ipl-logo

Is Torture A Justified Means To Prevent Terrorism

1685 Words7 Pages

Rules of War: Torture a Justified Means to Prevent Terrorism?

Is torture a good means of preventing terrorism? No, I believe it is not a way to prevent terrorism as it is a very barbaric and ancient method of obtaining information about upcoming terror attacks. Some proof about that is the capture of Hassan Ghul, who was interrogated and apparently gave info on Osama Bin Laden’s courier, but they had a breakthrough leading to him even before the interrogation even began. I will show you why it is an ineffective method of gaining information and why it will be beneficial that the Obama Administration has banned this practice (From what I am Aware of from research.)
From the first article, it seems that these tactics have been used by the …show more content…

This info was released over 25 years ago, long after the events happened. In fact, A CIA Operative was given permission to interrogate KGB Officer Yuri Nosenko by using the KUBARK methods, which are methods such as sensory deprivation techniques and forced standing. During the 1980s, in Latin America, The CIA has provided interrogation training to what was almost certain were the Nicaraguan Contras, The group responsible for the overthrowing of a Communist Government in …show more content…

One of these officers was Hassan Ghul, who was captured in 2002 and interrogated to reveal one of Bin Laden’s courier. This courier was already being tracked and there was actually a breakthrough that would eventually lead to him long before the interrogation of Hassan. There have also been attacks such as the MV Limburg that could not be prevented from these brutal and disturbing methods of interrogation. There are also speculations that some of the people that strongly support torture, sees this as an act of revenge of past terror attacks. Even when the individuals were told that the chances of actually obtaining verifiable intelligence ranged were 5 to 65% and this shows that people feel a strong dislike of those that are regarded as morally corrupt or an evil to the

Show More
Related

Article Analysis: The Case For Torture By Michael Levin

185 Words | 1 Pages

In the article “The Case for Torture”, Michael Levin argues that the use of torture as a way to save lives is justifiable and necessary. Levin draws a series of cases where torture might be acceptable so as to set certain precedent for the justification of torture in more realistic cases. HoweverLevin illustrates three cases where torture might be justifiable.he describes a terrorist keeping city of millions hostage to an atomic bomb, the second, a terrorist who has implanted remote bombs on a plane and the third, a terrorist who has kidnapped a baby. torture and its consequences have been recorded in countries around of world over a vast span of time, and for a variety of reasons. Levin makes no such attempt to expand his article beyond

Read More

Michael Levin The Case For Torture Summary

686 Words | 3 Pages

The Case for Torture Wins Torture is it morally acceptable? Many have debated this argument but I would like to bring up two main conflicting view points from Michael Levin, and Marzieh Ghisai. Michael Levin is a Jewish law professor who wrote The Case for Torture where he advocates where torture is acceptable in some circumstances.

Read More

Curt Goering's Rhetorical Analysis Of Torture Is A Crime

295 Words | 2 Pages

After finding some torture tactics, it helped me research about the negative effects of torture. In his article, “Torture is a Crime”, Curt Goering listed the negative effects of torture. He argues that torture is illegal, ineffective, immoral and makes those around us unsafe. Curt uses ethos in his piece to back up his main argument. For example, he mentions that in 1984, the UN adopted the Convention against torture and it was ratified by the U.S. Senate in 1990.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Stanford Prison Experiment And Philip Zimbardo

751 Words | 4 Pages

Neither one of the circumstances was ethical at any point and had been publicized by the media for its explicit type of interrogation methods as well as sadistic behavior. In particular, Phil Zimbardo has argued that the study shows that strong situational forces can override individual differences in personality and moral values. In Abu Ghraib, soldiers were inserted into the role of prison guards and began to sadistically torment prisoners there and at other detention sites in Afghanistan and Iraq. Many of the specific acts of humiliation were similar to those that transpired in the Stanford Prison Experiment, according to Zimbardo. This theory has been challenged by allegations by Seymour Hersh, in the New Yorker, that these soldiers were in fact acting under direct orders of their superiors as part of a top secret Pentagon intelligence gathering program authorized by Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis: The Case For Torture By Michael Levin

971 Words | 4 Pages

The author believes that the thoughts of enlightened societies are unwise and ascertains that there are situations whereby torture becomes morally mandatory in dealing with terrorists.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Torture Myth '

