticed this and decided to tell these children a story.

Read More

More about Is John Brown A Hero Or Villian?

Open Document