ipl-logo

Japan Culture Vs American Culture

873 Words4 Pages

In the 1800s there were many cultural differences surrounding Japan and the United States that directly resulted in differences in the opening of trade. The two countries shared the focus on the future and growth and development, however their ideology and methodology towards growth greatly differed. The Japanese culture placed a strong emphasis and focus on harmony, known as Wa, amongst their people and their country. This ideology is clearly seen through the Tokugawa’s leadership and their decision to close the country off to immigration, integration, and trade. This opposes the American ideology that favors Manifest Destiny and the interaction of nations. While these countries greatly differ in their ideology they both work towards growth, …show more content…

Japanese societies put the harmony of a group and the harmony of the nation above one’s individual opinions and preferences. Therefore, Japan views outsiders as a threat to their harmony and collective nature. Under the Tokugawas rule it was decided that “Wa could best be maintained by closing Japan to the west” (8). This directly stunted industry development and reduced temptation. This preference shows how in Japan people favor community growth and people’s participation in community over industry development and innovation. Japan was extremely resistant to “opening” Japan up to American trade because Japan values their nations unity and Wa over opening their trade to foreigners. Japan strives to keep their nation pure and remain a homogenous society. By letting in external resources Japan believes they are compromising their integrity and purity by opening trade routes and allowing in outside resources. LeFeber writes, “All seemed to agree that under no circumstances could Japan open its empire to foreign traders; their goods would upset the nation’s internal order” (14). It is a collective belief that opening the Japanese empire to foreign traders they will upset the nation’s internal order and their Wa and ultimately jeopardize their future and …show more content…

The United States was built on development and innovation. Americans are constantly moving up and forward, ideally. The United States held a heavy focus on Manifest Destiny, the United States growing desire to conquer Asian Markets and a fear of deepening internal crisis, the eventual Civil War (10). The United States was focused on conquering the Asian Markets even if it means war or turmoil in the countries. They believed that they had the right and ability to spread their goods and further grow as a nation. LeFeber says, “Americans believed they had God given rights to spread both their new political institutions and successful commerce across the continent” (11). They believed that they have the right to blend their culture with others and benefit from other countries prosperity. The United States opened trade with many countries, mainly in Asia, to maximize their resources and grow as a country. Wa is not a value held in the United States. They believed that growth came from each individual and their own personal wealth and

Show More
Related

Dbq Essay On Japan

947 Words | 4 Pages

Japan’s economic development had been shaped in various ways, including Japanese internal forces, and external forces from other countries. Although during the Tokugawa era, the Japanese were very closed off from the world for 250 years, once Commodore Perry and the rest of America threatened Japan with war Japan was forced to open ports for trade. Due to the Japanese lack of weapons the trading environment was very biased on the side of America with unequal trade. The shogun was once a Samurai and is now almost in control of Japan.

Read More

Ap Us Expansionism Dbq Analysis

447 Words | 2 Pages

Toward the end of the nineteenth century and early twentieth century, the United States was becoming an increasingly powerful nation and world power. The country was competing with other nations also expanding. Their motives for expanding were to gain land and resources. While there was a slight departure from past expansionism, the United States mostly continued as it had been in the previous years. In order to accomplish expansionism, the United States needed to acquire foreign territories to increase their global presence.

Read More

Meiji Period Dbq Essay

327 Words | 2 Pages

There are many nations that are continuously changing. Japan is one of the nation that is continually changing not only economy, but also the culture. According to the book, “the Western world was increasingly impinging upon Japan..” which result isolation from Europe and American. In the document 19.1 it stated, “We have issued instructions on how to deal with foreign ships on numerous occasions up to the present”. This have shown that the Japanese have isolated from foreign.

Read More

What Role Did Ideas Of Race Play In The Theory Of Manifest Destiny

173 Words | 1 Pages

Economic development, not geographical expansion, was the key to American’s

Read More

Pearl Harbor Research Paper Outline

1132 Words | 5 Pages

After trade was cut off with Japan, it was thought that it would stop Japan’s expansion, and everything would return to normal. The opposite happened. The trade being cut off led Japan to hold their ground,

Read More

How Did Penelope Perry's Impact On Japanese Society

765 Words | 4 Pages

government, changing its seclusion policy to the open policy, and later signing another unequal treaty, Harris treaty, later in 1858. So, the Influx of the foreign powers to the Japanese port then became direct threats to the ‘not civilised’ Japanese society which entailed the changed attitude on their ethnic consciousness for the national sovereignty which had long been protected by seclusion policy and its self-sufficient economy, but which now needed to be protected. Hence, the threats allowed Japanese to execute the national reforms of not only the political reform of Meiji restoration vanishing the samurai society under the feudal regime and resurrecting the emperor system to build one strong united empire empowering all authority

Read More

Us Vs Japanese Economic Power Essay

907 Words | 4 Pages

During the economic power play, the Us played direct offense to the Japanese subtle defense. While the Us was interested in Japan as a source of coal to have better access to China a global economy the Japanese wanted to maintain their Tokugawa Government and self-independence while profiting from Western technologies. Japan’s foreign policies also affected their domestic affairs. In contrast, the US sought to assert its own economic power on the global scale. Both nations saw the power in new technologies in particular militaristic weaponry, valued modesty, and had a strong sense of pride and nationality.