1050 Words | 5 Pages

Applebaum has plenty of evidence to back up her claim that physical torture is not effective, and there are many other ways to obtain information. While the fear-encouraging and questioning elements are potent to many who are afraid of terror committed against them, but when the overwhelming sentiment of Levin’s argument is being compared to the logic and ethical points of Applebaum it is clear to see the superiority of her argument. Although Levin would advocate for physical torture in extreme situations, one must expect extreme consequences. Physical torture is rarely effective, violates rights, and damages a whole nation’s credibility. This is why physical torture should not be

Read More

Torture In Night By Elie

893 Words | 4 Pages

About two years ago, a C.I.A. torture report was released, the subject on detainees captured after September 11, who were suspected to be linked to the attack. One of the more famous detainees, Majid Khan, who had been afflicted with Al Qaeda, was captured in 2003 and was held at Guantanamo Bay since 2006. He says that the interrogators waterboarded him twice, was moved among series of C.I.A. operated “black sites” over some months, and the torture still continued. He was beaten repeatedly, hung from a wooden beam for three days, and shackled and starved. He was even submerged in an ice bath, the transparent ice burning his skin like fire, slowly numbing his body.

Read More

Torture Anne Applebaum Analysis

208 Words | 1 Pages

Anne Applebaum states “The really interesting question is not whether torture works but why so many people in our society want to believe it works.” Applebaum is against the use of torture as she questions its effectiveness. America has operated under the false pretense that torture is a viable option for obtaining information. She argues that torture damages the country’s image and does little to acquire useful intelligence. Torture is merely a way for officers to take their anger and frustration out on detainees.

Read More

Ethical Arguments Against Torture

1032 Words | 5 Pages

Some may argue the terrorist is responsible for putting himself in a situation where torture would be the only answer (Mayerfeld 2008). This argument undermines the terrorist’s perspective. Ultimately, the terrorists believe what they are doing is right and have concrete reasoning for their actions (Mayerfeld

Read More

Annotated Bibliography On Torture

962 Words | 4 Pages

Web. 08 Feb. 2016. In this report the author explain that many CIA agents believe that physical torture is not as effective as psychological torture. For example, leaving them naked in front of other people will

Read More

Terrorism: A Critique Of Excuses

1055 Words | 5 Pages

In the Ethical Life, by Russ Shafer-Landau, chapters written by Michael Walzer and Alan Dershowitz express their knowledge and opinions on the topics of terrorism and torture. Is it possible to justify and defend such acts? In the chapter “Terrorism: A Critique of Excuses”, author Michael Walzer shuts down four excuses that attempt to justify terrorism. In the chapter, “Should the Ticking Bomb Terrorist Be Tortured?”, Alan Dershowitz defends his theory that it is necessary to torture a terrorist if that means saving the lives of innocent people while protecting their civil liberties and human rights at the same time. Terrorism can never be moral because it violates all “excuses” and torture is an acceptable tactic to save lives.

Read More

Believe Me It's Torture Analysis

1082 Words | 5 Pages

Most of the time when someone is tortured it is because the interrogators are desperate for Important or valuable information. However, why would real “terrorist” give up valuable information that would expose their cause and what they believe in when they know they are going to die one way or the other. This just goes to show that the “suspected terrorist” are in fact suspected and aren’t real terrorist and shouldn’t be

Read More

Torture Is Ineffective Essay

1464 Words | 6 Pages

The use of torture has long been a method of getting information in different types of situations. Perhaps governments use torture for the purpose of attaining information of the oppositions forces or plans. Or, perhaps the young boy down the street is torturing another boy to do his homework. In any case, both of these types of torture are forms of interrogation, which is the act of questioning to get information. However, after further looking into torture, many questions arise.

Read More

Ethical Issues In Interrogation

999 Words | 4 Pages

There are ethical issues that need to be recognized in interrogation which are, the use of false evidence, the use of torture, and deceptive promises. Starting off an interrogation, police will usually comfort a suspect by giving evidence that is not true, with the intention to make the suspect end up voluntarily confessing. Giving false evidence has a number of planning’s. One with the officer telling the suspect that he or

Read More

How Does George Orwell Use Torture In 1984

501 Words | 3 Pages

This is similar to our CIA society today, For torture to happened it can not happen on U.S soil. It must happen some place else.

Read More

More about Is Torture A Justified Means To Prevent Terrorism

Related Topics

Open Document