ipl-logo

Katherine Anne Porter's The Jilting Of Granny Weatherall

976 Words4 Pages

“The Jilting of Granny Weatherall” recounts the tragic experiences that Granny Weatherall experienced throughout her life and faced once again towards the end. The theme revolves around the term “jilting,” which is defined as an act of abandonment with no warning. People had jilted her twice, with each being a complete surprise. Aside from these two serious instances, she also faced other terrible life experiences as well. Katherine Anne Porter’s composition includes numerous literary elements, such as symbols and irony, but most notably a theme. This short story explains the results of abandonment and loss with their effects while delving into the different themes of the story. The first time Ellen, otherwise known as Granny Weatherall, was …show more content…

Right before she passed, Porter tells how Granny was surprised by her demise because of the lack of signals before it occurred. Porter states, “For the second time there was no sign…Again, there is nothing more cruel than this” (Porter). From this statement alone, one can gather that she is feeling a sense of abandonment once again, but this time by God. Porter’s tone in the last paragraph also adds to this emotional and deceiving scene. This section of the writing is somber and exemplifies the bitter feeling Ellen is suffering from. Not only from this part, but from others as well, the reader can sense the sympathy that Porter is relaying to them. An example is when her daughter and doctor treat her like she is a child, acting as though she cannot hear them whispering about her. Granny’s feelings were described with sorrow, giving the impression that she felt looked down …show more content…

After the first jilting incident, she had the mindset that she could potentially know when she was going to die and somewhat have control over it. She fought every time there was an obstacle to overcome, such as diseases and the other disasters she came across. Both instances correlate to the symbolic nature of her name. Porter purposefully created the character Granny with the last name Weatherall for a reason. When the name Weatherall is bisected into its base words, the two terms “weather” and “all” are obtained. The meaning of the word “weather” is to endure or withstand something, which concludes that she could survive and battle against the problems during her lifetime. Aside from her fate, all of Granny’s other trials were overcome and strengthened her. Although she “weathered” every difficulty, her fate was the last barrier she could not overcome. Her death could not be determined by her insane drive to conquer; instead, God determined when it was her time to

Show More
Related
1938 Words | 8 Pages

Her oldest daughter, Elsie, was a “touched” child who suffered from some degree of mental retardation and epilepsy (23). Despite the conditions, Henrietta loved her daughter unconditionally. Therefore, while they lived in Clover she provided Elsie with the around the clock care and supervision she required. As Elsie grew older she “never talked” and didn’t develop like other children (44). Henrietta tried to be able to continue to care for Elsie, even going as far as taking her to “revival meetings so preachers in tents could lay hands on Elsie to heal her” (44).

Read More
618 Words | 3 Pages

She also loses majority of her neighbors. I think the storms symbolize advancement because the protagonists matured and grown a lot after the storm, Janie being satisfied and Hushpuppy being

Read More
422 Words | 2 Pages

In “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall,” Porter uses multiple allusions to three of Emily Dickinson’s poems to show the change from total, unwavering Christian faith, to the absence of Jesus as Granny dies. In the story, Porter describes Granny stepping into a cart, whose driver Granny knew by his hands, and whose face she did not have to see, because she “knew without seeing” (Porter). This scene is almost identical to the scene in Dickinson’s “Because I could not stop for death-.” This allusion aids in conveying the Christian idea of death as Granny has come to accept it: a tranquil figure, Death, calmly and peacefully carries one’s soul to an eternity where centuries feel like days.

Read More
707 Words | 3 Pages

“Beyond, obscuring fields and landmarks, the lower of dust clouds made the farmyard seem an isolated acre, poised aloft above a sombre void,” “Thistles and tumbleweeds - it’s a desert,” and “It was the face of a woman that had aged without maturing, that had loved the little vanities of life, and lose them wistfully” show both the situation that they are in and the effects of being in such a situation. The surrounding land around is a desert, a place filled with nothing but the terrain of the land. With that in mind, Ellen only has her child and Paul to converse with. The only person who she is able to have a conversation with her is neglecting

Read More
444 Words | 2 Pages

Ellen moves families a lot, from her biological family, to a foster family, to her art teacher, to her grandma. Ellen Foster is a brave young girl that has overcome many things. There are some important themes in this book. For example, adversity through all the terrible things that's going on.

Read More
660 Words | 3 Pages

Janie’s grandmother, Nanny, forces Janie to marry a man she is not in love with out of convenience. Nanny does not want Janie to suffer the necessities of life, but Janie cares little about materials and seeks love. Nanny’s ideology haunts Janie for much of her life, influencing decisions she takes later in marriage. Huston says, “The memory of Nanny was still powerful and strong,” which shows how Janie conforms to the ideology her grandmother instilled in her. And although Janie conforms, she continues to question inwardly about love.

