ipl-logo

Lions Led By Donkeys Analysis

1907 Words8 Pages

A popular opinion amongst historians today is that the generals of World War One were incompetent and were just “a bunch of upper-class delinquents” (Blackadder Goes Forth, 1989). “Lions led by donkeys” was a common phrase which is directed towards the British infantry and the generals, stating that brave soldiers were being led by incompetent generals. Widely known British Sitcom Blackadder Goes Forth’s depiction of World War 1 strongly captures the idea of “Lions led by Donkeys”. There are mixed opinions on the TV show about the historical accuracy and whether it is gives a misleading perspective to the audience. Is the phrase “Lions led by donkeys” a fair judgement? Does Blackadder accurately showcase World War One? The British infantry …show more content…

More British generals were slaughtered than in the entire Second World War during the Battle of Loos. Statistics show that the casualty rates of ordinary soldiers were around 12% while the generals were 17% between the years of 1914-18. This cannot happen if the idea of the “generals hardly being in the front lines” were true. AJP Taylor’s verdict “Lions led by Donkeys” is a popular opinion amongst many historians, such as Alan Clark and Leon Wolff. In Alan Clark’s “The Donkeys” published in 1963. He states that most generals were ‘grossly incompetent for the tasks which they had to discharge and that Haig, in particular, was an unhappy combination of ambition, obstinacy and megalomania’ (Walker, n.d.) Leon Wolff states that World War 1 was ‘a caricature of war…It was unfairly and brutally conducted up to the highest level’ (Walker, n.d.) in his book “In Flanders Field” published in 1958. There are several historians who oppose this phrase, such as Gary Sheffield and Peter …show more content…

By 1918, they had a large and operative fighting force which lead to the defeat of Germany. In my opinion, the “Lions led by donkeys” phrase is not completely true. It may be true that the generals failed to lead the infantry safely but they shouldn’t be blamed for it completely. The Great War was unexpected and the generals could not have fully prepared for a war that long and of such a high calibre. The generals were blamed for the high casualty rates during WW1. However, historians don’t take into account that there are many factors contributing to the mistakes the generals had made such as the rapid increase in soldiers they had to control, where prior to the war the British infantry were known to be small but well experienced. More soldiers meant supplying more food, accommodation, medical supplies and clothes. People may say the generals are meant to be prepared for any type of war; although this may be true, WW1 was the world's biggest war at that point and no one else could’ve had more experience to lead the

Show More
Related
280 Words | 2 Pages

General Gates had underestimated his troops ability to fight until it was too late to back out. The start of the battle involved

Read More
1326 Words | 6 Pages

The Battle of Bunker Hill is perceived strategically through the words of Colonel William Prescott, "Don’t fire until you see the whites of their eyes.” A notorious contention during the American Revolutionary War encompassed not only decisive action military strategy and theory, but one of the purest understandings of mission command at its foundation. A single affirmation to his men, revolutionizing the art of command and science of control, formulated a tactical philosophy that is studied to this day by military scholars. Colonel William Prescott assumed command of the Patriots during the Battle of Bunker Hill, absent of orders and facing unwavering odds, achieving victory through the implementation of the modernly understood mission command

Read More
1439 Words | 6 Pages

When looking back onto the great history of American leaders and generals, many names notably stand out. These American heroes helped to shape the future of our country, from the efforts of General Dwight D. Eisenhower in the Second World War, to General Douglas Macarthur of the Korean War, to even George Washington in the Revolutionary War. Regardless, each of these brave leaders allowed for their respective forces to attain victory, yet in this caveat, the legacy of many brilliant and skillful generals is lost. Victory does not determine skill, and such a notion has never attested to a military leader as much as it applies to General Robert E. Lee, of the Confederate Forces in the American Civil War. Lee’s proficiency in battle tactics and

Read More
669 Words | 3 Pages

The authors of the book quote former President William Howard Taft by him saying that the war was “a cataclysm” and “a retrograde step in Christian civilization,” and “a disaster to mankind”. These profound words were found more prominently than you think, from different politicians and leaders in America. As the thought of war began to creep closer and closer into

Read More
220 Words | 1 Pages

After an exceptional fifteen minute war at the Plains Of Abraham.. Britain came home winning the battle and beating the French, they have surely made Britain proud. Sadly lot’s of brave British men died during the war, who dedicated their lives for Britain. Britain’s outstanding men are ready for battle. _______________________________

Read More
506 Words | 3 Pages

Suprised, General Ward ordered his men to march up the hill and attack. Tired and thirsty the Red Coats were ordered to march up to meet the Patriot troops. But wearing heavy uniforms and carrying large equipment didn’t make it any easier marching up a steep hill. Finally the British made it to the Patriot troops who were more than ready for them when they arrived. Right as the British charged General Howe called out to the soldiers “Don’t fire until you see the whites of their eyes”.

