ipl-logo

Lord Of The Flies Vs I Am Alive

525 Words3 Pages

The book Lord of The Flies and the documentary “I Am Alive” explore the topic of survival and moral rights. Lord of The Flies is more of a people vs self, while “I Am Alive” focus on people vs nature. Although they bear some superficial similarities, the differences between Lord of The Flies and “I Am Alive” are evident. To determine who was better in a situation of survival I will compare and contrast the book Lord of The Flies and the documentary “I Am Alive”.
The similarities of Lord of The Flies and “I Am Alive” are that they both crash into remote places. Also, they both pick the person most suitable to be a leader, like Ralph from Lord of The Flies, and Nando from “I Am Alive”. Furthermore, they both assign roles for people like Jack …show more content…

In Lord of The Flies, a group of schoolboy crash lands on an island that has warm weather and a food source. On the contrary in “I Am Alive,” a group of adults crashes lands on the Andes Mountains where the weather there is cold and had very limited food supplies. Unlike in Lord of The Flies, the boy did had a very good food supplied and did not had to resort to eating the dead to stay alive like in “I Am Alive”. Although, in Lord of The Flies the boys are fighting between savagery and civilization, meanwhile, the people in “I Am Alive” are fighting the cold and starvation. In Lord of The Flies the boy automatically picks the leader that looks the most like a leader which is Ralph, and in “I Am Alive” the people from the plane chooses the one that shows the most intelligence who is Nando. Conversely, the boys from the island became savage by killing the living flesh, unlike the people from the mountains that did not become savage from eating human flesh. Also that the Lord of The Flies is a fiction novel and an allegory, while the “I Am Alive” is a documentary of a true story.
Convincingly, I think the “I Am Alive” people has the better survival skill than the boys in the Lord of The Flies. In the “I Am Alive” documentary it tells the story of a group of people having no experience of the cold weather, having to eat their own dead friend's body in order to survive and having only their faith to keep them from pushing

Show More
Related

How Does Jack Change In Lord Of The Flies

1218 Words | 5 Pages

The novel, Lord of the Flies, by William Golding was inspired by his time as a veteran in World War II. His goal was to portray the change in people’s morality that he witnessed because of the war. He reflected this situation-based change into his characters. The most evident of which was Jack, who, initially described as a proper, cultured choirboy, slowly transitioned into savagery. He conveyed Golding’s idea that civilization’s conditioning of right and wrong merely masks humans’ more primitive and barbaric nature.

Read More

Lord Of The Flies Quotes

755 Words | 4 Pages

In the novel, Lord of the flies written by William Golding, a group of boys get stranded on an island. The group of boys has to overcome obstacles that the island brings them. The boys elected their chief, Ralph during the first assembly that Ralph called. Then the boys split apart making Jack's tribe which focuses mainly on hunting, while Ralph's tribe's priorities are making shelter. The boys become civilized to savage when they create rules for each other when the hunters brutally slaughter a pig, and when they kill Simon.

Read More

Lord Of The Flies Peer Pressure Analysis

1215 Words | 5 Pages

The Peer Pressure Factor of Lord of the Flies William Golding’s Lord of the Flies paints two stark and opposing images of reality. On the one hand, the novel suggests that certain characters have venerable attitudes, making them seem like the protagonists, like Simon or Piggy. This can be seen from the motivating forces behind Simon’s decisions, or by the civilized behavior portrayed by Piggy. On the other hand, the novel also suggests that a deep built-in mechanism exists in every human being, one that prioritizes survival over morality. Just by observation, the novel demonstrates Jack’s exercise of hunting instincts, his combat of the social recourse from Ralph, his influence on everyone else to join him, and his eventual takeover of the

Read More

Hunger Games And Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

1040 Words | 5 Pages

Often in literature, comparing stories will lead to revelations about human nature. Lord of the Flies and The Hunger Games both share a motif of being trapped and take human nature to another level. Lord of the Flies and The Hunger Games prove that working together and looking out for each other will give you a greater shot at victory. One very significant similarity is that in both books the characters are trapped on an island and fighting for their safety and survival. In Lord of the Flies, school boys, Ralph, Roger, Simeon, Piggy, Jack and along with other kids are trapped on an island and have to fight for survival, but, after a while of being on the island the civilization starts to die and so do the boys from violence and lack of communication.

Read More

Analogies In Lord Of The Flies

2042 Words | 9 Pages

Lord of the Flies dates back to 1954 when a famous novelist, William Golding decided to write a book which could show an unusual version of the human beings. Born into an environment where his mother was a suffragette and later experiencing World War II where human ruthlessness was at its peak, made him better inclined in to writing a piece where he could explain his readers how human beings react in different situations. The setting of the novel depicts a situation where the human behavior is rational. The novel hence persuades the readers to realize the importance of ethics and civilization and how their absence can disrupt the society .Furthermore, the novel shows a negative aspect of the mankind and explains the reason it develops savagery

Read More

Civilization Vs Savagery In Lord Of The Flies Essay

870 Words | 4 Pages

Lord of the Flies, by William Golding, is a novel that revolves around the concept of civilization versus savagery. The boys argue about points that eventually split the boys amongst themselves. These disputes come up multiple times over the course of the novel. One of which being the fight over the leader of the boys. Some believed the leader should be Jack while others believed it should be Ralph.