Read More
1254 Words | 6 Pages

Nanny who has been Janie’s caretaker has several hopes and dreams for her granddaughter. Nanny is not entirely perfect at her job of raising Janie, since her dreams for her are clouded by her own scarring experiences. Nanny attempts to insure a better life for Janie by forcing her to marry Logan Killicks, an old and wealthy man. Blinded by her own dreams, hopes, and desires, Nanny makes many impositions on Janie, “Have some sympathy fuh me. Put me down easy, Janie, Ah’m a cracked plate” (Hurston 20).

Read More
1548 Words | 7 Pages

Ellen knows that she is not going to live with her abusive father forever, she believes that she will find a loving family that will take her in and a place to call home. When Ellen goes to Church she notices a foster mother with many children. “I went to church and figured that the woman with all the girls lined up by her had to be the new mama for me and then I looked up and thanked the lord for sending me that dress. I said I look like I am worth something today and she will notice the dress first and then me inside it and say to herself I sure would like to have a girl like her”.

Read More
933 Words | 4 Pages

She is a selfish old woman, she is stuck in her backwards ways and criticizes Bailey and his wife’s parenting. She is blatantly racist and classist and lies throughout the whole story. O’Connor disagrees though, so much so that she wrote a letter saying how she did not appreciate readers and critics believing the grandmother was evil, and that the grandmother was in the story as a representation of grace. Which is noticeable in the story, she offered the misfit chance after chance to change his mind about murdering her and she clearly loved her family and worried about her son. The grandmother was an interesting character to analyze because she seems like such a selfish person

Read More
1620 Words | 7 Pages

After arguing with her granddaughter, the granny continues on with her normal chores as she “bring[s] in the laundry” attempting to hide her problems. This shows that she is stuck in a constant cycle of temporary cleansing briefly washing away her problems however, what she does not realize is that eventually her problems, like the laundry, will get dirty again, and she can continue to rinse them away but by doing so she is entrapping herself in this cycle; she needs to allow the dirtiness in order be able to face and deal her problems. However, just as the granddaughters “suitcases [are] never unpacked (2)” because she does not feel welcomed, the granny also does not feel like she can unpack her own “suitcases” but for different reasons. The granny believes her problems can hide away forever, but carrying around this old baggage shows she is only further entangling herself in the past and away from her granddaughter. The granny regularly visits her daughters grave with “seed[s] in her pocket,” which reveals that she has not yet moved on since the death of her daughter because she is still trying to keep her as close as she can, as if she feels some sort of guilt.

Read More
670 Words | 3 Pages

However, she dies with “her legs crossed under her like a child’s and her face smiling” as she has redeemed herself of her selfishness and lack of integrity (O’Connor 430). O’Connor’s use of situational irony in the shocking ending shows the Grandmother’s reclaim of childlike innocence and joy through her fatal brush with

Read More
339 Words | 2 Pages

After watching “The color purple” and “Akeelah and the Bee” if someone asked me what is my favorite occasion that happened in the 20th century and had the most progressive affect on the united state of American, my answer could be the civil right of the movement. I have understood and seen the black people faced many hardships when it came to their daily living before the civil right movement. In the “ The Color Purple “ movie Celie and her sister Nattie were not allowed to go to school, where on the second movie, Akeelah stand out by representing African American children’s via joining the competition for spelling Bee. It displays clearly from relating both movies, which the civil rights movement has changed to modern American. Damaging stereotype

Read More
140 Words | 1 Pages

Ellen, however, faces emotional isolation leading her belief that the farm is the crux of their problems. Ellen presents difficulties living on the farm , within the confinements of their home, distanced from others. Due to the hazards of the dust storm Ellen’s life is confined to “two rooms to live in”, with her contact outside the farm limited to “once a month [in] town” (6). The predicament she faces goes beyond physical isolation as Ellen shows that living on the farm under harsh conditions has a profound mental effect. Her frequent disagreements with Paul emphasize the isolation between them.

Read More
602 Words | 3 Pages

Having endured men’s “patronizing treatment of her” and their “inadequacies as providers,” it makes sense that Ellen would have likely “deviated from the conventional norm that views women’s identity as formed and expressed in relation to husband and children” (Hoefel). In need of a confidant, it makes sense that she would turn instead to a relationship in which she was not expected to sacrifice her sense of self, resulting in her more mutually-benefitting companionship with Hapsy. This perspective dramatically changes the meaning of the story, making it no longer a “tragic story… of a woman’s jilting by one man” or coming to terms with a false sense of religious security (Hoefel). It focuses, rather, on the positive impact of a symbiotic friendship on a woman’s life in contrast with the self-effacing roles that she originally thought were the key to

Read More
1016 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout the piece, the unnamed grandmother is shown to be an annoying and deceitful person. The Grandmother 's "selfish focus" has made the people around her miserable particularly her son (Brown 2). Bailey 's relationship with his mom is rocky but it is never shown just how long it had been deteriorating. In later paragraphs, the grandmother is revealed to be

Read More

More about Katherine Anne Porter's The Jilting Of Granny Weatherall

Related Topics

Open Document