ipl-logo

Luke Should Be Allowed To Return To School Essay

764 Words4 Pages

Luke should be allowed to return to NFA. New NFA transfer student by the name Luke is generally unproblematic. Although, one day he shows up to school wearing a tee shirt with the phrase “WHITE IS RIGHT! WHITE IS MIGHT!” And another day, comes to school with a Swastika tattooed onto the back of his neck. His actions lead to Luke getting into a fight with two other students, and ultimately, a ten day suspension. The Board of Education will decide whether or not Luke is allowed to return to NFA at all. This brings up the question of should Luke not be allowed to return, or is this a violation of his right of free speech and freedom of expression. Luke’s actions violate policies in The NFA Student Handbook, and his actions also will clearly make …show more content…

A public school should be an environment where anyone in attendance should feel safe and comfortable. In source 1, The NFA Zero Tolerance policy states “The goal in establishing NFA’s Zero Tolerance policy is to provide a safe and orderly campus for all of our students, faculty, and staff.” Source 1 later states that students will receive a 10-day out-of-school- suspension, and possibly result in expulsion for any of the following reasons: Possession of weapon(s), possession of drugs/alcohol, extortion, hate crimes, and assault. Luke’s shirt and tattoo is clearly showing prejudice against minorities and jews, and should be seen as a hate crime. The shirt also goes against NFA’s dress code which can be seen in source 1. The fight that Luke got into with the two other students is assault, which means Luke violated two of the bullet points on the Zero Tolerance policy, which I believe makes his expulsion …show more content…

Showing up to school with horribly offensive writing and imagery is not okay for a public environment. It makes other students feel uncomfortable, distracted, and unsafe. In source 3, Dylan Klebold, and Eric Harris conducted a mass shooting in Columbine High School while also using racist and anti semitic remarks and imagery prior and during the shooting. This gives a valid reason for concern and fear to those at NFA who witnessed Luke’s actions. In source 3, Tammy Theus, a mother of a victim in the shooting, sees Swastikas carved into the school and claims “It’s like they are laughing in our faces.” Source 3 also shows the Columbine High School principal stating that slurs and harassment in this manner is grounds for suspension. People are clearly affected by these harmful words and symbols, and they should not be allowed to be used in a public school. In source 4, this idea is only further emphasized. Students at Greenwich High School managed to figure out a way to spell out the N-word into the yearbook. At the end of source 4 it shows the reactions of fellow students feeling shame, embarrassment, anger, and sadness from the use of these types of words. I think that this justifies the reactions that NFA students and faculty are having to Luke’s

Show More
Related

Tinker Vs Moines Case Study

303 Words | 2 Pages

The suspension would last until they returned to school without the armband. Three students were suspended until they returned to

Read More

A Case Of Tinker V. Des Moines Independent Community School District

617 Words | 3 Pages

Because the wearing of the black armbands did not interfere or disrupt the school day of the students, the majority ruled that the students should not have been suspended. By punishing these students, the Des Moines Independent Community School District violated the first amendment and fourteen amendment rights of these

Read More

Tinker Vs Moines Case Brief

712 Words | 3 Pages

Fraser because both involve students’ First Amendment Rights. However, in Bethel School District v. Fraser, the Supreme Court ruled that Fraser’s school suspension was appropriate and nondiscriminatory because while the First Amendment guarantees free speech, Fraser imprudently and vulgarly spoke at a school assembly (Walsh, 2018). The Supreme Court determined, the role of schools is to teach socially appropriate behavior and speech. It is within the school’s sole discretion whether and how to punish such speech (Decker, 2014). This decision contradicted the political speech, which the Court had protected in Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District in 1969.

Read More

How Does Margaret Peterson Haddix Create A Sense Of Suspense

1271 Words | 6 Pages

"It's not reform school or anything." The word stuck in Luke's brain. Reform. Reform. Yes, they were going to reform him.

Read More

Tinker V. Des Moines Case Brief

427 Words | 2 Pages

“The first amendment explains the rights of the students and teachers.” (The principles didn’t want the students wearing them to school because it could become disruptive. The principal said that "the students were asked to take them off and if they didn’t then they

Read More

Speech On College Campuses: Lukianoff And Haidt

1230 Words | 5 Pages

They provide examples from the University of California administrators, who in 2014 gave them a list of seemingly common phrases that must be avoided to prevent offending students. The authors point out that the political correctness movement of the 1980’s and 90’s is similar but different from what we are currently experiencing; the current movement is driven by emotional well-being rather than protecting marginalized groups. Believing to have the freedom to not be offended is not a new concept, for example, people fought for the right to be offensive all the way back in the Victorian era. Starting in the 80’s, far left students on college campuses decided that women and minorities had the right to not be offended. The authors uses the term “vindictive protectiveness” to describe the brutal response by the current movement towards people who question whether or not the movement actually keeps students safe.

