ipl-logo

Mary Devereaux Triumph Of The Will Essay

1475 Words6 Pages

This paper will explore Mary Devereaux’s view on beauty and evil, and use Leni Riefenstahl’s Triumph of the Will documentary to demonstrate that it is possible to appreciate the beauty of a piece of art while having it challenge our morals. Thus allowing for the coexistence of beauty and evil which lead to the self-reflection of the viewer. Through Mary Devereaux’ application of non-formalism as her choice of evaluation of the beauty and evil, I will demonstrate that the film can be appreciated. Secondly, by discussing Devereaux’ correctness in selecting a non-formalist structure but her misuse in the application of this structure, thus presenting an invalid argument. In conclusion, this paper will explore the importance of the coexistence of beauty and evil in art and what is does for the being.

Mary Devereaux narrates Triumph of the Will, a film documenting the 1934 Nuremberg rally. Through its strong narrative …show more content…

However, her application of the non-formalist structure is what I disagree with. Firstly, her distinction between the film’s vision and her characterization of Triumph of the Will is flawed. She incorrectly creates a division between the “concrete vision” of the film and the evil vision of National Socialism and constructs this distinction in order to deliver a morally sound evaluation of the film’s artistic prominence. The visions are undeniably related and cannot be disconnected.

Riefenstahl’s vision stems from that of National Socialism. Riefenstahl was a vocal supporter of the party and of Hitler. “Riefenstahl was, as she willingly admits, a great admirer of Hitler” (Devereaux 1998: 237). Through the separation of the two visions, Devereaux disregards the tragic historical context and significance. In assessing morally, we cannot forget that this film was used to mobilize the German people towards the goals of the

Show More
Related
1515 Words | 7 Pages

The Devil’s Arithmetic, based on author Jane Yolen’s novel, is a 1999 film that aims to educate viewers about the horror, importance, and impact of the Holocaust. The director, Donna Deitch, depicts the journey of a modern teenager, with an apathetic view of her Jewish heritage, who travels back in time during her family’s Seder feast to a concentration camp in 1941. The protagonist experiences the terror of the Holocaust first hand as she develops a new, appreciative meaning for her existence and family’s history. The film serves as a non-violent and efficient way to inform young viewers, who may be uneducated or disinterested, of the Holocaust. This is especially true when considering the film’s engaging plot, cinematic techniques that recreate the horror of the Holocaust, and the film’s primary purpose.

Read More
1361 Words | 6 Pages

Alan Sennett gives more interesting insight about the power of imagery in his journal article, Film Propaganda: Triumph of the Will as a Case Study: Of particular significance and artistic merit is the aforementioned opening sequence that constructs Hitler as a god-like figure descending from the heavens through the clouds over Nuremberg to visit his adoring worshippers. The powerful religious imagery of the first part of the film surely could not have been achieved simply through competent montage of newsreel sequences. Riefenstahl’s careful editing of footage taken with wide angle and telephoto lenses from prepared positions locates the audience within the spectacle itself. One of the first feelings I had when watching the film was that

Read More
760 Words | 4 Pages

Conflating "resisters" with "opponents" ignores German’s participation in the Nazi state and the atrocities the government committed. Koonz first analyzes Agnes von Grone, the National Socialist director of the Protestant Women’s Organization. Von Grone faced barriers and challenges from the church during her tenure. The Reichsbischof, Ludwig Müller,

Read More
1175 Words | 5 Pages

Through Wiesel’s journey through all the concentration camps, the reader learns about Wiesel’s horrifying memories of the camps, the death of his family, friends, and himself as a Jew during the height of World War 2. Through imagery, Wiesel shows the brutal treatment given to the prisoners, showing the emotional trauma prisoners had to endure. By choosing between staying silent or speaking out during horrific events, Wiesel shows how the choice someone makes, either will stop suffering or let it continue. The first way,

Read More
499 Words | 2 Pages

Mary Mcleod Bethune’s life began in the same circumstances as many colored people during The Era Of Reconstruction. Bethune’s family was no exception to the entrapment that the withholding of civil rights caused. Bethune’s early realization that literacy could be used as a tool to potentially break and end the vicious cycle of degradation that occurred vapidly in her time would result in the founding of an amazing learning institute and years of service towards the cause of civil rights, her message of working for one’s self and compassion is still as powerful today as it was nearly a hundred years ago. Bethune was the only member in her family to attend school, a luxury for a child with sixteen other siblings. Bethune’s simple but poignant