Read More
645 Words | 3 Pages

World War One was a war unlike any other before or after; as time went on, countries from all around the world were dragged into European affairs, which led to powers exhausting resources to the fullest extent. Total War required all members of society to contribute and take on jobs of much significance that had lasting effects on culture. Throughout World War One both soldiers and civilians endured similar sufferings; however, the roles of each were significantly different from one another and they were affected by the war in various ways.

Read More
347 Words | 2 Pages

Yi Yang 802 Social Studies Leading up to the battles of World War One, or most commonly known as the ‘Great War’, or ‘The War to End all Wars’, geography and tactics played a major role towards the outcome of battles of World War One, and ultimately, the victory of World War One. Geography contributed to the war by providing an advantage to one side of the battlefield, geographically to ensure safety of soldiers, and waring technology. Combined that with tactics of the generals fighting in the war, only the smartest generals that truly strategize with their playing fields can bring their soldiers to victory. Geography-wise, World War One was most heavily centred around Central Europe, from both the Eastern

Read More
1089 Words | 5 Pages

In the story “All Quiet on the Western Front,” WW1 is narrated by a German soldier, Paul. The war is explained as having mainly negative effects on the soldiers: “...men who, even though they may have escaped its shells, were destroyed by the war.” (1) In the beginning of the novel, Paul and his friends dreams about what their life would be like if there was peace. Their view on the war’s brutality is not deep, but many feel it has ruined any chance at a normal life.

Read More
1064 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout the ages, wars have wreaked havoc and caused great destruction that lead to the loss of millions of lives. However, wars also have an immensely destructive effect on the individual soldier. In the novel All Quiet on the Western Front written by Erich Maria Remarque, one is able to see exactly to what extent soldiers suffered during World War 1 as well as the effect that war had on them. In this essay I will explain the effect that war has on young soldiers by referring to the loss of innocence of young soldiers, the disillusionment of the soldiers and the debasement of soldiers to animalistic men. Many soldiers entered World War 1 as innocent young boys, but as they experienced the full effect of the war they consequently lost their innocence.

Read More
1198 Words | 5 Pages

The term "Founding Father" is given to the men who fought for American liberation from Britain in the 18th century and proceeded to build an independent country from the ground up. Certain names are almost synonymous with the term founding father – George Washington, Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin for example. However, one man who embodied the American Dream before the term was even coined and had an enormous role in shaping America is Alexander Hamilton. Undoubtedly a lesser known figure to the general public, Hamilton is probably best known to most Americans for being on the 10-dollar bill. Hamilton was born in 1757 on the island of Nevis in the West Indies before he arrived in the colonies as an orphaned teenager, hoping to get a

Read More
245 Words | 1 Pages

In the Great War, many soldiers were losing their lives in the field. The alliance that were in the war, were ultimately fighting for the desire of power. Countries like Germany and Austria-Hungary that were a part of the war wanted to be in control of as much as they could. This caused a lot of tension with the Triple Entente, which was an alliance between France, Great Britain, and Russia. With all them waiting to be the best of the best, Austria-Hungary and Germany had to up their military and have their people ready to fight any war.

Read More
930 Words | 4 Pages

Remarque ties this specific theme of World War I to deliver the problem of bringing soldiers with no experience in the world, representing an entire country and consequently dying in the Front because they were not mature enough to fully comprehend their surroundings to light. Bringing young people away from their lives and to war takes away any chance they have at a normal life, sooner or later putting them in an exceptionally weak mental

Read More
914 Words | 4 Pages

The Unpreventable Great War World War I was one of the most devastating and destructive events that occurred during history. It was inevitable to happen due to three main factors including, militarism, nationalism, and alliances between certain countries. However, there are other people who believe that World War I was not inevitable and could have been prevented through certain measures. This source describes that World War I could have been prevented if there were more stable and successful negotiations between countries. However, due to the lack of peaceful negotiations between certain countries, many conflicts arose because of desires to expand military and navels.

Read More
1047 Words | 5 Pages

In times of war, soldiers must surpass obstacles and be ready to face challenges. Witnessing the valiant efforts of these men that throw their lives on the line instills an insurmountable sense of pride in the hearts of spectators. Both Lord Alfred Tennyson’s poem and Richard Caton Woodville Jr.’s illustration entitled “The Charge of the Light Brigade” incorporate literary terms to express their feeling of pride towards the Light Brigade. Tennyson exhibits this by using repetition to signify the danger of fighting in battle, in addition to imagery to help the reader imagine how terrifying war is, while setting a respectful tone. Woodville shows a feeling of pride through the setting, symbolism, and powerful imagery.

Read More

More about Lions Led By Donkeys Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document