Read More

Example Of Ethos Pathos Logos

672 Words | 3 Pages

Another demonstration of how logos show different perspectives is shown in the following quote, "It is also relevant that the school authorities did not purport to prohibit the wearing of all symbols of political or controversial significance. The record shows that students in some of the schools wore buttons relating to national political campaigns, and some even wore the Iron Cross, traditionally a symbol of Nazism." These quotes present the conservative bias of the school authorities, and how these biases are being used to discriminate against opposing ideas. Violating the students right of free speech. The logos in these quotes allow the audience to see the hypocrisy amongst school officials, as they disregard the rights of

Read More

Analysis Of The 2007 Supreme Court Case Of Morse V. Frederick

919 Words | 4 Pages

Joseph Frederick held a banner saying “Bong Hits 4 Jesus” at Juneau-Douglas High School during an Olympic Torch Relay on January 24, 2004. The principal of the school Deborah Morse asked Joseph to put the banner away but he refused to do so. Morse took the banner from him and for not putting it away Morse gave Joseph a ten day suspension from school. The principal thought that the banner was encouraging the use of illegal drugs. Joseph took the situation into his own hands and went to court for it saying that his First Amendment, Freedom of Speech was violated.

Read More

Irony In Avi's 'Nothing But The Truth'

2174 Words | 9 Pages

First up is his suspension. His suspension was not fair whatsoever. Students don’t listen to teachers all the time, and they don’t get suspended. He wasn’t even creating a scene. Students only got distracted when Miss Narwin started to pick on him.

Read More

Racist Speech As The Functional Equivalent Of Fighting Words

707 Words | 3 Pages

The First Amendment aims to protect the right of freedom of religion and the right of freedom of expression of all United States citizens. However, Lawrence states “The Supreme Court has held that words that ‘by their very utterance inflict injury or intend to incite an immediate breach of the peace’ are not constitutionally protected.” (Lawrence, pg 175) The First Amendment does not protect speech that maintains a sole purpose to inflict harm on other people. “Racial insults are undeserving for First Amendment protection because the perpetrator’s intention is not to discover truth or initiate dialogue, but to injure the victim” (Lawrence, pg 175)

Read More

Persuasive Essay On School Dress Codes

664 Words | 3 Pages

A situation like this happened at Canton High School. Over 100 students were suspended on the first day of school for wearing neon colored shoes or neon shoe strings because they were supposedly "gang related". There was also a girl last October that was taken out of class just because she had a necklace on that resembled a rosary. The principle took it as gang related also and reprimanded her for it (Kuczynski-Brown). Could you imagine being taken out of class for a necklace?

Read More

School Dress Code Individuality In Schools

985 Words | 4 Pages

Being able to choose what to wear is a right students are allowed to have, but schools are constantly trying to change that. Religious wear is not being accepted as part of the dress code causing problems between the school and the student whose identity is being taken away from them along with the boy who could not stand trying to be like everyone and ended his own life. Down to the basic right as a human to experience life just as anyone else has. There are many more reason as to why schools should allow students to dress how they want to, but these three reasons provide all of the points needed. Overall, schools should get rid of the dress codes enforced and allow the students to explore their

Read More

Zero Tolerance Policies In Schools

1012 Words | 5 Pages

Brian Wilson and Laura Finley discuss how they believe instead keeping violence out of schools the laws “prevent student learning” (Wilson and Finley). Regarding the purpose of the policies, Wilson and Finley state, “zero-tolerance policies are, in effect, a means of channeling young people into the juvenile justice system.” Some of the policies have nothing to do with the safety of the school such as being a distraction, and disobeying dress code. These types of infractions allows minority students to spend less time in school and more time home; time home allows students to find trouble in gangs and crime. Instead of sending students home for a dress code infraction, administrators could simply have clothing available for students who have these infractions.

Read More

Persuasive Dress Code

1220 Words | 5 Pages

In 1969, the U.S. Supreme Court case Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District upheld the right to freedom of speech of students to protest the Vietnam war by wearing black armbands. The case explained the problem that “students do not “shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.” (Student) As students, we are free to express ourselves through what we wear. As students, we have every right to proclaim our beliefs

Read More

Zero Tolerance Debate

736 Words | 3 Pages

The zero tolerance policy has been adopted by many school across the nation but a discussion is starting to take place about whether or not this is a good or helpful policy. A zero tolerance policy by definition is a policy of punishing any infraction of a rule, regardless of accidental mistakes, ignorance, or extenuating circumstances in schools. Since this policy has been implemented the suspension and expulsion rate at schools has risen drastically. An article on the zero tolerance policy states “Approximately 3.3 million suspensions and over 100,000 expulsions occur each year. This number has nearly doubled since 1974, with rates escalating in the mid 1990s as zero tolerance policies began to be widely

Read More

More about Luke Should Be Allowed To Return To School Essay

Related Topics

Open Document