Read More

Lord Of The Flies And The Most Dangerous Game Analysis

812 Words | 4 Pages

When comparing stories the reader may point out revelations about human nature. The two awesome stories, Lord of the Flies and The Most Dangerous Gameshow a motif of being trapped, and they show that being nice can be taken for granted. Lord of the Flies and The Most Dangerous Gameprove that people can behave like animals when it comes to survival. There are several different simalarities for the two trapped stories Lord of the Flies and Most Dangerous Game; however, the most significant would be the setting of the stories. For example when Golding was explaining what the island looked like.

Read More

Figurative Language In Lord Of The Flies

624 Words | 3 Pages

In the novel Lord of the Flies by William Golding, there is a scene in the book where a little boy named Simon talks with the sow head, or “The Lord of the Flies”. In my opinion, this is one of the most important scene in the book. The Lord of the Flies has become a physical manifestation of the Beast as well as a symbol for the power of evil and darkness that lies within each human being. It is within this scene that the embodiment of reason collides with the embodiment of evil. In the movie, directed by Peter Brooks, there are many differences in that scene.

Read More

Lord Of The Flies And The Giver Comparison

1674 Words | 7 Pages

The setting is a fundamental comparison for both of these stories. For example, in the “Lord of the Flies" Ralph quotes: “ This is an island, perhaps there aren 't any grown ups anymore." Ralph is alone in an island away from society, without no help or advice of an adult because of war with other boys, so the temptation of fighting over total power is

Read More

Lord Of The Flies Thesis Analysis

767 Words | 4 Pages

Thesis Statement: In Lord of the Flies William Golding throughout the book is trying to show you that society should recognize man is evil. Introduction Paragraph: In the book Lord of the Flies the author William Golding shows a group of boys losing their innocence throughout their life stuck on this inhabited island in the pacific ocean. These boys go from being quiet and shy to violent and dangerous young little boys. Golding uses the pigs, hunting, and the boys face painting to show their lose of innocence throughout the story. There 's no rules of any sort on this island these boys landed on they are free to do whatever they want whenever they want.

Read More

Dictatorship In Lord Of The Flies Essay

681 Words | 3 Pages

In the novel Lord of the Flies by William Golding, Ralph and Jack compete to have the title of chief, this illustrates Golding's message that in society dictatorship can be more successful than democracy. Characters in this novel resemble people in WWII. Jack is a symbol of dictatorship and Ralph is a symbol of democracy. Though in the beginning of the novel Ralph had control, Jacks dictatorship caused him to take total control. Between the two boys Jack is the more successful leader.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Wars With Native Americans

511 Words | 3 Pages

wars with Native Americans. During 1860, Americans kept on migrating throughout the Great Plains to get more land and discover gold, silver, and other minerals. There was a land called the Black Hills that was considered sacred by many Native Americans. In 1875 the U.S. government opened up the land to allow gold mining. The Native Americans who inhabited that land refused to leave, so the U.S. military decided to relocate them using force.

Read More

Human Nature In Lord Of The Flies And Kite Runner

1443 Words | 6 Pages

Both books consist of a lot of sacrifices and many religious parallels. The sacrifices in both books were symbolic of religious sacrifices, and regretted by the boys in both books. The main religious symbol and sacrifice in Lord of the Flies was Simon. Unlike the other kids, Simon seems to be inherently good. Simon is like Jesus, kind, good, and also sacrificed for a greater cause.

Read More

Lord Of The Flies Vs Movie Alive

116 Words | 1 Pages

Throughout life we are all faced with situations that may be hard to deal with, but for most of us, trying to survive in harsh conditions is not one of them. In the novel The Lord of the Flies and in the movie Alive!, trying to survive in harsh conditions was a similar problem that characters from both stories had to face in order to survive. The two settings, characters, and themes of these two stories have many similarities and many differences that cause these characters to react differently towards each other and towards the situations they are put in. What the characters do and how they react to one another throughout their story proved this.

Read More

Lord Of The Flies Movie Vs Book Analysis

746 Words | 3 Pages

In Lord of the Flies there were a lot of similarities and differences from the book to the movie. In the beginning of the book the boy’s plane crashed into a body of water and the pilot dies but, in the movie the pilot is alive but is severely injured. In both the movie and the book Piggy finds the conch and has Ralph blow it, due to his asthma. When on the island in both the book and the movie Jack was mean to Piggy and whipped some of the little un's.

Read More

More about Lord Of The Flies Vs I Am Alive

Related Topics

Open Document