ipl-logo

Jury System DBQ Essay

515 Words3 Pages

The jury system originated in England hundreds of years ago. The colonists brought the jury system from England to the United States. In 1733, John Zenger, a printer, printed a newspaper critical for the British Government. His attorney convinced the jury to be in favor for Zenger because his criticisms were true. After this trial, it gave ordinary citizens the freedom of speech and the power to go against the king. The Founding Fathers wanted the people of the United States to be in a democracy or self-government and established the jury system into the constitution. It is expensive and is a long process to start a jury trial. Also, jurors are not as professional as judges and can not determine a fair verdict. The Crime Scene Investigation (CSI) effect might also affect the verdict of the jury. The American jury system should not be used because of it not being cost-effective, the lack of experience of the jury, which leads to justice not being served, and the CSI effect impacting the …show more content…

Jurors should not know anything about a specific case and not follow public affairs and read the news (Doc F). When a person is selected to be part of a jury, they have to say an oath stating that they will not use their emotions to determine the verdict of a trial. If a juror is caught using their emotions, they will be fined for a crime called perjury. Since there are twelve people in a jury, there is a variation of opinions when the jury decides a verdict. But, a judge is more professional and knows how to only use the evidence provided and be less biased. A judge must meet many requirements before he/she is able to judge in court. A judge must have a law degree, a Juris Doctorate, and a numerous amount of other tests and jobs before he/she becomes a judge. Comparing the requirements of a juror and judge, a judge is more qualified to make a fair

Show More
Related

Jury Duty Research Paper

203 Words | 1 Pages

Compared to other countries, America is a land of freedom and endless rights. For example one of the rights are freedom of speech, why not express that feeling of power? It 's understandable that people do not want to serve on a jury, because of time not well spent in their opinions. As a

Read More

Explain Why The Jury System For Australia Is Not A Fair System

557 Words | 3 Pages

1.Intro The jury system for Australia is not a fair system. There are many fault with the structure of how it is decided and how is picked. The jury should be 100% fair and not biased in any way, if this is not the case a criminal or civil offences could be charged for the wrong thing. Some reasons why the jury system is not a fair system is because Ordinary people may not understand complex legal technicalities, some people are exempt from serving, the jury is not a true cross-section of society and also It is difficult for people to remain completely impartial, especially if they are influenced by the media coverage of the trial.

Read More

Jury System Dbq

842 Words | 4 Pages

Another reason citizens question juries is that they have bias from personal experience or the media. The defendant and the prosecution criticize the jury system because the actual jurors may not understand the situation from any point of view because they come from different lifestyles (Doc E). The American jury system is not a good idea anymore because juries are not experts in law, they have bias, and are not “a jury of peers”. Because jurors are not experts in law, they are subject to be

Read More

Twelve Angry Men By Reginald Rose: The American Justice System

470 Words | 2 Pages

In Twelve Angry Men, Reginald Rose portrays the American justice system to be fair. He gives examples that jurors could do. “The life of another is at stake, if there is a reasonable doubt in your minds as to the guilt of the accused–then you must declare him not guilty” (Rose 9). This is a fair system because the judge handed the case over to the jurors to let them look over the case instead of just saying that he is guilty. This lets the defendant get another chance to be proven not guilty.

Read More

Civic Duty In 12 Angry Men

578 Words | 3 Pages

In the film, “Twelve Angry Men” they show the role of the jury in finding the verdict for the court trial. In the US Constitution under the sixth amendment, this helps establish the procedures and right in criminal prosecutions and also gives some protections to the criminal. It is important to have an impartial jury and to be well informed on the cases. In the film the jury is tasked with finding the verdict of a young teen charged with the murder of his father. They have heard and seen the evidence involved and now they must come up with a verdict.

Read More

Should Citizens Be Required To Serve On A Juror Essay

647 Words | 3 Pages

This was determined from way back when America was first being created. Originally the U.S was control by the British but one of the main reasons for our independences from them other than the fact that the U.S. did not like their high taxes but also was because the jurors and their rights. According to the video “Annenberg Classroom: Juries” when a judge did not like the juries verdicts they were fine and threatened to have their nose cut off. American wanted their judicial to be fair and equal for all. However, they are wrong in the fact that all citizens should need to serve on the jury because people will misuse this power and will not truly understand their effect on the case and more importantly the people live on trail.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The American Jury System

1024 Words | 5 Pages

I believe that the jury system in the United States of America should be eliminated because it harder to get people that are un-basis, people don’t pay attention in court, and a bench judge is the best option for the people. The american jury system is not as good as it once was in the early years. People then didn’t have the problems with the media turning people's minds. This is because back then it took months for one piece of news to get to the people in that state and the case would be over by then.

