ipl-logo

Comparing The Economic Views Of Adam Smith And Karl Marx On Slavery

1933 Words8 Pages

SMITH, MILL AND MARX ON SLAVERY

ABSTRACT: Economic ideas of Adam Smith, J S Mill, and Karl Marx on Slavery are discussed. Adam Smith’s views on slavery and the causes to persistence and possible solution of persistence of slavery had been discussed in details. Followed by JS Mill’s perspective of Savagery, Slavery and Civilization, they are analyzed in isolation along with the benefits of slavery. Also, the Marxian perspective of Slavery is discussed with modern and ancient slavery and its transition. Lastly, a comparison of the ideas is done to sum up the essay.

Adam Smith, J.S. Mill and Karl Marx present compelling arguments against slavery. This paper aims to elaborate on the various economic ideas on slavery that these thinkers have …show more content…

Marx, through his observation of the New World and Europe, likens slavery to machinery or capital without which a bourgeois industry not only cannot sustain but wouldn’t have found its existence. “Without Slavery you have no cotton; without cotton you have no modern industry. It is slavery that has given the colonies their value; it is the colonies that have created world trade and it is world trade that is the pre-condition of large scale industry. Thus slavery is an economic category of the greatest importance”. (Marx) The system of slavery like any other exploitative system is a dynamic system that transform from increasing production to stagnation followed by decline and over …show more content…

He identified that for indirect slavery to exist in Europe, in the industries, it was essential for direct, pure slavery to exist in the New World. As seen in the cotton industry, capitalism in agriculture follows development of industry because agriculture profit depends on industrial profit. The influence of capitalism is seen in industry much before it is seen in agriculture. And it is only after capitalism strengthens its hold over industry that the agriculture is forced to transform. It is the “stormy growth” of industry in England that transformed slavery in the United States into a form of commercial exploitation. This transition from pre-capitalist slavery to capitalist slavery comes about when the system devoted to earning subsistence evolves to a system that aims to generate surplus-value. In this process, the working condition is worsened. This becomes the seed for violent crises. Wage labour emerges from the breakdown of the system of slavery and serfdom however if slavery does survive as an anomaly, the slave owners become the capitalist, slaves the proletariats and the product becomes commodity.
According to Karl Marx within capitalism, slave and wage labors have a distinctive characteristic. While a slave has an exchange value, a wage-worker has no exchange value. A slave in

Show More
Related
266 Words | 2 Pages

Slaves’ value was both as labour force in the profitable cotton industry but also as tradable property and the loss of slavery would mean a massive

Read More
1599 Words | 7 Pages

American society before the Revolution was in many ways dependent on slavery. This institution would seem to contrast sharply with the aura of enlightenment and “unalienable rights” that surrounds our nation’s founding. However, slavery had an economic role that is impossible to ignore. The story of Venture Smith’s life, a man who was born free, then enslaved, and finally earned his freedom, reveals the financial opportunities behind slavery’s that encouraged white members of society to prolong its existence despite the rallying cries of freedom and independence that were the basis of the American Revolution. Venture, originally named Broteer, was the eldest child born to Saungm Furro, a “Prince of the Tribe of Dukandarra” in Guinea (para.

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

From the time of the American Revolution in 1776, to the year 1852, there has been many causes to the opposition to slavery. Some have shown the support for increased opposition while others have shown to not support this opposition. This has caused many disputes about who is in the right. There is plenty of evidence between the two groups which were either supporting the opposition to slavery or they were not supporting the opposition. Three causes exist in support of and against this opposition: Social Darwinism, increased tolerance, and the need to unite the nation.

Read More
748 Words | 3 Pages

During the slave trade it was inhumane and violence, million of African people and children were taken away from their home to work in the new world. The slave trade took away many productive workers from Africa which they are skilled in farming and other establishment. The captain of the ship would try to enlarge their profit by trying to fit as many slaves as possible in the new world. Sometime slaves are captured and placed into dungeon with other captives. People would protests to be released but the two kings was corrupted and demanding

Read More
570 Words | 3 Pages

Between the 1820s and 1860s, a time period that was greatly influenced by the Industrial Revolution, people were willing to work hard so that they could provide for their families. Slaves were still being used to help develop the United States of America by harvest crops such as cotton, and please their “masters.” were forced to work and help develop the country. Both slavery and industry helped the country grow financially. Slaves had to work harder to meet higher cotton demands. The introduction of the cotton gin also aided in the aided in the rapid production of cotton (PIIP 9).