Read More

How Did China Change Throughout The Nara Period

834 Words | 4 Pages

However, when centralized power emerged again, in the form of the Tokugawa Shogunate, Chinese influence did not immediately gain much strength. The Tokugawa Shogunate heavily restricted foreign influence, to prevent it from destabilizing Japan, using a policy of isolationism. Only small numbers of Chinese and Dutch merchants were allowed to trade at the port of Nagasaki, only continuing a weak Chinese influence. Although this current influence was weak, the lasting impacts of Chinese influence on previous periods greatly influenced Japan during the Tokugawa Shogunate. Confucian principles supported the Tokugawa Shogunate’s bakufu government and its social order, so the shogun promoted the

Read More

Silk Roads Dbq Essay

1043 Words | 5 Pages

This caused China to only let higher officials trade with the West and only specific products such as silk and porcelain were traded to the West. The Tokugawa government of Japan created a policy called the “Closed Country Edict”, “1. Japanese ships shall by no means be sent abroad. 2. No Japanese shall be sent abroad,” (Document 10).

Read More

How Did Imperialism Affect World War 1

1039 Words | 5 Pages

The United States had for years been improving and growing rapidly. Away from the other world powers in Europe, they were able to avoid their conflicts for a long time, but that changed. America got involved in World War One and it affected some of their advancements. U.S imperialism was able to thrive in WWI, with America using the power to expand their empire. American progressivism however, fell between the cracks and disappeared for a long while during and after the war.

Read More

How Did Japan Come Under Western Imperialism

1326 Words | 6 Pages

As the shogunate began to lose control of Japan in the middle-late 19th century, the period of time known as the Meiji restoration took place, leading to leadership being acquired by a younger generation who sought to, and successfully did modernize Japan. This modernization was not gained through violence or conflict, but by using, largely accepting, and drawing up on of the western ideology which had permeated areas such as China and the Ottoman empire. According to Strayer, one of the most prominent pushers of the Western ideology in Japan, Fukuzawa Yukichi, summarized the accepted need to familiarize and modernize with Western ways in an 1870s statement: “If we compare the knowledge of the Japanese and Westerners, in letters, in technique, in commerce, or in industry, from the largest to the smallest matter, there is not one thing in which we excel…. In Japan’s present condition there is nothing in which we may take pride in vis-a-vis the West.” This statement being made by a leader shows a willingness to acknowledge the advancements brought by the Western world’s expansion, and how Japan had lacked behind. This sets apart Japan from others who came under Western imperialism during this

Read More

American Imperialism In The 19th Century

718 Words | 3 Pages

Economically the U.S. had made advances in technology and began to get oversea territories. Culturally they had used the

Read More

What Were The Strengths And Weaknesses Of The Tokugawa Dynasty

790 Words | 4 Pages

“To guard against external influence, they also worked to close off Japanese society from Westernizing influences, particularly Christianity. When the Tokugawa shogunate grew increasingly weak by the mid-19th century, two powerful clans joined forces in early 1868 to seize power as part of an “imperial restoration” named for Emperor Meiji.” This restoration was the beginning of the end of feudalism, or the way of structuring society around relationships derived from the holding of land in exchange for service or labour, in Japan. The Tokugawa regime acted to exclude missionaries because of suspicion of foreign intervention and colonialism. Eventually, they issued a complete ban on Christianity in Japan.

Read More

Rice Japanese Culture

2365 Words | 10 Pages

Co-operation takes the focus away from individuals and creates a community that depends on the harmony of society, and removes the emphasis on individualism (Henry, 2013) which has directly influenced the culture of Japan we see today, hard workers that focus on the group rather than individual prowess. Although the factor of rice this essay has discussed may seem minimal, its importance has been a major factor in moulding Japanese society to what is seen today and although this has meant a suppression of individualism, to try and alter the “system” in order to increase Japanese individualism is futile ,as this would mean that Japanese society, tradition and religious beliefs would need to be altered drastically and this would entail “ stepping outside the square” which in Japan is such a faux pas that it seems a futile exercise. Farming in Japan bought rice, which in turn became the symbol of a bond between the Japanese people and Kami which enhanced the Shinto religious traditions that have enriched the Japanese collective culture. If taken in this context we can see that rice has become Japans spiritual connection with the spiritual world, nature and society (Demetriou,

Read More

Confucianism In Japan

914 Words | 4 Pages

As we have learnt in class, it was the common characteristic of all societies before the 18th century that decisions about the priority of wants and the allocation of resources necessary to satisfy them were “dictated by central authority and reinforced by custom.” The law of tradition kept decision making “outside of the scope of individual action” (Rima, 2001). According to an economist Donald W. Katzner, it was mostly the religious dogmas of Buddhism and Confucianism that determined the central values of the society in Japan. The fulfillment of obligations as well as the “furtherance of group harmony” rather than the pursuit of self-interest always determined the Japanese workers’ behavior. As it is explained by the Japanese academic of

Read More

More about Japan Culture Vs American Culture

Related Topics

Open Document