ipl-logo

Like Water For Chocolate Book Analysis

1431 Words6 Pages

In both Like Water for Chocolate by Laura Esquirel and Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck, the role of motherhood is emphasized. Everybody has a version of what they picture a mother to be, but some qualities, such as being nurturing and protective, can be agreed upon. In these two books the main roles of motherhood, protector and emotional supporter, are both explored.
One of the roles of motherhood is to be a protector to the children, especially when a father isn’t in the picture. Mama Elena, in Like Water for Chocolate, assumes masculine power after her husband dies. She dismisses the usual roles of the mother, cooking and feeding, and adopts the role of control while eliminating men from her life. She even ignores the priest’s fears that she would be alone and vulnerable at the ranch with the absence of men, after her husband dies. She even goes as far to say that “it’s worse to have chiles without water” than to be without a man and that she’s “never needed one”. Mama Elena likes …show more content…

The difference between the two mothers is how they assume these roles. Throughout Like Water for Chocolate, Mama Elena uses violence as her form of control. This isn’t surprising, though, as in the book most people, such as the soldiers in the Mexican revolution, tended to turn to violence when they couldn’t come to an agreement. This mindset is what makes Mama Elena the mother that she is to her children. In Grapes of Wrath it seems that the women look on silently, trying to read their husband’s expression while the man considers the loss. Ma Joad isn’t the type to sit back when the family is in trouble. Her great compassion for everyone in her family greatly contrasts Mama Elena’s. Her main concern throughout the novel is her concern for her family’s happiness, and she controls it, as best she can, through tough

Show More
Related
875 Words | 4 Pages

Laura Esquivel in the book “Like Water For Chocolate” uses many strategies throughout the book like imagery ,and exaggeration. Both imagery and exaggeration helped develop the tone and the mood ,and set the purpose the passages that were given to us by Esquivel. Esquivel is trying to convey to the readers that you don’t need to be just plain like other writers to have a good story to tell, as she demonstrates in her way of writing and strategies. The use of words that Esquivel uses gives us a better understanding of the strategies being used by the author, and what she is trying to say by using those words. There are many other strategies that Esquivel uses, but exaggeration and imagery have a huge role in the book, and not only in the passage where she describes Nacha, but in others where the food is involved.

Read More
698 Words | 3 Pages

The definition of motherhood is “the state of being a mother.” Throughout the novel, The Bean Trees, written by Barbara Kingsolver, Taylor Greer learns the simple things about motherhood when a toddler, Turtle, is thrown in her car. Learning to raise the child brings up many tough decisions and obstacles, letting Tayor experience what love really is. Readers get to see everything Taylor does, reading through her eyes and getting to watch her mature into a young, independent individual. In the book, the storyline revolves around Taylor Greer’s growth, as she explores motherhood through love, maturity, and sacrifice.

Read More
876 Words | 4 Pages

Her mother is mean and severely strict. Tita, being the youngest child, is pulled into the family tradition of the youngest daughter looking after her mother until death. Even though Mama Elena, Tita’s mother, is terrible mother, the message of what it means to be a mother is shown in the book. In Like Water for Chocolate the author uses Tita, a shotgun, and the kitchen as symbols to show that being a mother doesn’t have to do with having gave birth to a child, but is defined by traits shown by a person.

Read More
949 Words | 4 Pages

Being Unique Before Fitting In During the 1950s, a majority of women were expected to live up to certain standards. Each member of the family was expected to act a certain way and fit into the mold of society. Woman in the 1950s typically did not look at a man on the side of the street to see what is inside a bucket, let alone even stop to ask what is in the bucket. But the mother in “Bucket of Blood” written by Katherine Waugh displays a different approach to life and her family. She displays how every family is unique and it is okay to be the one that stands out.