Read More
1777 Words | 8 Pages

In this paper, I discuss how Karl Marx, Adam Smith, and Andrew Carnegie agreed and disagreed about the concepts of capitalism with different standpoints. For example, Karl Marx mainly focused on the function of communism; Adam Smith emphasized the free trade in market, and Andrew Carnegie adopted the form of capitalism. I further explain the different perspectives of capitalism that impacted on society, and social and economic situation. The word, capitalism, is defined as an economic and political system in which a country’s trading business and industrial activities are made by private ownerships or corporations through the means of production, distribution, and social wealth. In 19th century, as the development of Industrial Revolution

Read More
1396 Words | 6 Pages

William’s main argument in this book is that the rise of industrial capitalism in Europe would not have been possible without the profits derived from African slave labor. Williams does an exceptional job of demonstrating how slavery transformed England into an economic superpower. This book illustrates the economic aspects of the slave trade as it addresses who benefited from it, how it contributed to the formation of capitalism. When referencing the book by Eric Williams, “Capitalism and Slavery” the origin of Negro slavery is something in history that is disputed and misconstrued. According to William’s book slavery was caused by numerous economic

Read More
648 Words | 3 Pages

The Civil War not only abolished slavery, but also threw the significant challenge of rebuilding a war-torn nation. Although initiated with the best hopes and intentions, the ‘Reconstruction’ of the USA had collapsed miserably for it had failed to establish a nation with equal rights for all. As a consequence, class discrimination and racial injustice had engulfed the American society. Besides having similarities and differences, the struggles for racial justice in the late 19th century and the struggles for economic justice in the Gilded Age are not only reminders of the failed ideology of the reconstruction, but are also evidence which shows us that the upper class of the society in that era were reluctant about the upward mobility of the poor.

Read More
766 Words | 4 Pages

No matter your stance at the time, one thing became clear: socially, politically and economically, slavery was the fabric of American success and gave birth to the Old South as we know it today. At the center of the entire institution of slavery, and central to its defense, was the economic domination it provided a young country in international markets. In the early 19th century, cotton was a popular commodity and overtook sugar as the main crop produced by slave labor. The production of cotton became the nation’s top priority; America supplied ¾ of the cotton supply to the entire world.

Read More
722 Words | 3 Pages

Without money, people become hopeless, which eventually leads to desperation. Where there is desperation is desperate people willing to do whatever it takes to survive. In the book, Inside the Business of Modern Slavery, there is a lot of startling information about this industry. Siddharth Kara, the author of this book, focuses a lot on the statistics and the logistical aspects of this disgusting

Read More
1093 Words | 5 Pages

The economic views of Adam Smith and Karl Marx Microeconomics Eduardo De Oliveira Superti   Table of Contents: Abstract 3 Introduction 4 The economic views of Adam Smith 5 The economic views of Karl Marx 6 Adam Smith vs. Karl Marx 7 Examples in the world of today 9 Conclusion 10 Recommendations 11 Bibliography 12 Introduction Adam Smith and Karl Marx were completely contrasting economists throughout their time and had an enormous effect on the world and the way we view economics. They represent the ideas of capitalism and socialism.

Read More
2053 Words | 9 Pages

The beginning of the 17th Century marked the practice of slavery which continued till next 250 years by the colonies and states in America. Slaves, mostly from Africa, worked in the production of tobacco and cotton crops. Later , they were employed or ‘enslaved’ by the whites as for the job of care takers of their houses. The practice of slavery also led the beginning of racism among the people of America. The blacks were restricted for all the basic and legally privileged rights.

Read More
390 Words | 2 Pages

In the beginning of the 19th century, the Industrial Revolution caused a massive economic spike from small-scale production to large factories and mass production. Capitalism became the prevalent mode of the economy, which put all means of production in the hands of the bourgeoisie, or the upper class. Karl Marx and Frederick Engels argue that capitalism centralizes all the wealth and power in the bourgeoisie, despite the proletariat, or the working class, being the overwhelming majority of the population. The manufacturers would exploit the common proletariat and force them to would work in abysmal conditions and receive low wages, furthering the working class poverty. “The Communist Manifesto” predicts that as a result of the mistreatment

Read More
847 Words | 4 Pages

Marx and Engels look at capitalism with seriously negative opinions. They regard the system as extremely unsuitable, and are deeply concerned with getting rid of it. In a capitalist society, capitalists own and control the main resources of production - machinery, factories, mines, capital, etc. The modern working classes, or proletariats, own only their labor. Proletariats work for the capitalists, who own the product that was produced and then sell it for a profit.

Read More
1074 Words | 5 Pages

Marx’s theory on exploitation is related to his earlier writings on the theory of alienation. They are both similar in that they are both highly critical of the capitalist system. Grint,(2005) emphasises that before Karl Marx nobody had ever confronted the idea of exploitive wage labour, many great thinkers of Marx’s time like Locke and Ricardo thought that the value of the wage labour was exactly equivalent to the labour expended while producing a product. Watson,T.J (2008) states that “ capitalist employment is exploitive in attempting to take from working people the value which they create through their labour and which is properly their own. ”P.62.

Read More

More about Comparing The Economic Views Of Adam Smith And Karl Marx On Slavery

Related Topics

Open Document