Read More

America's Jury System

736 Words | 3 Pages

THE EFFECTIVENESS OF AMERICA'S JURY SYSTEM Eighteen out of one-hundred people are summoned for jury duty each year. Each jury member a normal person whose decisions are influenced by the world’s culture and affected by their busy schedules. Therefore, Americas jury systems are no longer effective in the twenty-first century, as a result of outside opinions, beliefs, and events taking place in our world. First, jury members in today's society don't have time to recall for jury duty. In fact, jury duty is often dreaded or avoided among Americans.

Read More

Impartial Jury System Analysis

959 Words | 4 Pages

The US Constitution gives American the right to a criminal trial by jury, and the Bill of Rights gives us the right to impartial jury in the Fifth, Sixth, and Seventh Amendments. To truly be impartial jury and avoid biased decisions. The jury of twelve ordinary citizens swarms to solely

Read More

Essay On Jury Nullification

635 Words | 3 Pages

The history of jury nullification goes all the way back to the 1670s. In Bushell’s case, the jury’s power to nullify law became an important part of the Common legal system. Although the defendants of the case were found guilty and charged with substantial evidence, the jury members acquitted and refused to convict the defendants. Thereafter, the judge ordered the jury to change their verdict, and without any agreement from the jurors, the judge found them

Read More

Trial By Jury Differences

399 Words | 2 Pages

Trial by Jury Everyone has the right to a trial by jury is a practice that the United States adapted from England common law. The United States Constitution guarantees the right to trial by jury for most criminal and many civil offenses.

Read More

Jury Should Be Abolished Essay

894 Words | 4 Pages

In the article of Connect US “… prosecutors and defendants to have limited removal power over the formation of the jury so that it can seem fair to both sides in the case. ”(Chief, Editor) This makes it where both parties have some leeway to either stay with the chosen jury or replace someone if they feel that it will be biased for one side. Also having a trial by jury highly eliminates bias because of the twelve people, which makes it harder if a jury to make everyone vote guilty or not guilty. It’s important to know someone’s background and what condition they are in before being given an important task such as jury duty since they are contributing to either putting someone behind the bar or releasing them back to society, in the article Connect US, “…Judges and lawyers have the opportunity to question each one to see if they can be fair and impartial.”

Read More

Disadvantages Of Trial In Australia

1382 Words | 6 Pages

• An emotional jury can actually be good when the defendant wants to have them to feel emotion for the crime. As mentioned above, jurors are directed not to get emotionally involved, but while deliberating, no matter what they are told, they still use their emotions. Better for cases where the defendant has major public support or simphaty. • Jurors have more space for interpretation and what one thinks is beyond a reasonable doubt another may not see it the same way and this can lead to a long time for a jury to come back with a verdict. • There have been a number of high-profile judge-only trials recently, including that of Simon Gittany, who was found guilty of murdering his fiancée, cases like this have prompted legal experts to consider the value of judge-only trials and examine the limitations of trial by jury.

Read More

Trial By Jury Advantages And Disadvantages

1472 Words | 6 Pages

They have to decide important matters, verdicts, without giving reasons about their decision (Hostettler, 2004); they can nullify a verdict even if the evidence is overwhelming (Joyce, 2013). Furthermore, juries are too expensive, prolong the length of the trial (Davies, 2015) and the guilty can walk free, while the innocent is convicted (Joyce, 2013). In addition, jurors should be representative of society, but it is not

Read More

Essay On Jury System

1594 Words | 7 Pages

Jury systems exist all around the world. Many have a long history, while others are just emerging. Juries of different countries examine trials and decide on many factors in a court case. They play a vital role in court and are the deciding factor about whether a victim is guilty or not. The role of a jury may be different depending on the country.

Read More

More about Jury System DBQ Essay

Related Topics

Open Document