Read More
1989 Words | 8 Pages

Wiesel is baffled to watch as the brawny men beat at such a frail woman with her own young boy watching. The absurdity continues when his dad is beaten for morsels of scraps and as children abandon their families that they found have been holding them back. All these occurrences absolutely stun him in the fact that such events simply give the Nazi’s confirmation that the Jewish people are horrid swine and assuring the Nazi’s that their extermination is undoubtedly the just thing to

Read More
1009 Words | 5 Pages

At the time over 90% of the German people agreed with Hitler and the Nazis, it was not such a bad thing at the time to be working for Hitler and the films like Olympia and triumph of the will were received well by the general public. Themes of anti-Semitism and racial purity were not uncommon in 1934 Germany. To her last days, Riefenstahl always disputed the significance of her role in promoting Nazi Germany. In memoirs and interviews, she claims she was never interested in politics, never a member of the Nazi Party she said: 'I was not a Communist.

Read More
1437 Words | 6 Pages

With some of the best selling books and highest rated movies being of the memoir genre, it’s easy to wonder how much of an impact they may have on the world. Through Elie Wiesel’s carefully crafted words in the critically acclaimed “Night”, the reader is immersed into the harsh reality that is the Holocaust and granted the opportunity to glance at Wiesel’s personal story. Though however renowned a memoir may be, the genre lacks the ability prevent such atrocities from happening again due to it’s unreliability, the readers own perception of the book and the obstinacy of human nature. Though unable to hinder forthcoming events, memoirs do present the freedom for one to share their intimate experiences, thoughts and feelings.

Read More
1085 Words | 5 Pages

In 1933, George was standing with his father under the Brandenburg Gate where there was a victory parade for the Nazi party. They had music, drumming and marching. George’s dad stared crying. When George saw his father crying he asked his father, “why are you crying?”

Read More
941 Words | 4 Pages

Purpose is said to be what drives humans, such as instinct is what drives a stork to migrate every first fall of snow. In My Hands: Memoirs of a Holocaust Rescuer details the found purpose of Irene Gut Opdyke, a young Polish woman regarded highly for her actions during the Holocaust and the savior of six Jews during her time as a maid for the Nazis. Irene’s story circumvents the idea that a person looks out for only themselves and their own kind, and instead pushes forward facts of selflessness and responsible use of power, which continue to be present in modern, young female leaders. During World War II, there were truly no bystanders. It was practically impossible to feign ignorance to the pervasive and overbearing power of the Nazi party,

Read More
686 Words | 3 Pages

Being the oldest of seven kids and the absents of dad being around has forced me to step up and help out the family. While doing that I was able to finish high school and still attend college. Since I was a young girl my inspiration was to become a nurse and being able to help other and making a difference in other people’s life everyday. A person who reminds me a lot of me and has inspired me to continue going to school and not letting anything get in the way is Mary Lewis Wyche. She was born in Henderson in Vance County.

Read More
444 Words | 2 Pages

The structure set by Mr. Trier, often resorting to flashbacks, awaken my curiosity for the story, but some of the film’s sections deliberately disguise those familiar routines, typical of the genre in question, which revealed to be sparse in terms of inspiration. Here, the characters’ feelings are explicit rather than implicit, contrasting with the secrets of Isabelle and the doubts related to her death. “Louder than Bombs” is a minor film when compared with the filmmaker’s earliest works.

Read More
831 Words | 4 Pages

Indeed, her purported suicide at the end of the movie is no longer an outcry against the “Isolation Torture”, but a desperate attempt to desert her RAF comrades. Was this the director’s subtle expression of sympathy for Meinhof (a sentiment expressed widely among many activists in far-left milieu upon news of her self-radicalization) or was it an astute calculated move which seeks to indict the senseless violence of RAF members? This leaves us viewers

Read More
1235 Words | 5 Pages

German women’s lives changed significantly in the 1930s when the Nazi party came to power. Towards the end of the Weimar Republic, women had become more emancipated and were allowed to work, vote and take office. However, during the Gleichschaltung period, women in Nazi Germany were allocated specific roles within Nazi society. (Evans,2006). These roles were in line with the Nazi ideology that was being driven in Germany at the time: a woman’s place was in the home supporting her husband and providing children.

Read More
765 Words | 4 Pages

Having an Abnormal sperm is a very severe problem and it is totally different from the low motility of the sperm or low sperm count. Low sperm count can be corrected in lots of different ways. One can follow a healthy lifestyle, by eating the correct foods, substituting briefs with boxers and doing regular exercises to keep fit. Basically, a change in your day to day activities to help increase the sperm count. No doubt one puts a lot of effort in treating the low sperm count as it a lot easier as compared to the abnormal sperm.

Read More

More about Mary Devereaux Triumph Of The Will Essay

Related Topics

Open Document