Read More
752 Words | 4 Pages

The job of a mother automatically comes with sacrifice. The mindset of a mother shifts to where her paramount priority is her family. In The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck, Ma Joad sacrifices herself and her emotions in order to keep the hopes of the family to be fulfilled. Although the world and her seem to be crumbling down, Ma Joad is still able to keep the family together. Through her emotional and physical sacrifices, Ma Joad proves that her family is what she treasures most.

Read More
550 Words | 3 Pages

She will never do what is best for herself, but what is best for everyone else. Ma Joad is also a Group Oriented Hero. Group Oriented Heroes tend to be a part of a group in the beginning, venture into a far and unknown land, and is then separated

Read More
1130 Words | 5 Pages

She controls all of the interactions of the family; everyone is dependent on her. When Walter starts skipping

Read More
639 Words | 3 Pages

As demonstrated through the water imagery, both Sethe and Denver have developed their own definitions and roles as “mothers.” This contrast may serve to be a point of tension as the meaning and extent of “motherhood” continues to be defined throughout the

Read More
961 Words | 4 Pages

(Steinbeck 144) Ma Joad displays the similarity between her and Virgin Mary through her strength and selflessness. At the time the Joads were crossing into California, she keeps quiet about Grandmas death and rides along with her dead body the whole night. This actions suggests that Ma thinks of the family as an unit that must always stick together, her sense of honesty since she tells Grandma directly that she can’t be helped, and her own appreciation of beauty, especially seen in her remarks about burying

Read More
1238 Words | 5 Pages

Morrison’s authorship elucidates the conditions of motherhood showing how black women’s existence is warped by severing conditions of slavery. In this novel, it becomes apparent how in a patriarchal society a woman can feel guilty when choosing interests, career and self-development before motherhood. The sacrifice that has to be made by a mother is evident and natural, but equality in a relationship means shared responsibility and with that, the sacrifices are less on both part. Although motherhood can be a wonderful experience many women fear it in view of the tamming of the other and the obligation that eventually lies on the mother. Training alludes to how the female is situated in the home and how the nurturing of the child and additional local errands has now turned into her circle and obligation.

Read More
775 Words | 4 Pages

The author of A Thousand Splendid Suns demonstrates the significance of motherly love through Nana, Laila, and Mariam. The novel gives the reader a better insight of how passionate a mother’s love for her children can be, and how far she may go for the love of her

Read More
761 Words | 4 Pages

Based throughout the story, Ma continued to watch over the emigrants, especially her son Tom, because he had went to prison for a murder crime and she does not want him to break his parole. Even though there had been some negative outcomes from their journey, Ma stood up for everyone when they were in miscommunication with the bank, salesman, and everyone else who was not in favor of the Joad’s arrival in California. When Steinbeck first introduced Ma at the beginning of the story, she did not act as a role model to the family, because Pa and the other men were in charge of the entire expedition. Ma was able to experience the exploration of happiness within every moment of dejection. She began her role

Read More
1598 Words | 7 Pages

Such is shown through, feminism, gender role reversals and cultural symbols. Mama Elena displays traits of gender role reversals. Throughout the novel, Mama Elena is seen as a tyrannical figure, hindering her daughters’ lives and causing an inconvenience to those around her. However, no one seems to take into account the backstory that hangs over Mama Elena like a giant thundercloud. In the beginning of the novel, she loses her husband.

Read More
641 Words | 3 Pages

Parenting is hard. Being a mother can be a natural instinct for some, but how do mothers protect and care for their children throughout their years? In the nonfiction text "Think Mothering Young Kids is Hard? Get Ready for Even Tougher Times" the author describes what mothering is like for the different ages of their children and provides surveys of how moms feel during their parenting years. "The Raincoat" similarly has a theme about mothers.

Read More
936 Words | 4 Pages

It's common knowledge that a mother is a woman that gives birth to a child. This has always been so. The role of a mother, however, has not always been the same. A mother’s life and responsibilities can alter through the times. Since The Help takes place in 1960’s Jackson, Mississippi, the mothers either stay home and do a little housework or they go to gatherings with other women from town.

Read More

More about Like Water For Chocolate Book Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document