ipl-logo

Is Plato's Account Of The Forms True

1083 Words5 Pages

Is Plato’s account of the Forms true? Plato is well known as a brilliant philosopher whose intelligence has surpassed the understanding of many other philosophers. He developed detailed concepts to explain the many questions that the world presents to its people. I believe that Plato is right in his theories, but I also believe that he is wrong with the way he portrays objectivity as superior to subjectivity. One cannot, and should not exist without the other. In a world free of human emotion, objectivity can certainly be the rule of order for the world. However, this is certainly not possible, and therefore makes the argument for the importance of subjectivity a valid one. I agree with Plato’s statements that all the objects we perceive …show more content…

A table is a table. Because of my objective experience, I can tell you it is flat and hard. If I come upon a flat object that is the size of a table and soft, my objective experience would tell me it isn’t a table but is more likely a bed or a pillow. My experiences with a bed and a table are very real and there is very little to argue about when it comes to their functions in this world. There is subjectivity if I discuss the difference between the softness of different beds or pillows or the type of wood on a table, but a bed is flat and soft and a table is flat and hard. On the other hand, a living thing like a tree is constantly changing. To say that it is an objective image to incorporate into our minds does not make sense to me. Every day, a leaf will fall, be a slightly different color or a bug will chew on it, and this makes the tree different every day, never the same. From the completely objective perspective, the tree IS different. I do not believe that living things fit into the theory of the Forms. I agree that there are Forms which shape our concept of the world such as roundness and square-like and color and taste and odor. However, to categorize the world in this way without including subjectivity renders it …show more content…

I disagree with Plato when he states that the more objective a concept is, the more real the thing it represents. We show that we believe this by the way we uses objectivity to distinguish appearance and reality. Banach (2006) states a version of Plato’s principle: The more objective you get, the more real you get. The Forms are more objective than material objects according to Banach (2006). Therefore, the forms are more real than material objects. While this may be true in a world without human interaction, what meaning does it hold for a world with humans, guided by subjectivity? What good is a completely objective world, because in one there is no love, no pain, no sorrow? A completely objective world disallows the human experience and the very realness that brings to it. The ethical problems that we face are humans living a fulfilling life; a happy life in a depending, changing world where everything they attach themselves to can be taken

Show More
Related

Compare Plato's Theory Of Akrasia

613 Words | 3 Pages

Still, Plato’s full psychological theory is much more complicated than the basic division of persons would suggest. First, there are different kinds of appetitive attitudes (558d–559c, 571a–572b): some are necessary for human beings; some are unnecessary but regulable (“lawful”), and some are unnecessary and entirely uncontrollable (“lawless”). So there are in fact five kinds of pure psychological constitutions: aristocratically constituted persons (those ruled by their rational attitudes), timocratically constituted persons (those ruled by their spirited attitudes), oligarchically constituted persons (ruled by necessary appetitive attitudes), democratically constituted persons (ruled by unnecessary appetitive attitudes), and tyrannically constituted

Read More

Symbols In The Outsiders

693 Words | 3 Pages

In the novel the outsiders, S.E. Hinton does a great job bringing more readers to the young adult fiction genre. It was the reason she captured the reader that keeps it popular among middle schoolers everywhere. Her revealing acts is why it is a staple for schools and readers throughout the decades. S.E. Hinton does a great job showing revealing acts through the church fire. Johnny, Ponyboy, and Dallas all risk their lives to save people, that alone shows that those three are very courageous and caring, despite being greasers.

Read More

The Importance Of Objectivism In Ayn Rand's Anthem

1162 Words | 5 Pages

Judging the morals in life regarding different societies expectations quickly became the focus of Equality’s thoughts, exactly as Ayn Rand had made it the importance of her own efforts. Objectivism is different from what many people live by, but it worked for Equality by the end of Anthem. It is important to realize everybody needs different things, which leads to thinking diversely. Some need self-respect to be able to give respect, and others live their life following instead of leading. It is impossible however, to say objectivism needs to vanish when it never has before, more so, the world would be unbalanced with only equal thoughts from all; there would be no innovation if all thoughts were for the same narrow concept.

Read More

Frankenstein And Allegory Of The Cave Comparison Essay

988 Words | 4 Pages

Plato writes, “And suppose someone tells him that what he’s been seeing all this time has no substance, and that he’s now closer to reality and is seeing more accurately, because of the greater reality of the things in front of his eyes -- what do you imagine his

Read More

The Final Argument Of Plato's Phaedo

411 Words | 2 Pages

For example, given Plato’s logic a painting isn’t beautiful because of brush strokes and the meticulous placement of them, yet it is because the painting holds the essence of beauty and participates in the form of beauty. However, given difference of opinion not everyone will find the painting beautiful, and so how are innate forms classified and when? Another question being as to when the soul leaves the body. For example, if a heart is still beating while the brain is dead does the body still carry the essence of immortality and thus the soul? While we may never know, I still find Plato’s explanations vacuously platitudinous, hardly truly giving an explanation at all and instead to be grasping at straws to ease Socrates own fears of death before execution within the

Read More

What Is Bertrand Russell's Contribution To American Monism

1806 Words | 8 Pages

In his earlier years, Russell was greatly influenced by G.E.Moore 's Principia Ethica. Along with Moore, he then believed that moral facts were objective, but known only through intuition; that they were simple properties of objects, not equivalent to the natural objects to which they are often ascribed. Yet another of Russell’s major contributions is his defence of neutral monism, the view that the world consists of just one type of substance which is neither exclusively mental nor exclusively physical. Like idealism (the view that nothing exists but the mental) and physicalism (the view that nothing exists but the physical), neutral monism rejects dualism (the view that there exist distinct mental and physical substances). However, unlike both idealism and physicalism, neutral monism holds that this single existing substance may be viewed in some contexts as being mental and in others as being

Read More

Descartes Sixth Meditation Analysis

1919 Words | 8 Pages

Conclusion: The mind is substantively different from the body and indeed matter in general. Because in this conception the mind is substantively distinct from the body it becomes plausible for us to doubt the intuitive connection between mind and body. Indeed there are many aspects of the external world that do not appear to have minds and yet appear none the less real in spite of this for example mountains, sticks or lamps, given this we can begin to rationalize that perhaps minds can exist without bodies, and we only lack the capacity to perceive them.

Read More

William Blake Research Paper

592 Words | 3 Pages

Mental things are alone real: what: What is call’d corporeal, nobody knows of its dwelling place! It is in fallacy

Read More

Objective Truth In Plato's Allegory Of The Cave

817 Words | 4 Pages

South African Journal of Philosophy, vol. 28, no. 4, Nov. 2009, pp. 415-432. EBSCOhost, dcccd.idm.oclc.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=48656660&site=ehost-live. 3. Plato.

Read More

Searching For Truth In Plato's Allegory Of The Cave

836 Words | 4 Pages

Firstly, human beings should always search for the real truth because not everything that a society perceives as reality is real considering that some of it might only be the reflection of truth. In the allegory written by Plato, he described a group of cavemen who believed the shadows on the cave walls were the real image of objects instead of the objects themselves due to the fact that they have never seen any other objects besides the shadows in their entire life. The shadows

Read More

The Nature Of Reality In Plato's Allegory Of The Cave

728 Words | 3 Pages

Introduction Plato, a famous Greek philosopher wrote the Allegory of the Cave. He tried to answer some of the profound questions which arose about the nature of reality. He tells the story of 'Allegory of the Cave' as a conversation between his mentor, Socrates (Plato’s mentor), who inspired many of Plato's philosophical theories, and one of Socrates' students, Glaucon (Plato’s older brother). He uses an allegory as a short informative story, to illustrate 'forms' and the 'cave,' in his main work, The Republic (which first appeared around 380 BC). It is one of the most perceptive attempts to explain the nature of reality.

Read More

Three Classes And The Soul In Plato's The Republic

1442 Words | 6 Pages

Joseph Daunis Three Classes and the Soul In Book IV of Plato’s The Republic, Socrates draws a comparison between the classes evident in their fictional city to the human soul. Socrates clearly defines the three forms he finds in the city as being the appetites of mankind, or in other words, all human desires, such as pleasure, comforts, and physical satisfaction. The second form discussed by Socrates is the spirit or the component of the soul which deals with anger and perceptions of injustice. The third and final form is the mind or reason, which analyzes and rationally weighs options and solutions to problems. Socrates compares these three forms of the soul to the three classes in the city: producers, auxiliaries, and guardians.

Read More

Heraclitus: The Doctrine Of Flux And The Unity Of Opposites

1856 Words | 8 Pages

Heraclitus Heraclitus is a Greek philosopher of which not much is known beyond his works. What we do know is that he lived in Ephesus, a city on the Ionian coast of Asia Minor, and that his character has largely been inferred from his writings on philosophical issues. Two philosophical theories come to mind when the name Heraclitus is mentioned: The Doctrine of Flux and the Unity of Opposites. In his espousal of these theories he managed to draw the ire of many -- even Aristotle and Plato, who believed that his hypothesis of the world was one of logical incoherence.

Read More

Ethical Relativism Strengths And Weaknesses Essay

2607 Words | 11 Pages

The Strength and Vulnerability of Different Moral Views Over centuries of fervent discussion in the moral world, there is still nothing like a consensus on a set of moral views. This essay attempts to outline and critically evaluate two moral views, namely ethical objectivism and cultural relativism. It is crucial to understand that both moral theories cannot be true at the same time as it results in contradictions, contributing to false beliefs. Additionally, it is essential that we discuss these issues with an open-mind so as to gain deeper insights from them. First and foremost, we will be looking at the prominent view of ethical objectivism.

Read More

Similarities Between Plato And Socrates

984 Words | 4 Pages

“Plato’s philosophy is an attempt to justify Socrates’ belief in the objectivity of moral virtues.” As one of Socrates’ most loyal disciples, Plato’s own philosophy was heavily influenced by Socrates’ own thoughts and teachings. Much of Plato’s philosophy is a direct extension of some of the questions Socrates posed, i.e., Socrates asked what justice is, and Plato explored this question in his own writings. It is Socrates’ code of ethics, however, that most closely corresponds with Plato’s ethics.

Read More

More about Is Plato's Account Of The Forms True

Related Topics

Open Document